Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wine Switch - petty or IANBU?

86 replies

Swinewitch · 21/12/2022 16:27

Two lovely women have cleaned my house for several years, they do a great job and we’re on friendly terms. Today I left out some extra money and a bottle of wine each, as a Christmas thank you. I came home a little earlier than expected, so they were still here. I noticed that the wine bottles were different! When I checked later, the original bottles I’d selected were back in the box so they had clearly switched the bottles - perhaps to a wine they preferred!

I was quite shocked and I think a little put out. It’s not the biggest deal in the world I know, but they do hold a trusted position and this seemed a little… untrustworthy. It was meant to be a nice thoughtful gesture which now feels a bit soured.

So…AIBU I’m thinking this wine switch was a little sneaky?

OP posts:
RunningFromInsanity · 21/12/2022 19:49

So it’s ballsy and ok for someone to steal a box of chocolates from a workplace (see other trending thread) but theft and sackable to swap a bottle of wine to an equal bottle of wine?

Cleaners really are assumed to be lesser people on MN.

VladmirsPoutine · 21/12/2022 19:48

ForestofD · 21/12/2022 19:38

That is cheeky. My OH carefully selected certain wines for a few friends as Christmas gifts when he ordered a wine box. (E.g. Bob loves Merlot etc)

You could drop her a message along those lines- 'I selected a certain wine as a gift for someone else and it's not there anymore; do you know what happened to it?'

You could drop her a message along those lines- 'I selected a certain wine as a gift for someone else and it's not there anymore; do you know what happened to it?

Don't word it like this because what if she says "Nope, not a clue" that leaves you at a dead end. Just text and explain that you 'noticed' they've swapped the bottles. The fact remains even if they're amazing cleaners this will always be niggling away at you and the longer you leave it the more absurd it gets to bring it up. Send a message, be calm about it and see where you land.

girlmom21 · 21/12/2022 19:42

I'd have trust issues with them after this, personally.

ForestofD · 21/12/2022 19:38

That is cheeky. My OH carefully selected certain wines for a few friends as Christmas gifts when he ordered a wine box. (E.g. Bob loves Merlot etc)

You could drop her a message along those lines- 'I selected a certain wine as a gift for someone else and it's not there anymore; do you know what happened to it?'

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 21/12/2022 19:37

Was there a vast difference between the different wines in the case - e.g. was it a mixed case of red and white? Just trying to understand why someone would bother.

Swinewitch · 21/12/2022 19:37

Flyingsatsuma · 21/12/2022 18:12

I am a cleaner. I would never have done this. I would be happy with any gift a client gave me. Though I wouldn’t expect one, it’s a lovely thought. You sound generous and I wouldn’t have abused your generosity.

Thank you so much 😊

OP posts:
Swinewitch · 21/12/2022 19:35

wackamole · 21/12/2022 18:16

If they've really taken bottles from elsewhere in your house and switched them for the ones you clearly left as gifts, that's really odd. Fine if they switched with each other, or did anything they wanted with the bottles they were given, but not OK to take yours. Personally I probably wouldn't care which bottles they got, but helping themselves to non-gift bottles without asking, even though leaving something of apparent equal value, would make me wonder if I could trust them.

This is exactly it!

OP posts:
Swinewitch · 21/12/2022 19:34

Mummieslncorporated · 21/12/2022 19:30

Then I checked the box of wine to find the original bottles gone and two empty places where the other bottles had been

So are you saying they took two bottles each?

Sorry, I worded that really badly (may have just had a large glass of that wine myself!).

it was a new case of wine this morning. I took two bottles out as gifts for them. They then switched to two other bottles from the same case, leaving two empty spaces.

I reckon they assumed I wouldn’t have noticed, but I did.

OP posts:
Judgyjudgy · 21/12/2022 19:32

That's very rude, I find that quite appealing behaviour

Swinewitch · 21/12/2022 19:31

VladmirsPoutine · 21/12/2022 19:03

If this is true what have you done or said to them about it?

At the moment nothing. I didn’t at the time, as explained in my last post. I am currently ruminating about whether or not to say anything or to let it go.

I try to be kind and compassionate and I know they’ve had a pretty rubbish time over the last couple of years. I do appreciate what they do for me (it was so lovely to come home to a clean house when I’ve been so busy with some really challenging work). I know what’s going on here - I’m hesitant about saying anything as I don’t want them to be upset, but that’s leaving me feeling pretty pissed off and taken advantage off, which I like even less.

OP posts:
Mummieslncorporated · 21/12/2022 19:30

Then I checked the box of wine to find the original bottles gone and two empty places where the other bottles had been

So are you saying they took two bottles each?

honeylulu · 21/12/2022 19:30

I would feel that was a bit of a slap in the face. As they're good cleaners i wouldn't dispense with their services but there would be no wine gift next Christmas.

Swinewitch · 21/12/2022 19:26

Sorry for the random 🤣 - the app is playing up. That was to the person asking another poster if she was the cleaner!

to answer some questions:

No partner, just two teens who were still in bed at this point. Whilst they may possibly nick a bottle of wine, I am 100% sure that they wouldn’t have swapped them over. It just wouldn’t be on their radar.

This morning, I left £100 on kitchen counter (pay £70 usually). On top of the notes I put the 2 bottles. I’d also messaged one of the women with a few specifics about what needed to be done and the added that I was going out but had left money & wine out for them.

I had opened a new case of wine and selected the same bottles for them both (aware I didn’t want to differentiate between the two as I like them both). I put the bottles in the kitchen, briefly wondered if I should put them in gift bags but decided not to. I noted which wine is selected - I vividly remembered doing so, noted the label, grape, country, etc. I vividly remember doing this - menopausal or not!

I came home earlier than usual. They were still here, kids still in bed. As I walked through the front door, I noticed 2 bottles of wine there (moved from the kitchen), with some keys. That put me a bit off balance - I knew it wasn’t the wine I left out for them. A few things went through my mind - was that a gift from them for me? Had a neighbour dropped them round for me? It initially didn’t occur to me that they might have made a switch. So I didn’t bring it up then, as I was a bit wrong-footed by it.

I then had to go and do some work, but the confusion about it stayed with me. They called out to say goodbye and then I went to the kitchen, saw the original wine had gone, as had the bottles by the front door. Then I checked the box of wine to find the original bottles gone and two empty places where the other bottles had been. I am absolutely 100% sure on this. I know it to be true. I may be of menopausal age, but I know myself, I have good self-awareness and am quite willing/able to admit when I’ve got something wrong, but I know I’m right in this case.

I would’ve been more than happy to have suggested that they choose a bottle they’d like. But that didn’t happen, instead they chose to help themselves. And that has caused me to question what else they may cross the line with.

OP posts:
VladmirsPoutine · 21/12/2022 19:03

If this is true what have you done or said to them about it?

Swinewitch · 21/12/2022 18:55

😂

OP posts:
Arniesleftleg · 21/12/2022 18:33

Thats pretty out of order. Makes me wonder what else they may have 'swapped' over the years. I have my own cleaning business and am super grateful for anything I get given, and boy have I been given lots of Prosecco this year. I would never dream of swapping anything, it's rude and pretty disrespectful, even if they were all of the same value. How were they to know you hadn't earmarked the rest of the box?
Also, say you left them a tenner each, what would you do if they swapped it for a twenty? Same principle!

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 21/12/2022 18:32

One possibility is that one tidied away the bottles before one or both realised they were left out as a gift and then they took them out again but didn’t remember the exact bottles.

I thought this too - but OP hasn't been back to say whether she has a partner/housemate/child living with her who swapped them, which is even more likely.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 21/12/2022 18:30

It does seem a really surprising thing to do.

I would let it go, if all the wine was of a similar value. If you left them a £4.99 bottle of Tesco plonk de plonk and they swapped it for an 1846 Château Lafite, that's a different matter.

CoffeeBoy · 21/12/2022 18:28

Yes, maybe one didn’t realise they were a gift and put them in the box and then the other said where’s our wine. So they got two bottles out thinking they’d got the right ones. That does sound plausible actually.

CoffeeBoy · 21/12/2022 18:26

They thought you’d get away with it and not notice. Which makes me worry what else they might do if they thought you wouldn’t notice. But I also see that maybe they thought it wouldn’t matter. But they should have asked.

vincettenoir · 21/12/2022 18:23

I also feel like it is unlikely they switched. It sounds like you have a good long-standing relationship so it would be an offbeat thing to do.

One possibility is that one tidied away the bottles before one or both realised they were left out as a gift and then they took them out again but didn’t remember the exact bottles. Maybe I am being overly generous in my estimate of what happened but I’d give them the benefit of the doubt if you’re otherwise happy with them.

purplecorkheart · 21/12/2022 18:20

Mumdiva99 · 21/12/2022 17:32

Sorry but I donthink they switched them at all. I think you, by mistake, left different ones out.

I do things that I can argue till I'm blue in the face I did X but the only thing that can have happened is Y.

Maybe you were rushing. Maybe you were distracted. But there is no way 2 great employees would do this and risk their job. Especially as you have always been happy before.

I think this too.

lovedoris · 21/12/2022 18:19

I came here to say are you menopausal?! Im perimenopausal and I keep doing things I don’t mean to, or forgetting a stage in some process, etc. I forgot my handbag the other day and had to look back on the ring doorbell because I simply couldn’t remember leaving the house, had I locked the door etc? Just a thought…

wackamole · 21/12/2022 18:16

If they've really taken bottles from elsewhere in your house and switched them for the ones you clearly left as gifts, that's really odd. Fine if they switched with each other, or did anything they wanted with the bottles they were given, but not OK to take yours. Personally I probably wouldn't care which bottles they got, but helping themselves to non-gift bottles without asking, even though leaving something of apparent equal value, would make me wonder if I could trust them.

thelobsterquadrille · 21/12/2022 18:14

Are you absolutely sure they switched?