Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If clinicians can be drafted in to answer 999 calls today…

31 replies

Treedecsandtinsel · 21/12/2022 20:48

If clinicians were able to be drafted in today to answer 999 calls today during the paramedic strike, AIBU to think the government could have taken the same action earlier when we started to see ambulances stuck outside hospitals and no-one available to get to other emergencies?

I stopped to chat to some paramedics on the picket line at my local ambulance station today. They wanted to be clear that they had been responding to calls when needed but that they are certain that having clinicians answering 999 calls has helped to manage the calls coming through to them. So they asked why on earth that wasn’t arranged before?

AIBU to think that this government has just shown that it has been sitting about watching the ambulance lines getting longer and longer when more could have been done?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ihavedogs · 22/12/2022 08:30

Namenic · 22/12/2022 06:24

I agree with @SavoirFlair . The nhs is in a spiral of lack of retention, which causes understaffed shifts which means work is worse for those who remain (encouraging them to leave or retire early).

The underlying issue is retention of experienced staff. Juniors prefer to work in a system where they are properly supervised and trained so that they can deliver a good service. Seniors prefer to work in a system where they have enough time to train juniors and keep up their skills with CPD and discuss hard issues with their senior colleagues rather than being asked to make a million different decisions because they are asked to cover the work of several people.

nhs has fewer doctors and nurses and hospital beds per capita than many developed countries. We are objectively under-staffed. Under-staffing contributes to inefficiency because over-burdened people ‘push’ work they could have solved to others (as they have no time/energy). I used to work in nhs.

This!!!!!!!!!

I am ex NHS and for me it was the working practice and lack of support that made me walk away. Retention is a huge issue along with the constant reorganisations. I lost count of how many reorganisations we had since 2013, how many times I had to reapply for my own job, how many times I was prevented from getting on and doing the job I was paid to do and how many excess hours I worked for no extra pay. I never lost sight of we were there for the benefit of patients but sadly within the chaos I knew that patients were not getting what they deserved. I just couldn’t do it any more.

LakieLady · 22/12/2022 08:24

Afterthought: and they need to bring back training bursaries too, and write off student debt after, eg 10 years' NHS service.

BewareTheBeardedDragon · 22/12/2022 08:23

Actually we had hospital managers musing about “how many more discharges” we had during the junior doctors’ strike, and insinuating it would be better if we got rid of “inefficient” junior doctors altogether and just had consultants delivering the service. Heard similar comments from patients too.

The point about the effect on other services to having consultants writing discharge letters and putting in cannulas had to be made pretty strongly.

If this is true then one really has to wonder about the intelligence of these hospital managers. How do they think people become consultants? Magically, presumably. They magically pop into existence, fully trained and with years of experience. And junior doctors remain junior doctors forever?!? 🤔

LakieLady · 22/12/2022 08:22

It would make a big difference if there weren't shedloads of patients who are medically fit to be discharged but awaiting assessment by adult social care. That would free up beds and speed up the throughput of A&E patients who need to be admitted, enabling swifter handovers on arrival at A&E and getting the paramedics back on the road.

But councils have had their government grant cut year after year for a decade or more so they don't have the money to employ enough people to get the assessments done promptly. All this stuff is joined up, and not all of the problem is within the NHS.

Having said that, improved pay will improve retention. I know a paramedic who has recently left the service to become a PIP assessor for the company that holds the DWP contract. It's better paid (£42k to start, rising to £46k on satisfactory completion of training), no unsocial hours, and far less stressful. Two of his colleagues have done or are doing the same. It's not a job I'd ever do, but I can see how attractive it is for nurses or paramedics.

Wazzzzzuuuuuuup · 22/12/2022 08:19

@MarshaBradyo that is certainly true, calls to ambulance services were down as were self presentations to A&E. However, there are concerns that the 'missing' numbers will come back through the system today and tomorrow, and that a proportion of people will be more acutely unwell than if they'd attended yesterday.

This is at the time when the NHS is usually doing its big decant before Christmas. The days after boxing day are always incredibly busy, and we will have more strikes to manage from Wednesday next week. In my organisation we have been running the last two days as a critical incident (as we are again today) which meant much less work has been done, including standing down some routine activity which just makes the backlogs worse.

MarshaBradyo · 22/12/2022 08:02

It doesn’t sound a good idea. But listening this morning overall calls were down hugely. So the public’s behaviour did change

whataballbag · 22/12/2022 07:57

Nat6999 · 21/12/2022 21:33

Why aren't they using clinicians to take the place of paramedics? Surely they would be more use actually treating & assessing patients?

Paramedics are clinicians 🤦🏻‍♀️

Musicaltheatremum · 22/12/2022 07:51

I'm in Scotland...I rang to speak to the gynae registrar on call yesterday to ask them to see a patient only to get the consultant. He said this was typical now, that they couldn't get enough middle grade staff to cover the rotas.
I do think that many times jobs are advertised but the successful applicant wants 70-80% time and then they allow this but don't bother getting anyone else for the remaining 20-30% of time so you never have enough staff.

MushMonster · 22/12/2022 07:15

Yes, I am 100% sure much much more can be done to sort the NHS issues.
Proper organisation is a main one indeed.

FarmGirl78 · 22/12/2022 06:57

Nat6999 · 21/12/2022 21:33

Why aren't they using clinicians to take the place of paramedics? Surely they would be more use actually treating & assessing patients?

Because we're not paramedics and don't have their skills or knowledge! Pharmacists are clinicians, as are Scientists, Oncologists, Anaesthetists etc etc. You give me a broken leg or a burn and I wouldn't have the faintest idea what to do, barr common sense. If I was given a portable ECG machine thing I'd be kneeling by the casualty looking up instructions on Google.

The other reason we can't just take their place is because a lot of us had annual leave cancelled or our normal shift pattern changed to cope with the fall out from strikes. Yeah that's shit, it happens, we'll cover for our colleagues when their union is out on strike, but I'd like to be able to some my leave at some point!

Namenic · 22/12/2022 06:29

Personally I think all the upheavals of yet another re-organisation will not help. Nhs has had several re-orgs (lansley, hunt) - which cost time and money. running an insurance based system will require employment of a whole dept of people who check and chase payments.

more efficient to see if adequate pay and better staffing will address the problems before jumping in to ‘change the model’

Namenic · 22/12/2022 06:24

I agree with @SavoirFlair . The nhs is in a spiral of lack of retention, which causes understaffed shifts which means work is worse for those who remain (encouraging them to leave or retire early).

The underlying issue is retention of experienced staff. Juniors prefer to work in a system where they are properly supervised and trained so that they can deliver a good service. Seniors prefer to work in a system where they have enough time to train juniors and keep up their skills with CPD and discuss hard issues with their senior colleagues rather than being asked to make a million different decisions because they are asked to cover the work of several people.

nhs has fewer doctors and nurses and hospital beds per capita than many developed countries. We are objectively under-staffed. Under-staffing contributes to inefficiency because over-burdened people ‘push’ work they could have solved to others (as they have no time/energy). I used to work in nhs.

Treedecsandtinsel · 22/12/2022 05:44

SavoirFlair · 21/12/2022 21:14

God, everyone has an answer to the NHS who doesn’t work in the NHS. (I don’t work in the service but just saying.

i mean I loved this one in particular:

We can’t just go on expecting the system to work. It’s collapsed. It is time to look at what can change.

do you also do a greetings card writing service @Treedecsandtinsel ?

We all know this.

It needs to start however with PAY. Attract people. Retain them. Make it fair so they’re not trying to live on 2013 wages in 2023.

Well yes obviously pay needs sorting out. That needs sorting out across the NHS and Social Care love. Yes it will help attract and retain staff. But that’s not the full issue.

so You don’t work in the NHS and you don’t have any ideas. Best not be so rude then!

OP posts:
memorial · 21/12/2022 22:33

From the magic clinician tree?? Do you really believe there are loads of clinicians sitting around doing nothing then??

Georgeskitchen · 21/12/2022 22:22

Why are the 6 figure salaries NHS managers not sorting this out? Isnt tha what we pay them for or do they just sit on their arses all day looking for more ways to waste money?

Nat6999 · 21/12/2022 21:33

Why aren't they using clinicians to take the place of paramedics? Surely they would be more use actually treating & assessing patients?

ChocHotolate · 21/12/2022 21:25

I am an A&E nurse. I wasn't allowed to strike as A&E is an essential service. However, I was asked to volunteer 12 hours of my time to cover the ambulance strikes. That was a no

HymenOrNot · 21/12/2022 21:25

Don't know if you remember but before 111 service was set up there was a service mainly staffed by clinicians [nurses and GPs] called NHS 24 which was much more efficient but more expensive to run

NHS24 was disbanded by the incoming tory government in 2010 - good old 'efficiency savings' - and replaced by 111 which is largely staffed by non-hcps using an algorithm wh some people feel drives referral to hosp and use of 999

So not really surprising that it might be a good thing to use clinicians

Changechangychange · 21/12/2022 21:24

HelsyQ · 21/12/2022 21:20

would have been a decent point without the unnecessary sarcasm

Actually we had hospital managers musing about “how many more discharges” we had during the junior doctors’ strike, and insinuating it would be better if we got rid of “inefficient” junior doctors altogether and just had consultants delivering the service. Heard similar comments from patients too.

The point about the effect on other services to having consultants writing discharge letters and putting in cannulas had to be made pretty strongly.

HelsyQ · 21/12/2022 21:20

Changechangychange · 21/12/2022 20:56

When you say “clinicians” you mean “GPs”.

Yep, great idea, let’s stop GPs seeing patients in primary care and draft them into manning 999 call centres on normal non-strike days instead, it’s not like GPs have anything else to do, or like there are already huge delays to see a GP is it?

During the junior doctors’ strike, consultants did all the work of the junior doctors, and it worked very well. Better than normal in fact. So from that we can conclude that if we could only cancel all outpatient activity, all elective surgery, all routine scans, and shut down the dialysis units and chemo suites, the NHS would run fine.

would have been a decent point without the unnecessary sarcasm

mumda · 21/12/2022 21:19

The BBC explained they have more clinicians there in the call centres these days to help with calls. Including midwives and nurses and doctors.

SavoirFlair · 21/12/2022 21:14

God, everyone has an answer to the NHS who doesn’t work in the NHS. (I don’t work in the service but just saying.

i mean I loved this one in particular:

We can’t just go on expecting the system to work. It’s collapsed. It is time to look at what can change.

do you also do a greetings card writing service @Treedecsandtinsel ?

We all know this.

It needs to start however with PAY. Attract people. Retain them. Make it fair so they’re not trying to live on 2013 wages in 2023.

FreyaHazel · 21/12/2022 21:08

No, the clinicians are not necessarily GPs and most likely are not! I'm a paramedic and have worked in the control room triaging calls in the past. We have a number of paramedics, advanced paramedic practitioners and some nursing staff triaging calls, not a GP in sight. We are all clinicians.

Csaattendance · 21/12/2022 21:07

Treedecsandtinsel · 21/12/2022 21:04

Rather than throwing our hands up and going well it’s impossible to solve.

if having clinicians (GPS?) answer 999 calls works to reduce the flow of work to the ambulance service, does that then reduce the flow of people into hospitals?

what could be done on GP/ other clinicians work demands to make that happen?

We can’t just go on expecting the system to work. It’s collapsed. It is time to look at what can change.

Well if gps can reduce the amount of ambulances needed just by answering the calls imagine the difference they could make if they actually saw patients and opened surgeries 7 days a week…

whataballbag · 21/12/2022 21:06

There are clinicians working within EOC's 24/7 anyway usually on the CHUB desk.