Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU? People often ask me, "do you celebrate Christmas"?

170 replies

July70 · 21/12/2022 19:34

WTF do they ask me and not the others in the office. Even my stupid clients do that. It's nothing new as I have it at school than less so at uni, and now had this at every place I've worked at. Even those stupid people that live in the close, some ask me.

We are not from the UK and tBH I was never offended but in recent days, possibly too many people being offended over everything and me getting older, should I be offended?

What I find even more offensive is when I tell them that we have always celebrated Christmas sine I can recall in the UK but only in the commercial sense like the vast majority in England, and some roll their eyes.

I know why they ask me, but am I being too sensitive now as I'm pretty sure the vast majority are not being offensive IMO?

OP posts:
roarfeckingroarr · 22/12/2022 09:30

I now wish people a merry Christmas "if you celebrate it" following a diversity drive at my work. I would make sure to do this if someone is Asian or has a non UK/American/Aussie/Kiwi/SA accent I suppose, as there's a larger chance they're not Christian OR don't celebrate "Christmas" in the secular sense that most Brits do celebrate,

It's really not trying to "other" people (ridiculous phrase), it's what we have been told is the right thing to do.

girlmom21 · 22/12/2022 09:27

MrsDoyle351 · 22/12/2022 07:39

FFS - the OP is sick of people making assumptions and comments that are microaggressions. BECAUSE if she was white - the question 'Do you celebrate Christmas?' would not be asked. What is so hard to understand?

So many saying the OP is taking offence too easily. Maybe she's just f sick of it? Please watch the youtube video

My SIL is white and Jewish and celebrates Christmas so she gets asked lots of questions

georgarina · 22/12/2022 09:25

MrsDoyle351 · 22/12/2022 07:39

FFS - the OP is sick of people making assumptions and comments that are microaggressions. BECAUSE if she was white - the question 'Do you celebrate Christmas?' would not be asked. What is so hard to understand?

So many saying the OP is taking offence too easily. Maybe she's just f sick of it? Please watch the youtube video

The only person being aggressive and making racist assumptions is OP by calling people stupid and saying English people only celebrate a commercialised version of Christmas.

Let's say I were a white person living in the Middle East. My colleagues ask if I celebrate Eid. I characterise them as 'stupid' for asking and reply that I only celebrate in the commercial sense, like the vast majority in the country. Then I get offended when this statement isn't taken well.

According to you, that would be perfectly reasonable.

MrsDoyle351 · 22/12/2022 08:49

Haha - right - I've seen it all now.

What the heck is an anti-White rascist assumption?

People are frickin' nuts on this site!

Stop finding offence where there isn't any. We also can choose how we react to things, whether we are offended by things

Geeze - I never would have known any of that - had you not told me. Thanks so much Xmas Grin

Wishawisha · 22/12/2022 08:36

Talipesmum · 21/12/2022 23:29

Agree with this - OP I think this is why people might be reacting in a strange way when you reply that you celebrate Christmas in a “commercialised way, like many others in the UK” or something like that. Yes you’re right, it is very very commercial, and yes, loads of people who celebrate Christmas aren’t actually Christian (like me). But it’s not just a “commercial” festival for many of us. It’s got deep rooted traditions and cultures, it goes back way before Christianity even, and stripping the traditions and history away and saying it’s just commercial is going to put peoples backs up.

If you said “yes I do celebrate Christmas, I’m not religious but I like the traditions and the festival” or something like that, it would be much more palatable I guess, and perhaps less likely to get odd reactions. Obviously don’t say that if you don’t like the traditions but it sounds like you do like it! People are probably asking if you are of a different religion that specifically ignores Christmas. Saying you celebrate in a non religious way helps to answer that.

I think this.

I’ve bristled a bit at the OP calling Christmas purely commercial for most people. I am not religious but culturally Christian and my Christmas doesn’t involve anything particularly religious but it’s still a lot more than commercial. Yes I eat and drink more than normally but it’s about a lot more than that. A lot of our presents to relatives have been hand made by the DC - it’s about showing you care, visiting relatives you don’t often see so much (I’ve got one such visit today lined up and I can assure you I wouldn’t be doing it if Christmas was just a commercial exercise!!), spending intensive family time with children.

I don’t think I’ve ever asked if anyone celebrates Christmas BUT I have wondered if I should be asking. We send Christmas cards to all of DC’s friends including of different religions. Because I know, and get on well with, the parents I know they will take the cards well but if they were people I didn’t know so well, perhaps I would ask. Of the 2 Hindu families we are closest to I know one does celebrate Christmas - not as intensely as we do, as it’s our main holiday, but Santa brings presents to the children etc - and the other doesn’t seem to acknowledge it at all. I only know this because I know the families but surely people are asking because they simply don’t know and don’t want to assume. They are trying to be polite and inclusive.

booklovingmum · 22/12/2022 08:31

MrsDoyle351 · 22/12/2022 08:20

@nancydroo yes I am angry on the OPs behalf because it literally is a microagression and people on the thread are being deliberately obtuse in pretending that it isn't. How many of your white skinned colleagues would get asked this question every year? Literally zero.

The OP has never once said she would be offended if someone wished her a Merry Christmas - that's just making stuff up!

I'm sorry but that's utter BS.

It could and maybe is on some occasions a "micro aggression" depending on the thoughts of the person stating it or asking the question. I don't however think asking somebody if they celebrate Christmas reflects a negative attitude towards a culture or religion.

But for many it's just an innocent question to try and understand somebody's culture and belief and the rest.

The fact that we live in a world where we cannot do anything without it being called a micro aggression or offending somebody because there are so many snowflakes in the world these days is insufferable.

Stop finding offence where there isn't any. We also can choose how we react to things, whether we are offended by things.

I can however imagine it's annoying being asked it often for the OP but that's not the same thing as being actually offended by it in an entirely different level.

liveforsummer · 22/12/2022 08:28

If you are from a culture that doesn't traditionally celebrate Xmas then of course it's not an offensive question. Surely they are just showing an interest in you?

Trainbear · 22/12/2022 08:26

MrsDoyle351 · 22/12/2022 08:20

@nancydroo yes I am angry on the OPs behalf because it literally is a microagression and people on the thread are being deliberately obtuse in pretending that it isn't. How many of your white skinned colleagues would get asked this question every year? Literally zero.

The OP has never once said she would be offended if someone wished her a Merry Christmas - that's just making stuff up!

Another antiWhite racist assumption.

Trainbear · 22/12/2022 08:25

MrsDoyle351 · 22/12/2022 07:39

FFS - the OP is sick of people making assumptions and comments that are microaggressions. BECAUSE if she was white - the question 'Do you celebrate Christmas?' would not be asked. What is so hard to understand?

So many saying the OP is taking offence too easily. Maybe she's just f sick of it? Please watch the youtube video

Well that’s an anti White racist assumption.

MrsDoyle351 · 22/12/2022 08:22

Happy Holidays!! 💩

Charmed I'm sure. Now who exactly is being 'deeply unpleasant?'

BrokenAndAfraid · 22/12/2022 08:22

Are you vocal that you are another religion that doesn't typically celebrate Christmas? If the question is based purely on your ethnicity or where you from it would about me!

MrsDoyle351 · 22/12/2022 08:20

@nancydroo yes I am angry on the OPs behalf because it literally is a microagression and people on the thread are being deliberately obtuse in pretending that it isn't. How many of your white skinned colleagues would get asked this question every year? Literally zero.

The OP has never once said she would be offended if someone wished her a Merry Christmas - that's just making stuff up!

Hillcrest2022 · 22/12/2022 07:58

I'm confused. So you do celebrate Christmas and are offended if people ask whether you do but you're also offended of people ask you what your Christian name is.. so, you don't want any mention of Chritianity, is that it?

Anothernamechange1010 · 22/12/2022 07:52

Some people will literally get offended over ANYTHING

You can't win:

Wish a Merry Christmas to someone not celebrating = Offended

Check if someone celebrates Christmas before wishing them a Merry Christmas = Offended

Don't wish someone a Merry Christmas because you're not sure if they celebrate it = Offended

TBH OP with the way you've come across in this thread you're lucky anyone even talks to you as you sound deeply unpleasant.

Happy Holidays!! 💩

Itloggedmeoutagain · 22/12/2022 07:51

If you need to ask if you should be offended then there's something wrong. You're either offended or you're not. It's not up to others to decide for you

nancydroo · 22/12/2022 07:48

MrsDoyle351 · 22/12/2022 07:39

FFS - the OP is sick of people making assumptions and comments that are microaggressions. BECAUSE if she was white - the question 'Do you celebrate Christmas?' would not be asked. What is so hard to understand?

So many saying the OP is taking offence too easily. Maybe she's just f sick of it? Please watch the youtube video

You are very angry on OP's behalf. It's just small talk not micro-aggression. There are lots of people who do not celebrate Christmas and it has nothing to do with what you are suggesting.

MrsDoyle351 · 22/12/2022 07:39

FFS - the OP is sick of people making assumptions and comments that are microaggressions. BECAUSE if she was white - the question 'Do you celebrate Christmas?' would not be asked. What is so hard to understand?

So many saying the OP is taking offence too easily. Maybe she's just f sick of it? Please watch the youtube video

tigger1001 · 22/12/2022 07:38

I think you are just looking to be offended.

And are being offensive yourself by referring to Christmas as commercial and excess food and drink etc. just because someone isn't religious doesn't mean they celebrate "commercial Christmas". It means they enjoy the holiday, time with friends and family. Yes, having a feast - maybe look beyond the Christian tradition and look at the origins of why we have a feast/lights in December. Maybe stop referring to non religious celebrations as "commercial celebrations"

We were talking christmas traditions yesterday at work. And it was interesting to learn other countries traditions of when the tree goes up, when presents are exchanged etc. not everything is about causing offence.

Riu · 22/12/2022 07:38

You are either offended, or you are not. Why are you asking people if you should be?

Calling people stupid, in the way you have done it, is definitely offensive though.

booklovingmum · 22/12/2022 07:30

YABU I think they're just trying to be respectful and if you're offended then you need to look at why that offends you.

Its an innocent question IMO.

LynetteScavo · 22/12/2022 07:20

No king after I posted on this thread yesterday someone asked me if I celebrate Christmas. They went in to ask if I put decorations up in my house. I asked them if they were doing anything for Christmas. They replied that they were going to Birmingham and the conversation moved on. We were simply making small talk. I'd don't think either of us were offended. Christmas in the commercial sense means different things to different people, you only have to read a Christmas thread on MN to realise that.

freyamay74 · 22/12/2022 07:18

I expect the only thing that would offend the OP more is if people did assume s/he celebrated Christmas!

Some people just want to be offended and look for a problem where there isn't one.

Jackie17177 · 22/12/2022 07:12

moofolk · 22/12/2022 07:04

Reading the thread, I can see a lot of comments that could be construed as defending (unintentional) racism.

I'm wondering if the phrase 'what do you do at Christmas?' (something I commonly hear), would be better for those well meaning people to ask?

Racism? Can you highlight the racist posts/comments because I don't see that in the OP or a lot of the comments... prejudice yes - you could say there is prejudice in that you are being pre-judged on your beliefs based on your appearance (I am not sure why that is a bad thing in this instance though).

moofolk · 22/12/2022 07:04

Reading the thread, I can see a lot of comments that could be construed as defending (unintentional) racism.

I'm wondering if the phrase 'what do you do at Christmas?' (something I commonly hear), would be better for those well meaning people to ask?

RambamThankyouMam · 22/12/2022 06:52

I love being asked this. It's such a relief. Better than everyone assuming, and asking "have you put your tree up yet?" or quizzing DD about Santa.