Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Re Ambulance/ nurse strikes

432 replies

TheWindIsChanging · 21/12/2022 15:17

The last thread reached 1000 messages so assume that means it automatically closes any thread so thought I would continue the debate. My view is that it is unreasonable for any person in charge of a person's life to simply down tools regardless of pay issues. I wouldn't disagree pay is too low but so are many jobs yet not all jobs carry the responsibility of saving lives which will be lost during the strikes.
It's no great shock the usual suspects are screaming about the tories again waving tiny fists around red faced incandescent with rage. The reality is increasing wages across the board would lead to an inflation death spiral which happened in the 70s further decreasing quality of life for all of us, not just the NHS workers.
Inflation is the main issue that causes issues with wages, and the reason for this is principally covid lockdowns which ( cue the drumroll) were brought in to protect the useless NHS... the irony that this same "service" is now complaining about economic problems which it helped to instigate is hilarious. I can't remember a single year in the last 20 where it wasn't nearly "bursting at the seems" and given the amount of tax payers money disappearing into it like the metaphorical black hole perhaps time it was scrapped. I don't see these same issues in other countries..a healthcare worker is not a typical profession as the basic goal is to save lives not abandoning ship. As others have said, all very well to type YABU, but I suspect the wind would change quickly if it was a relative who died as a consequence of these disgusting strikes which will cost lives make no mistake about it. That said, the same people raging about the state of the economy were labelling anyone not supporting lockdowns as a " granny killer" which anyone with an IQ over 70 could see would lead to this mess.

OP posts:
noblegiraffe · 22/12/2022 19:41

DuncinToffee · 22/12/2022 18:20

In June 2017 309 MPs voted to give nurses a proper pay rise. 323 MPs voted against it, including every Tory MP except one.

When the result of the vote was announced & the Tories found they had succeeded in blocking the nurses pay rise, they cheered.

twitter.com/SaulStaniforth/status/1603433860796145665?t=FnxI8hswUs77soUEaPa-_g&s=19

That was utterly disgusting behaviour and they should be ashamed.

DuncinToffee · 22/12/2022 19:38

Care staff deserve more, they are only paid a fraction of a nurse's salary.

Here is novel idea, pay both professions a decent wage.

It's not a race to the bottom

DuncinToffee · 22/12/2022 19:35

ThisAgainForTheMillionthTime · 22/12/2022 19:15

I totally agree with you and think these people are in the wrong jobs if they think more pay is more important than peoples lives. There are bound to be lives lost because of these strikes. How they can stand on their picket lines and live with that on their conscience I really don’t know.
Lots of people want better conditions. Imagine if fire fighters did the same thing -“ no fire trucks coming to you, if your house burns down, tough, but if we bother to answer the phone and there’s enough people trapped we might come, if not phone the local clowns they can throw some buckets of water on it”.

We should just pay them with claps and banging pots Xmas Biscuit

pointythings · 22/12/2022 19:33

Nurses are already leaving. Taking early retirement, returning to the countries they originally came from, leaving the NHS and working as agency staff where they earn much more and cost the NHS much more. Not enough nurses are being trained because of the cost.

Nurses are in demand in many wealthy countries around the world and they will vote with their feet. The shortage of nurses is increasing, so anyone saying they won't leave is delusional.

DontStopMeNow7 · 22/12/2022 19:32

ThisAgainForTheMillionthTime · 22/12/2022 19:15

I totally agree with you and think these people are in the wrong jobs if they think more pay is more important than peoples lives. There are bound to be lives lost because of these strikes. How they can stand on their picket lines and live with that on their conscience I really don’t know.
Lots of people want better conditions. Imagine if fire fighters did the same thing -“ no fire trucks coming to you, if your house burns down, tough, but if we bother to answer the phone and there’s enough people trapped we might come, if not phone the local clowns they can throw some buckets of water on it”.

Have you read anything that’s been explained about why nurses are striking? It’s for the exact opposite reason.

Also, this is a last resort. I wouldn’t be surprised if many more nurses leave the profession; will you hold them accountable for patient deaths then? Who will you blame?

A&E and critical care nurses will not be striking. You conflate a strike with death so easily yet dismiss the working conditions of those who love to care for them but can’t do so safely and effectively and without detriment to their own wellbeing.

Take a look at that double standard. The public have a right to safety and health….yet nurses don’t?

It has always been that workers are allowed to strike. It isn’t illegal. Are there any adverse working conditions under which you think striking would be justified, or are you just against it no matter what? And if so, what would you do if you were in such a situation?

So, if you have it your way, here is what will happen. We will burn out and leave permanently. Then what? IMO you should consider a strike as fair warning, as should the government.

I find the lack of compassion here from some people disgusting.

mbosnz · 22/12/2022 19:32

Um, it's already happening. That's why there's 30,000 vacant positions.

Lucimaya · 22/12/2022 19:27

ThisAgainForTheMillionthTime · 22/12/2022 19:15

I totally agree with you and think these people are in the wrong jobs if they think more pay is more important than peoples lives. There are bound to be lives lost because of these strikes. How they can stand on their picket lines and live with that on their conscience I really don’t know.
Lots of people want better conditions. Imagine if fire fighters did the same thing -“ no fire trucks coming to you, if your house burns down, tough, but if we bother to answer the phone and there’s enough people trapped we might come, if not phone the local clowns they can throw some buckets of water on it”.

Yep. Also people saying nurses would leave etc, it wouldn't happen. Police can't strike, they have to put up and shut up with whatever they are given, they don't leave in droves. Care staff deserve more, they are only paid a fraction of a nurse's salary.

mbosnz · 22/12/2022 19:26

I think what really sticks in far too many Tory craws, is the hoi polloi not knowing their place, and simply tugging their forelocks and getting on with being the economic units they are, without complaint, needs, wants, hopes, or dreams.

Florence Nightingale could afford for nursing to be a vocation, she was from a very supportive, upper middle class family, didn't marry or have a family to support. Most nurses these days don't have quite that level of luxury.

noblegiraffe · 22/12/2022 19:26

Imagine if fire fighters did the same thing

I remember the fire fighter strike. The army rolled out Green Goddesses.

Bepis · 22/12/2022 19:24

malificent7 · 22/12/2022 19:19

Well i'm thinking about leaving so i can get decent pay elsewhere. I am passionate, I got a first, but if I am not appreciated I will take my skills elsewhere.

I can't really blame you with how things are but I really hope things get sorted for you all. I have huge respect for what you do.

mbosnz · 22/12/2022 19:20

Mmmmmm, but we're already tens of thousands of people short in these jobs. And if pay and conditions continue to be as bad, and/or deteriorate yet further, I imagine we'll be even more people short. . .

How can we live with people not having enough to live without assistance when they are doing such important and necessary work, feeling constantly vulnerable when at work to loss of their job due to the working conditions being so poor that patients are at risk, worrying that patients might die because they were unable to provide the necessary level of care, on our conscience?

malificent7 · 22/12/2022 19:19

Well i'm thinking about leaving so i can get decent pay elsewhere. I am passionate, I got a first, but if I am not appreciated I will take my skills elsewhere.

pointythings · 22/12/2022 19:19

@ThisAgainForTheMillionthTime maybe we should just not pay these people at all, because it's a vocation. Or maybe we should just continue the race to the bottom where we all get less and less while a small number of people get riher and richer and laugh at us sucker.

Or maybe we should finally stand up to them and say 'enough'? I know where I stand. 12 years of year on year pay cuts - that's more than enough. If people like you won't see that, maybe look in the mirror and wonder where your conscience went.

ThisAgainForTheMillionthTime · 22/12/2022 19:15

I totally agree with you and think these people are in the wrong jobs if they think more pay is more important than peoples lives. There are bound to be lives lost because of these strikes. How they can stand on their picket lines and live with that on their conscience I really don’t know.
Lots of people want better conditions. Imagine if fire fighters did the same thing -“ no fire trucks coming to you, if your house burns down, tough, but if we bother to answer the phone and there’s enough people trapped we might come, if not phone the local clowns they can throw some buckets of water on it”.

mbosnz · 22/12/2022 19:08

And of course, the other option to 'work to rule', is 'leave this field of work altogether', or 'leave this country to work in another'. We don't really want that, do we?

pointythings · 22/12/2022 19:06

If you stop people from striking, the next step they will take is work to rule. And it is possible to play this cleverly so that it is just as disruptive as a strike, because the public sector depends on goodwill and people working more and harder than their hours. It's easy to say 'stop striking and suck up yet another massive pay cut', but people have reached the end of their rope. And 'action short of a strike' can be kept up for much longer, with a much worse impact.

Lucimaya · 22/12/2022 18:57

Cheshiresun · 22/12/2022 18:14

I agree. As a medical professional, I would never (and have never) considered industrial action.

The problem is too, since Agenda for Change, Nurses are on the same pay scales as other NHS staff, over a million of them I think. So it's not possible just to give nurses (or paramedics) or one discipline of staff a pay rise. That is not saying they don't deserve it. Everyone wants a pay rise, if one sector was given one, others may strike for a pay rise too. In the long term it would lead to higher taxes, higher prices etc.

Police and the Army are not allowed to strike. I do not think fire officers or NHS staff should be able to either, along with other essential services. As I said before, speaking as a healthcare worker myself.

Totally this.

Get back to work and stop striking.

SinnerBoy · 22/12/2022 18:55

DontStopMeNow7

Ive been unable to work consistently as a nurse, and two years later I am still sick, have spent numerous months in bed also resulting in depression and anxiety effectively disabled by long covid, and facing medical discharge from my very first nursing job.

Oh no, that's terrible for you and not only you. What a waste that you can't work in the essential job you love, because the cheapskate bastards didn't get you effective PPE.

My sister is a school nurse, she'd been a TA when her kids were young, but reactivated her qualifications. She's avoided it, despite doing loads of tests, from the off. Her school provided her with a "moon suit." Several of her colleagues, teachers, caught it. They're all women in their 50s.

None of them were really ill with the actual disease, but three of them developed Long Covid. One was signed off last year, after 6 months, she could barely answer the door. The other two are back, part time. I hope you can recover at some point and get yourself back.

mbosnz · 22/12/2022 18:49

I worry about indenturement (so bonding employees for a set period of time to 'repay' the cost of their qualification), as a way to avoid actually improving safety for both health care workers, and patients by way of improving conditions.

pointythings · 22/12/2022 18:45

@Cheshiresun oh do go away with the endless repetition of the inflationary death spiral theory. It's a theory. Other economic theories about inflation are available. Current inflation is not wage driven.

Your lack of compassion for your colleagues is concerning and repellent.

orchid220 · 22/12/2022 18:42

DontStopMeNow7 · 22/12/2022 16:06

I started nursing school in my late thirties and qualified during the start of the pandemic. I was one of the “lucky” ones that got in before Jeremy Hunt scrapped the bursary. This means my fees were paid and I got about £500 per month in bursary and £250 per month student maintenance loan. Tbh I don’t know what I was thinking because I had to work on top of my 37.5 hour weeks of placement or being in uni full time (degree is 50% placement hours / 50% coursework and exams). I actually did more paid working hours than student nursing hours in order to survive. I stuck with it because I love the job and my patients.

I really genuinely don’t know how any mature single student would do all of that now without the bursary. It would be impossible. Another example of the Tories cutting spending and reducing the workforce.

I have never worked so hard in my life plus on top of contributing to the workforce, you’re being assessed and getting paper signed off. I completed about 3200 hours of work as a student nurse. What do I have to show for it now?….

Right after my degree I went straight out to work again as a healthcare assistant while I waited for my nursing pin. I was sent by an agency to a covid ward where I was promised full PPE. This ward had been created just to look after covid positive patients and as there were no staff in the Trust available, they had to hire numerous agency staff to run the ward. We were not provided with/allowed proper face masks and after 12 hours in close proximity to these patients (toileting, washing, dressing, feeding, mobilising), two days later I had symptoms, day 3 I tested positive and by day 5 I was more sick than I’ve ever been in my life.

Ive been unable to work consistently as a nurse, and two years later I am still sick, have spent numerous months in bed also resulting in depression and anxiety effectively disabled by long covid, and facing medical discharge from my very first nursing job. On top of that there were times working in A&E and ITU during the pandemic which are too surreal to even talk about and I suffer from nightmares.

Apart from a degree and the qualification (which I am proud of) I am in even more debt due to having to borrow money during my original covid sickness when I was unemployed, just so that I could pay the rent. (Benefits do not cover basic living expenses).

I have no idea what is going to happen but if the last few years have taught me, in order to recover my health I will likely need to take a break from nursing. The potential issue with that is if you don’t work enough hours within a 3 year period, you can’t re validate and your pin expires.

No good deed goes unpunished.

This really isn’t just about pay. But how much does the government and, dare I say it, appear to value nurses?

I'm so sorry. Your story makes feel so angry with the idiots on this thread (and others) that deny/minimise the seriousness of COVID.

Blossomtoes · 22/12/2022 18:37

Stompythedinosaur · 21/12/2022 23:17

It is very very common for nurses to decide very early in their career that they want to leave, that nursing if not the profession they thought it was. The drop out rather in the first couple of years after qualifying is very high.

Do we really think that forcing miserable junior nurses to stay in a job they feel unable to cope with is the solution? How much help would they realistically be? They will end up off sick due to stress I imagine.

The only feasible solution is to address some of the reasons that nurses want to leave, and that primarily comes down to improving staffing levels and retaining experienced staff so that new nurses can be supported to find their feet and feel adequately recompensed for the work they do.

Surely if we trained nurses at no cost to themselves and asked them to commit to a period working in the NHS staffing levels would automatically improve.

CherApparent · 22/12/2022 18:35

FallSpringing · 22/12/2022 18:19

I also question the value of this when the yearly fees are now nearly 10,000. I know it's a contentious issue, but I wonder if it would make nurse training more attractive to bring back the extended diploma. I work in HE, and the nursing entry requirements are much lower. Also AHPs, whilst under AFC, are not in the same pay band as nurses, they tend to progress up the bandings more quickly.

AHPs, whilst under AFC, are not in the same pay band as nurses, they tend to progress up the bandings more quickly.

Yes we are, and not necessarily.

Flipthefrugal · 22/12/2022 18:22

Cheshiresun · 22/12/2022 18:14

I agree. As a medical professional, I would never (and have never) considered industrial action.

The problem is too, since Agenda for Change, Nurses are on the same pay scales as other NHS staff, over a million of them I think. So it's not possible just to give nurses (or paramedics) or one discipline of staff a pay rise. That is not saying they don't deserve it. Everyone wants a pay rise, if one sector was given one, others may strike for a pay rise too. In the long term it would lead to higher taxes, higher prices etc.

Police and the Army are not allowed to strike. I do not think fire officers or NHS staff should be able to either, along with other essential services. As I said before, speaking as a healthcare worker myself.

You don't decide whether you are going to strike though.
As previously said Derogation and complex legal negotiations take place.
The vast majority of acute areas will be derogated and so those staff are working as usual.
They cannot strike even if they want to.
Others in less acute areas can strike or present themselves to work in Derogated areas.
They cannot do their normal job, the Trust would be fined.
As if nurses are just going to decide not to go in!
It's far more complex.

DuncinToffee · 22/12/2022 18:20

In June 2017 309 MPs voted to give nurses a proper pay rise. 323 MPs voted against it, including every Tory MP except one.

When the result of the vote was announced & the Tories found they had succeeded in blocking the nurses pay rise, they cheered.

twitter.com/SaulStaniforth/status/1603433860796145665?t=FnxI8hswUs77soUEaPa-_g&s=19