Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Wedding Troubles - Best Man & Wife

190 replies

GuestlistTrouble · 22/12/2022 10:12

DF and I are planning our wedding in summer next year and have run into an issue with his best man (BM). Or maybe we have, I'm not sure!

When BM met his wife a few years ago, we didn't get on very well. He had just dated a string of fairly unstable women and to be honest, we thought she was just another one and would sooner or later disappear from our friendship group again. So we didn't have the best start with her. they got engaged then married, and all in all, it was fine. We saw each other every couple of months and felt we were getting on okay, despite her being really quite different from us, but we tried.

Then, just before Covid hit, we had an argument and she hasn't spoken to us since. Blocked us on social media and we can't see any of her profiles. BM is still friends with us but has said his wife feels she has "given us enough second chances" and refuses to talk to us. Which was fine until now, as BM really wants her to come to the wedding with him. There will be mutual friends of ours from school and I think he is worried about the awkward conversations, and also just nervous about attending the wedding on his own. We have invited his wife but thus far she is refusing to come.

Should we try to get her number from BM to talk to her or do you think that would make it worse? And if we call her, what do you even say if she picks up?!

(been on and off of Mumsnet for a few years - new account as I deleted the last one after one of the data breaches)

OP posts:
NotSoInvisible · 22/12/2022 12:32

GuestlistTrouble · 22/12/2022 12:24

There is only me and one other woman in our friendship group, so we used to be expected to welcome and include any girlfriends. I don't know why, it is just how it worked out. The guys are all straight, I have been with DF since school and the other woman in our group is my best friend and chronically single, so I don't know if it would have been different with a male partner.

For those of you accusing me of racism, we are all white, just different cultural backgrounds.

So the two queen bees didn’t want anyone other females in the group?

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 22/12/2022 12:31

GuestlistTrouble · 22/12/2022 12:24

There is only me and one other woman in our friendship group, so we used to be expected to welcome and include any girlfriends. I don't know why, it is just how it worked out. The guys are all straight, I have been with DF since school and the other woman in our group is my best friend and chronically single, so I don't know if it would have been different with a male partner.

For those of you accusing me of racism, we are all white, just different cultural backgrounds.

Because most people are nice and welcome others. You aren't a kind person at all. You don't see why you should be welcoming to partners, it's not high school. Friendship groups change

RampantIvy · 22/12/2022 12:30

The argument was about a different friend's new girlfriend. We were discussing whether to invite friend's new girlfriend to a gig or not and BM's wife insisted we should invite her and just let the two of them decide, even though none of us liked the girl. It kicked up some dust and she went on about how we treated her like this in the beginning and that she never got an apology.

The thing is, I'm not even sure what to apologise for. Yes, we could have made more of an effort to include her in conversations at the start but I feel that really should have been BM's job when he introduced her to the group. He expected us to welcome someone new every couple of weeks and include them when, to be honest, I and DF just wanted a chilled night out with close friends. It was hard work for us but sounds as if most would have found it easier.

It is not as if we were the only people there, there are 7 of us who all became friends at school/uni.

All this comes across as a very cliquey, closed and unwelcoming social group. How can you not see this? You are incredibly socially unaware, racist and not very nice. I belong to a few different social groups and always make new people feel welcome. TBH I’m surprised you have any friends at all.

I'm just not very good in social situations

Clearly Hmm
Every time you post you are digging yourself into a deeper hole. Why did you ask this guy to be best man if you knew this would be a problem? And why is it her fault that you thought she was just the latest in a long list of short term “relationships”. It’s the best man who doesn’t come off well here.

There is only me and one other woman in our friendship group, so we used to be expected to welcome and include any girlfriends.

Why is that a problem? How on earth will you cope if you have children and have to advocate for them?

Is this a reverse?

DrSmoot · 22/12/2022 12:30

GuestlistTrouble · 22/12/2022 11:17

The thing is, I'm not even sure what to apologise for. Yes, we could have made more of an effort to include her in conversations at the start but I feel that really should have been BM's job when he introduced her to the group. He expected us to welcome someone new every couple of weeks and include them when, to be honest, I and DF just wanted a chilled night out with close friends. It was hard work for us but sounds as if most would have found it easier.

JFC.
Still not getting that you are the issue.
It’s not just that ‘most would have found it easier’ it’s just that decent human beings would make someone feel welcome, not treat them the way you did.

LolaMoon · 22/12/2022 12:29

GuestlistTrouble · 22/12/2022 12:24

There is only me and one other woman in our friendship group, so we used to be expected to welcome and include any girlfriends. I don't know why, it is just how it worked out. The guys are all straight, I have been with DF since school and the other woman in our group is my best friend and chronically single, so I don't know if it would have been different with a male partner.

For those of you accusing me of racism, we are all white, just different cultural backgrounds.

I think some self reflection would be good here looking at why literally ALL the girlfriends in your group are labelled as "unstable" or "difficult" when the men's behaviour is far from stellar either yet that is not commented upon. Even if you arent inherently racist, surely you could see how that might come across as racist to person joining your group from a different ethnicity/cultural background who has maybe experienced racism in the past and now gets the cold shoulder from yet another group of people? some empathy would not go amiss here

JauntyJinty · 22/12/2022 12:29

Lockheart · 22/12/2022 12:18

Probably "hypocrisy" too.

While we're doing that maybe you can read up on false equivalence?

NotSoInvisible · 22/12/2022 12:28

How is OP getting people deleted for talking about their own experience with a similar situation? A pp said they had been in a similar situation and called the people in that group ‘cunts’ but it’s been deleted.

Get a grip OP, and mumsnet moderators. Virtually everyone here agrees OP and he’d gang of bullies are the issue.

You’ve behaved appallingly OP. You need to own up to the horrible, bitchy behaviour and apologise. I wouldn’t want anything to do with any of you. I’d question my husband wanting to be part of the bully gang too.

BatshitBanshee · 22/12/2022 12:27

GuestlistTrouble · 22/12/2022 12:24

There is only me and one other woman in our friendship group, so we used to be expected to welcome and include any girlfriends. I don't know why, it is just how it worked out. The guys are all straight, I have been with DF since school and the other woman in our group is my best friend and chronically single, so I don't know if it would have been different with a male partner.

For those of you accusing me of racism, we are all white, just different cultural backgrounds.

So.... Xenophobia?

Cool. That's better then.

toastofthetown · 22/12/2022 12:26

For those of you accusing me of racism, we are all white, just different cultural backgrounds.

So not racist, but xenophobic. Splendid.

WisherWood · 22/12/2022 12:26

We were discussing whether to invite friend's new girlfriend to a gig or not and BM's wife insisted we should invite her and just let the two of them decide, even though none of us liked the girl. It kicked up some dust and she went on about how we treated her like this in the beginning and that she never got an apology.

So basically she had to stand there and listen to exactly the kind of conversation you had previously had about her? I mean it must have been quite an eye opener for her. I think you have to leave it, OP. You've invited her, she's said no. It's up to the BM whether he actually wants to come along or not. But if he doesn't, do be a bit careful about choosing a second best man. 'Hi John, we're not really besties but our actually bestie, James, doesn't want to play with us any more because we were mean to his wife, please will you be best man, you're only our second choice' is not likely to go down too well.

SaveMeCheezus · 22/12/2022 12:26

God this is all so weird. So BM acts like an absolute player continually turning up to things with his girlfriend of the week and yet it's the Women in the scenario that were the problem for you, not the BM who was your existing friend and yet apparently had no concern for your boundaries or your new-girlfriend fatigue?

It's not difficult to be nice to someone new in ANY situation though, never mind a group getting together socially. Sounds like you just didn't like new Women muscling in on 'your' Men?

I suspect this Woman has the measure of you all (except perhaps her DH, who doesn't exactly leave this situation covered in glory himself) and honestly I don't blame her for not wanting to go to your wedding if it'll be full of like-minded mean girls.

Lochroy · 22/12/2022 12:25

Lockheart · 22/12/2022 12:17

The gag of posters piling on to kick OP, talking about bitchy cliques and making personal attacks really need to take a good look in the mirror and then look up "irony" in the dictionary.

Er, no. This is a discussion forum amongst a bunch of random strangers and the OP chose to post in AIBU which is known for pointing out harsh truths. Sometimes the most/only effective way for an OP to see a different point of view is to realise that either there is a different point of view, or that theirs is the minority view.

I get your point, and it would be different if we were all pals sitting around together but we're not.

GuestlistTrouble · 22/12/2022 12:24

There is only me and one other woman in our friendship group, so we used to be expected to welcome and include any girlfriends. I don't know why, it is just how it worked out. The guys are all straight, I have been with DF since school and the other woman in our group is my best friend and chronically single, so I don't know if it would have been different with a male partner.

For those of you accusing me of racism, we are all white, just different cultural backgrounds.

OP posts:
Mari9999 · 22/12/2022 12:24

You have issued an invitation, it is up to her to accept or decline the invitation. If her husband has issues they she be discussed with his wife rather than you.

Your group as a whole seems fairly judgemental, but that is how we make friends by judging the fit between us and the person in question.

She is neither rewarding you tor punishing you with her decision. You have done your part and now it is up to her.I would not invest anymore head space on this issue. Within a year, she may change her mind several times.

Milkand2sugarsplease · 22/12/2022 12:22

What the bloody hell does BM want you to do if you've invited her anyway. You can't force her to come any more than he can. In fact? He's probably got more chance than you of getting her to come along. Though, if I were you, I'm not sure I'd want her there.

whynotwhatknot · 22/12/2022 12:20

sorry id feel the same-but if he feels uncfortmable about going on is own he shoud pull out of being bm

TedMullins · 22/12/2022 12:19

You and your whole clique sound awful. What kind of 20something at uni finds it “hard” to accommodate someone else in the group? So what if previous women were just casual dates, you must have had a very different uni experience to me because nights out were basically a free for all for whoever wanted to join in. And your further excuses about why you were so standoffish and rude to this poor woman are just racist.

seriously, get over yourself. It doesn’t matter if you THINK you haven’t hurt her feelings - you have. Apologise and learn how to behave like an adult around people.

ABBAsnumberonefan · 22/12/2022 12:19

GingerScallop · 22/12/2022 11:40

You were judgemental, excluded her, didn't think she was worth the effort (and there was me thinking every human is worth some effort) and now you don't know what to apologise for? So happy she values herself enough to cut off toxic discriminating people. BM dated 6-7 women in quick succession and a woman was punished for that? And the other women branded unstable? How. Have you considered that may be BM was the dickhead in these relationships? Or may be since you were all so young, everyone was just having fun? No, it's all the fault of the women. Wow Just wow

100% this! You have a lot to apologise for actually OP.

LolaMoon · 22/12/2022 12:18

ps assume it’s only the new women to the group that get the cold shoulder and all your male partners are totally welcomed right? Thought so

This.

Lockheart · 22/12/2022 12:18

Probably "hypocrisy" too.

Lockheart · 22/12/2022 12:17

The gag of posters piling on to kick OP, talking about bitchy cliques and making personal attacks really need to take a good look in the mirror and then look up "irony" in the dictionary.

ThirtyThreeTrees · 22/12/2022 12:17

I have a really strong suspicious that this woman is really pretty and has a lovely personality and you viewed this as a threat and that jealousy was a motivator for your behaviour.

Thedoglovesmemore · 22/12/2022 12:13

FetchezLaVache · 22/12/2022 11:42

Explain to her as you have to us

Oh, great idea.

"Florence, I know we treated you so badly at the beginning, but we assumed you were just John's latest shagpiece and couldn't be arsed to make the effort to be nice to you or even remember your name. It's nothing personal, we just like to police other women's membership of our special little friendship group, as you know from when we fell out over inviting Jade to that gig. Anyway, we didn't really do anything wrong as it was obviously on John, not us, to ensure that you were included in conversations. But anyway babes, I'm now a bit worried that people will think it's strange if the BM's wife isn't at our wedding, so I'd like to extend the opportunity for you to get over yourself and accept the invitation."

That should do the trick!

This is the speech to use
Absolves you from any responsibility.

You could add that you are a bit of a gentle flower who doesn’t like newbies in the group and your husband has to protect you from these newbies so that’s why you were both so cold. And the other new girlfriend you were discussing how much you don’t like and should therefore exclude was totally ok as she’s horrid and not suitable for your special group and no way should that trigger BMs wife to recall exactly how you treated her.

and of course she should get over it and come to the wedding so you don’t look like rude mean people. Only make sure she relegates herself again after the wedding as you don’t actually want to hang out with her.

job done! Champagne anyone?

ps assume it’s only the new women to the group that get the cold shoulder and all your male partners are totally welcomed right? Thought so.

Lochjeda · 22/12/2022 12:12

No would I fuck even of invited her in the first place. You done your part she said she's not coming, end of. Dont pander to her this is your wedding and you are letting her make it about her. She can get to fuck. If her husband wants her there he can talk her round.

Campervangirl · 22/12/2022 12:12

No, no, no don't leave her alone, you need to apologise for what really is shitty behavior.
You recognise that you treated her badly in the beginning, you've argued with her regarding your unwelcoming treatment of another new partner into your friendship group (there's a pattern emerging here, can you see it?) which has clearly hit a nerve with BM DW.
Then you actually expect BM to attend your wedding alone after your treatment of his DW, he's expected to rock up and celebrate with people who have no respect for her, whilst she sits at home.
If I was the BM I wouldn't attend at all.
Do the right thing op, apologise, recognise your bad behavior in the apology and don't add a BUT . . . . .

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread