Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not give main Xmas presents?

35 replies

EmojiSadFace · 22/12/2022 11:39

Hello Everyone,

So essentially just before we broke up for the school holidays, DS9 was permanently excluded from school. So next term he is basically going to be school-less, bearing in mind he was attending a specialist school for those with behaviour problems and learning difficulties.

He was diagnosed with ADHD and OCD a few years ago, but he shows that he can behave, it almost seems as if he misbehaves because he knows he can, and there are no consequences.

Now, I don’t know if anyone here can relate… because I find it very hard to deal with him and manage his behaviour.

Last incident was yesterday….

We went food shopping, he wanted a game for his current console, I said no and tried to explained to him that he only has to wait a few more days until Xmas.

He was not happy with this, which led to him refusing to get into the car.

Faced over an hour of verbal abuse from him, before he decided he was tired and went to sleep.

As always at the end of the day, he cried apologised and said that he doesn’t like being horrible to me because he loves me, and he doesn’t know why he does it.

I’m trying my utmost best, I always praise good behaviour, what makes it worst for me is that I do not have anyone that can relate to what I’m going through.

My circle of friends have very well behaved privately educated children, which was the plan for my son, but unfortunately it hasn’t worked out like that.

I have come to terms with it, and if I am honest I am very envious of my friends children. Am I wrong for feeling like this?

We were invited out to Winter Wonderland but skipped because his behaviour can be very unpredictable, and also for my own sanity.

My son can do whatever he wants to do, and I never punish him. But I want to start drawing the line now, he needs to learn that he can’t misbehave and still get rewarded.

For Christmas his three main presents which he asked for are an two expensive Lego sets & Steam Deck console. I have purchased all of them, AIBU for wanting to hold one of the gifts back?

Thank you for listening.

(I would appreciate if people couldn’t pass judgement, if there is anything I have missed and or anything you want to ask, please feel free; but please do it with a good heart)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EmojiSadFace · 22/12/2022 13:45

@TheSandgroper

Thank you! very kind of you 🙂

OP posts:
FriedasCarLoad · 22/12/2022 13:18

I used to work in a residential setting for children with SEN, so I have just a small taste of the situation. It must be so hard.

Seeking advice on parenting children with ADHD is vital. The usual parenting strategies don't work.

Absolute consistency and the right kind of discipline are absolutely necessary. And that's going to make life harder work for you in the short term, particularly when you're on your own. But it'll be 100% worth it in the longer term.

TheSandgroper · 22/12/2022 13:12

@EmojiSadFace I’m sorry you are in this predicament. I don’t have a SN child but may I gently make one suggestion?

Most parents learn to set boundaries when their children are very young but you seem to have not done that. Perhaps a book on parenting toddlers might be a start followed by a parenting course? Something like 1-2-3 Magic is one that I know of. I don’t think you can start setting boundaries successfully until you have taken the baby steps in your own mind.

As above, asking Mumsnet to transfer this thread to www.mumsnet.com/talk/special_needs will result in better targeted replies.

EmojiSadFace · 22/12/2022 13:07

@Survey99

Great advice thank you, he has been well behaved at home today, except for at breakfast time. Didn’t want to eat his bagel because he believed that I used the same knife for the butter and crème-cheese (part of his OCD and also everything has to be spotless)

He has asked if we can go for a walk today, I said we can. Going for walks can be a big problem, if he had his own way we would stay out all day.

I try the advice given in this thread today.

OP posts:
balzamico · 22/12/2022 13:00

It's even more important to have clear rules and boundaries for a ND child than an NT one.
It won't be easy to start now but I suggest you research and look for a parenting course before he gets too much bigger

LlynTegid · 22/12/2022 12:57

I think you should, but it should not be an action in isolation, but the start of his actions having consequences.

Survey99 · 22/12/2022 12:53

EmojiSadFace · 22/12/2022 12:03

No, there’s never been any consequences or discipline. I’m a very weak parent, I find that I can only show my son love.

I am also a single parent so I don’t have anyone to step in and help me.

Showing him love is giving him firm consistent boundaries that make him feel secure. You don't need anyone to step in you need to step up.

Big knee jerk consequences like withholding Christmas presents don't work. Little ones consistently are more effective.

Everyone parents differently and every child is different, this would have worked with ds; you will need to think carefully about your ds and how his adhd affects him, but the key is always consistency.

We went food shopping, he wanted a game for his current console, I said no and tried to explained to him that he only has to wait a few more days until Xmas. - You don't need to explain - he thinks it is then open to negotiation. A simple no/not today is enough. If you are in the habit of just buying him things in a shop when he asks I would suggest stop doing that as it leaves them confused why they sometimes get things and other times they don't.

He was not happy with this, which led to him refusing to get into the car. - Calmly in low voice - "Get into the car now or no computer tonight/event tomorrow/takeaway tonight". Don't overdue the punishment, make it something he values, and always make sure you follow through every time.
Faced over an hour of verbal abuse from him, before he decided he was tired and went to sleep. - Calmly, in a quiet voice say "Do not speak to me like that or it will be no computer for 2 nights, go to your room and calm down and we will talk about it when you are calm - I will not repeat myself" Then ignore, and if he continues then tell him he just lost the computer for 2 nights.

As always at the end of the day, he cried apologised and said that he doesn’t like being horrible to me because he loves me, and he doesn’t know why he does it. - If he is calm accept his apology, discuss and ask for ideas how you can both avoid it escalating in the future - acknowledge it is normal to feel disappointed when you can't get something your want, but that is no excuse for bad behaviour. Can he maybe go to his room until he feels calm/can he accept "not today" as an answer in the shop and wait until you are home to discuss when/how he can get the new game (Xmas, birthday, save his pocket money). Whatever the outcome of your discussion the consequence for the behaviour is still followed through with.

LunaLoveFood · 22/12/2022 12:52

lollipoprainbow · 22/12/2022 12:34

Thank you too, I admit I don't give boundaries to my dd as it's often easier to give in to her demands. I'm a worn out single mum and life is bloody hard. People with NT kids just don't understand.

I don't agree with this. My ds has autism and attends an sen school that teaches children with really complex needs but also has high expectations of behaviour. They have simple rules and boundaries that are tailored to the children to ensure they are able to follow them, to help keep them safe.
It can be much more difficult and really hard work to put into place boundaries, especially when you are starting with a 9 Yr old who has never had any, but I think you would be doing him a disservice not to try.

Beautiful3 · 22/12/2022 12:46

"My son can do whatever he wants to do, and I never punish him."

That was what ruined him. All children need disciplining and set boundaries. You need to start now. If he's badly behaved, take away him gaming device and phobe for the day and night. He will soon learn.

Blinki · 22/12/2022 12:35

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

lollipoprainbow · 22/12/2022 12:34

TotteringByGenteely · 22/12/2022 12:23

Your child has been failed by their specialist school that was unable to meet their needs and must feel confused and rejected. They need you to be their safe space in a world that is extremely difficult and confusing for neurodiverse children.

Please, please don't listen to the 'boundaries brigade'. Their advice comes from a place of being parents to compliant regular, neuro-typical children. The skills and instincts that you are developing to deal with your complex child are very different; love-bombing and being sensitive to their needs is a very good place to start.

Thank you too, I admit I don't give boundaries to my dd as it's often easier to give in to her demands. I'm a worn out single mum and life is bloody hard. People with NT kids just don't understand.

OriginalUsername2 · 22/12/2022 12:34

YellowTreeHouse · 22/12/2022 12:29

For years, it’s been best for me to give and buy him what he wants, just for a quiet and easier life.

But he’s your child. Don’t you care what’s best for him?

This is the problem, sadly.

Parenting isn’t supposed to be easy and quiet. Do the hard work of discipline. You’re only doing him a disservice if you don’t teach him how to be a pleasant member of society. You want people to like him and accept him, right?

LunaLoveFood · 22/12/2022 12:32

I suggest a parenting course to help you put into place rules, boundaries, and consequences. In my area, it is standard that you complete one during any diagnosis process.
There are ones specifically for children with additional needs.
Once the rules and consequences have been put in place, expect behaviour to get worse before it gets better. He will push against them to find out if you really mean what you are saying.

JustAnotherManicNameChange · 22/12/2022 12:32

EmojiSadFace · 22/12/2022 12:03

No, there’s never been any consequences or discipline. I’m a very weak parent, I find that I can only show my son love.

I am also a single parent so I don’t have anyone to step in and help me.

That's part of the issue. You can't go from zero to nuclear.

Consequences don't mean you do the love him or being ridiculously strict or ignoring his needs.

Keep them small,simple and preferably natural. He kicks off, you need to leave or you miss the train/show. He throws something and it's broken then it goes in the bin and that's that. He can use his own money or wait for bday/xmas to replace. Refuses to wear a coat, he can be cold. He hits you, you stay away from him until he calms down. He refuses to come off the ipad when you ask, he loses the ipad (or you install controls that turn it off after a set time). That sort of stuff. Of course these are very basic examples , if you give some specific ones I can advise further.

Thing you can do to preempt meltdowns. First of all, too many choices and freedom can be very unsettling and confusing for a child with SEN. So clear boundaries, clear plan for the day and structure. Now and next prompts so he always know what's coming. Now you are on your ipad, next you will brush your teeth kind if stuff. Repeated warnings and countdowns , we are leaving in 5 minutes, 3 minutes left, we are going in a minute. Choices limited to two options that you are happy with. Would you like toast or cereal? And just repeat those options.

Sounds silly, but sometimes ending a request with thank you rather than please helps, and it tricks the child into thinking that they already agreed to it, which is why you are thanking them.

Clear,broken down instructions. Rather than "clean your room" try "put your legos in this box". Lots of praise and then another clear specific instruction.

Highly praise the behaviour you want to see. Ignore unwanted behaviours unless dangerous or upsetting for others.

None of these are magic wands , but over time it should make your life and his easier. Sometimes, you'll just have to give him the space to feel what he feels and have his meltdown.

EmojiSadFace · 22/12/2022 12:31

TotteringByGenteely
@TotteringByGenteely

Thank you so much, this is only something that parents with a SN child will understand, hence why I can’t discuss this with my friends; those with well behaved children.

OP posts:
CitronVert22 · 22/12/2022 12:30

That sounds really tough, but I don't think the answer is to remove a Christmas present. You give Christmas presents because he's your son and you love him, not as a behaviour reward. Use Christmas day as a day for you both to enjoy (even though of course it won't be perfect - and that's fine!)

But I think if you say he doesn't face consequences ever that you do need to make sure that you apply discipline properly, albeit appropriately for his SEN. Work with him to help him understand why you expect certain behaviour, as well as what. Maybe try the SEN board here for strategies.

But make punishment small and immediate, rather than grand gestures. This will help him relate behaviour to consequences.

You also say he came to you and apologised. That is good! Can you have a talk where you gently question him about how he feels in these situations and why he then behaves how he does? To try and help him work out the things that push his buttons and how he can manage himself.

Say to him that this stuff is hard! We all have to learn to manage ourselves. Books that spoke to me about this struggle as a kid were Mallory Towers with Darrell and her temper and What Katy Did with Katy changing. These may not be the books that will speak to him, but are there any books/TV/films he's already consumed that might do this for him that you could talk about? It's important that he doesn't label himself as a bad person, but as a person who is working to grow like we all are.

Approach this as a problem you work together on, rather than bad child, punishing mum as much as possible. Although there does come a time as the adult when you need to put your foot down.

Happy Christmas!

YellowTreeHouse · 22/12/2022 12:29

For years, it’s been best for me to give and buy him what he wants, just for a quiet and easier life.

But he’s your child. Don’t you care what’s best for him?

Daydreamer22 · 22/12/2022 12:29

You are blaming school for excluding him and not dealing with his behaviour yet you’ve never given him boundaries or consequences?

boobybum · 22/12/2022 12:28

Hi OP, I’d ask for this to be moved to the SN Children section if I were you. You’ll get replies from parents who have more experience of your issues there.

Dogsgottabone · 22/12/2022 12:27

OP that's so hard. ASD parent here.

But Xmas day isn't the day to start with boundaries, it really isn't.

And my advice would be to start small. That said I often give in to DS because life is easier. Where an NT child would stop asking after a while, a ND child KEEPS GOING and is relentless.

Poppyblush · 22/12/2022 12:27

Parenting is hard, harder with special needs kids, but I’m your life is hard anyway because of his behaviour. New year, new boundaries. It’s for his own good too.

TotteringByGenteely · 22/12/2022 12:23

Your child has been failed by their specialist school that was unable to meet their needs and must feel confused and rejected. They need you to be their safe space in a world that is extremely difficult and confusing for neurodiverse children.

Please, please don't listen to the 'boundaries brigade'. Their advice comes from a place of being parents to compliant regular, neuro-typical children. The skills and instincts that you are developing to deal with your complex child are very different; love-bombing and being sensitive to their needs is a very good place to start.

EmojiSadFace · 22/12/2022 12:22

lollipoprainbow
@lollipoprainbow 🤗

Everydayimhuffling
@Everydayimhuffling

Yes, I intend to get help after the Christmas break, I do not want to live like this anymore.

Poppyblush
@Poppyblush

Correct, I don’t think you understand how difficult things are for me. For years, it’s been best for me to give and buy him what he wants, just for a quiet and easier life.

OP posts:
Poppyblush · 22/12/2022 12:18

So your kid has zero consequences???? Wow! Seriously, sort this out now as you are contributing to his issues.

Everydayimhuffling · 22/12/2022 12:16

You need to put consequences in place (negative and positive), but they need to be immediate or at least the same day. What you are suggesting isn't that.

Also, having no consequences isn't showing love. It's setting him up for a really difficult and lonely life. Try to remember that when you are struggling to follow through. You may want to look for parenting classes that are specific to children with ADHD/ASD as it often requires a particular approach.