Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If everyone was taxed an extra pound, would that save the NHS?

414 replies

EddyF · 22/12/2022 11:49

Might be a silly question but if you don’t ask, you don’t learn!

I have just a post elsewhere (not MN) where people are discussing their wait time to be seen at A&E and it’s quite shocking.

I think people would be In favour of paying a slight tax increase of a minimal amount such as £1/1.50 from tax to try and fix the NHS. Is this unrealistic?

I have attended a hospital in the US, and the experience was such a stark contrast to the feel of hospitals here. I know obviously because the US is not ‘free’ like the NHS. I just remember it being like a spa service.

OP posts:
Badbadbunny · 22/12/2022 13:58

scaredoff · 22/12/2022 13:39

Well the poster didn't say anything about student loans (which the tax-loving left tend to argue against and believe should be covered instead by general, progressive taxation as they used to be). And pension deductions are just putting your own money in a different place (with generous tax treatment by the government) to spend when you're older. They're not something the pesky government is "taking" from you for public services. They're certainly not a tax, which is what the objection was about.

The poster said "deductions", but you started talking about tax. I merely pointed out that "deductions" are more than just tax.

Hereeverysaturdaynight · 22/12/2022 13:58

Badbadbunny · 22/12/2022 13:49

Yep, same with my OH and his cancer treatment. 3 different trusts inc the GP and two different hospitals. None of them communicate with eachother. He had to have whole body x-rays, MRI scans, CT scans, and bone marrow samples taken by each of the hospitals as they didn't "share" results between them. That's in addition to the x-rays and scans organised by the GP surgery prior to cancer diagnosis. Same with blood tests, GP wants a monthly blood test for the drugs they prescribe, hospital want a monthly one for the drugs they prescribe and a different part of the same hospital want a monthly blood test for his monthly infusion! Once he broke a bone in his foot, and had his foot x-rayed three times, once by the GP, then by the oncology dept and finally by othopaedics. Then you get them arguing between themselves as to who is responsible for prescribing, say, a supplement or vitamin - OH has had times when the oncologist has said he needed, say, iron or calcium supplement, and told him to go to his GP for them, only for the GP to do a blood test and "decide" that the levels are within tolerance and no prescription needed, so OH has to go back to oncologist, and so it goes on. They simply won't communicate and it's down to the patient to try to organise which inevitable means duplicated tests.

I remember the time he was first "referred" to the second hospital. (Our local do chemotherapy but not surgery, so referred him to one about 2 hours away for the surgery). The consultant at hospital 2 opened his file at our first appointment and there was only a one page letter basically introducing OH and confirming the diagnosis - absolutely zilch in the way of test results, x-ray/scan imaging results, not even blood tests. That first consultation was a waste of time as the consultant had nothing to work with, all he could do was order more tests at his hospital! I'd at least have thought that a referral would have included copies of test results!

Precisely the situation I'm in, but with a different diagnosis. It's just unbelievable.

The only way I could describe is if you went into a shoe shop and you had to have you feet measured for every different shoe in the shop! It's fucking ridiculous. The scans, the mris, the echos, the ct scans, the bloods, the ecgs, NONE OF THEM are shared. So I now have 3 hospital trusts addressing the same issue, with only the information gleaned from their individual trusts at their disposal.

I'm now having to carry every test result with me everywhere. It's utterly ridiculous. It's a duplication and triplication of services. FFS. One test is enough! I don't need three!

caringcarer · 22/12/2022 13:58

Over 500 managers earn over £100k each year.

Badbadbunny · 22/12/2022 13:55

Hereeverysaturdaynight · 22/12/2022 13:39

I am trying to act as my own medical secretary without having access to my files. It's stressful, exhausting, infuriating and utterly baffling. I've seen desk-chairs more efficient that some people within the NHS.

Yep, OH is the same, he jokes it's almost a full time job to organise his almost weekly blood tests, arrange drugs to be issued/collected (both hospital and GP), arrange infusion/treatment appointments, etc, and then chase up when things aren't done properly, re-arrange cancelled appointments, etc. He really can't see how confused/elderly patients manage. Basically he has to arrange it all himself because no one else within the NHS will do it. When it's something really important like long term cancer and lifetime chemotherapy, you'd think it would all be done automatically within the NHS as literally every 4 week cycle is the same, but he has to phone to organise everything and often has to explain to them what he needs and why it needs to be specific dates etc. To make things worse, they won't allow him to make regular bookings and he can only ever book "the next" date so that just means multiple phone calls to various depts every 4 weeks, taking up their time too, when the simpler option would be a recurring appointment, same place, same time, every 4 weeks, but apparently the NHS "diary" can't do that!

Theeyeballsinthesky · 22/12/2022 13:54

A doctors view on whther the nhs had too many manager A doctors view on nhs management

caringcarer · 22/12/2022 13:52

When my Mum died in took her walking frame and 2 walking sticks back to hospital as in perfectly good condition. I was told they will be disposed of. I was shocked they won't be reissued to someone else. They could easily be sterilised. This sort of waste is rife in NHS.

Fameinaframe · 22/12/2022 13:52

*That can't be right.

Your first grand or so a month should be subject to no tax as it's below the personal allowance. You're basically being taxed 50% on the remainder which should be basic rate*

Definitely how much my deductions are altogether!

Fifi00 · 22/12/2022 13:50

I'm a HCP and I think the NHS is failing and it won't exist very soon for adults. The main reason is we have a massively aging population and medicine is becoming more sophisticated. When the NHS was founded people spent less time in poor health and typically died quickly. Now you might have someone needing intensive support for 10 years now before death. It wasn't designed for what it's expected to do, we are going to have to look at alternative funding models which doesn't mean the US style.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 22/12/2022 13:49

It might not fix everything, but that money could be ring fenced for say, A&E or maternity care

There is a lot of health tourism in A&E and in Maternity.

Maybe sort out that first?

caringcarer · 22/12/2022 13:49

Lack of funding is not crippling the NHS. The money is spent on tiers and tiers of management structure. There are so many chiefs being paid way over £150k each for stupid things whilst nurses on the front line suffer unimaginable stress and shortages. Some operations, mostly cosmetic, costing lots of money should be banned on NHS. Breast enhancement, breast reduction, breast removal, circumcision, gender reassignment should all only take place for purely medical reasons not social or cultural reasons. Patients should buy their own food. A person needs to buy food if home or in hospital so should not expect to get food provided for free. It is a National Heath Service not National cafe. Staff should be better paid but at any one time up to 1/3 of staff are off sick at any one time. Sick pay should be less because clearly some staff are constantly off on sick with out sick notes as lots of short sick time off less than a week each time so never have to produce sick note.

Badbadbunny · 22/12/2022 13:49

Hereeverysaturdaynight · 22/12/2022 13:36

I've said it before and I'll say it again, there is complete lack of communication within the NHS. I am now under 3 different trusts for the same thing (yes, that is THREE). The GP is supposed to coordinate my care except GPs simply file results and do not action them. Therefore, I now have 3 trusts doing the exact same tests (expensive and time-consuming and labour intensive tests) as the GP can not seem to simply forward results from one to the other. It would be like throwing good money after bad. Utterly pointless.

Yep, same with my OH and his cancer treatment. 3 different trusts inc the GP and two different hospitals. None of them communicate with eachother. He had to have whole body x-rays, MRI scans, CT scans, and bone marrow samples taken by each of the hospitals as they didn't "share" results between them. That's in addition to the x-rays and scans organised by the GP surgery prior to cancer diagnosis. Same with blood tests, GP wants a monthly blood test for the drugs they prescribe, hospital want a monthly one for the drugs they prescribe and a different part of the same hospital want a monthly blood test for his monthly infusion! Once he broke a bone in his foot, and had his foot x-rayed three times, once by the GP, then by the oncology dept and finally by othopaedics. Then you get them arguing between themselves as to who is responsible for prescribing, say, a supplement or vitamin - OH has had times when the oncologist has said he needed, say, iron or calcium supplement, and told him to go to his GP for them, only for the GP to do a blood test and "decide" that the levels are within tolerance and no prescription needed, so OH has to go back to oncologist, and so it goes on. They simply won't communicate and it's down to the patient to try to organise which inevitable means duplicated tests.

I remember the time he was first "referred" to the second hospital. (Our local do chemotherapy but not surgery, so referred him to one about 2 hours away for the surgery). The consultant at hospital 2 opened his file at our first appointment and there was only a one page letter basically introducing OH and confirming the diagnosis - absolutely zilch in the way of test results, x-ray/scan imaging results, not even blood tests. That first consultation was a waste of time as the consultant had nothing to work with, all he could do was order more tests at his hospital! I'd at least have thought that a referral would have included copies of test results!

cinnabongene · 22/12/2022 13:46

No because it would just be wasted like all the other hundreds of millions the NHS pisses away every year; taxis to take forgotten medicines to patients after discharge anyone? Thrown out walking frames after being used once? Bank staff paid twice or three times the amount of regular nurses? The waste is eye watering

Hereward1332 · 22/12/2022 13:45

@BungleandGeorge Your right of course that the real figures are far more complex. Perhaps you could share some data that shows the average annual cost of conditions that could be privately treated?

XingMing · 22/12/2022 13:45

@poetryandwine the HMO model used in the US works well. I was a member of one as it was an (inexpensive) option for staff at the pension and insurance company where I worked. Israel's health system has four national HMOs which compete with one another. Their menus vary slightly, but all cover the basic stuff.

LexMitior · 22/12/2022 13:42

Yes if you have a chronic condition then private medicine is probably useless. It is excellent for;

Bespoke procedures such cataracts, hip replacement, straightforward caesarean, laser eye surgery, etc. most posters who are still in their 40s could get this kind of insurance very cheaply.

Private medicine is great. But you are paying for time. And if you have a chronic problem, then either you are not covered or you can pay. The cost is eye watering. Think a good house deposit for a few weeks treatment in a private hospital in London.

DarkOphelia · 22/12/2022 13:41

Anotherbloomingchristmas · 22/12/2022 13:19

And how poor have you got to be to pay no income tax.
It's a disgrace that 25% earn so little.

I don't pay income tax because I earn under the personal allowance. I'd in no way say I was "poor".

A lot of women who work part time find themselves earning under the threshold. Indeed, my house runs off about £35k combined gross a year for two adults and a child. We pay a mortgage out of that, and we do all right. I don't need to visit food banks or anything.

Sometimes, I wonder what folk spend their money on. 🤔

Lostinalibrary · 22/12/2022 13:40

Anotherbloomingchristmas · 22/12/2022 13:30

After tax and NI someone on 100k takes home £6k a month before private pension deductions. They're doing fine.

No they don’t, it’s about 5.5k. It’s basic economics and has been tried before. There is always a tipping point where raising taxes lowers the yield. The previous poster was quite right.

scaredoff · 22/12/2022 13:39

Badbadbunny · 22/12/2022 13:33

Employees NIC, student loan deductions, workplace pension deductions, etc. It's not just basic rate tax which is deducted!

Well the poster didn't say anything about student loans (which the tax-loving left tend to argue against and believe should be covered instead by general, progressive taxation as they used to be). And pension deductions are just putting your own money in a different place (with generous tax treatment by the government) to spend when you're older. They're not something the pesky government is "taking" from you for public services. They're certainly not a tax, which is what the objection was about.

Hereeverysaturdaynight · 22/12/2022 13:39

Hereeverysaturdaynight · 22/12/2022 13:36

I've said it before and I'll say it again, there is complete lack of communication within the NHS. I am now under 3 different trusts for the same thing (yes, that is THREE). The GP is supposed to coordinate my care except GPs simply file results and do not action them. Therefore, I now have 3 trusts doing the exact same tests (expensive and time-consuming and labour intensive tests) as the GP can not seem to simply forward results from one to the other. It would be like throwing good money after bad. Utterly pointless.

I am trying to act as my own medical secretary without having access to my files. It's stressful, exhausting, infuriating and utterly baffling. I've seen desk-chairs more efficient that some people within the NHS.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 22/12/2022 13:37

Anotherbloomingchristmas · 22/12/2022 13:16

Not if you don't work even if your pension is as much as the average wage.

Which will be taxed. NI was set up to be <quote>a tax on earnings and self-employed profits paid by employees, employers and the self-employed. They can help to build your entitlement to certain benefits depending whether you are employed or self-employed, such as the State Pension and Maternity Allowance <unquote>

If people have enough in pensions to be able to retire early and not rely on having a full state pension, why should they pay NI that won't be of any benefit to them? why don't you offer to pay more tax?

advisingfamilies.org/uk/information-portal/managing-money/can-i-pay-more-tax-voluntarily/

BungleandGeorge · 22/12/2022 13:36

Hereward1332 · 22/12/2022 12:13

How about incentivising people not to use the NHS - allow private health insurance to be tax-deductible. Annual cost in lost tax revenue for a family of 4 would be around £1000. While it's skewed, public spending on health services for a family of 4 is around £8000.

Private healthcare transfers anything complex/ expensive back to the nhs so your figures don’t really work. The policies are nowhere near comprehensive

Hereeverysaturdaynight · 22/12/2022 13:36

I've said it before and I'll say it again, there is complete lack of communication within the NHS. I am now under 3 different trusts for the same thing (yes, that is THREE). The GP is supposed to coordinate my care except GPs simply file results and do not action them. Therefore, I now have 3 trusts doing the exact same tests (expensive and time-consuming and labour intensive tests) as the GP can not seem to simply forward results from one to the other. It would be like throwing good money after bad. Utterly pointless.

Badbadbunny · 22/12/2022 13:35

Fadedpicture · 22/12/2022 13:30

It's not enough though is it? Surely you can see that £700 pm is unlikely to be sufficient to cover the cost of the schools, roads, policing and health care you make use of and set something aside for your pension, even if you are a low user of these services. The vast majority are not net contributors.

Yes, but £700 is a hell of a lot more than lots of people who earn less or live mostly on benefits.

We can't continue increasing the tax burden on less than half of the population, in fact probably less than a quarter of the population who earn more than average wages.

EddyF · 22/12/2022 13:34

MandyMotherOfBrian · 22/12/2022 11:54

What do you mean? £1 how often? There’s only about 32 million income tax payers in the UK.

This would include everyone; even those on benefits. So over the age of 18.

It might not fix everything, but that money could be ring fenced for say, A&E or maternity care.

Also an option for people to pay more than the £1/1.50 tax.

I just feel something has to give because the thought of losing the NHS is quite devastating.

OP posts:
WhatsitWiggle · 22/12/2022 13:33

Well the government did plan to increase national insurance in order to better fund social care. That was rolled back when COL increased so dramatically as the Torys are not a party of tax increases, it doesn't win votes.

The NHS has been woefully underfunded for years, but the service it's trying to provide now is dramatically different to when it was originally created.

Swipe left for the next trending thread