Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU? People often ask me, "do you celebrate Christmas"?

170 replies

July70 · 21/12/2022 19:34

WTF do they ask me and not the others in the office. Even my stupid clients do that. It's nothing new as I have it at school than less so at uni, and now had this at every place I've worked at. Even those stupid people that live in the close, some ask me.

We are not from the UK and tBH I was never offended but in recent days, possibly too many people being offended over everything and me getting older, should I be offended?

What I find even more offensive is when I tell them that we have always celebrated Christmas sine I can recall in the UK but only in the commercial sense like the vast majority in England, and some roll their eyes.

I know why they ask me, but am I being too sensitive now as I'm pretty sure the vast majority are not being offensive IMO?

OP posts:
Wombatbum · 22/12/2022 10:35

I have lots of Muslim friends, they all take part in Christmas gift giving at work, Christmas cards etc. Some have Christmas trees/decorations and do Christmas dinner. I genuinely don’t think anyone would ever be offended by receiving a Christmas card or gift if they aren’t Christian!

girlmom21 · 22/12/2022 10:34

July70 · 22/12/2022 10:31

@girlmom21

So why not just wish me a "Happy Christmas" like you presumably would to those that looked like indigenous people of the UK?

It's not me that feels like that and there are several others examples on the thread.

I never ask anyone if they celebrate Xmas etc so why am I often asked that??

Because a lot of people don't celebrate Christmas. As I mentioned, my SIL is Jewish. Some of her family celebrate Christmas, some don't.

I have Muslim friends who celebrate Christmas and Muslim friends who don't.

I've asked Muslim people if they're fasting for Ramadan etc to get an insight into them and their religion or culture. It's not offensive.

July70 · 22/12/2022 10:31

@girlmom21

So why not just wish me a "Happy Christmas" like you presumably would to those that looked like indigenous people of the UK?

It's not me that feels like that and there are several others examples on the thread.

I never ask anyone if they celebrate Xmas etc so why am I often asked that??

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 22/12/2022 10:25

July70 · 22/12/2022 10:22

@girlmom21

I'm not sure if you are taking the p with that post

Why not just wish me a "Happy Christmas"?????

As we celebrate it like millions in a secular way, I said same to you/happy xmas..don't drink too much , have a nice hols

If I did not celebrate and you said "Happy Christmas" to me - I'd say thanks, same to you.

Simples.

No I'm not, but I think your posts are incredibly contradictory.

It's offensive to you if people ask if you celebrate, but you can't see how people would feel uncomfortable if they don't celebrate but are asked by you what their plans are.

It's offensive to you if people say 'Jesus wept' but not for you to ask if someone's taking the pee.

You're looking for things to be offended by while not considering anybody else. Some of the ways you've said you treat people are rude and unnecessary.

July70 · 22/12/2022 10:22

@girlmom21

I'm not sure if you are taking the p with that post

Why not just wish me a "Happy Christmas"?????

As we celebrate it like millions in a secular way, I said same to you/happy xmas..don't drink too much , have a nice hols

If I did not celebrate and you said "Happy Christmas" to me - I'd say thanks, same to you.

Simples.

OP posts:
July70 · 22/12/2022 10:19

@baublebeard

Many many thanks, I can 100% relate to that.

I am often asked if Im "Muslim" as well, I'm not as I'm a British Indian and I ask the person in return, "are you Muslim" and the expression on their face IMO educates them not to ask a silly question like that again.

For me, and those twisting my comments can say what they want - I live and let live but this/England is my country as much as the next person and between my parents, family, friends and me, we like many others have paid millions in taxes and contiue to do so and I am ticked off for being asked these questions oftem EG

Do you celbrate Christmas?
What is your Christian name
Are you Muslim

I'm Brith Indian that love England and her traditions and also celebrate both ie UK and my motherland ones. For the record, even the motherland celebrations are in the commercial sense as is life.

If England was attacked by Russia/France, any country, I would defend our land from the trenches unlike our leaders hiding in the bunkers.

I'm entitled to say how I feel when asked as above but I'm not "woke" etc and I have a lot of respect for all, especially those that respect me.

Happy Christmas😀 to all (simple as that) :)

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 22/12/2022 10:14

I've never asked anyone if they "celebrate Christmas" but what I have heard is talking to people I don't know well and whne I've said "what are you doing over Christmas," one responded "we don't celebrate it" I said ok and moved on

so why make people feel uncomfortable by asking if the celebrate it as I dont want to be asked every year about it

I personally feel like asking what someone's doing and them having to tell you they don't celebrate would make them more uncomfortable than if you asked if they celebrated Christmas.

roarfeckingroarr · 22/12/2022 10:12

Some D&I training from work suggested that asking is better than assuming people do celebrate Christmas.

You clearly disagree.

It's almost like the corporate D&I industry speaks a load of bollocks...

roarfeckingroarr · 22/12/2022 10:11

"Jesus wept" is not offensive. It's a common exclamation in the UK.

July70 · 22/12/2022 10:09

@Wibbly1008

Why is it "repsectful to ask"? I get fed up with it as per my OP
Why not just say to me, EB, "have a nice xmas, happy xmas etc"?/ Why not just say that as my response would be = "thanks...happy xmas to you and enjoy... don't drink too much,lol etc etc"

depending if a work mate or who said it

I've never asked anyone if they "celebrate Christmas" but what I have heard is talking to people I don't know well and whne I've said "what are you doing over Christmas," one responded "we don't celebrate it" I said ok and moved on

so why make people feel uncomfortable by asking if the celebrate it as I dont want to be asked every year about it

OP posts:
baublebeard · 22/12/2022 10:08

Yeah I'd say it's annoying but I'm not white and get asked all the time. I was born here and have a British parent and guaranteed I'll be the only person asked out for a group of white people.

I'm not really offended so much as aggrieved that I can never ever fit in here despite having only know the U.K. as my home culturally and literally. Just another thing to add to a long list of things that add to a feeling of being displaced in a country I'd like to think is where I am from.
Most people celebrate Christmas here. I think it's rude in the U.K. to not be able to say something like, are you up to much over the Christmas holidays. Personally I think in a n almost secular country with Christian foundations it's fair to assume one is celebrating Christmas in some way or another ie not religiously vs assuming you might offend someone by incorrectly guessing they won't be.

The amount of time people assume I'm either Muslim or Hindu as well gets on my nerves. But hey just part of being brown here I suppose.

Wibbly1008 · 22/12/2022 10:02

I think it’s important to ask. I have friends who are Jewish and they don’t celebrate Christmas, it’s respectful to ask and not just presume.

nancydroo · 22/12/2022 10:00

Jesus wept is an exclamation rather than swearing. A lot of people say Jesus Christ as an exclamation. Common parlance imo. Like OMG oh my Lord. Oh my god! And so on.

Wibbly1008 · 22/12/2022 09:58

If people presume you celebrate Christmas they get berated for not being culturally sensitive. If people ask if you celebrate Christmas they are upsetting people by asking. Only in the UK are you never able to win.

July70 · 22/12/2022 09:56

sorry did not add name

@roarfeckingroarr

It is offensive and if you don't recognise that I have nothing more to add. FYI, I'm not Christain but have a lot of respect for all religions

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 22/12/2022 09:56

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

July70 · 22/12/2022 09:55

It is offensive and if you don't recognise that I have nothing more to add. FYI, I'm not Christain but have a lot of respect for all religions

OP posts:
roarfeckingroarr · 22/12/2022 09:51

Thanks @girlmom21

roarfeckingroarr · 22/12/2022 09:49

@July70 that's not how I use "Jesus wept". It's not "cussing" anyone, it's like a resigned sigh at how ridiculous something is.

But as you're not a Christian, although you do celebrate the excesses of Christmas, just not the religious bits, surely that isn't offensive?

You do sound like someone looking to find offence.

girlmom21 · 22/12/2022 09:48

July70 · 22/12/2022 09:46

@roarfeckingroarr

About you stating at the end of your silly post, "Jesus wept."

You are cussing me and then make an offensive comment like that.

Incredible but shows what you are like.

How is saying "Jesus wept" offensive? It's a commonly used phrase.

OnBoardTheHeartOfGold · 22/12/2022 09:47

I get asked all the time and it's never been anything other than out of interest.
I'm pretty sure they don't care one way or the other but are just making conversation or interested.
I've never had anyone follow up with 'fuck off then' when I explain not really but we do have a family get together and traditional Xmas food.

July70 · 22/12/2022 09:46

@roarfeckingroarr

About you stating at the end of your silly post, "Jesus wept."

You are cussing me and then make an offensive comment like that.

Incredible but shows what you are like.

OP posts:
July70 · 22/12/2022 09:42

Here is the link that proves what I have said re the vast majority and Xmas

www.thisislocallondon.co.uk/indepth/features/23207053.christmas-commercialisation-olivia-eyeson-parmiters-school/

From the guradian

One well-established tradition of Christmas is the publication of studies showing the threat to Christmas traditions. This year we learn, according to a study by online marketplace Groupon, that 46% of the young have never sung a traditional Christmas carol and 47% think that midnight mass has had its day.

www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2022/dec/03/christmas-past-present-how-secular-britain-found-new-ways-to-celebrate-the-season

===========

to be clear, you can wih me "happy Christmas and ask me for my "Christian name" I won't be offended but get fed up as I/we have always celebrated xmas a an excuse to drink and eat in excess, spend money on gifts, get togther for kness up etc like millions of others. As for my "Christian name" it is my first name but some people will never change and I get that.

Those twisting my comments, please carry on as everyone can see through you.

Happy Christams to all and have a nice break and don't spend money you cant afford to spend and do not get too drunk

:)

OP posts:
roarfeckingroarr · 22/12/2022 09:37

@July70 so you get annoyed about people asking your "Christian" name but also at people questioning whether you celebrate Christmas...

Jesus wept

July70 · 22/12/2022 09:34

@MrsDoyle351 Thank you

As I said, several re twisting what I have said.
I get annoyed and IMO I'm asked this question because of the colour of my skin.
However, we have always celebrated Christmas as in the commercial aspect of just like tens of millions of others in the UK that celebrate xmas a secular event.

I get fed up with the older group aged 65+ asking me my Christian name.

With the above two scenarios I never get upset, I don't challenge but just state how I feel

i love England and the majority of people here as having travelled the world inc the motherland, IMO, England is a much fairer place than most.

I even posted a link from a media source a well known one from London that confirmed Xmas for most was "secular" in the uk

Yes, ignore reality and twist my comments if you wish but I'm not alone in feeling like this but to be clear, when people give me a xmas card or wish me happy xmas I always return the good wishes. Now, keep on trying to twist what I have stated

www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2022/dec/03/christmas-past-present-how-secular-britain-found-new-ways-to-celebrate-the-season

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread