Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Performance parenting rant!

139 replies

Iwantquietargh · 22/12/2022 10:19

On the bus with 6yo child today - spent about 10 minutes explaining about being considerate to others on the bus as she was quite loud. To be fair the bus was empty up the top where we but that’s not the point.

anyway woman gets on with 2 boys between 7-9. Sat directly next to us with every other seat empty upstairs and starts being SO LOUD. changed names but all ‘Harry! Can I sit underneath you? Sit on my lap! Oh can we see this can we see that. Oh dear we forgot the library books! Are we excited for the museum?’

to add, the boys got on the bus and talked quietly between themselves. I know it’s common but my lord, SHUT UP 😂 Sorry I just needed to rant after 30 minutes of listening to that.

OP posts:
Summerbabypending · 22/12/2022 13:31

I don’t understand why people expect children to behave like adults.

Children are loud, funny, creative and imaginative. It’s sad that as a society we sit and judge children and their parents for daring to have a loud conversation or have any form of fun.

You were on a bus, not in a library. The children I see who sit quietly like little mice scared to speak to their parents in public through fear of being told they are ‘naughty’ make me very sad.

Honestly what is the point in having children and knocking the spirit out of them from day 1? Life really is not that serious.

LonginesPrime · 22/12/2022 13:31

OP, I can see how it must feel a bit annoying when you're trying to teach your child "this is how you should behave on public transport" and another parent appears and encourages the thing you're trying to guide your child away from, but that doesn't mean the other parent is doing something wrong, despite the fact you've taught your child that she would be in the wrong to behave that way.

It's like when parents have rules on limiting sweets or fizzy drinks and another child is allowed them - it's awkward and can feel like one parent's choice is a direct criticism of the other's, but ultimately, people just have different values, and that's a useful lesson for children to learn too.

pandarific · 22/12/2022 13:29

Sounds to me like SHE’S excited? To be with them, to be off work for Christmas, to be taking them off to the museum…

op really - chilllll.

Snowpaw · 22/12/2022 13:26

I mean...I will definitely carry on talking to my daughter when I take her on the bus. Some of the most interesting things we see are on our bus rides. I enjoy our bus chats.

Thepeopleversuswork · 22/12/2022 13:19

Blueeyedgirl21 · 22/12/2022 13:07

You’ll get loads of people on here saying it’s just communication with your kids etc but everyone can tell the difference between LOOK A PTERODACTYL CAN YOU SAY PTERODACTYL WOW YES CAN YOU SAY IT IN MANDARIN VERY GOOD ATTICUS NOW HERES YOUR ORGANIC FLAX SEED SMOOTHIE and ‘wow look a pterodactyl, that’s cool isn’t it! Do you want a little drink?’

So basically what you are saying is that middle class people should shut the fuck up in public?

I have come across people like the (overdone) stereotype you paint here and yes they can be a bit cringe, but no worse than loud parents from other social demographics.

But why is it incumbent on people like this to self censor and not people who would be shouting at their kids to shut up, sit down and have another packet of crisps?

I really think if you unpick this most of it boils down to people feeling insecure about other people who they suspect may be parenting their children more actively. It makes you feel shit about yourself because you want to sit staring at your phone in silence. Instead of having a go at other people who actually do engage with their kids why can’t you learn from them?

audeloquipalam · 22/12/2022 13:15

Blueeyedgirl21 · 22/12/2022 13:07

You’ll get loads of people on here saying it’s just communication with your kids etc but everyone can tell the difference between LOOK A PTERODACTYL CAN YOU SAY PTERODACTYL WOW YES CAN YOU SAY IT IN MANDARIN VERY GOOD ATTICUS NOW HERES YOUR ORGANIC FLAX SEED SMOOTHIE and ‘wow look a pterodactyl, that’s cool isn’t it! Do you want a little drink?’

Exactly

audeloquipalam · 22/12/2022 13:13

The MN reading middle class Uber-mums coaching Tabitha and Ivor don’t bother me. It’s Tracey “I love my kids, I do…” parenting little Dwayne from 50 yards away at 100db thats gets a bit irritating.

Blueeyedgirl21 · 22/12/2022 13:07

You’ll get loads of people on here saying it’s just communication with your kids etc but everyone can tell the difference between LOOK A PTERODACTYL CAN YOU SAY PTERODACTYL WOW YES CAN YOU SAY IT IN MANDARIN VERY GOOD ATTICUS NOW HERES YOUR ORGANIC FLAX SEED SMOOTHIE and ‘wow look a pterodactyl, that’s cool isn’t it! Do you want a little drink?’

Nowhereelsetogo90 · 22/12/2022 13:06

What a weird thing to get upset about! You’d hate my family! DSD speaks 24/7 about things that people like you would call “performing” and loves museums, libraries, etc.

CovertImage · 22/12/2022 13:05

Hugasauras · 22/12/2022 10:37

I suspect it was the volume rather than the content OP is referring to.

It very obviously was. I don't know why people are ignoring this

Giggorata · 22/12/2022 13:04

FancyFanny · 22/12/2022 11:29

"Can I sit underneath you?" Eh?
I've never heard anyone say that before, such a strange thing to say!

I was going to post just this. My DC are adults - is it a new thing?

WarmWinterSun · 22/12/2022 13:03

I can’t get on board with judging a parent who is talking to her children on the bus. How odd to take offence. I don’t catch the bus often, and neither do my kids, and on the odd occasion we do catch the bus we are often a bit excited as it may be for a special trip. We possibly could inadvertently annoy someone but that would be their problem and not mine.

purpledalmation · 22/12/2022 13:00

I'd have got up after 5 minutes and gone upstairs or at least moved as far away as possible.

Blackeyesbluetears · 22/12/2022 12:59

@Dancingdragonhiddentiger I was going to say that about the autism 😆 you should see the sheer effort it takes me to get my autistic child around the supermarket. And he struggles with auditory processing so I have to be louder than background noise and have to be repetitive

Devoutspoken · 22/12/2022 12:57

I travel alot on public transport with kids and generally we're all pretty self contained and quiet

ShimmeringShirts · 22/12/2022 12:55

So fucking tired of people calling someone talking loudly performance parenting. I have to talk loudly to mine, one has reduced hearing and the other has ASD and will not respond if I talk in a low tone. Get over yourself OP and maybe focus on raising your own child.

TheNoodlesIncident · 22/12/2022 12:54

I used to spend our commute time on teaching DS social skills via acting out some story with small toys, like Matchbox cars. I'd be working on very basic things like car A meets car B, what does he say to car B? And so on. All the time I had a mental thread running where I hoped to hell nobody was listening to us saying "Hello car B! Have you run out of petrol? I can give you some of mine!" (Greetings, sharing and being kind) or "Hi there car A! How are you? Is your sore exhaust better?" (Greetings and showing care) I did always try to reassure myself that nobody was listening and nobody gave a stuff, but then I read threads like this and have that doubt again.

Secondary school kids shouting and swearing on the bus, yes. Someone being aggressive with someone else, yes. Mother engaging with her children about their day's plans? Nope nope nope. Even if she's hoping someone's listening and thinking what a great parent she is, it's still not remotely crime-like and worthy of anyone's attention. Stop being so judgy, we're all just getting by in our own way.

PennyRa · 22/12/2022 12:52

Molytol · 22/12/2022 12:41

People who sulk about 'performance parenting' have to have the biggest egos going.

"Is this parent interacting with their child for good reason? No, it must be for my benefit!"

This, and I've never understood what the supposed performance parent would get out of it

Thepeopleversuswork · 22/12/2022 12:45

Molytol · 22/12/2022 12:41

People who sulk about 'performance parenting' have to have the biggest egos going.

"Is this parent interacting with their child for good reason? No, it must be for my benefit!"

I know it’s such an egotistical and miserly approach to life.

It also takes as its starting point the idea that there’s something unusual and exhibitionist about having a pleasant conversation with your children. Such a mean minded and depressing outlook on life.

I’m not going to apologise to randoms on public transport for the fact that I like talking to my kid and less still am I going to shut her up because other people who don’t want to talk to their kids are going to feel insecure about their shortcomings.

Molytol · 22/12/2022 12:41

People who sulk about 'performance parenting' have to have the biggest egos going.

"Is this parent interacting with their child for good reason? No, it must be for my benefit!"

Haydugee · 22/12/2022 12:41

I'm not claiming to never have found a loud middle class parent irritating but what has happened here - presumably inadvertently - is that your daughter has been taught to take up as little space (including aural space) as possible in a public place and her sons have been taught they are allowed to take up space in a public place. All the kids will have witnessed this. Thus the world turns and who ends up ruling it?

Seems a bit of a leap as the OP says the boys were chatting quietly and it was their DM who was being loud, ergo a woman taking up the space, no?

Calphurnia88 · 22/12/2022 12:36

YesIReallyDoLikeRootBeer · 22/12/2022 11:07

So you get to decide what is and is not necessary in regards to how another woman interacts with her children?

This.

Although if we are going to go there, I find a ten minute conversation about bus etiquette more unusual behaviour.

PennyRa · 22/12/2022 12:33

It's far, far stranger to make your child sit in silence than trying to interact with them about their day.

Thepeopleversuswork · 22/12/2022 12:33

So your child was loud and then her children were loud…. What’s the difference and why does her interaction with her children constitute “performance parenting” while you’re involved disciplining them?

To be honest most of the time when people complain about “performance parenting” it usually boils down to inverse snobbery (people being irrationally irritated with references to museums and such) and people objecting to parenting which involves people speaking to their children as opposed to sitting in grim silence.

I would put money on the idea that had she come on the bus and talked about taking her kids to a phone shop or an Argos you wouldn’t have posted about it.

This is a you problem OP. If her taking her kids to museums and libraries makes you feel insecure do something about it rather than bitching about her on the internet.

NightTerrors · 22/12/2022 12:32

I can speak quite loudly without realising I do really try not too but I have some hearing difficulties/sensory processing issues so if there is background noise like the engine humming or other noises around me I compensate for that even when other people say they can't hear the noise I'm referring too. It could be that the woman had similar issues and just didn't realise how loud she sounded. I do talk to my children and point things out though so maybe I'm one of those parents 😳.