Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Re Ambulance/ nurse strikes

432 replies

TheWindIsChanging · 21/12/2022 15:17

The last thread reached 1000 messages so assume that means it automatically closes any thread so thought I would continue the debate. My view is that it is unreasonable for any person in charge of a person's life to simply down tools regardless of pay issues. I wouldn't disagree pay is too low but so are many jobs yet not all jobs carry the responsibility of saving lives which will be lost during the strikes.
It's no great shock the usual suspects are screaming about the tories again waving tiny fists around red faced incandescent with rage. The reality is increasing wages across the board would lead to an inflation death spiral which happened in the 70s further decreasing quality of life for all of us, not just the NHS workers.
Inflation is the main issue that causes issues with wages, and the reason for this is principally covid lockdowns which ( cue the drumroll) were brought in to protect the useless NHS... the irony that this same "service" is now complaining about economic problems which it helped to instigate is hilarious. I can't remember a single year in the last 20 where it wasn't nearly "bursting at the seems" and given the amount of tax payers money disappearing into it like the metaphorical black hole perhaps time it was scrapped. I don't see these same issues in other countries..a healthcare worker is not a typical profession as the basic goal is to save lives not abandoning ship. As others have said, all very well to type YABU, but I suspect the wind would change quickly if it was a relative who died as a consequence of these disgusting strikes which will cost lives make no mistake about it. That said, the same people raging about the state of the economy were labelling anyone not supporting lockdowns as a " granny killer" which anyone with an IQ over 70 could see would lead to this mess.

OP posts:
TheWindIsChanging · 21/12/2022 19:12

IAmADancer · 21/12/2022 18:55

@Puzzledandpissedoff i know it’s risky but it is a key cost in NHS expenditure, one that didn’t exist at its inception, but no one wants to talk about it.

at some point, we have to have the very difficult conversation about what you treat first and the impact obesity has on the NHS

I agree to an extent with the point of personal responsibility but prioritising patients on lifestyle decisions would never work as someone obese could simply claim mobility problems which may be a legitimate reason contrary to laziness/ gluttony etc. It would be going down a dangerous road similar to when people were implying the unvaccinated shouldn't be treated etc.

OP posts:
pointythings · 21/12/2022 19:11

@IAmADancer solving the obesity crisis is going to be difficult - and it's down to money. Wages in the UK are low, and the food that is worst for us in terms of weight is also the cheapest. So dealing with that would be the solution, but guess what? It's going to cost money. Actual investment in the health of the population. Not going to be popular with Conservative voters.

The diversity managers that people like to rail against are (at £4m) not all that expensive, and they do a lot of good work. Having a workforce that is representative of the general population is good for people's health because it means the workforce is trained to recognise issues that are particular to people's cultural backgrounds. Just one example of this is in mental health, where people from Afro-Caribbean cultures have been historically less likely to engage with mental health services, more likely to do so late when their condition is already very severe, and less likely to engage with medication and therapy. This is now very slowly changing because staff are better at engaging with this group so that they are able to trust the professionals and seek help before their acuity levels become so very high. There are many other examples, and going on about 'diversity managers' is a cheap shot used by people who actually don't know what these people do.

Iwanttoquitthegym · 21/12/2022 19:08

And yes lots had ‘underlying conditions’ like mild asthma, high blood pressure, high cholesterol, BMI of 30. Not conditions that were going to kill them any time soon. think how
many people you know have one of those and if you think they are terminally ill.

orchid220 · 21/12/2022 19:07

IAmADancer · 21/12/2022 19:05

I think the NHS would be even more screwed if those awful private sector workers stopped earning the amounts they earn, and paying 45% tax rate on their earnings.

Just because people earn above average wage, doesn’t mean they are nasty hateful human beings who despise anyone that earns less than them.
Most higher earners come from working class roots, are likely to have been the first in their family to go to university, wholeheartedly support the nurses and doctors striking but want to have proper conversations about the NHS not just continue to throw unending amounts of money at it.
But yeah, it’s easier to demonise people who dare to earn a bit more than everyone else and call them Tory scum

The tax doesn't have to be paid by private sector workers. Public sector worker also pay tax and if they earned more they would pay more tax.

Iwanttoquitthegym · 21/12/2022 19:06

I’m glad the nightingales weren’t needed because if we had got to that situation it would have been game over for anyone with any other illness in the normal hospitals.
the vaccine has had an enormous effect. April 20 and January 21 in the peaks we had 100s of critically ill patients with covid dying everywhere. Mothers and sons, husbands and wives, fathers and daughters. It was horrendous and i am sure there will be huge mental health consequences for families and staff.
now there are lots of people in hospital with covid but I can’t remember that last time someone I cared for died from it. While in the peak I was losing several patients a day on my itu. And numbers in itu now are tiny. So the vaccine worked.

IAmADancer · 21/12/2022 19:05

I think the NHS would be even more screwed if those awful private sector workers stopped earning the amounts they earn, and paying 45% tax rate on their earnings.

Just because people earn above average wage, doesn’t mean they are nasty hateful human beings who despise anyone that earns less than them.
Most higher earners come from working class roots, are likely to have been the first in their family to go to university, wholeheartedly support the nurses and doctors striking but want to have proper conversations about the NHS not just continue to throw unending amounts of money at it.
But yeah, it’s easier to demonise people who dare to earn a bit more than everyone else and call them Tory scum

Puzzledandpissedoff · 21/12/2022 19:01

I completely agree, IAmADancer, but as suggested this probably isn't the most productive place to discuss obesity, coming back as it does to a subject people would rather not address

Pursue it and I absolutely guarantee you'll be told that you "have no idea", "simply don't understand" and in any case are merely aiming to "fat shame"

Eleganz · 21/12/2022 19:00

Pinkblanket · 21/12/2022 18:56

Have you also started a thread about how outraged you are about the private sector pay rises that are also escalating inflation?
It's not hard to find examples of substantial pay awards this year.

But these are the rewards of honest enterprise, not the undeserved largess of feckless public servants sponging off the taxpayer! 😉

Pinkblanket · 21/12/2022 18:56

Have you also started a thread about how outraged you are about the private sector pay rises that are also escalating inflation?
It's not hard to find examples of substantial pay awards this year.

IAmADancer · 21/12/2022 18:55

@Puzzledandpissedoff i know it’s risky but it is a key cost in NHS expenditure, one that didn’t exist at its inception, but no one wants to talk about it.

at some point, we have to have the very difficult conversation about what you treat first and the impact obesity has on the NHS

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 21/12/2022 18:55

TimBoothseyes · 21/12/2022 18:39

Well if the Government succeed with this then problem solved.....lots of money to pay those striking a better wage....except they'll make up some lame reason as to why that won't happen.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-64029040

£112 million would cover an increase to nurses salres of around 0.5%.

However, if the tories hadn't created a £30 billion hole in the economy with Trussenomics

Or if they hadn't lost £40 billion in tax revenue due to how they enacted brexit

Or if they hadn't spent £38 billion on test and trace

Or if they hadn't written of £4 billion of covid fraud

Or if they hadn't wasted £9 billion on useless PPE

Or if they hadn't overpaid £11 billion on interest to service our national debt

Or if they hadn't committed to spending £40+ billion on HS2

Or if they hadn't already spent £18.5 billion on yet another trainline for London

Or if they hadn't accepted they'll lose around £11 billion in failures to repay covid loans

They probably would have had they money to fund pay rises for public sector workers.

But that wouldn't enrich them or their mates so it's not going to happen.

Notonthestairs · 21/12/2022 18:53

What about the £3 billion spent on agency nurses per annum?

Do we want to maybe reduce those costs by retaining existing staff and attracting new ones?

IAmADancer · 21/12/2022 18:53

@Blossomtoes the main use for an MBA is if you work in strategy. (This is why lots of consultants have MBA’s) It helps you to identify issues in a business, normally the underperforming/loss making, and how you can turn the business around so that it makes money.
There are better course, that cost less, that people could go on rather than an MBA, which will of minimal use to a business that doesn’t charge people for its services

Puzzledandpissedoff · 21/12/2022 18:52

Managing the cost of obesity and all the issues that come with that at £6.5b a year www.frontier-economics.com/uk/en/news-and-articles/articles/article-i9130-the-annual-social-cost-of-obesity-in-the-uk/

Bit risky to mention obesity on here, IAmADancer
On such a fast moving thread you may well escape, but otherwise you could quickly discover that it's the ultimate it's-not-my-fault topic

IAmADancer · 21/12/2022 18:49

@pointythings out of interest as you work in the NHS, what are your thoughts on how much obesity costs the NHS(£6b per year) and the £4m spent on diversity training? Or is that the Tories fault too?

Blossomtoes · 21/12/2022 18:48

IAmADancer · 21/12/2022 18:43

@Blossomtoes i don’t work in the NHS and I don’t think critically analysing marketing strategies for the last 2 decades helps it to run more efficiently……

I didn’t say you did work for the NHS. Presumably there’s more to an MBA course than that?

pointythings · 21/12/2022 18:46

@Iwanttoquitthegym the myth that NHS staff were sitting around doing nothing during COVID is so, so toxic. The reality is as you describe - ITU and high dependency beds being created and staffed out of nothing (through redeployments), and the same for post COVID rehab beds for older patients. I know, because I was part of the team that project managed the creation and staffing of those beds. In three weeks we took unused spaces, got Estates to ensure the equipment was all there and that clinical waste disposal was available - especially important with COVID positive patients, that the beds had adequate staffing, that provision of meals was in place - you name it, we did it. My average working day during the first 3 months of COVID was 10 hours and 14 hour days were frequent. Staff were ripped from their posts and had their schedules messed around, and they coped because the patients needed them. Stress, burnout and moral injury levels exploded.

Shame on everyone on here talking down the NHS - after 12 years of Tory rule, you should be grateful for crumbs.

TheWindIsChanging · 21/12/2022 18:44

Iwanttoquitthegym · 21/12/2022 18:32

I’m not sure you appreciate quite how bad the situation was in covid. Lock downs were to try and halt the spread of covid and reduce numbers when we had no vaccine. It was done badly and communication was poor many times.
however I work in ITU, we usually have 20 ITU bed (life support machines) and 10 high care beds (CPAP). We increased to nearly 50 ITU beds and 30 high care beds by taking over theatre recovery spaces. Do you have any idea the amount of extra staffing that needed and how much extra hours everyone had to put in? And the rest of the hospital was full. So yea we were close to being overwhelmed and at that point if you had a heart attack or a car accident there would be no space for you. That was why we had to ‘protect the nhs’

The florence Nightingale hospitals were set up to give added capacity for covid patients and most of them were not used having been subsequently dismantled.

As you say, we were locked down waiting for the "vaccine", but as a mainly vaccinated nation over 90% of the Uk population have had covid so the transmission argument for the jab doesn't really stack up if 9 in 10 have contracted covid anyway. The vaccine also needs multiple boosters with efficacy starting to wane after 10 weeks for a virus that has an average age of death above natural life expectancy. I accept that individual employees of the NHS were blameless in policy decisions, but I don't accept these factors being sufficient to drive the country to economic oblivion protecting a health service where there is no proof lockdowns saved a single life. Infact there are more people likely to die as a consequence of poverty related factors which we are now seeing.

If the NHS was at danger of being overrun with covid patients, the Florence Nightingales would have been full but the government realised they had massively overestimated the danger of both the virus and underestimated the danger of the subsequent policy measures to the health of the general population. ( as did most nations bar Sweden and a few others)

OP posts:
midgetastic · 21/12/2022 18:43

It was the government who put the "business" crap into the nhs

IAmADancer · 21/12/2022 18:43

@Blossomtoes i don’t work in the NHS and I don’t think critically analysing marketing strategies for the last 2 decades helps it to run more efficiently……

TimBoothseyes · 21/12/2022 18:40

Headline reads

"Government to sue Mone-linked PPE firm for £122m"

TimBoothseyes · 21/12/2022 18:39

DuncinToffee · 21/12/2022 18:28

Not using taxpayers money for Johnson's partygate defence lawyers would save another £220k

Well if the Government succeed with this then problem solved.....lots of money to pay those striking a better wage....except they'll make up some lame reason as to why that won't happen.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-64029040

Blossomtoes · 21/12/2022 18:36

TheWindIsChanging · 21/12/2022 18:35

At least we can agree you can't read your own statistics which you put up to substantiate a failed argument repeatedly making false claims.

We agree nothing.

TheWindIsChanging · 21/12/2022 18:35

Blossomtoes · 21/12/2022 18:28

I love how you’ve derailed your own thread @TheWindIsChanging.

At least we can agree you can't read your own statistics which you put up to substantiate a failed argument repeatedly making false claims.

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 21/12/2022 18:33

Puzzledandpissedoff · 21/12/2022 18:00

The same people raging about the state of the economy were labelling anyone not supporting lockdowns as a "granny killer" which anyone with an IQ over 70 could see would lead to this mess

Quite - though you missed off " murderers", "eugenicists" and a motley selection of obscenities

I wouldn't try to claim decisions around Covid were the only cause of the mess, much of which existed before it came along. Trouble is, so did the mindet of those who were making the decisions, hence the situation we're in now

This is part of the problem I agree.