Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Wedding Troubles - Best Man & Wife

190 replies

GuestlistTrouble · 22/12/2022 10:12

DF and I are planning our wedding in summer next year and have run into an issue with his best man (BM). Or maybe we have, I'm not sure!

When BM met his wife a few years ago, we didn't get on very well. He had just dated a string of fairly unstable women and to be honest, we thought she was just another one and would sooner or later disappear from our friendship group again. So we didn't have the best start with her. they got engaged then married, and all in all, it was fine. We saw each other every couple of months and felt we were getting on okay, despite her being really quite different from us, but we tried.

Then, just before Covid hit, we had an argument and she hasn't spoken to us since. Blocked us on social media and we can't see any of her profiles. BM is still friends with us but has said his wife feels she has "given us enough second chances" and refuses to talk to us. Which was fine until now, as BM really wants her to come to the wedding with him. There will be mutual friends of ours from school and I think he is worried about the awkward conversations, and also just nervous about attending the wedding on his own. We have invited his wife but thus far she is refusing to come.

Should we try to get her number from BM to talk to her or do you think that would make it worse? And if we call her, what do you even say if she picks up?!

(been on and off of Mumsnet for a few years - new account as I deleted the last one after one of the data breaches)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Rogue1001MNer · 22/12/2022 16:19

It's bullying.

The majority of posters on here. Bullying

ImaniMumsnet · 22/12/2022 16:19

Hi everyone,

We are closing this thread now as we've had a few reports and would like to take a closer look.

WisherWood · 22/12/2022 16:01

Iudncuewbccgrcb · 22/12/2022 14:30

So many deletions on this thread!

I'd be surprised if they don't pull it, to be honest. I wouldn't blame the OP if she didn't come back. It's one thing pointing out that she and her friends seem cliquey, quite another accusing her of narcissism and whatever else has been slung at her.

Rogue1001MNer · 22/12/2022 15:53

@Lockheart 👊🌟
@GuestlistTrouble 💐

REGARDLESS of who is right or wrong in the scenario, one of the nastiest threads I've read on here.
It's like sharks smelling blood in the water

Posters lining up to make the nastiest comments

It's shameful

DilemmaADay · 22/12/2022 15:05

I have also experienced this and its so mean and unkind. If you truly care about someone, you would make an effort to include the person they love. I have also found that such cliques dont last long term with these kinds of negative attitudes. If someone is prone to being unkind, then they are unkind by nature and eventually it will seep out and affect their "friends". Most cliques that operate like this implode due to their own bitchiness and back stabbing tendencies.

@Thighlengthboots It's so uncomfortable isn't it. It's strange because they're all nice enough to me and buy me birthday presents, but they just don't seem to have a genuine interest in anyone's lives beyond gossip. I never get asked how's work/family/pets/kids etc. I genuinely feel like they have absolutely no idea about who I am as a person, but yet again I feel like they don't really ask those sort of questions of each other either. I genuinely don't think I've encountered a more difficult to connect with group of people before.

gannett · 22/12/2022 14:41

Dying to know the nature of these "cultural differences"

2bazookas · 22/12/2022 14:40

I would not contact her. Give BM a deadline to confirm if he will attend wedding or does the groom need to find a replacement BM.

.
Married couples are not joined at the hip; it's perfectly easy for one to attend a wedding alone ; if asked all he needs say to other guests is that she was working/ unwell/ visiting her mother.

dontputitthere · 22/12/2022 14:40

Oh diddums.

Not sure why my post was deleted.

Just pointed out how unbelievable the ops behaviour was

It's become a pile because unlike most normal People with some sort of empathy and understanding when confronted with some harsh truths can take that on board she has continued this tale of oh woe is me, I excluded her and made her feel shit along with every other person who attempts to join our 'group' I don't know what I should be apologising for.

Hope the BM also pulls out.

Team BMs wife!

Iudncuewbccgrcb · 22/12/2022 14:30

So many deletions on this thread!

purpledalmation · 22/12/2022 14:20

You and your friends sound like immature school kids. Adults don't make snap judgements then argue about them with someone with a different opinion.

JustKittenAround · 22/12/2022 14:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

KatherineJaneway · 22/12/2022 14:08

She should not come to your wedding. The purpose of attending a wedding to to celebrate the day with the bride and groom. She doesn't speak to either of you and doesn't want to know you, so she would be off my guest list.

Also, if the BM is a grown ass man, he can attend one social function on his own surely? He can just tell anyone who asks that his partner couldn't make the wedding.

AndEverWhoKnew · 22/12/2022 13:57

You were in the wrong and you haven't taken responsibility or apologised. Tbh I'm also surprised that her DH has agreed to be BM when you were so unwelcoming to her. It isn't a lot of effort to be nice to someone especially when there are only two other women in the group and you have a long-established dynamic. That actually makes it easier to welcome someone else in.

Your posts don't show any understanding of what you did. If you take time to reflect and realise you do in fact owe her an apology (saying you now behave better has no impact at all on what you did to her - it doesn't undo it) then it might be better to put the apology in writing. From your posts on here, I think a call would probably end up in another argument because you are not taking responsibility well.

Coffeeandcake15 · 22/12/2022 13:56

You don’t sound like pleasant people anyway, if I was her, I’d stay well away.

DucklingDaisy · 22/12/2022 13:55

burnoutbabe · 22/12/2022 13:48

Agreed.

And it sounds like the blokes just bring a new lady along and "turn her over" for the women to make small talk with. The other blokes don't bother, so all socialising is heaped on the 2 existing females. Who get bored of the role after a while and want to just have a chilled time with their mates.
M

But no, women should be kind. The op here is blamed for the whole group, including bm and op's bloke not including gf satisfactorily.

They were having a meeting about whether someone's partner should be invited to a gig or not.

burnoutbabe · 22/12/2022 13:48

whiteroseredrose · 22/12/2022 13:02

I don't think you sound nasty.

Some people are 'the more the merrier' some prefer a smaller group.

OP has already said that she is quiet and that the DW has a confrontational personality which I would find exhausting. And it sounds like the OP is the same.

So to those that would be terribly welcoming to everyone whether you like them or not, good for you.

But with limited free time, I'd much rather not spend it with someone argumentative. Just my nice comfortable group.

Agreed.

And it sounds like the blokes just bring a new lady along and "turn her over" for the women to make small talk with. The other blokes don't bother, so all socialising is heaped on the 2 existing females. Who get bored of the role after a while and want to just have a chilled time with their mates.
M

But no, women should be kind. The op here is blamed for the whole group, including bm and op's bloke not including gf satisfactorily.

Thighlengthboots · 22/12/2022 13:46

DilemmaADay · 22/12/2022 13:39

God, your group sounds a lot like the first time I met DHs friends in a pub. There was a mixed group of men and women and I might as well have not been there, they spent all evening cracking in-jokes and having conversations that I was unable to get involved in (talking about friends of friends I had no idea about). Even to have been asked one question as an opening would have made the world of difference. I left the pub that night almost in tears thinking it was a 'me' problem. Since seeing how how they treat DH now as an outsider I realized it's very much a 'them' problem. They are a clique of very boring dull people and when we go to meet ups it's like been sat with the Royale Family. They even talk like them, just no effort, energy or social skills between them.

I couldn't stand them for a long time and if it wasn't for DHs feelings I'd have probably had nothing to do with them either.

Yabu

I have also experienced this and its so mean and unkind. If you truly care about someone, you would make an effort to include the person they love. I have also found that such cliques dont last long term with these kinds of negative attitudes. If someone is prone to being unkind, then they are unkind by nature and eventually it will seep out and affect their "friends". Most cliques that operate like this implode due to their own bitchiness and back stabbing tendencies.

Honeyroar · 22/12/2022 13:45

whiteroseredrose · 22/12/2022 13:02

I don't think you sound nasty.

Some people are 'the more the merrier' some prefer a smaller group.

OP has already said that she is quiet and that the DW has a confrontational personality which I would find exhausting. And it sounds like the OP is the same.

So to those that would be terribly welcoming to everyone whether you like them or not, good for you.

But with limited free time, I'd much rather not spend it with someone argumentative. Just my nice comfortable group.

That’s fine. But don’t then expect these people you’ve not socialised with or welcomed to be over the moon at being invited to your wedding. And don’t expect things to go smoothly when the people you’re snubbing become partners and spouses to people from your little social group…

notsorich · 22/12/2022 13:43

It sounds like you're quite content to have the same friendship group since school, and you find it difficult to adjust to new people. Your friend had a string of girlfriends, and rightly or wrongly, you gave up trying to befriend them as they kept disappearing from your life, and it felt like a waste of effort. I can understand why you felt that way, but I don't condone what you actually did.

Maybe your friend wasn't very nice to all these women. Maybe he introduced them to his friendship group too soon. Maybe you should have made more of an effort. Maybe your other friends in the group should have tried harder too.

There are lots of maybes there, but the one clear thing is that this woman didn't do anything wrong. Her (then) boyfriend introduced her to his friends, and they didn't try to integrate her. She felt rejected, which was the correct response, given she was being rejected.

You never apologised for any of this, bumbled along, and then tried to push out a new partner from the friendship group in front of her. I'm not surprised she snapped. She could see that you definitely hadn't changed since you mistreated her.

Would you even be trying to build bridges if your fiance didn't want her husband to be his best man? (Not that I think you're really trying to build bridges very well.) Or are you reaching out now because you want something (her husband to be there)? Do you even care if she doesn't go? Do you only care because her husband doesn't want to go alone?

If you don't give a shiny shit as to whether she turns up to your wedding, as long as your fiance gets his choice of best man, you have to appreciate there is no reason why she should want to attend, and there is no reason why her husband should want to attend, knowing how you feel about his wife.

Forget the wedding. You either want to apologise and integrate her into your life, or you don't.

DilemmaADay · 22/12/2022 13:39

God, your group sounds a lot like the first time I met DHs friends in a pub. There was a mixed group of men and women and I might as well have not been there, they spent all evening cracking in-jokes and having conversations that I was unable to get involved in (talking about friends of friends I had no idea about). Even to have been asked one question as an opening would have made the world of difference. I left the pub that night almost in tears thinking it was a 'me' problem. Since seeing how how they treat DH now as an outsider I realized it's very much a 'them' problem. They are a clique of very boring dull people and when we go to meet ups it's like been sat with the Royale Family. They even talk like them, just no effort, energy or social skills between them.

I couldn't stand them for a long time and if it wasn't for DHs feelings I'd have probably had nothing to do with them either.

Yabu

Par91 · 22/12/2022 13:39

GuestlistTrouble · 22/12/2022 10:57

We have gotten much better about inviting new partners since the argument, it is not as if we have not recognised that we have some fault in this!

We were all quite young when BM met his wife, early 20s, and yes, in hindsight, we didn't do great. I just find it difficult that she can't seem to see that we have changed and move on.

@GuestlistTrouble but she has moved on - without your clique!

You sound awfully entitled
Leave the woman alone.

Actions = consequences.

WonderingWanda · 22/12/2022 13:35

It's her choice if she doesn't want to come. Your best man sounds a bit wet if he is worrying about attending his best mates wedding alone. Is he a wet blanket or is this a case that his dw isn't going to let him come and he doesn't know how to tell you because of course that would show him to be in a controlling relationship and be a victim and he isn't ready to admit that?

Tell him you are sorry she refused to come but you would still love him to be there let him get involved in the seating plan and have a back up best man in line.

LolaMoon · 22/12/2022 13:34

whiteroseredrose · 22/12/2022 13:02

I don't think you sound nasty.

Some people are 'the more the merrier' some prefer a smaller group.

OP has already said that she is quiet and that the DW has a confrontational personality which I would find exhausting. And it sounds like the OP is the same.

So to those that would be terribly welcoming to everyone whether you like them or not, good for you.

But with limited free time, I'd much rather not spend it with someone argumentative. Just my nice comfortable group.

Really? so if one of your friends met someone they really liked you'd refuse to engage with them, refuse to talk to them and and insist they didnt come along to your "nice comfortable group"? Your group doesnt sound that "nice" TBH.

Eddielizzard · 22/12/2022 13:30

Stravaig · 22/12/2022 11:55

Too many people seem to think that when you wrong someone, you wait a while, and then the next step is that they forgive you, and that if they don't, then they are at fault for 'holding a grudge' or 'refusing to move on'. No, no, no.

Here are the steps when you've wronged someone:
Acknowledge what you did, with no excuses or equivocation.
Apologise, sincerely and wholeheartedly.
Make amends in whatever way is appropriate.
Ask for their forgiveness. (They do not have to give it.)

Have you done all of this, OP? Any of it?

Yes this!!

You're a mean girl in a mean girl's clique.

If you really absorb and understand what people are saying, take it to heart and go from there you have a chance of healing this awful hurt. I'm surprised her DH is happy to be your DH's BM tbh.

Whatever you feel inside - social anxiety / shyness / whatever - please be aware that that isn't how you come across. Have a really good think and be absolutely honest with yourself about all this, and your part in it.

Sandra1984 · 22/12/2022 13:27

Eatingjumper · 22/12/2022 10:18

You've invited her, that's all you need to do. Don't make it more of a drama than it already is. She'll either come or she won't.

This. Why are you forcing a person into doing something she doesn't want to and has clearly stated? Why are you not respecting her wishes, why it has to be your way or the highway here? I'm starting to see why she cut loose from you...

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.