Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If everyone was taxed an extra pound, would that save the NHS?

414 replies

EddyF · 22/12/2022 11:49

Might be a silly question but if you don’t ask, you don’t learn!

I have just a post elsewhere (not MN) where people are discussing their wait time to be seen at A&E and it’s quite shocking.

I think people would be In favour of paying a slight tax increase of a minimal amount such as £1/1.50 from tax to try and fix the NHS. Is this unrealistic?

I have attended a hospital in the US, and the experience was such a stark contrast to the feel of hospitals here. I know obviously because the US is not ‘free’ like the NHS. I just remember it being like a spa service.

OP posts:
Badbadbunny · 22/12/2022 14:31

vivainsomnia · 22/12/2022 14:27

Thrown out walking frames after being used once? Bank staff paid twice or three times the amount of regular nurses? The waste is eye watering
No it isn't. You are talking peanuts. Not even .001% of the while funding.

It's as stupid a statement as someone saying they are crap at money and easing their income because they use two sheets of toilet paper when they could use one. Probably true, but I don't that would explain why a family is £10000s in debts.

The public really need to educate themselves about the scale of money we are talking about, and focusing on very minimal issues solely whilst ignoring the issue that costs half the NHS IS bad management.

As a percentage, yes, a small proportion. But it's still huge in real monetary terms and would pay for extra nurses. And it's not just walking frames is it? It'll be everything that is used/provided in the NHS from cheap sheets of paper through to unused expensive drugs, unused medical consumables, etc.

Even 0.01% of a huge figure is still a huge figure!

I think you're attitude typifies a lot of the NHS wastage - just because you consider it "tiny" in the big scheme of things, you don't care about the waste. Extrapolate that across over a million NHS staff and you've a big waste problem.

If every member of staff wastes just a pound a day, that's a million pounds wasted every day.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 22/12/2022 14:29

scaredoff · 22/12/2022 13:22

Have "lifestyle related health issues" gotten worse in the period the NHS has existed? Genuine question - I'm not sure. On one hand I suppose obesity is probably worse. On the other, far fewer people smoke now.

I also wonder how many health issues are NOT in some way lifestyle-related, and where you draw the line. Healthy lifestyles are also easier for the economically comfortable to maintain than for the poorest, for a variety of reasons.

Obesity has increased massively ( to coin a phrase). Smoking is less common, but alcohol related injuries and diseases have increased, and drug related illness was tiny . Plus of course that they used to kill you, you weren’t continually patched up and sent out to resume consumption.

vivainsomnia · 22/12/2022 14:27

Thrown out walking frames after being used once? Bank staff paid twice or three times the amount of regular nurses? The waste is eye watering
No it isn't. You are talking peanuts. Not even .001% of the while funding.

It's as stupid a statement as someone saying they are crap at money and easing their income because they use two sheets of toilet paper when they could use one. Probably true, but I don't that would explain why a family is £10000s in debts.

The public really need to educate themselves about the scale of money we are talking about, and focusing on very minimal issues solely whilst ignoring the issue that costs half the NHS IS bad management.

Theluggage15 · 22/12/2022 14:25

It doesn’t need more money, it needs total reform along the lines of the best European health systems. But people can’t bear the thought of that and shriek about the USA and ‘our NHS’ so it will carry on being an expensive shambles.

Badbadbunny · 22/12/2022 14:23

Hereeverysaturdaynight · 22/12/2022 14:16

All I know is that my health is deteriorating rapidly because of a complete lack of information sharing and a lack of centralised control and dissemination of the information between trusts. It's such a simple fucking solution and my patience has run out.

Yep, OH has now been waiting over a year for a prescription for Vitamin D supplements!

He was already on the strongest dose available over the counter from the pharmacy. And pharmacists have told him not to take more than the daily dose of that as it "may be" dangerous and cause issues with his other medication.

His oncologist has highlighted low Vit D and told him to contact the GP surgery. His orthopaedic surgeon highlighted low VT D and told him to contact the GP surgery. He's had numerous phone calls with the GP reception asking for Vit D prescription, a few phone consultations with the nurse practioner, and a couple of phone consultations with a GP. Answer is always the same - "just go to the chemist and ask for Vit D" to which OH always replies, "I've been on strongest OTT Vit D for a couple of years and it's not enough", then they say they'll "consult" the "prescribing team" and get back to him, but they never do.

So he's taken numerous phone consultation appointments just to tell them the same thing and get the same answer, but he's still not got his prescription which everyone agrees he needs! And yet the GP surgeries always complain of being too busy! How about they deal with things first time then and not cause patients to have to keep calling back because they've not done the simplest of things!

Yes, his patience has run out too! Even moreso that he has a broken bone in his foot that's not healing, which the orthopaedic surgeon says is probably caused by lack of Vit D!

vivainsomnia · 22/12/2022 14:20

I think my family paid about USD 80-100/month as a standing fee
Yes, when you're young and healthy. Add a chronic or genetic condition and this suddenly triple or more.

Hereeverysaturdaynight · 22/12/2022 14:18

This is not about payment or taxes. This is about utter idiocy.

Fifi00 · 22/12/2022 14:17

I think we had people who had been in care homes for 10-15 years. If people think their basic tax pays for that they are surely mistaken. It costs a fortune to fund. People who retire at 60 expecting their full care to have been paid for until 100 it's not true.

Hereeverysaturdaynight · 22/12/2022 14:17

But let me have 3 echocardiograms for good measure.

Hereeverysaturdaynight · 22/12/2022 14:16

All I know is that my health is deteriorating rapidly because of a complete lack of information sharing and a lack of centralised control and dissemination of the information between trusts. It's such a simple fucking solution and my patience has run out.

LexMitior · 22/12/2022 14:14

Gosh it's almost as if the NHS has been set up for private providers to bill you. What a surprise

vivainsomnia · 22/12/2022 14:13

which would also need a fully integrated universal computer system for all providers, which would make a private contractor an unfathomable amount of money at the prices they would charge for it
The NHS already has this in place for almost all appointments and certainly all surgeries. Hospitals could already bill individual patients if it were a new policy. I don't think it's right though as the majority.

LexMitior · 22/12/2022 14:12

And the reason I am even thinking about France and Germany is that we have had years to do this. Yet all the Tory politicians I have ever met engaged with health are working US healthcare.

That is what is wanted. The Tory Party have had 12 years to do otherwise. If you think they are going to be interested in making costs reasonable then this imo cuts across their own self interest.

Hereeverysaturdaynight · 22/12/2022 14:12

LexMitior · 22/12/2022 14:08

@Hereeverysaturdaynight - it is extremely expensive in the UK and the US.

Ten years ago, 44000 spent in London. Insurance paid.

Please tell my colleagues in the US private medicine is cheap. They will laugh at you.

You're not listening.

The US SYSTEM is as alien to me as an African system might be.
There are very effective and cost efficient and working systems in Europe.

Badbadbunny · 22/12/2022 14:12

Fifi00 · 22/12/2022 14:08

They should make rich pensioners pay NI. They probably haven't contributed enough for their care especially if they develop Dementia. Theresa May did try but the press started shouting Dementia tax. I work in an organic ward for complex dementias , brain injury one of our beds costs the NHS at least 10,000 a week. It's far from cheap.

Or better still, scrap NIC and increase income tax so everyone pays based on income, not where that income comes from, nor their age. OAPS with low incomes probably won't pay any more, but an OAP with an income of £50k would pay the same as a worker with an income of £50k which is only fair - why should a pensioner with high income pay less tax than a worker on a lower income?

Fifi00 · 22/12/2022 14:10

poetryandwine · 22/12/2022 14:06

What models do you have in mind, @Fifi00 ? I am no fan of the traditional American insurance model, but what I described is, as @XingMing said, an HMO. It has much in common with the very successful French and German systems.

Very interested in your thoughts

Australian which is a mixed system of state and private and Singapore.

Fifi00 · 22/12/2022 14:08

They should make rich pensioners pay NI. They probably haven't contributed enough for their care especially if they develop Dementia. Theresa May did try but the press started shouting Dementia tax. I work in an organic ward for complex dementias , brain injury one of our beds costs the NHS at least 10,000 a week. It's far from cheap.

LexMitior · 22/12/2022 14:08

@Hereeverysaturdaynight - it is extremely expensive in the UK and the US.

Ten years ago, 44000 spent in London. Insurance paid.

Please tell my colleagues in the US private medicine is cheap. They will laugh at you.

vivainsomnia · 22/12/2022 14:07

No, I mention what I imagine are several million £1 letters every year. And it's just one example of one inefficiency. Plus, it's not £1, it's £1 plus the staff costs of sending them out
But £1 per patient say is much less than the cost of 1 missed appointment. If out of 100 patients, 2 will not missed their appointment because they got a letter, than it's a cost benefit.

Still 1 million compared to 1 billion is not very comparable.

poetryandwine · 22/12/2022 14:06

What models do you have in mind, @Fifi00 ? I am no fan of the traditional American insurance model, but what I described is, as @XingMing said, an HMO. It has much in common with the very successful French and German systems.

Very interested in your thoughts

Hereeverysaturdaynight · 22/12/2022 14:05

LexMitior · 22/12/2022 13:42

Yes if you have a chronic condition then private medicine is probably useless. It is excellent for;

Bespoke procedures such cataracts, hip replacement, straightforward caesarean, laser eye surgery, etc. most posters who are still in their 40s could get this kind of insurance very cheaply.

Private medicine is great. But you are paying for time. And if you have a chronic problem, then either you are not covered or you can pay. The cost is eye watering. Think a good house deposit for a few weeks treatment in a private hospital in London.

Not in other countries it's not! Stop peddling this nonsense!

HighAsAKiteAgain · 22/12/2022 14:05

Nothing will save the NHS, its all part of the plan. The NHS doesn't have a budget, it IS the budget- it is designed to make you all sick (by lying to you about what you should eat and by piling medication on you,meds which cause new diseases) so that the pockets of the pharmaceutical companies are lined.

If you really want to 'save the NHS' or even your own health you should switch off the TV and media and do some research into whats going on around you. Stop eating carbs and processed food. Stop drinking tap water unless you've filtered it, stop running to the doctor everytime your nose runs. Stop believing the 'virus' and contagion lies and start taking responsibility for your own health.

"The Contagion Myth" book is a good place to start.

If you're doing what the NHS or government are telling you, you're a hypocrite.

Hereeverysaturdaynight · 22/12/2022 14:02

ItsDinah · 22/12/2022 13:58

I reckon we'd need to double the overall NHS budget to get it to a standard our population would be happy with. It's currently around £200 billion. To double it, all 32 million taxpayers would need to pay an extra £52 a month tax.

There is an alternative and many countries work with a different system. Not the US system. A system that is tiered where the basic level of care is free and is on a par with the NHS and then if you can afford private healthcare, you pay for it and you take the pressure off the NHS.

Swissnotswiss · 22/12/2022 14:00

I moved abroad to an EU country over 20 years ago. When I first moved I felt that the NHS was far better than in my new country but in the last two decades, the health service where I live has innovated a lot. It's still far from perfect (and I'm not bashing the UK, I love the UK!) but certain aspects work far better here. My parents are in England and they still get appointments sent by post, often they arrive too late. The other day my dad got an appointment he wasn't expecting with a consultant he saw 5 years ago. After numerous phone calls, nobody could tell him what it was for. He turned up as he didn't want to be counted as absent only for the consultant to berate him for wasting his time! Apparently it was an admin error (how??) Here I have an electronic medical folder on my phone and I can book my own appointments directly once my GP has approved/recommended them. My prescriptions are sent directly there too. Unfortunately the NHS needs,a massive overhaul. I just hope the next government will make it a priority.

ItsDinah · 22/12/2022 13:58

I reckon we'd need to double the overall NHS budget to get it to a standard our population would be happy with. It's currently around £200 billion. To double it, all 32 million taxpayers would need to pay an extra £52 a month tax.