Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Re Ambulance/ nurse strikes

432 replies

TheWindIsChanging · 21/12/2022 15:17

The last thread reached 1000 messages so assume that means it automatically closes any thread so thought I would continue the debate. My view is that it is unreasonable for any person in charge of a person's life to simply down tools regardless of pay issues. I wouldn't disagree pay is too low but so are many jobs yet not all jobs carry the responsibility of saving lives which will be lost during the strikes.
It's no great shock the usual suspects are screaming about the tories again waving tiny fists around red faced incandescent with rage. The reality is increasing wages across the board would lead to an inflation death spiral which happened in the 70s further decreasing quality of life for all of us, not just the NHS workers.
Inflation is the main issue that causes issues with wages, and the reason for this is principally covid lockdowns which ( cue the drumroll) were brought in to protect the useless NHS... the irony that this same "service" is now complaining about economic problems which it helped to instigate is hilarious. I can't remember a single year in the last 20 where it wasn't nearly "bursting at the seems" and given the amount of tax payers money disappearing into it like the metaphorical black hole perhaps time it was scrapped. I don't see these same issues in other countries..a healthcare worker is not a typical profession as the basic goal is to save lives not abandoning ship. As others have said, all very well to type YABU, but I suspect the wind would change quickly if it was a relative who died as a consequence of these disgusting strikes which will cost lives make no mistake about it. That said, the same people raging about the state of the economy were labelling anyone not supporting lockdowns as a " granny killer" which anyone with an IQ over 70 could see would lead to this mess.

OP posts:
Orangepolentacake · 22/12/2022 01:16

Overthebow · 21/12/2022 15:39

I agree with you. I am starting to think it's time we had different system as the NHS just isn't working anymore. Throwing more money at it won't help in the long run. I'd rather pay a bit at the moment and have proper healthcare than have the free inadequate system we have now.

And the tories have won.
the above is exactly what they wanted

ironingboredrefusal · 22/12/2022 01:08

TheWindIsChanging · 21/12/2022 15:17

The last thread reached 1000 messages so assume that means it automatically closes any thread so thought I would continue the debate. My view is that it is unreasonable for any person in charge of a person's life to simply down tools regardless of pay issues. I wouldn't disagree pay is too low but so are many jobs yet not all jobs carry the responsibility of saving lives which will be lost during the strikes.
It's no great shock the usual suspects are screaming about the tories again waving tiny fists around red faced incandescent with rage. The reality is increasing wages across the board would lead to an inflation death spiral which happened in the 70s further decreasing quality of life for all of us, not just the NHS workers.
Inflation is the main issue that causes issues with wages, and the reason for this is principally covid lockdowns which ( cue the drumroll) were brought in to protect the useless NHS... the irony that this same "service" is now complaining about economic problems which it helped to instigate is hilarious. I can't remember a single year in the last 20 where it wasn't nearly "bursting at the seems" and given the amount of tax payers money disappearing into it like the metaphorical black hole perhaps time it was scrapped. I don't see these same issues in other countries..a healthcare worker is not a typical profession as the basic goal is to save lives not abandoning ship. As others have said, all very well to type YABU, but I suspect the wind would change quickly if it was a relative who died as a consequence of these disgusting strikes which will cost lives make no mistake about it. That said, the same people raging about the state of the economy were labelling anyone not supporting lockdowns as a " granny killer" which anyone with an IQ over 70 could see would lead to this mess.

So I presume you're training to be a nurse or paramedic then to help solve the problems of lack of staff? Or maybe you are going to be a manager in the nhs to undo all the problems that have been caused? Are the doctor's striking or do they get paid enough? Who sees the patients on the frontline and does most of the work, including the physical and emotional toil and doesn't get paid what they are worth? Not the top dogs thats for sure. How about they pay the nurses etc more and the managers less. That would cover it.

UntilHootOwlReturns · 22/12/2022 01:03

noblegiraffe · 21/12/2022 15:44

As for pay rises causing an inflationary death spiral, I'd appreciate a response to this economist's analysis that says that the increased tax revenue from the pay increases means that they are affordable, and that inflation will come down next year anyway.

Pic is part of a much larger thread here: twitter.com/richardjmurphy/status/1603280799482068992?s=61&t=PObT0Rk1mbrwghNzhlprtw

LOL! Richard Murphy is a discredited nutter.

UntilHootOwlReturns · 22/12/2022 01:02

You don't get health care for free

Indeed. The NHS costs a fortune for very poor wuality service.

national insurance was invented as the way in which you pay for it

Most people pay nowhere near enough NI to cover their healthcare costs. Some people pay extortionate amounts and still receive appalling quality healthcare from the NHS, if they manage to get treated at all.

Good grief at this rate you will let the government force you to get private healthcare and let them keep the money you pay in taxes for healthcare!

Many are in this position already due to how appalling NHS services are, if they can be accessed at all. We'd be far better off with a system similar to most continental European countries: broadly similar level of expenditure in terms of proportion of GDP but far superior patient access, treatments and health outcomes.

orchid220 · 21/12/2022 23:45

TheWindIsChanging · 21/12/2022 20:28

This was back in April, the figure is much higher now www.theguardian.com/world/2022/apr/22/seven-in-10-people-in-england-have-had-covid-research-shows-omicron

You say " Even if that is true it shows that even if people haven't had it they will still have high levels of antibodies from vaccination i.e. vaccination works" I don't know how you can reach that conclusion.

www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/how-long-do-covid-antibodies-stay-in-your-system 500 days is the time anti bodies stay after natural infection, so a high level of anti bodies isn't evidence the vaccine works

7 in 10 is 70% not 90%. The figure may be higher now but you don't know that it is 90%. If you have the evidence, please link.
I reach the conclusion that the vaccines work because if 99% of people have antibodies and only 70% (or even 90%) of people have been infected then how did the 29% (or 9%) get antibodies if it wasn't via vaccination? And why are highly vaccinated age groups (e.g. those over 80 years) much more likely to have antibodies to covid than age groups that are less likely to be vaccinated? (e.g. 8 to 11 year olds).

I'm not sure how you think that article shows that "high level of anti bodies isn't evidence the vaccine works".

Stompythedinosaur · 21/12/2022 23:17

Blossomtoes · 21/12/2022 23:02

Except that multiple studies show far better patient outcomes and reduced mortality, when nurses on wards are university educated.

But they don’t show why. The alternative could be that nurses still get degrees but get their fees paid and are paid In training in exchange for an obligatory period of work in the NHS. Personally I find it scandalous that undergraduate nurses are exploited as unpaid labour.

It is very very common for nurses to decide very early in their career that they want to leave, that nursing if not the profession they thought it was. The drop out rather in the first couple of years after qualifying is very high.

Do we really think that forcing miserable junior nurses to stay in a job they feel unable to cope with is the solution? How much help would they realistically be? They will end up off sick due to stress I imagine.

The only feasible solution is to address some of the reasons that nurses want to leave, and that primarily comes down to improving staffing levels and retaining experienced staff so that new nurses can be supported to find their feet and feel adequately recompensed for the work they do.

Blossomtoes · 21/12/2022 23:02

Except that multiple studies show far better patient outcomes and reduced mortality, when nurses on wards are university educated.

But they don’t show why. The alternative could be that nurses still get degrees but get their fees paid and are paid In training in exchange for an obligatory period of work in the NHS. Personally I find it scandalous that undergraduate nurses are exploited as unpaid labour.

Iwanttoquitthegym · 21/12/2022 22:25

SchoolQuestionnaire · 21/12/2022 20:46

This.

Likely outing but a few weeks ago I had to watch paramedics try and save my dm’s life. They didn’t succeed but it brought home to me what a challenging job they do. Not only trying to help my dm, but also trying to prise essential info out of me - a useless relative in shock. They were in a life of death situation but remained kind, compassionate and did everything they could. They were then forced to hang around writing up notes and waiting for the police to arrive (unexpected death) which took up more of their precious time.

I have no doubt that if anyone was at death’s door they would be the first to leave the picket line and rush off to help. They aren’t cold or heartless, if they were they wouldn’t be doing the job they do for piss all money in the first place. They want better pay because they know the current conditions are dangerous and they want more people to remain in the role to ensure that people aren’t failed in their hour of need.

What paramedics do isn’t easy. I have an office based job and outearn them significantly which is an utter travesty given the level of responsibility they hold. They deserve more money and more respect. I fully support them and will continue to do so whatever the outcome.

I always find it interesting that MPs all seem to agree that vocational workers definitely earn enough, but you don’t see any of them willing to undertake any role for that amount of money.

I’m so sorry for your loss in such circumstances. I hope you have all the support you need Flowers

HeyBlaby · 21/12/2022 22:14

user1754980 · 21/12/2022 17:18

Maybe if they dropped the degree they would get more applicants, the entry requirements look pretty low so it is a lot to pay for a degree from a not very good university so why need a degree anyway

Except that multiple studies show far better patient outcomes and reduced mortality, when nurses on wards are university educated.

Nevermind the fact that it would be at odds with the vast, vast majority of countries (and at odds with the training of all AHP's on the same pay band as nurses) Making becoming a nurse in the UK even less desirable.

FixTheBone · 21/12/2022 22:09

TheWindIsChanging · 21/12/2022 16:32

" No healthcare worker striking is killing anyone" .. what utter naive rubbish . If that's the case as you claim, then being at work must save no lives so what function do they serve? As just 1 eg, ambulances will be massively delayed even more than normal, so the notion that someone who could have been saved with prompt medical attention isn't going to die with strikes is for the birds.

No, I'm agreeing they will die.

But it's your fault for not being a healthcare worker....

Very big semantic, moral, ethical and legal difference between 'not saving' and what you said, which was 'killing'.

NurseButtercup1 · 21/12/2022 20:59

Flamingogirl08 · 21/12/2022 17:00

Any chance OP can just shut up, have a baileys and go and enjoy Christmas 😏

For any strikers following this I support you 100%

I wholeheartedly agree with this suggestion

pointythings · 21/12/2022 20:50

Go away " Stompy"

Going full five-year-old now, OP?

SchoolQuestionnaire · 21/12/2022 20:46

Katapolts · 21/12/2022 16:10

If you don't offer adequate pay and conditions, you won't find anyone to do the job.

It's silly to whinge about how unsafe it is for nurses and paramedics to partially strike on a particular day, but not give a fuck that we're rapidly running out of anyone willing to do the jobs full stop.

Are you going to propose banning healthcare workers from handing in their notice? Or start conscription maybe into the NHS?

This.

Likely outing but a few weeks ago I had to watch paramedics try and save my dm’s life. They didn’t succeed but it brought home to me what a challenging job they do. Not only trying to help my dm, but also trying to prise essential info out of me - a useless relative in shock. They were in a life of death situation but remained kind, compassionate and did everything they could. They were then forced to hang around writing up notes and waiting for the police to arrive (unexpected death) which took up more of their precious time.

I have no doubt that if anyone was at death’s door they would be the first to leave the picket line and rush off to help. They aren’t cold or heartless, if they were they wouldn’t be doing the job they do for piss all money in the first place. They want better pay because they know the current conditions are dangerous and they want more people to remain in the role to ensure that people aren’t failed in their hour of need.

What paramedics do isn’t easy. I have an office based job and outearn them significantly which is an utter travesty given the level of responsibility they hold. They deserve more money and more respect. I fully support them and will continue to do so whatever the outcome.

I always find it interesting that MPs all seem to agree that vocational workers definitely earn enough, but you don’t see any of them willing to undertake any role for that amount of money.

itsjustnotok · 21/12/2022 20:44

TheWindIsChanging · 21/12/2022 15:17

The last thread reached 1000 messages so assume that means it automatically closes any thread so thought I would continue the debate. My view is that it is unreasonable for any person in charge of a person's life to simply down tools regardless of pay issues. I wouldn't disagree pay is too low but so are many jobs yet not all jobs carry the responsibility of saving lives which will be lost during the strikes.
It's no great shock the usual suspects are screaming about the tories again waving tiny fists around red faced incandescent with rage. The reality is increasing wages across the board would lead to an inflation death spiral which happened in the 70s further decreasing quality of life for all of us, not just the NHS workers.
Inflation is the main issue that causes issues with wages, and the reason for this is principally covid lockdowns which ( cue the drumroll) were brought in to protect the useless NHS... the irony that this same "service" is now complaining about economic problems which it helped to instigate is hilarious. I can't remember a single year in the last 20 where it wasn't nearly "bursting at the seems" and given the amount of tax payers money disappearing into it like the metaphorical black hole perhaps time it was scrapped. I don't see these same issues in other countries..a healthcare worker is not a typical profession as the basic goal is to save lives not abandoning ship. As others have said, all very well to type YABU, but I suspect the wind would change quickly if it was a relative who died as a consequence of these disgusting strikes which will cost lives make no mistake about it. That said, the same people raging about the state of the economy were labelling anyone not supporting lockdowns as a " granny killer" which anyone with an IQ over 70 could see would lead to this mess.

@TheWindIsChanging its not just about money though. I’ve listened to nurses who have given interviews stating they are being left on their own with a ward of patients and no one is listening. if you think it’s safer to just allow that to continue then it’s that attitude that’s part of the problem because right now patients are being failed in their care and nurses are being failed in turn. Factor in that the government don’t seem to want to pay them appropriately but are happy to leave them and their PINs at risk says it all. I highly doubt there are many people on here who would happily go into work knowing they were being left solely responsible for patients lives and care, whilst paying to be nurses with their registration fees and their student loans. The idea they should just put up with it is ridiculous because that’s also saying we are happy for our loved ones to receive less than ideal care.

TheWindIsChanging · 21/12/2022 20:41

Stompythedinosaur · 21/12/2022 20:40

When people resort to name calling, I assume they know they are wrong.

Your initial post is clearly copied and pasted from the last thread on this topic.

Go away " Stompy" , I said earlier I posted at the end of the last thread but havent started any other thread bar this one

OP posts:
Stompythedinosaur · 21/12/2022 20:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

When people resort to name calling, I assume they know they are wrong.

Your initial post is clearly copied and pasted from the last thread on this topic.

DontStopMeNow7 · 21/12/2022 20:40

Whether strikes happen or not, the NHS cannot and will not be able to provide proper care for patients. I am a nurse and my automatic reaction to this, I’m sorry to say, was like an internal shrug. A day here and there might make things worse temporarily but I actually can’t imagine things being much worse. And if you don’t work in the NHS you won’t get what I mean. You have to work there to believe it. Because it’s that bad.

Come and do a day of work experience with us for a day and I guarantee you will soon change your tune. Look after 10 patients on your own for 12 hours on your feet without proper breaks and see what you think then. What would you do?

Would you simply resign or would you strike first??

If pay and working conditions don’t improve many more nurses will leave. The real point of voting to strike is that it is our way of providing the government another option before we walk off the job permanently. When that continues to happen, what will everyone do?

We are not doing it without good reason. It’s a last resort because we literally can’t take it anymore. You complain about how badly you will be affected by a few days of strikes yet you don’t care about the health of those striking. You are completely lacking in compassion

The government can either increase pay, improve working conditions and staffing… OR they can refuse to do so and lose more staff permanently. Honestly, it is such a double standard to think that nurses do not even have the right to strike.

A similar mindset is what has led to this situation deteriorating as far as it has. Nurses apparently don’t deserve to be treated well, yet we’re still expected to look after you when you’re sick.

The level of arrogance is mind blowing.

TheWindIsChanging · 21/12/2022 20:32

bellamountain · 21/12/2022 20:30

Population growth and an ageing population, yet A&E departments have been closed across the country. The demand on hospitals is immense. We need more hospitals and staff. That will take a long time.

In the first instance, to increase funding, I think GP appointments should be paid for in the same way we pay for NHS dentist visits. That should be the first step. There needs to be a cull on roles that are frankly not needed. These include PR, diversity and equality managers, director roles that in the past simply did not exist because they were not needed and are not required now. Huge salaries being paid for non medical personnel is absurd. You only have to look at a job site to look at the roles the NHS are advertising for. It certainly looks like the cash is being spent in the wrong areas.

Non jobs are cropping up all over the place and we are all paying for it.

Agreed

OP posts:
TheWindIsChanging · 21/12/2022 20:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

bellamountain · 21/12/2022 20:30

Population growth and an ageing population, yet A&E departments have been closed across the country. The demand on hospitals is immense. We need more hospitals and staff. That will take a long time.

In the first instance, to increase funding, I think GP appointments should be paid for in the same way we pay for NHS dentist visits. That should be the first step. There needs to be a cull on roles that are frankly not needed. These include PR, diversity and equality managers, director roles that in the past simply did not exist because they were not needed and are not required now. Huge salaries being paid for non medical personnel is absurd. You only have to look at a job site to look at the roles the NHS are advertising for. It certainly looks like the cash is being spent in the wrong areas.

Non jobs are cropping up all over the place and we are all paying for it.

Stompythedinosaur · 21/12/2022 20:28

TheWindIsChanging · 21/12/2022 20:03

Privileged? You have no idea what race, gender, age, country or financial status I have so keep virtue signalling with your silly phrases. I'll continue to laugh at you- people like you derail every thread throwing out the usual tired cliches. Healthcare is healthcare, not a box ticking exercise

I'm quite impressed that I'm able to detail every thread just by pointing out that diversity does matter.

It is ok @TheWindIsChanging if you don't like how this thread turns out, you can start another identical thread like you did last time.

TheWindIsChanging · 21/12/2022 20:28

orchid220 · 21/12/2022 20:17

Do you have a link showing that 90% of the population have had covid? Even if that is true it shows that even if people haven't had it they will still have high levels of antibodies from vaccination i.e. vaccination works. Further evidence that vaccination provides antibodies is that levels are highest in older people who are more likely to be vaccinated and lower in children who are less likely to be vaccinated. Only 41.6% of 8 to 11 year olds had high levels compared with 94.1% of people over 80.

This was back in April, the figure is much higher now www.theguardian.com/world/2022/apr/22/seven-in-10-people-in-england-have-had-covid-research-shows-omicron

You say " Even if that is true it shows that even if people haven't had it they will still have high levels of antibodies from vaccination i.e. vaccination works" I don't know how you can reach that conclusion.

www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/how-long-do-covid-antibodies-stay-in-your-system 500 days is the time anti bodies stay after natural infection, so a high level of anti bodies isn't evidence the vaccine works

OP posts:
orchid220 · 21/12/2022 20:17

TheWindIsChanging · 21/12/2022 20:00

Ty for the link but you stated " 99% of people have high levels of antibodies now regardless of whether they have had a previous infection which suggests the vaccine efficacy does not decrease to zero."

As the link doesn't distinguish between natural infection and any vaccine acquired immunity, given over 90% of the population have caught covid, this stat of 99% having anti bodies means nothing. The vast majority have caught covid and have natural immunity. I'm pleased to hear your parents are ok, but it's anecdotal evidence, many people I know have not had covid and are unvaccinated so it tells us nothing.

Do you have a link showing that 90% of the population have had covid? Even if that is true it shows that even if people haven't had it they will still have high levels of antibodies from vaccination i.e. vaccination works. Further evidence that vaccination provides antibodies is that levels are highest in older people who are more likely to be vaccinated and lower in children who are less likely to be vaccinated. Only 41.6% of 8 to 11 year olds had high levels compared with 94.1% of people over 80.

PinkWindows · 21/12/2022 20:16

mbosnz · 21/12/2022 19:41

I'd like to see a cancer specialist who was educated and attuned to the variations in patients inherent to their culture and gender, and therefore less likely to miss or dismiss symptoms or risks as a result of ignorance.

In the real world, I don't know if people would agree with me, and I'm quite happy to speak for myself, without raising a phantom chorus of others who I claim would agree with me.

I agree with you.

generalh · 21/12/2022 20:09

Everyone should have the right to withdraw their labour.