Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Smuggest mum blogger post ever?

266 replies

Yippitydoodah · 21/12/2022 20:18

I follow a mum blogger who lives in a very remote location in the UK. Posts have always been a bit ‘aren’t we wholesome’ but with some interesting stuff too. But just recently the smug has reached a new level! She homeschools her kids (not short of a bob or two) and posted about their day outdoors in the nice winter sunshine. She said ‘my son said, just think mum, if I went to school like everyone else I would be sat in a classroom missing this beautiful day. Isn’t he wise?’

AIBU to ask if this is the most self congratulatory post ever?!

OP posts:
melcalfe · 23/12/2022 03:22

This thread has taken an interesting turn but it's an example of when people assume Russia=bad (as it was with the anti-American adoption law) and now over a decade later people started to realise that Russia were right to do this.

Morestrangethings · 23/12/2022 01:45

A really interesting post @mathanxiety , thanks for sharing your knowledge.

mathanxiety · 23/12/2022 01:42

I agree with your thoughts there, @BertieBotts.

The older children adopted from Russia were never the blank canvases the adoptive parents imagined them to be, and they resisted the projecting of American expectations of 'rescued' Russian children.

Russia was absolutely right to stop the adoptions, especially to the US.

On top of all you describe, there was also a thick layer of 'saving the children from the Red Peril', with children taken from humble but secure and predictable surroundings and plunged into a world of OTT materialism, bedrooms decorated with Disney images and paraphernalia, etc, and often called by americanised versions of their names - people adopting children who basically swallowed the capitalist vs Communist gospel without ever chewing it and had no idea of the emotional, psychological, and spiritual needs of the children, who saw tired old orphanage playgrounds and spare, shabby buildings, and thought only in terms of Russia Bad/ America Good, and bringing the narrative to its logical conclusion - "I am doing a heroic and patriotic thing."

Of course in reality, while the chdren were happy to have a family adopt them, they were not thinking "I am saved from this wretched post Soviet existence in the Evil.Empire and I can now enjoy the American Dream". The idea that the children could miss the staff and their friends from the shabby orphanage, the plain food, the squeaky beds with the chipped paint - and wouldn't gleefully embrace out and out materialism, wall to wall Disney decor,, etc was something many of the parents couldn't accept at all.

For some adopters, the idea that not every single person in every corner of the world cherished the American Dream close to their bosom was a reality they simply couldn't wrap their heads around.

The level of American patriotic pride and the psychological impact of the Cold War and decades of anti Soviet propaganda in the US weren't appreciated by the people vetting adopters.

Veronika13 · 23/12/2022 00:08

BertieBotts · 22/12/2022 21:58

The "rehoming" adoptive children is really sickening, I think there is a really disturbing narrative about adoption in some parts of America, it's all tied up in religion, abortion rights and a load of other complicated stuff. The reality when the children aren't grateful for being saved (not to mention traumatised or having other complex needs) is too much for a lot of people to handle, and really they shouldn't have been allowed to go into it with that mindset and understanding.

Lot of private adoption agencies and international adoption tied up in all this. It's unfortunately all linked back to money, but I see it as a form of human trafficking.

Russia banned adoption of Russian children into America. It caused an outrage from the world at the time.

Tinner01 · 23/12/2022 00:07

Blueeyedgirl21 · 22/12/2022 19:02

@Tinner01 maybe he has an organic Japanese wank sock from her fabric stash ??? He must be about 17 🤣🤣

PMSL🙈🙈🙈

BertieBotts · 22/12/2022 21:58

The "rehoming" adoptive children is really sickening, I think there is a really disturbing narrative about adoption in some parts of America, it's all tied up in religion, abortion rights and a load of other complicated stuff. The reality when the children aren't grateful for being saved (not to mention traumatised or having other complex needs) is too much for a lot of people to handle, and really they shouldn't have been allowed to go into it with that mindset and understanding.

Lot of private adoption agencies and international adoption tied up in all this. It's unfortunately all linked back to money, but I see it as a form of human trafficking.

BertieBotts · 22/12/2022 21:52

Glad that the sew liberated blog gave so many people a smile.

I did used to follow some blogs back before the whole influencer thing kicked off. I don't now because they are mostly tedious and very very obviously fake. But I used to find somebody that I admired or found interesting or lived a different life from me and follow them. I liked Amsterfamily, very funny account of a woman who had emigrated to Amsterdam. Renegade mothering (she has coincidentally also emigrated to Amsterdam, no relation between the blogs), carried family, that was an attachment parenting one I liked when DS1 was small. Can't remember others now. Random reality, an ambulance driver.

Kanaloa · 22/12/2022 20:07

That’s what it was for me. We just ‘rehomed’ our adopted baby with disabilities. Like? And then ‘gotcha day.’ Just a whole commodification of an extremely vulnerable child. It blows my mind that they must be surrounded by people (family, friends, social workers) and not one person said ‘what are you doing? This is insane.’

mathanxiety · 22/12/2022 19:40

Agree, @Kanaloa

The use of the term 'rehoming' is revolting.

I have a suspicion that a person who
would do this is so far up their own asshole that very little of other people's reality ever intrudes upon their consciousness.

mathanxiety · 22/12/2022 19:36

I'm glad the Liberated family seem to be doing well too. I looked through some random posts from the Sew Liberated archives last evening and saw the middle child had heart surgery as a newborn, so I'm especially glad to see he came through that.

The blogger herself apparently started her sewing site when she and her H were living on a doctoral student stipend, and managed to make money selling patterns and keep the family afloat. The lifestyle blog grew from that. It's not so hilariously lacking in self awareness any more, which is a pity.

I'm going to raid the archives to see if they ever went through with the nighttine elimination bowl for their newborns and if so, how long it took before they bought a big box of Pampers.
Smile

Kanaloa · 22/12/2022 19:31

mathanxiety · 22/12/2022 19:23

@Kanaloa

They're vanity projects. The children's task was to reflect back the overblown self image of the adopter back at them.

The Russian government was right to stop foreign adoptions.

Still - imagine adopting a child then saying you’ve ‘rehomed’ them 😢 Surely you would have your family tell you this was unacceptable language. I heard China has also restricted international adoption, not totally banned but very harshly restricted. I think it’s a good choice. Adopted children are already traumatised so how is ripping them from their home and culture going to help?

mathanxiety · 22/12/2022 19:23

@Kanaloa

They're vanity projects. The children's task was to reflect back the overblown self image of the adopter back at them.

The Russian government was right to stop foreign adoptions.

BedTaker · 22/12/2022 19:10

You can see Finn and his two younger siblings on the Instagram page 'mamaliberated'. They actually seem like a relatively normal family now!

Blueeyedgirl21 · 22/12/2022 19:02

@Tinner01 maybe he has an organic Japanese wank sock from her fabric stash ??? He must be about 17 🤣🤣

TruckerBarbie · 22/12/2022 18:55

Tinner01 · 22/12/2022 16:40

god I’d hate to hear about “Finns Montessori puberty”🤣🤣

do you think he’s still sleeping in a 15inch organic bed, wiping his nose and using the potty in the mirror as a 13 year old?

😂😂😂

Tinner01 · 22/12/2022 16:40

BertieBotts · 21/12/2022 21:12

It's much of a muchness, but I couldn't help reading your post and being reminded of a very old MN post mocking "Finn's Montessori Nursery".

Finn must be a great hulking teenager by now Smile

Found the post (can't find the MN thread)

sewliberated.typepad.com/sew_liberated/2009/04/finnians-montessori-room.html

She still posts incredibly perfect shots on instagram, you've got to respect the dedication.

god I’d hate to hear about “Finns Montessori puberty”🤣🤣

do you think he’s still sleeping in a 15inch organic bed, wiping his nose and using the potty in the mirror as a 13 year old?

lessthanathirdofanacre · 22/12/2022 13:59

Yes, it was extraordinarily cruel to “rehome” her adopted children but unsurprising given her track record. Somebody once called her Joyce Me Me Me Maynard, which is quite apt. I very much hope the new family gave those girls the love and security they deserved.

Emotionalsupportviper · 22/12/2022 13:48

Thanks @Skinnermarink and @Kanaloa - that's bliddy brutal.

As you say, you'd put more care into re-homing a cat. What a horrible way to treat a child.

Children who have been adopted are often so desperately vulnerable to begin with, and then to be passed on like a book you've read but weren't keen on and don't want anymore - how soul-destroying is that for them? Poor kids.

And how vulnerable they are then to anyone who tries to groom them - they will be desperate for love and affection and stability. I hope all of these children ended up with better families. It shocks me sometimes, the casual cruelty some people display - and don't see anything wrong with their own appalling actions.

Kanaloa · 22/12/2022 13:39

@Emotionalsupportviper

She didn’t send them back (to the familiar place they’d been born). She sent them, after a year, to another random American family. Like rehoming a cat.

Same as the other influencer mentioned above who ‘rehomed’ her adopted son when he turned out to be too much hard work. Makes you wonder if they’re so shallow they’d ‘rehome’ their own kids, or if they just see adopted kids from other countries as more akin to animals/pets/toys that can be chosen and bought and used and discarded.

Skinnermarink · 22/12/2022 13:39

Emotionalsupportviper · 22/12/2022 13:35

she adopted two little girls from Ethiopia, then ditched them when the reality of adoption turned out to be different from her fantasies

"Ditched them"?

You mean - actually sent them back, like unwanted parcels? Bliddy hell - that's cruel.

No she didn’t send them back, she sent them to live on a farm in Wyoming, and then removed all trace and mention of them from her website! Shocking.

Emotionalsupportviper · 22/12/2022 13:35

she adopted two little girls from Ethiopia, then ditched them when the reality of adoption turned out to be different from her fantasies

"Ditched them"?

You mean - actually sent them back, like unwanted parcels? Bliddy hell - that's cruel.

lessthanathirdofanacre · 22/12/2022 13:23

The mother of them all (ha!) is Joyce Maynard. She was a mum blogger before blogging existed. She wrote a newspaper column back in the 1980s all about her family, using their real names and personal details. When the column was discontinued and her marriage broke down, she started a widely distributed newsletter. Of course she became an enthusiastic user of social media as soon as it appeared. Along the way she published several books exploiting her family and revealing private details I would imagine her children never consented to have revealed. Then when her kids were grown up, she adopted two little girls from Ethiopia, then ditched them when the reality of adoption turned out to be different from her fantasies. It would be difficult to find a more self-absorbed person anywhere.

Name99 · 22/12/2022 13:14

Skinnermarink · 22/12/2022 13:08

I didn’t know nannies were excluded from calling a twat a twat! Well I never.

Anyway. Lifting my handiwork on birthday cakes, craft activities and nutritious aesthetically pleasing dinners for her own Instagram and getting all the credit and praise WAS pretty twatty. I’m not sorry if that offends any nanny employers on here.

Nah, she sounds 100% a twat.

Skinnermarink · 22/12/2022 13:08

I didn’t know nannies were excluded from calling a twat a twat! Well I never.

Anyway. Lifting my handiwork on birthday cakes, craft activities and nutritious aesthetically pleasing dinners for her own Instagram and getting all the credit and praise WAS pretty twatty. I’m not sorry if that offends any nanny employers on here.

Ocrumbs · 22/12/2022 13:00

Yippitydoodah · 22/12/2022 12:45

I can absolutely see a need to home school, for instance, where the child is disabled and no local school can accommodate them.

But when it’s because mum and dad are ‘free spirited hippies’ or whatever, it’s like a weird form of indoctrination that (in my experience) produces odd kids - very intense, taking themselves seriously, no real idea of how to socialise with other children. It’s a self fulfilling prophecy because then the parent will think ‘aww little Sophie is so introverted and clever and eccentric, I did the right thing home schooling’ when Sophie is actually like that because having years of those values drummed into her with no dilution from her peers and wider society.

Some people just want to home school their kids ok. Leave them be.

Swipe left for the next trending thread