Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU? People often ask me, "do you celebrate Christmas"?

170 replies

July70 · 21/12/2022 19:34

WTF do they ask me and not the others in the office. Even my stupid clients do that. It's nothing new as I have it at school than less so at uni, and now had this at every place I've worked at. Even those stupid people that live in the close, some ask me.

We are not from the UK and tBH I was never offended but in recent days, possibly too many people being offended over everything and me getting older, should I be offended?

What I find even more offensive is when I tell them that we have always celebrated Christmas sine I can recall in the UK but only in the commercial sense like the vast majority in England, and some roll their eyes.

I know why they ask me, but am I being too sensitive now as I'm pretty sure the vast majority are not being offensive IMO?

OP posts:
Zanatdy · 22/12/2022 06:23

I work in a very multi cultured office and in the past I probably would have asked that. Now I just ask ‘what are your plans for Christmas?’. As I’ve realised there’s nothing wrong with asking that. It’s the Christmas break. We all live in the U.K. and I’ve realised after 20yrs that everyone wishes everyone a happy Christmas regardless of race or religion. So now I just ask what they are doing, I’m not asking if they are all having a Turkey dinner, but what their plans are with their family and their time off work. I do agree that people shouldn’t be asking one person if they celebrate and assuming they don’t.

closingscore · 22/12/2022 06:19

It's your own choice to be "offended" by anything. Personally I think it's fine for people to ask the question 🤷🏼‍♀️

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 22/12/2022 06:18

I am not bothered if someone wishes me a happy Christmas either. I might sometimes say, if you think planning for Christmas is stressful, try Channukah it's 8 days of family dynamics

ClarathecrosseyedLioness · 22/12/2022 06:18

WTF do they ask me and not the others in the office. Even my stupid clients do that. It's nothing new as I have it at school than less so at uni, and now had this at every place I've worked at. Even those stupid people that live in the close, some ask me.

Why are people 'stupid' because they are trying to do the right thing and not cause offence?

It seems we're 'damned if we do and damned if we don't'.

There was a thread last year where an atheist said she hated Christmas being 'shoved down her throat' and if anyone gave her a Christmas card she tore it up and threw it in the bin.
With attitudes like that around, some of us would rather known where we stand before we wasted our time and money. 🙄

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 22/12/2022 06:15

I am Jewish; I wish everyone a happy winter vacation when I am at work as a uni. lecturer (currently on ML) it's not really something to be offended about OP.

HollyDollyChristmas · 22/12/2022 06:14

sashh · 22/12/2022 03:09

Not everyone believes there is only one God.

Some people believe in more gods and some people reject the idea of gods/ a god entirely.

The thing with the 'Christian name' bothers me too, in my parents generation this was the same as asking your given name, but Christian names are not your given name.

It really irritated me when my mum used it as she had her given name, a totally different name from her baptism and a third from her confirmation.

I always say forename and wince a little when colleagues ask customers what their Christian name is.

nancydroo · 22/12/2022 06:10

I thought this was a genuine post but it's just an opportunity to diss Christmas...excess blah blah blah. Fair enough. I'm surprised anyone bothers talking to you at all. Your attitude stinks. Wind your neck in and stop looking to be offended.

HollyDollyChristmas · 22/12/2022 06:10

I don’t assume as I used to work with a lady who was a Jehovah’s Witness and she didn’t even open a card if someone gave her one. She’s white, British.

LordEmsworth · 22/12/2022 05:41

July70 · 21/12/2022 21:41

@LordEmsworth
Are you saying that the majority of people in the UK don't see Christmas as a commercial exercise, EG, excess food, drink, holidays, partying and buying presents one cannot afford?

Actually, I'm saying it's a socially inept and unacceptable thing to say. Believing it is one thing, but saying it suggests that you are trying to be provocative and upset whoever you're speaking to. It's ok not to say everything you think, that's how social etiquette works. "I speak my mind, me" is not an attitude that generally wins respect or friends, however proud you are about it

BabyFour2023 · 22/12/2022 05:29

shivawn · 21/12/2022 19:46

Sounds like you're just looking for something to get offended over.

This.

Most people wouldn’t want to wish someone a merry Christmas and offend them if they don’t celebrate. They’re asking to clarify this. Confirm either way and move on. Nobody is being rude to you here.

Muddays · 22/12/2022 05:26

OP you're allowed to be annoyed, people are flaming annoying, simple.
However, Christmas is treasured and valued far more than you think. The rampant commercialism that underlies everything these days doesn't reflect the deep love Christians of all nationalities feel about the birth of a child who was going to revolutionise the entire world and bring a courageous light to humanity.
The corrupt politics of religion in the wrong hands has disrupted the simple message of a child born not in a palace but in poor, basic conditions.
He grew up challenging hypocrisy, defending the most hated and lost in society saying that they were worth more love than the wealthy self serving judges of them; at considerable cost to himself.
He was given many opportunities to flee but was determined that humankind would know that they were worth dying for; that they could find an extraordinary soul within themselves and others because they were loved and could also love.
We are celebrating this beautiful child of God bringing light into a very dark human world. Like
Christmas lights should remind us of the starlight the vast infinite universe can't consume.

Maybebabyno2 · 22/12/2022 04:21

Ilovehamandtoast · 21/12/2022 20:26

Would it not be more offensive if people assumed you did celebrate Christmas? I've a Jewish friend who's feeling a bit frustrated with all the Christmas wishes when he doesn't celebrate but he takes them in good faith as they're meant. I think people just don't want to make assumptions

I don't understand this mentality at all. I work with a lot of people from different cultures and religions. I don't get irritated when people wish me a Happy Divali or . I just thank them and wish them the same. They aren't 'assuming I celebrate' that holiday, they are just being inclusive and sharing their celebrations and traditions.

silentpool · 22/12/2022 03:25

I just say enjoy the holidays and be done with it. You don't have to be a church going Christian to enjoy time off and trashy TV, do you?

Not sure why people get so offended, I used to love Lunar New Year, Diwali etc in the appropriate countries when I lived there - clearly wasn't my festival but enjoyed it.

sashh · 22/12/2022 03:09

July70 · 21/12/2022 21:39

@MindPalace

Thank you. I'm like that, sort of by my children are 101% like that. We wear western clothing at all times bar Indian weddings for the ladies and the blokes most in western suits but some may wear traditional Indian mens suits, fancy ones. We were the first our of every Indian family I know to have fry ups and even eat beef, yes, I eat beef mum did not as she was veggie and fellow Indians turned up their nose. Until I told a friend that the steak and kidney he was eating was beef - this is in the late 70's and the chap had arrived from overseas a few years before.

So I guess I'm westernised in the way of lif other than we've never borrowed money other than a mortgage as paying interest on cc's HP etc is against our nature.

However, I have started getting offended possibly because I'm getting older but not offended to an extent where I think its racists. I'm not stuip I know that 99% of those that ask are being genuine but it winds me up just like the iditos often those in their late 60's and older ask me for my "Christian name" - I just give them my first name and don't make a scene.

I'm not woke etc and for years I failed to recognise the glass ceiling and this is how brain-washed I was.

However, having started this thread and my comments - this is my home and where my parents, my inlaws, our children have contributed millions in taxes and helped England become a better place. My parents told me we must work and work to better ourselves and build on that. Thanks to my parent's education to us we are financially comfortable and never get in trouble with the law.

TBH, England is a lot less racist compared to many countries I've been to as most of the people of all backgrounds are nice/fair people.

I'm actual so westernised that unlike many, I have been in many religious places of worship with friends as it does not bother me as there is only one God.
Sadly, someone that was born again was astounded when they were discussing religion as they often brought up the subjet and shocked when I told them I had no problem visiting ????'s place of worship

But, I do get wound up being asked about Xmas in recent weeks.

Not everyone believes there is only one God.

Some people believe in more gods and some people reject the idea of gods/ a god entirely.

The thing with the 'Christian name' bothers me too, in my parents generation this was the same as asking your given name, but Christian names are not your given name.

It really irritated me when my mum used it as she had her given name, a totally different name from her baptism and a third from her confirmation.

Fleurdaisy · 22/12/2022 02:53

Tbh I think it’s a combination of people not wanting to offend and being totally confused by who celebrates Christmas and who doesn’t, who cares and who doesn’t.
I googled something today as I’d watched Stacey Solomon making Christmas decorations and I thought she was Jewish. Whole articles about how and why lots of Jewish people celebrate Christmas. This was one www.myjewishlearning.com/article/jews-christmas/
DP and I lived in a predominantly (90%+) Muslim country for a short time and were surprised to receive Christmas cards, mostly from work colleagues. They weren’t offended we were observing Christmas ( they assumed, we weren’t big on it) in their country and we were touched to receive their greetings in cards.

Agapornis · 22/12/2022 02:33

From one 'perceived foreign' to another: YANBU. It is very othering to get this question in a country you think of as home - it makes you feel like you are not the norm. See also: "but where are you really from" which has hopefully now been consigned to the rubbish bin post-Ngozi Fulani.

I tend to reflect the question right back at them i.e. 'yes, what about you, do you celebrate Christmas?' - saves me from tedious explaining and people tend to be flattered thinking you are interested in their answer. (I'm not, because it's never close friends asking these questions, is it.)

For all the confused people: "are you doing anything nice over the holidays?" covers a lot and focuses on the positive.

DuchessofSandwich · 22/12/2022 02:24

July70 · 21/12/2022 21:19

People wish me happy easter, exmas, ramadan, dawali, and a few more I guess. Why should I mind if people wished me 'happy..' something?

I don't go around asking people if they celebrate, Christmas.

Well, you don't mind. I have had colleagues who did mind so now I ask. Most people at my office with a brown skin tended to not be christian, so why is it offensive to ask if they celebrate christmas? It's a bit difficult to not be offensive if not asking if someone celebrates is offensive and so is asking....

anon666 · 22/12/2022 00:16

I feel for you. Personally I think it's very tedious for you to have to hear this over and over.

It's an example of people being thoughtless but not necessarily malicious. Still annoying. ☹️

Hopefully if more people speak out and say it's a bit annoying, the general culture will change and people will stop asking.

FarmGirl78 · 21/12/2022 23:55

"Should I be offended?"

What? I don't understand how anyone can even ask this. This is the height of stupidity and so much of what's wrong with the world today. There's not a big list somewhere of what you should or shouldn't be offended by. You are you. No-one else is. If it doesn't offend YOU then it doesn't offend you. No-one else needs to, or has the right to, say "Yes, you need to start being offended by that from now on. That's the rules". I despair.

SkylightSkylight · 21/12/2022 23:34

belowfrozen · 21/12/2022 19:48

Hence why in the states people just use 'happy holidays'

I hate 'Happy Holidays'.

I celebrate Christmas, (pagan version.). Everyone can choose what they celebrate, but depersonalising celebrations -nope.

it's an Americanism that can stay in America.

Talipesmum · 21/12/2022 23:29

Jackie17177 · 21/12/2022 22:20

But people who celebrate Christmas in a non spiritual/non religious way still enjoy the occasion for more than commercialism in my experience. It's not just about buying things - it is about spending time with family, looking for ways to take part in your community and it is about appreciating what you have got.

You have undermined all that with your entrenched ideas about a commercialised Christmas. And I feel offended by your posts and your inability to understand the country you have lived in for so long.

Agree with this - OP I think this is why people might be reacting in a strange way when you reply that you celebrate Christmas in a “commercialised way, like many others in the UK” or something like that. Yes you’re right, it is very very commercial, and yes, loads of people who celebrate Christmas aren’t actually Christian (like me). But it’s not just a “commercial” festival for many of us. It’s got deep rooted traditions and cultures, it goes back way before Christianity even, and stripping the traditions and history away and saying it’s just commercial is going to put peoples backs up.

If you said “yes I do celebrate Christmas, I’m not religious but I like the traditions and the festival” or something like that, it would be much more palatable I guess, and perhaps less likely to get odd reactions. Obviously don’t say that if you don’t like the traditions but it sounds like you do like it! People are probably asking if you are of a different religion that specifically ignores Christmas. Saying you celebrate in a non religious way helps to answer that.

Spidey66 · 21/12/2022 23:09

I'd ask it (or words to that effect eg 'what do you do over the Christmas period') if I knew someone wasn't British and/or I knew the person was Jewish or Muslim, for example. I asked my driving instructor last week. She's from Afghanistan and came here as a refugee and is Muslim and I know she has young children born and bred here and I was genuinely interested in how her children grow up in a country which celebrates it when they're in a family that doesn't.

If I knew someone was Jewish or Muslim and it was Hannukah or Eid, I'd pass on greetings of their season, and ask what they do to celebrate. Talking to people helps you learn about other cultures surely? I've never met anyone get upset or offended if I ask eg a Jewish person how Hanukkah is celebrated. They're often happy to tell me what food they eat, what clothes they wear, what religious services they attend.

I think when people ask its a combination of being interested in other cultures and of out of respect.

Caulidop · 21/12/2022 23:07

I'm sure someone has already said it, but I think it's a product of the media- social media probably more so. People hear about examples of others being upset by 'disrespectful' or 'ignorant' people and feel they need to be more careful/walk on eggshells to avoid offending others. Mostly, I expect they do not mean to offend, but the action of singling you out because of your appearance obviously does offend! I grew up in a small village, moved to a small city, and now work in a predominantly London based team. I have never been more aware of the kaleidoscope of different beliefs, and find that i sign off emails/wish people well in a more general way. For example, I might say I hope you get chance to enjoy some time off over the Christmas period if I am not aware if that person celebrates Christmas or not, but I would never ask someone if they celebrate Christmas. I think it's best put down to a misguided ignorance, so maybe the best way forward is to approach it with a need to educate on how you feel about that approach, and that you celebrate in the way the majority of other people living here do!

HJ40 · 21/12/2022 22:48

Once upon a time, not that long ago, you could wish everyone a happy Christmas, Christian or not. You could say it implying enjoy the season and the excitement. Enjoy the school holiday. Enjoy the office or factory shut down.

Now, heaven forbid you may innocently and with good intentions dare possibly wish someone who might possibly not be Christian glad tidings. And therefore we have to trip over ourselves to awkwardly try and enquire if someone 'celebrates' Christmas to then decide if it's safe to continue without causing offence when all we want to do is wish them a happy bloody Christmas.

Chances are we don't give a shiny shit anyway, it's just trying to be polite like asking 'how are you?' or 'did you have a nice weekend?' but the woke-ones have decided it's preferable to be a miserly Scrooge than possibly dare assume anything about what someone thinks about this time of year.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 21/12/2022 22:37

daisymade · 21/12/2022 22:29

My boss in my old job asked a colleague this. It’s a very middle class white profession and the guy he asked was Indian. I can remember my jaw physically dropping when the words came out of his mouth “what do you chaps do for Christmas, a curry?!” And I can’t believe how well he handled it. I actually told him I’d back him up if he reported it to HR and he just rolled his eyes at me - obviously it is something he gets often.
sorry OP x

Not really same as politely acknowledging that someone who may not be Christian might not celebrate Christmas though, is it?