Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be feeling low that I have an osteoporosis diagnosis at 52?

35 replies

Namechangedfortodayspost · 21/12/2022 16:13

I realise there are far worse things that could happen to me.

However, after a routine DEXA scan - I've had fairly stable osteopenia for over 9 years due to an early menopause - my neck of femor is moving into osteoporosis territory. On the line.

I do weights, I take exercise seriously and have done for years - I've taken calcium and Vit D for years too. And yet, I'm still at this place.

I feel worried about falling, worried that it's going to keep getting worse.

I've got an appointment in Jan with a bone consultant who's great, but just...well, just wanted to voice my frustration with it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
weebarra · 22/12/2022 13:53

I feel for you, I'm dreading this.
I had a surgical menopause at 37 and I'm now 45. I've been osteopenic for a while now but waiting for a hip scan as it's become very painful.
I'm also now terrified of ice which makes me feel ancient.

Hahahahohoho · 22/12/2022 13:43

Namechangedfortodayspost · 22/12/2022 11:19

Thanks so much. Such interesting posts and I'll definitely check out the FB groups and get tested for PTH - although, given it runs very strongly in the family, I don't suspect it will be that.

Two more questions for those in the know. I do lots of exercise, including weight bearing. But I'm aware I might need to be more mindful now about what exercise I do.

A: I love to box. In a class, with a partner. Or with a bag. I thought it was probably good for bone density, given the constant 'thuds.' Now I wonder if it's considered too 'jerky', which is an osteoporosis no-no and if it's really a fracture waiting to happen.

B: Also, I was looking and comparing my DEXA scans. See my table comparison. I don't think the advance is bad - in fact it's minor except for the NOF T. Just wondered if anyone had any thoughts? Aware no one is a doctor!

Is the change even significant - there's a margin of error on the Dexa Scan. They are not always consistent - was it the same machine?

Namechangedfortodayspost · 22/12/2022 11:19

Thanks so much. Such interesting posts and I'll definitely check out the FB groups and get tested for PTH - although, given it runs very strongly in the family, I don't suspect it will be that.

Two more questions for those in the know. I do lots of exercise, including weight bearing. But I'm aware I might need to be more mindful now about what exercise I do.

A: I love to box. In a class, with a partner. Or with a bag. I thought it was probably good for bone density, given the constant 'thuds.' Now I wonder if it's considered too 'jerky', which is an osteoporosis no-no and if it's really a fracture waiting to happen.

B: Also, I was looking and comparing my DEXA scans. See my table comparison. I don't think the advance is bad - in fact it's minor except for the NOF T. Just wondered if anyone had any thoughts? Aware no one is a doctor!

AIBU to be feeling low that I have an osteoporosis diagnosis at 52?
OP posts:
HundredMilesAnHour · 22/12/2022 11:17

123boom · 22/12/2022 07:35

@HundredMilesAnHour i don’t understand why you keep saying the OP would have to have symptoms and to base it on this. Many don’t have symptoms and osteoporosis can be a symptom. Yes, the bloods don’t always show it if you’re normocalcemic. But better to have the bloods in case as it will show in many (as it did for me!). It’s just a test for calcium and PTH and better to rule it out. Along with coeliac test as suggested by another poster.

Because the vast majority of people with parathyroid disease have a variety of (usually non-specific) symptoms (and probably don't even realise why) and is why doctors will test PTH levels in addition to calcium. Yes of course the OP should ask for it to be checked but your implication that it will have happened when she had her calcium checked is quite misleading and could cause unnecessary worry both for the OP and for anyone with osteoporosis / osteopenia reading this.

123boom · 22/12/2022 07:35

@HundredMilesAnHour i don’t understand why you keep saying the OP would have to have symptoms and to base it on this. Many don’t have symptoms and osteoporosis can be a symptom. Yes, the bloods don’t always show it if you’re normocalcemic. But better to have the bloods in case as it will show in many (as it did for me!). It’s just a test for calcium and PTH and better to rule it out. Along with coeliac test as suggested by another poster.

Orangeover · 22/12/2022 04:14

HundredMilesAnHour · 21/12/2022 22:33

It's not particularly common to test for PTH as a matter of course unless someone is having symptoms such as fatigue, brain fog, stomach pain, etc and/or has high calcium (which might have been picked up in a urine test). This is why I've asked several times on this thread if the OP has any other symptoms.

Also to be clear (in case the OP needs this info), PTH isn't a 'simple test'. It's essential that a EDTA vial is used to test PTH - some hospitals use non-EDTA vials which renders the result meaningless. And obviously serum calcium (and adjusted calcium) must be part of the same draw as the PTH.

Apologies OP, I don't mean to derail your thread. Parathyroidism can be complex and isn't well understood by many UK medical professionals and there are some real horror stories of people with this disease fighting for years to be treated and/or recognised as having the disease.

Do you know which hospitals use the non-EDTA vial? As far as I know my blood was tested for it as standard screening - my only symptom was a broken bone (well multiple really)

HundredMilesAnHour · 21/12/2022 22:33

Orangeover · 21/12/2022 22:17

I think if you’ve had bloods taken to test for Vit D Ana Calcium there’s a very good chance they have tested for parathyroid - you just need to ask the question- it’s a simple test

It's not particularly common to test for PTH as a matter of course unless someone is having symptoms such as fatigue, brain fog, stomach pain, etc and/or has high calcium (which might have been picked up in a urine test). This is why I've asked several times on this thread if the OP has any other symptoms.

Also to be clear (in case the OP needs this info), PTH isn't a 'simple test'. It's essential that a EDTA vial is used to test PTH - some hospitals use non-EDTA vials which renders the result meaningless. And obviously serum calcium (and adjusted calcium) must be part of the same draw as the PTH.

Apologies OP, I don't mean to derail your thread. Parathyroidism can be complex and isn't well understood by many UK medical professionals and there are some real horror stories of people with this disease fighting for years to be treated and/or recognised as having the disease.

Orangeover · 21/12/2022 22:17

HundredMilesAnHour · 21/12/2022 22:05

I'm a member of this group as I've had primary hyperparathyroidism. However, other than osteoporosis, the OP hasn't yet said anything which indicates she has a problem with any of her parathyroids.

I think if you’ve had bloods taken to test for Vit D Ana Calcium there’s a very good chance they have tested for parathyroid - you just need to ask the question- it’s a simple test

HundredMilesAnHour · 21/12/2022 22:05

Toothpastestain · 21/12/2022 21:44

The facebook group called, "Hyperparathyroid UK action4change" really helped my friend who was in your position. Good luck.

I'm a member of this group as I've had primary hyperparathyroidism. However, other than osteoporosis, the OP hasn't yet said anything which indicates she has a problem with any of her parathyroids.

HundredMilesAnHour · 21/12/2022 22:02

Talapia · 21/12/2022 21:30

Thanks for telling me this. I've had so little advice.
I'll take the calcium in the morning.

You should also split your magnesium up rather than taking it in one big dose. So, for example, in the morning take minimum 200mg magnesium malate plus 2-3000iu vit D plus 50mg vit K2 plus 3-6mg boron, 4 hours later take your calcium, 30 mins before bed take minimum 200mg magnesium glycinate (or threonate).

Also be aware that your body absorbs calcium more efficiently from food than from supplements so it's important to consider what you're eating.

Hope this helps!

Toothpastestain · 21/12/2022 21:44

The facebook group called, "Hyperparathyroid UK action4change" really helped my friend who was in your position. Good luck.

Talapia · 21/12/2022 21:30

HundredMilesAnHour · 21/12/2022 20:59

Please make sure that you're taking your calcium 2-4 hours apart from your magnesium as not doing this badly affects absorption.

Thanks for telling me this. I've had so little advice.
I'll take the calcium in the morning.

HundredMilesAnHour · 21/12/2022 20:59

Talapia · 21/12/2022 20:22

Me too, following a surgical menopause. I'm also worried about falls and it's made me feel really old.

I work out, lift weights and take calcium/Vitamin D, magnesium and B vits.

Please make sure that you're taking your calcium 2-4 hours apart from your magnesium as not doing this badly affects absorption.

Orangeover · 21/12/2022 20:36

Talapia · 21/12/2022 20:22

Me too, following a surgical menopause. I'm also worried about falls and it's made me feel really old.

I work out, lift weights and take calcium/Vitamin D, magnesium and B vits.

Do you take vit k?

Talapia · 21/12/2022 20:22

Namechangedfortodayspost · 21/12/2022 16:13

I realise there are far worse things that could happen to me.

However, after a routine DEXA scan - I've had fairly stable osteopenia for over 9 years due to an early menopause - my neck of femor is moving into osteoporosis territory. On the line.

I do weights, I take exercise seriously and have done for years - I've taken calcium and Vit D for years too. And yet, I'm still at this place.

I feel worried about falling, worried that it's going to keep getting worse.

I've got an appointment in Jan with a bone consultant who's great, but just...well, just wanted to voice my frustration with it.

Me too, following a surgical menopause. I'm also worried about falls and it's made me feel really old.

I work out, lift weights and take calcium/Vitamin D, magnesium and B vits.

PinewoodScent · 21/12/2022 20:18

Have you been checked for Coeliac disease?
www.coeliac.org.uk/information-and-support/coeliac-disease/conditions-linked-to-coeliac-disease/osteoporosis/

HundredMilesAnHour · 21/12/2022 20:16

123boom · 21/12/2022 16:40

Hi OP, it can be linked to hyperparathyroidism so worth a test to confirm that’s not the underlying reason. You won’t necessarily have other symptoms. I hope the appt you have is reassuring and all goes ok. It’s a lot to take in at the moment and will be a shock

You won't necessarily have high calcium levels either but it could still be hyperparathyroidism. Other symptoms will be more indicative.

Orangeover · 21/12/2022 18:27

One of my friends is a radiologist - she agreed with me that biphosphates that should have said - she agreed with me that I was too young for biphosphates and she wouldn't take them either. And I should say I had a horrific wrist injury - still suffering 10 months later - was very careful in the ice, more so than I have ever been before.

Orangeover · 21/12/2022 18:23

Moderate www.facebook.com/groups/381491778677183

Hardcore www.facebook.com/groups/555356381725468

There are many more - don't let perfect be the enemy of good - I can't go hardcore but I do a mix.

We all take risks with every choice but you'll consider more closely what risk suits you, that the doctor who just wants you out the door as quickly as possible without truly understanding your situation - you feeling happy about your meds is hugely important.

TinaTeaspoons · 21/12/2022 18:19

DH has rheumatoid arthritis and ulcerative colitis and being tested for osteoarthritis as well. 😔

Orangeover · 21/12/2022 18:16

One of my friends is a radiologist - she agreed with me that biphosphates, they do not improve bone strength - only the density, your bones need to be strong. As far as I can see studies have shown (I have read them) they make very little difference to hip results, better density results with spine , but what good is improved density if your bones aren't stronger and the dexa can't tell you. My spine scores are absolutely fine so what's the point?

You need to link up with some facebook groups to dig down into the latest research. Not trying to convince you either way - we all have to make a decision we are comfortable with - my first GP couldn't even read the scan results - he had no clue - told me lifestyle changes were absolutely pointless - thing is you need more than Vit d and calcium to build bone - you need lots of protein and collagen, you need the right Vit K to absorb the Vit D, you need Vit C - not citric acid, you need magnesium glycinate - not citrate- you need the full suite - I'm not done yet!
The consultant who read my scan results didn't feel I needed to know what he had tested me for or what my blood results were - take ownership of your health they say - no one else will - the NHS has cast me adrift before and I have healed myself (more than once).
Anyway here's the link
www.osteoscanuk.com/

Namechangedfortodayspost · 21/12/2022 17:51

Orangeover · 21/12/2022 17:05

I've had the same this year - no opportunity to speak to a consultant. I've started my research - enough to know I'm not going to take Alendronic Acid - I'm too young and the side effects are horrific and more likely the longer you take it, I got my blood test results - all normal, I've started on a few supplements magnesium Vit K fish oil and vit D - not taking Calcium - excess quantities can cause problems as can excess Vit D, I will attack this with diet, lifestyle and HRT.
Going to book in an Echolight scan which will give me more information on bone strength not just bone density. And I'll start to get the done every year so I can monitor my progress. Not that it's cheap but I'm a clumsy bugger so tripping over things is my way of life!

I can't see where you can get an echolight scan in the uk. are you able to link me to locations?

I'm on the fence about bisphonates. The problem is that i think you can attack it with lifestyle, diet and exercise but there'll be a baseline that you can't change with that alone. As proven in my case!

OP posts:
ghjklo · 21/12/2022 17:43

I was reading that vitamin K can be really helpful for the D / Calcium absorption, something about Jarlsberg cheese! Might be worth looking into if you don't already take K. Some study was done and it helped women with bone issues.

HopingSomeoneIsAwake · 21/12/2022 17:40

I have borderline osteoporosis at 27 years old… according to the DEXA scan I had… it is depressing to think about so I try and not dwell on it too much and just do what I can to prevent any further damage being done! Sending hugs xx

Orangeover · 21/12/2022 17:05

I've had the same this year - no opportunity to speak to a consultant. I've started my research - enough to know I'm not going to take Alendronic Acid - I'm too young and the side effects are horrific and more likely the longer you take it, I got my blood test results - all normal, I've started on a few supplements magnesium Vit K fish oil and vit D - not taking Calcium - excess quantities can cause problems as can excess Vit D, I will attack this with diet, lifestyle and HRT.
Going to book in an Echolight scan which will give me more information on bone strength not just bone density. And I'll start to get the done every year so I can monitor my progress. Not that it's cheap but I'm a clumsy bugger so tripping over things is my way of life!