Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Re Ambulance/ nurse strikes

432 replies

TheWindIsChanging · 21/12/2022 15:17

The last thread reached 1000 messages so assume that means it automatically closes any thread so thought I would continue the debate. My view is that it is unreasonable for any person in charge of a person's life to simply down tools regardless of pay issues. I wouldn't disagree pay is too low but so are many jobs yet not all jobs carry the responsibility of saving lives which will be lost during the strikes.
It's no great shock the usual suspects are screaming about the tories again waving tiny fists around red faced incandescent with rage. The reality is increasing wages across the board would lead to an inflation death spiral which happened in the 70s further decreasing quality of life for all of us, not just the NHS workers.
Inflation is the main issue that causes issues with wages, and the reason for this is principally covid lockdowns which ( cue the drumroll) were brought in to protect the useless NHS... the irony that this same "service" is now complaining about economic problems which it helped to instigate is hilarious. I can't remember a single year in the last 20 where it wasn't nearly "bursting at the seems" and given the amount of tax payers money disappearing into it like the metaphorical black hole perhaps time it was scrapped. I don't see these same issues in other countries..a healthcare worker is not a typical profession as the basic goal is to save lives not abandoning ship. As others have said, all very well to type YABU, but I suspect the wind would change quickly if it was a relative who died as a consequence of these disgusting strikes which will cost lives make no mistake about it. That said, the same people raging about the state of the economy were labelling anyone not supporting lockdowns as a " granny killer" which anyone with an IQ over 70 could see would lead to this mess.

OP posts:
FallSpringing · 22/12/2022 18:19

HeyBlaby · 21/12/2022 22:14

Except that multiple studies show far better patient outcomes and reduced mortality, when nurses on wards are university educated.

Nevermind the fact that it would be at odds with the vast, vast majority of countries (and at odds with the training of all AHP's on the same pay band as nurses) Making becoming a nurse in the UK even less desirable.

I also question the value of this when the yearly fees are now nearly 10,000. I know it's a contentious issue, but I wonder if it would make nurse training more attractive to bring back the extended diploma. I work in HE, and the nursing entry requirements are much lower. Also AHPs, whilst under AFC, are not in the same pay band as nurses, they tend to progress up the bandings more quickly.

Cheshiresun · 22/12/2022 18:14

I agree. As a medical professional, I would never (and have never) considered industrial action.

The problem is too, since Agenda for Change, Nurses are on the same pay scales as other NHS staff, over a million of them I think. So it's not possible just to give nurses (or paramedics) or one discipline of staff a pay rise. That is not saying they don't deserve it. Everyone wants a pay rise, if one sector was given one, others may strike for a pay rise too. In the long term it would lead to higher taxes, higher prices etc.

Police and the Army are not allowed to strike. I do not think fire officers or NHS staff should be able to either, along with other essential services. As I said before, speaking as a healthcare worker myself.

Bepis · 22/12/2022 18:09

I think it needs to be recognised that emergency and healthcare personnel are effectively serving the country. Without them, we would be in a big mess and it's time appreciation was shown to what they do and what they have to endure.

I feel that their training could be funded by the government if they agreed to work for the NHS for a certain length of time, for example, 5 years at least.

I also don't believe a yearly fee should have to be paid to maintain licenses. This should be provided for by the government as these workers are serving the public.

JusteanBiscuits · 22/12/2022 16:57

Maybe both nurses and ambulance staff should start only working what they should work. Only do the work they should do, only work the hours they are employed to work, take the breaks they need and are entitled to. That would hit everything so so much more than one day of strike. Maybe close all wards that have an unsafe staffing level and send the patients elsewhere. Maybe send ambulances in order of the calls, rather than prioritise them.
Or maybe we could pay for the extra hours worked. The (unpaid) lunchbreaks worked through. Pay for their PIN registration every year.

I would be so proud if either of my children became a nurse, or ambulance worker. But I would, and do, very very strong discourage it. I don't want my kids going into healthcare - not because it's not an amazing profession, but because I don't want my kids utterly broken by the understaffing and pressures. And by the ignorant and awful crap that is spread by the usual suspects.
The current government has done nothing to help the NHS. Yes, it does need increased work around efficiency and spending. But they don't receive any support. All they receive are the threats of their service being sold to the lowest bidder every few years. Level of service isn't taken into account - just who can do it cheapest.

I've had the pleasure (coughs) of using private medical care recently. I transferred it back to the NHS as the level of care was abysmal. Oh, the sandwiches and coffee was great, but the jumps that I, while quite ill, had to jump through to get appointments was making me worse. And the wait for follow up care was longer private than on the NHS!!!

DontStopMeNow7 · 22/12/2022 16:06

Blossomtoes · 21/12/2022 23:02

Except that multiple studies show far better patient outcomes and reduced mortality, when nurses on wards are university educated.

But they don’t show why. The alternative could be that nurses still get degrees but get their fees paid and are paid In training in exchange for an obligatory period of work in the NHS. Personally I find it scandalous that undergraduate nurses are exploited as unpaid labour.

I started nursing school in my late thirties and qualified during the start of the pandemic. I was one of the “lucky” ones that got in before Jeremy Hunt scrapped the bursary. This means my fees were paid and I got about £500 per month in bursary and £250 per month student maintenance loan. Tbh I don’t know what I was thinking because I had to work on top of my 37.5 hour weeks of placement or being in uni full time (degree is 50% placement hours / 50% coursework and exams). I actually did more paid working hours than student nursing hours in order to survive. I stuck with it because I love the job and my patients.

I really genuinely don’t know how any mature single student would do all of that now without the bursary. It would be impossible. Another example of the Tories cutting spending and reducing the workforce.

I have never worked so hard in my life plus on top of contributing to the workforce, you’re being assessed and getting paper signed off. I completed about 3200 hours of work as a student nurse. What do I have to show for it now?….

Right after my degree I went straight out to work again as a healthcare assistant while I waited for my nursing pin. I was sent by an agency to a covid ward where I was promised full PPE. This ward had been created just to look after covid positive patients and as there were no staff in the Trust available, they had to hire numerous agency staff to run the ward. We were not provided with/allowed proper face masks and after 12 hours in close proximity to these patients (toileting, washing, dressing, feeding, mobilising), two days later I had symptoms, day 3 I tested positive and by day 5 I was more sick than I’ve ever been in my life.

Ive been unable to work consistently as a nurse, and two years later I am still sick, have spent numerous months in bed also resulting in depression and anxiety effectively disabled by long covid, and facing medical discharge from my very first nursing job. On top of that there were times working in A&E and ITU during the pandemic which are too surreal to even talk about and I suffer from nightmares.

Apart from a degree and the qualification (which I am proud of) I am in even more debt due to having to borrow money during my original covid sickness when I was unemployed, just so that I could pay the rent. (Benefits do not cover basic living expenses).

I have no idea what is going to happen but if the last few years have taught me, in order to recover my health I will likely need to take a break from nursing. The potential issue with that is if you don’t work enough hours within a 3 year period, you can’t re validate and your pin expires.

No good deed goes unpunished.

This really isn’t just about pay. But how much does the government and, dare I say it, appear to value nurses?

DontStopMeNow7 · 22/12/2022 14:30

whatkatydid2013 · 22/12/2022 14:12

Honestly I struggle with how anyone can’t think this whole situation is the fault of our conservative government. Even if things were done wrong under prior administrations (which I’m sure some were) they’ve been in charge for 12 years and the result is that healthcare provision is demonstrably worse now than it was when they came into power. They had someone on radio 4 yesterday representing the government trying to say the issue isn’t understaffing but increasing demand. The thing is with an ageing population it’s massively apparent there will be increased demand and you can’t just stick your fingers in your ears and ignore that then blame healthcare staff for eventually not being able to absorb any further work and leaving in their droves/going on strike. If we want healthcare for all with a large elderly population, increasing ability to save very sick babies and new (expensive) treatments for many illnesses we will have to accept that all of us (including those in the 20% bracket, those of us who only have unearned income and pensioners) are going to have to pay more tax. We might also want to have a look at all the money that has passed into the hands of the very wealthy during the pandemic under very questionable circumstances and how to claw some of it back. I support all the strikers. I’m massively pissed off the strikes in January are likely going to result our planned trip to London with our kids having to be cancelled and we will likely lose the money spent on theatre/museum tickets. I’m directing that anger at Mark Harper because he’s a complete wanker who has openly said he’d rather play chicken with the unions than compromise in any way. I’d quite like politicians running the country with better negotiation skills and if they could also have some empathy that would be nice too.

^OMG Thank You

You nailed it
I 100% agree

BabyFour2023 · 22/12/2022 14:27

noblegiraffe · 22/12/2022 09:22

The problem with the media is that the strike is only about pay. Legally. And unions have to be careful when they talk about the strike to talk about what they want in terms of pay, the negotiations have to be only about pay. Because the government have been trying to make it very difficult to go on strike in the first place, if the legal basis for the strike is undermined by unions suggesting that it's actually about other stuff, they could be in trouble.

It'll be the same with teachers if the teacher ballot is in favour of striking. Teachers will want to highlight the intolerable working conditions and how the education system is failing our children, but the strike will be about pay, and that's what will have to be talked about when the strike is discussed.

Thank you for posting this, I wasn’t aware of this.

whatkatydid2013 · 22/12/2022 14:12

Honestly I struggle with how anyone can’t think this whole situation is the fault of our conservative government. Even if things were done wrong under prior administrations (which I’m sure some were) they’ve been in charge for 12 years and the result is that healthcare provision is demonstrably worse now than it was when they came into power. They had someone on radio 4 yesterday representing the government trying to say the issue isn’t understaffing but increasing demand. The thing is with an ageing population it’s massively apparent there will be increased demand and you can’t just stick your fingers in your ears and ignore that then blame healthcare staff for eventually not being able to absorb any further work and leaving in their droves/going on strike. If we want healthcare for all with a large elderly population, increasing ability to save very sick babies and new (expensive) treatments for many illnesses we will have to accept that all of us (including those in the 20% bracket, those of us who only have unearned income and pensioners) are going to have to pay more tax. We might also want to have a look at all the money that has passed into the hands of the very wealthy during the pandemic under very questionable circumstances and how to claw some of it back. I support all the strikers. I’m massively pissed off the strikes in January are likely going to result our planned trip to London with our kids having to be cancelled and we will likely lose the money spent on theatre/museum tickets. I’m directing that anger at Mark Harper because he’s a complete wanker who has openly said he’d rather play chicken with the unions than compromise in any way. I’d quite like politicians running the country with better negotiation skills and if they could also have some empathy that would be nice too.

WatchoRulo · 22/12/2022 12:17

UntilHootOwlReturns · 22/12/2022 01:03

LOL! Richard Murphy is a discredited nutter.

Has anyone told the University of Sheffield?

Togoodtobeforgotten · 22/12/2022 09:56

TheWindIsChanging · 21/12/2022 20:41

Go away " Stompy" , I said earlier I posted at the end of the last thread but havent started any other thread bar this one

Your very rude to people that disagree with you, one may think you revel in all this hence your post!

noblegiraffe · 22/12/2022 09:43

Calling a national strike requires an issue that affects all union members and pay affects all members.

You can strike about things like staffing levels but they would be more likely to be local strikes. You couldn't really have a national negotiation about staffing levels in individual hospitals.

pointythings · 22/12/2022 09:39

@noblegiraffe there absolutely are other economists who do not accept the inflationary death spiral theory. It is only an economic theory, nothing more. It's just that it's so very convenient as a stick to beat people with if you're a Tory supporter like so many on this thread. The reality is very much more complex.

MushMonster · 22/12/2022 09:34

I did not know that.
So there are legal issues about the reasons for the strike?
I never knew, I always thought that you could strike due to bad working conditions (like understaffing), on its own basis.
That explains quite a lot indeed!

noblegiraffe · 22/12/2022 09:22

The problem with the media is that the strike is only about pay. Legally. And unions have to be careful when they talk about the strike to talk about what they want in terms of pay, the negotiations have to be only about pay. Because the government have been trying to make it very difficult to go on strike in the first place, if the legal basis for the strike is undermined by unions suggesting that it's actually about other stuff, they could be in trouble.

It'll be the same with teachers if the teacher ballot is in favour of striking. Teachers will want to highlight the intolerable working conditions and how the education system is failing our children, but the strike will be about pay, and that's what will have to be talked about when the strike is discussed.

noblegiraffe · 22/12/2022 09:13

UntilHootOwlReturns · 22/12/2022 01:03

LOL! Richard Murphy is a discredited nutter.

Is he?

Could you please attack his arguments then? Rather than an ad-hom which isn't particularly helpful.

I've checked, and for example he is correct that freezing the tax allowances will raise billions in tax revenue, and it makes sense that freezing the tax allowances and giving bigger pay rises would raise more billions in tax revenue. Giving people who are on low wages a pay rise will result in more money going into the economy, hence more taxes.

His prediction that inflation will fall next year for various reasons seems backed up by other sources.

Walkaround · 22/12/2022 08:22

Sorry for jumping on you, @BabyFour2023 .Yes, it was a very insightful post and your last post makes sense. I think a lot of the media reporting has been pretty dire.

BabyFour2023 · 22/12/2022 08:18

Walkaround · 22/12/2022 08:14

Sorry, @BabyFour2023 , it was rude of me, but it’s somewhat surprising that you have basically admitted to reading the same thing again and again until you read this thread. Did you really think the people working in the NHS right now think their only problem is pay?! Do you really think they just want danger money?

No, I haven’t admitted that in any way, shape or form. I said I’ve heard people on our local radio station and I’ve seen multiple social media posts / statuses saying the same thing.
of course I have seen and heard other angles but, as I pointed out in my initial sentence to the PP I replied to, I felt her reply was a really helpful insight. Obviously I’ve heard others talking about various issues but not as in depth.
literally; we don’t have enough staff. Of course I don’t think the single issue is pay.
My post was meant to be appreciative of the fact someone cared enough and is clearly passionate about the current state of her wards to post on here. It was better than; I need a food bank / There isn’t enough nurses in my hospital. I’ll bow out now.

Walkaround · 22/12/2022 08:14

Sorry, @BabyFour2023 , it was rude of me, but it’s somewhat surprising that you have basically admitted to reading the same thing again and again until you read this thread. Did you really think the people working in the NHS right now think their only problem is pay?! Do you really think they just want danger money?

BabyFour2023 · 22/12/2022 08:11

Walkaround · 22/12/2022 08:09

@BabyFour2023 - what media do you read/listen to?! Sorry, but you’re part of the problem if the only media you read is just spouting that. Your choice to take so little genuine interest that so far you’ve just stopped at what your choice of media chooses to say on the subject.

I take so little interest yet respond to a PP offering a different perspective. Ok then.

BabyFour2023 · 22/12/2022 08:11

Walkaround · 22/12/2022 08:09

@BabyFour2023 - what media do you read/listen to?! Sorry, but you’re part of the problem if the only media you read is just spouting that. Your choice to take so little genuine interest that so far you’ve just stopped at what your choice of media chooses to say on the subject.

Like I said, I’ve read peoples social media posts. Many peoples. This is something that’s been repeated again and again.

Walkaround · 22/12/2022 08:09

@BabyFour2023 - what media do you read/listen to?! Sorry, but you’re part of the problem if the only media you read is just spouting that. Your choice to take so little genuine interest that so far you’ve just stopped at what your choice of media chooses to say on the subject.

Desiredeffect · 22/12/2022 05:36

Nurses should strike and get better pay etc. I'm also hoping as a carer we strike to for same reasons as nurses

BabyFour2023 · 22/12/2022 04:56

QueenCremant · 21/12/2022 17:19

Do people not get that this isn’t just about pay? But without fair pay we cannot recruit and retain staff. Believe it or not we are trying to protect patients.

Lockdowns were indeed to protect the NHS. Not the staff working in the NHS. It was to protect ITU beds so that people that needed care could get it. It was so that staff could be redeployed to ITU and covid wards.

The system is broken and no one is listening. Every day patients are at risk because of staffing levels, because ambulances are stuck outside hospitals. Demand has outstripped supply and hospital, community and ambulance staff are emotionally exhausted and morally injured.

Imagine doing a job every day that you cannot do to your ability. Imagine having to prioritise care between a deteriorating patient and one sitting in their faeces. Imagine your professional registration being at risk every day, going home, hoping you haven’t made a mistake and being relieved if all your patients are still breathing. Imagine spending your shift in an ambulance outside a hospital with a sick patient but unable to get them into hospital to get the care they need. Imagine whilst doing that listening to control staff constantly asking if there are any free ambulances.

Imagine that every day you do your best but the media bashes you. Threads on mumsnet bash you.

I get it, it’s frightening. I am frightened because I see first hand how the system is broken. But it is not our fault. We do not want to continue working like this. Even if we manage to get a pay rise it won’t make much difference in the short term. It will hopefully stop some people leaving the professions but hopefully what it will do is encourage more to train into the professions. It won’t get magically make the NHS a better place but it’ll hopefully give a morale boost to those working in it which will ultimately be good for patients.

Until you have worked just a day in healthcare and deal with the emotional strain that it brings then you have no idea what it is like.

f people die during the strikes, it is not our fault. Instead it is the fault of the system. People are dying anyway and we are trying to prevent further unnecessary deaths.

If you want the NHS to continue then please support the strikes. Morale is at rock bottom and being denied a pay rise is likely to see many more people leaving the professions. You cannot expect outstanding care if you’re not prepared to pay the workers providing it .

We care. We care too bloody much which is why we are striking.

This is one of the most helpful replies on this thread. I think the problem is that so many nurses have been in the media, or even just on their own social media, stating they’re striking for opposite reasons to the ones you mention. I have personally seen posts from people, and heard them on the radio, saying they’re striking because they can’t afford to pay their bills, because they are relying on food banks, because they can’t buy their children Christmas presents this year. I think this is what is getting peoples backs up. There are many people who earn less than the equivalent of a band 6 AFC but who aren’t experiencing these struggles so it can seem disingenuous. I think if the narrative reflected what you’ve posted here, people would be understanding and support the strikes as they understand the logic and the long term goal.
When certain areas have been hearing on loop that a person cannot survive on £33k+ Minimum it will frustrate people and it will lead to less support.

user1964097 · 22/12/2022 04:10

Are people on this thread a bit thick and can't read, they keep saying about OP's other threads, the last thread wasn't the same OP, nor was the one that was deleted.

Swipe left for the next trending thread