Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If everyone was taxed an extra pound, would that save the NHS?

414 replies

EddyF · 22/12/2022 11:49

Might be a silly question but if you don’t ask, you don’t learn!

I have just a post elsewhere (not MN) where people are discussing their wait time to be seen at A&E and it’s quite shocking.

I think people would be In favour of paying a slight tax increase of a minimal amount such as £1/1.50 from tax to try and fix the NHS. Is this unrealistic?

I have attended a hospital in the US, and the experience was such a stark contrast to the feel of hospitals here. I know obviously because the US is not ‘free’ like the NHS. I just remember it being like a spa service.

OP posts:
XingMing · 22/12/2022 15:12

Type 2 diabetes is, with ageing, the biggest single element in NHS care at about 10% and a lot is preventable by better diet; it's even reversible in the early stages. But that would require the general public having the self-awareness to recognise their obesity and the determination to correct it.

Smokers usually die younger, and pay huge extra tax on their addiction. At one time, before smoking declined, tobacco contributed significantly to the NHS budget. For all I know, it may still.

Hereeverysaturdaynight · 22/12/2022 15:09

Theluggage15 · 22/12/2022 14:25

It doesn’t need more money, it needs total reform along the lines of the best European health systems. But people can’t bear the thought of that and shriek about the USA and ‘our NHS’ so it will carry on being an expensive shambles.

God forbid we learned anything from Europe.

vivainsomnia · 22/12/2022 15:08

The idea that so called "health tourism" presents a significant financial burden on the NHS was de-bunked years ago
Another ignorant comment fuelled by the media. Almost all trust now employ a team to pick up patients not entitled to NHS treatment. There are national systems in place that allow potential fee paying patients. Being registered with a GP and having an NHS number won't allow you to filter through the process. Dors the public know that overseas visitors are billed at 150% of the NHS costs? I bet not!

poetryandwine · 22/12/2022 15:07

Pensioners paying higher rate tax could continue to pay NI. (IMO the triple lock should be maintained, for many reasons. This would help make it palatable.)

The HMO system @XingMing and I have been describing does not have public funding (employers make a large contribution). But in practice it works like a public-private hybrid model or like the French system. Again I emphasise that, unlike traditional US healthcare, no one can be excluded and pre-existing conditions must be fully covered.

vivainsomnia · 22/12/2022 15:02

Even 0.01% of a huge figure is still a huge figure!
No it isn't! It is to you, not to the NHS!

Can't you understand that to manage a system of ultimate efficiency cost extra resources? Massive improvements have been made in these areas, but it will never be perfect because perfection will cost more to implement.

It's quite infuriating when those people who don't any experience and clue of what they are talking about criticize those who do and insist they know better then them. All they know is their very limited personal experience, always focusing in what goes wrong if course and taking the rest for granted, and what they hear in the news and then think that makes them experts in the natter and more knowledgeable than those who have worked in the system for donkey years. It's laughable!

I am certainly not saying that the NHS is perfect and blameless but what has been spurted here about what are the reasons for it are frankly risible. Can we once again focus on the NHS biggest problem by million miles, diabetes, 90% of which is preventable?

BuckarooBanzai · 22/12/2022 15:00

I'm a carer and tonight I will be working a 6 hour shift for 4 and a quarter hours pay. This is due to the delights of block pay. I never finish on time either as most visits have been cut by social services to make savings. I can't stand to do a bad job so I do it in my own time essentially. My mileage isn't fully covered and there's nothing towards wear & tear of my car or my business insurance. The company I work for make about £750k pure profit a year which is largely tax payers money from care budgets. The staffing levels are so low because the pay is a joke. If a decent care system was in place where hospitals could discharge non clinical need patients this would free up beds & staff and take off some of the pressure from hospitals. Councils should be accountable for the money they are paying to private health care providers who are providing a sub standard service because they want to make thousands and thousands in profit rather than paying staff fairly so they can have decent staffing levels.

pinneddownbytabbies · 22/12/2022 15:00

The NHS needs more front-line staff and fewer people sitting round board tables.

Nat6999 · 22/12/2022 14:53

Why don't they get rid of individual NHS trusts & bring everything under one massive trust & get rid of all the executives? I know that wouldn't raise all the money but it would help, when you see executive jobs being advertised at £150k a year, the same with procurement, if one trust needs scalpels, gloves & PPE foe example, they all need them.

fyn · 22/12/2022 14:52

@Delectable the crown estates are the largest landowners in the country (owning things like Buckingham palace, the foreshore etc…). The income from that goes to the treasury, they then get a small proportion of it to maintain the royal collection and for staff costs) it isn’t the royal families personal income.

DarkOphelia · 22/12/2022 14:51

My mother and mother in law worked in the NHS all their lives. My cousins now do so. All of them say it's a bottomless pit. It's unfundable.

A lot of this has been exacerbated by PFI. A £70 million hospital building will end up costing £350 million by the end of the term. That's Blair's government who wanted to produce shiny new buildings, knowing there wasn't the tax base to really afford them (so they just used capital instead, leaving us all with a mill stone round our necks).

For those that scoff at the impact of waste, let me tell you it all mounts up. I've known of NHS labs that throw away unopened solutions by the bucket load because of bizarre procurement policies. I also know a situation where a hospital was quoted £16k to widen a doorway by two inches. Over time, this stuff means that department budgets are far higher than they actually need to be.

The whole thing needs rebuilding really.

PearlclutchersInc · 22/12/2022 14:50

MajorCarolDanvers · 22/12/2022 11:53

In Scotland we are already paying more tax for the NHS £100s to £1,000s and it's just as shit here.

No, not quite. I needed an ambulance at the end of the summer. One arrived within half an hour and I got a bed the same day.

Have things really deteriorated that much since then?

ZeViteVitchofCwismas · 22/12/2022 14:49

@Wardrobemalfunction22

My friend trained to be a nurse and worked NHS and private. She said in private every pen was taken into account and you wouldn't help yourself to one. .NHS was a free for all.
Absolutely zero accountability.

ZeViteVitchofCwismas · 22/12/2022 14:48

No because it's not all a Money issues it's a basic function issue as well.

Wardrobemalfunction22 · 22/12/2022 14:47

For those saying the UK is already a high tax country, there was a study published earlier this week comparing income tax rates in England/Scotland with other countries. UK is actually one of the lowest effective tax rates for income tax, being around 20% for the average wage and its only when you get to 2x average wages that it starts getting closer to other countries tax rates.

Study here for those interested in comparing tax rates: www.taxpolicy.org.uk/wages_chart/

Tax is obviously a political issue and we have just had the additonal NI levy of 1.25% removed by the latest government, after it was introduced last April to help cover health and social care.

I'm not saying increasing NI is the answer but I do think that a lot of UK taxpayers don't realise they pay relatively low income taxes.

The NHS is currently a bottomless pit lacking in accountability due to decentralisation and before we start pouring more more money into it I think it would be sensible to look at controlling spending and making sure money is spent on things that are needed, not on bureacracy, waste or other management issues which don't benefit patients or clinical staff.

Disclaimer: I'm a tax accountant but my family work in the NHS

If everyone was taxed an extra pound, would that save the NHS?
DrMarciaFieldstone · 22/12/2022 14:46

I don’t want to pay any more for the NHS. There needs to be more tax-deductible incentives to not use it. With the state of the (generally self-inflicted) overall and ageing health of the UK population, there is no amount of money that will cover everything needed. It needs some fresh thinking.

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 22/12/2022 14:45

No way would I be willing to pay a single penny more towards the NHS. If everyone gave every single penny they earn to the NHS, it would be no better than it is now. It is a massive monster of a financial black hole. It needs to be disbanded and we need a system that actually works and which reflects the needs of the population as it is now (including huge numbers of old and obese people, and those who smoke, drink too much, eat crap and don't get any exercise).

LexMitior · 22/12/2022 14:45

I think my perhaps cynical point is that while there are some good ideas in terms of replicating European models, that has been an option for a long time.

If a politician does not do something for over a decade but which benefits a donating party interest, then a voter should join the dots. The changes that are happening to the NHS support an expensive US model. The management is extremely costly, the same as the US, the waste is similar in as much as private treatment puts everything at beyond economic cost because of the clear profit motive, and further there are independent trusts with a billing system.

The very clear expectation is that if you want timely treatment you will pay for it privately. That is not an accident.

CakeCrumbs44 · 22/12/2022 14:44

They would be better off trying to reduce costs in the NHS rather than increase funding. Things like educating people about when they can go to a pharmacy rather than a doctor, or a minor injuries centre rather than calling an ambulance. Stop offering things like paracetamol for free on prescription when people could just buy it for 30p off the shelf. Encourage nurses to stay in the job so they don't have to employ agency nurses which cost 3x as much.
Obviously none of these things are simple fixes, but there must be so many places where the NHS is just haemorrhaging money. It needs rebuilding from the ground up.

XingMing · 22/12/2022 14:43

Actually, figures from the last two or three years suggest the UK spends about the same, or slightly more, on healthcare as a % of GDP compared to comparable EU countries. Very similar to France, a little less than Germany and Switzerland, but more than Spain, Italy, Belgium. I read it yesterday, but can't remember where. I will look for the source.

Fifi00 · 22/12/2022 14:42

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 22/12/2022 14:35

They should make rich pensioners pay NI

And we're back to asking, what's the definition of rich?

I'm not a politician but many have retired at 60 living until 90s even 100s. They haven't paid enough in for the scale of care needed. Every UTI , medications , every fall, dysphagia , special diets, 24/7 supervision, pressure ulcer all needs funding out of the pot.

Fifi00 · 22/12/2022 14:39

Theluggage15 · 22/12/2022 14:25

It doesn’t need more money, it needs total reform along the lines of the best European health systems. But people can’t bear the thought of that and shriek about the USA and ‘our NHS’ so it will carry on being an expensive shambles.

Exactly not even just European , Australia and Singapore have very good systems. We will be forced into the US system because everyone keeps burying their heads in the sand. Or they will bring euthunasia in and it won't be out of the the kindness of Tory hearts but to bring the care bill down.

poetryandwine · 22/12/2022 14:37

No, @vivainsomnia Your statement that payments go up would be true of a traditional insurance plan.

In an HMO, all employees of a given employer in a category pay the same rate (there are plans for singles, families, etc). Also, pre-existing conditions must be covered and no one may be denied coverage

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 22/12/2022 14:35

They should make rich pensioners pay NI

And we're back to asking, what's the definition of rich?

neverbeenskiing · 22/12/2022 14:34

There is a lot of health tourism in A&E and in Maternity.

The Royal College of Physicians, the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health, Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists, the Royal College of Midwives and the Faculty of Public Health, amongst others, disagree with you. The idea that so called "health tourism" presents a significant financial burden on the NHS was de-bunked years ago. Many top Doctors and public health experts have called out the discourse around "health tourism" as being a wilful distraction from the fact that successive governments have chosen to spend a much lower proportion of gross domestic product on healthcare than other high-income countries.

Fadedpicture · 22/12/2022 14:34

vivainsomnia · 22/12/2022 14:27

Thrown out walking frames after being used once? Bank staff paid twice or three times the amount of regular nurses? The waste is eye watering
No it isn't. You are talking peanuts. Not even .001% of the while funding.

It's as stupid a statement as someone saying they are crap at money and easing their income because they use two sheets of toilet paper when they could use one. Probably true, but I don't that would explain why a family is £10000s in debts.

The public really need to educate themselves about the scale of money we are talking about, and focusing on very minimal issues solely whilst ignoring the issue that costs half the NHS IS bad management.

No, it seems to me the NHS needs to understand it's own costs. Of course one walking frame isn't going to break the MHS but 1000s of walking frames every year, plus the letters, plus unaudited overtime, plus wasted GP appointments because they didn't do what they said they'd do the first time, plus not dealing with minor things that then become bug things etc etc etc.

Of course getting all these things running properly would make a huge difference. Of course the NHS is always going to need a lot of money, but you can only spend it once, save it on crutches you can fund a nurse

Swipe left for the next trending thread