Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Re Ambulance/ nurse strikes

432 replies

TheWindIsChanging · 21/12/2022 15:17

The last thread reached 1000 messages so assume that means it automatically closes any thread so thought I would continue the debate. My view is that it is unreasonable for any person in charge of a person's life to simply down tools regardless of pay issues. I wouldn't disagree pay is too low but so are many jobs yet not all jobs carry the responsibility of saving lives which will be lost during the strikes.
It's no great shock the usual suspects are screaming about the tories again waving tiny fists around red faced incandescent with rage. The reality is increasing wages across the board would lead to an inflation death spiral which happened in the 70s further decreasing quality of life for all of us, not just the NHS workers.
Inflation is the main issue that causes issues with wages, and the reason for this is principally covid lockdowns which ( cue the drumroll) were brought in to protect the useless NHS... the irony that this same "service" is now complaining about economic problems which it helped to instigate is hilarious. I can't remember a single year in the last 20 where it wasn't nearly "bursting at the seems" and given the amount of tax payers money disappearing into it like the metaphorical black hole perhaps time it was scrapped. I don't see these same issues in other countries..a healthcare worker is not a typical profession as the basic goal is to save lives not abandoning ship. As others have said, all very well to type YABU, but I suspect the wind would change quickly if it was a relative who died as a consequence of these disgusting strikes which will cost lives make no mistake about it. That said, the same people raging about the state of the economy were labelling anyone not supporting lockdowns as a " granny killer" which anyone with an IQ over 70 could see would lead to this mess.

OP posts:
Choccolatte · 21/12/2022 15:52

DP is a paramedic, about 15% of his team are off with stress long-term. It's going to be more and for longer unless something is sorted. They used to get 15 mins unofficial break between jobs (often lasting 4 hours)to recover and regroup. No more. It's so harsh. Watched a child nearly die- next job. Shouted at for 3 hours by a paranoid schizophrenic - next job, get called out for a fucking ear infection - next job and on and on. Often no break is given for a 12 hour shift.

Stompythedinosaur · 21/12/2022 15:51

Tinkerbyebye · 21/12/2022 15:47

I agree with what the op says

The NHS is not fit for purpose and needs a drastic overhaul instead on money being thrown at it. There us plenty of evidence of waste, of contracts being given that should not have been. It’s to management heavy and as to streamlining paperwork millions could be saved

However as soon as anyone makes suggestions unions kick off. Until such time as the unions accept they have a part to pay in moving forward by accepting change is necessary and support it nothing will happen

staff also have a part to play I undertook a course with someone who was sent into a hospital to look at how working practices could be made better and any ideas were blocked by consultants and surgeons as soon as suggested as they wanted to do what they wanted when they wanted no matter more operations could be done if the suggestions were implemented.

We only need to look at what is happening with GPs to believe this is what may be happening across the board

You are aware we have had multiple overhauls in the 16 years I've worked for the NHS? Bringing in Foundation Trusts, entirely different funding routes via CCGs etc?

What evidence do you have about Unions "kicking off"? I lived these changes and have no recollection of any such thing happening.

I find people often suggest an overhaul when they really just want someone to magically manage to provide more resources with less funding. It is a very naive viewpoint.

TheWindIsChanging · 21/12/2022 15:51

SnackSizeRaisin · 21/12/2022 15:28

I disagree with everything you've written. The reason other countries have better healthcare is because they spend more on it per head. You can easily look up those figures if you want to. The reason for inflation is putting more money into circulation, which was for furlough payments and PPE contracts. Most NHS staff obviously weren't furloughed.
You don't seem to have read the previous thread!

Inflation is surging worldwide so implying it is down to " furlough" is disingenuous. You say most NHS staff weren't furloughed but getting a GP appointment as one eg has been close to impossible for 3 years as many of them seem to have been at home ( and still are).

Most economists predicted economic oblivion due to lockdowns and now we are seeing it. The reason for these lockdowns was to "protect the NHS".

OP posts:
Badgirlriri · 21/12/2022 15:49

But if nurses and paramedics are so vitally important, why aren’t we valuing them more?!

Walkaround · 21/12/2022 15:49

They said the nationalised railways were not fit for purpose, too, privatised them and created railways that are not fit for purpose and a society with ever greater inequality. I wouldn’t trust the fuckers in power to improve anything but their own private wealth funds.

Virginiaplain · 21/12/2022 15:48

Nursing is either a profession or a calling - profession means being paid adequately for your skills and knowledge -calling means simpering and smiling and being thrown crumbs for always putting the patient first and having the gov take the piss—

They should have gone on strike 20 years ago and we would have fully staffed wards now and a half decent NHS

bridgetjonesmassivepants · 21/12/2022 15:48

Making nursing a profession that required a degree is also part of the issue. You can't expect people to get into £60,000 worth of debt and then do a job that doesn't pay that much more than non-degree jobs.

Same as with teaching. We have reached a point where public sector workers have put up with either very low, or non exsistant, pay rises for the last ten years. Those workers are now underpaid by roughly 20% and the goodwill has run out. Add in that nursing is very stressful.

Fund training, possibly depending on working in the public sector for a number of years, and improve the pay. Otherwise expect there not to be a nurse for you or a teacher for your child.

Nimbostratus100 · 21/12/2022 15:48

For any striking health care workers reading this thread

I have cancer. I have appointments and treatment postponed and cancelled

I 100% support you

Stompythedinosaur · 21/12/2022 15:48

loveisagirlnameddaisy · 21/12/2022 15:44

Is the NHS underfunded or wasteful, or both?

If it's wasteful, why is this rarely spoken about in serious terms?

Remarkable that you think no one has spoken about waste before, when this has been a leading topic in the NHS for over a decade.

Tinkerbyebye · 21/12/2022 15:47

I agree with what the op says

The NHS is not fit for purpose and needs a drastic overhaul instead on money being thrown at it. There us plenty of evidence of waste, of contracts being given that should not have been. It’s to management heavy and as to streamlining paperwork millions could be saved

However as soon as anyone makes suggestions unions kick off. Until such time as the unions accept they have a part to pay in moving forward by accepting change is necessary and support it nothing will happen

staff also have a part to play I undertook a course with someone who was sent into a hospital to look at how working practices could be made better and any ideas were blocked by consultants and surgeons as soon as suggested as they wanted to do what they wanted when they wanted no matter more operations could be done if the suggestions were implemented.

We only need to look at what is happening with GPs to believe this is what may be happening across the board

loveisagirlnameddaisy · 21/12/2022 15:47

noblegiraffe · 21/12/2022 15:44

As for pay rises causing an inflationary death spiral, I'd appreciate a response to this economist's analysis that says that the increased tax revenue from the pay increases means that they are affordable, and that inflation will come down next year anyway.

Pic is part of a much larger thread here: twitter.com/richardjmurphy/status/1603280799482068992?s=61&t=PObT0Rk1mbrwghNzhlprtw

I don't understand his logic. How can pay rises costing 28 billion bring in 55 billion in tax revenues? That's double the pay rises?

Stompythedinosaur · 21/12/2022 15:45

Both nurses and paramedics have tried every option before striking. The government will not even meet to negotiate. The choice is between strikes and doing nothing, and this in healthcare see on a daily basis just how critical the situation is.

The strike today may effect access to ambulances today, but believe me there wasn't good access yesterday and their won't be tomorrow. When the nurses were on strike, many wards found their emergency strike staffing level was above the staffing level they are usually at.

I think that people blaming healthcare workers are not really seeing things as they are. Stopping fighting for improvements to pay and conditions is just accepting the breakdown of our healthcare system.

loveisagirlnameddaisy · 21/12/2022 15:44

Is the NHS underfunded or wasteful, or both?

If it's wasteful, why is this rarely spoken about in serious terms?

noblegiraffe · 21/12/2022 15:44

As for pay rises causing an inflationary death spiral, I'd appreciate a response to this economist's analysis that says that the increased tax revenue from the pay increases means that they are affordable, and that inflation will come down next year anyway.

Pic is part of a much larger thread here: twitter.com/richardjmurphy/status/1603280799482068992?s=61&t=PObT0Rk1mbrwghNzhlprtw

Re Ambulance/ nurse strikes
midgetastic · 21/12/2022 15:42

Overthebow · 21/12/2022 15:39

I agree with you. I am starting to think it's time we had different system as the NHS just isn't working anymore. Throwing more money at it won't help in the long run. I'd rather pay a bit at the moment and have proper healthcare than have the free inadequate system we have now.

You don't get health care for free

national insurance was invented as the way in which you pay for it

Good grief at this rate you will let the government force you to get private healthcare and let them keep the money you pay in taxes for healthcare!

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 21/12/2022 15:40

Puzzledandpissedoff · 21/12/2022 15:36

Borrowing something from the previous thread, it was asked why the government "didn't prepare" for an increasingly aged population with the complex illnesses this involves

Rightly or not I believe the only real answer to this is for people to accept that not everyone can be cured of everything all the time, and that preserving life indefinitely is neither possible nor desirable; however I'm not convinced it's a message the wider population's prepared to take on board and until it is I see no answer to the mess we're in

I agree ( and I’m in the age group affected)@

Walkaround · 21/12/2022 15:40

@Puzzledandpissedoff - if this is why the Government has done nothing to resolve the crisis, then the Government has a responsibility to govern, to say what it actually thinks and means and actually do something about it. Saying one thing and doing another is otherwise known as incompetence and corruption.

Overthebow · 21/12/2022 15:39

I agree with you. I am starting to think it's time we had different system as the NHS just isn't working anymore. Throwing more money at it won't help in the long run. I'd rather pay a bit at the moment and have proper healthcare than have the free inadequate system we have now.

AutumnCrow · 21/12/2022 15:37

noblegiraffe · 21/12/2022 15:35

My view is that it is unreasonable for any person in charge of a person's life to simply down tools regardless of pay issues. I wouldn't disagree pay is too low

So you agree pay is too low, but you don't want them to down tools by striking for a day to try to improve their pay.

Would you prefer that they downed tools on the NHS permanently and got higher pay by working in a different job?

Or how else would you like them to get higher pay, given that you agree that the pay is too low?

What @noblegiraffe said ^^

A coherent answer this time, on this thread, would be welcome.

Sirzy · 21/12/2022 15:37

The health system is in a mess. Staff sitting back and accepting being treated like rubbish won’t do anything to improve things for anyone.

my dad qualified as a nurse 50 years ago. He said the other day maybe if his generation of nurses had stood up more for the pay and conditions things wouldn’t be the mess they are now. The government have got to used to thinking health care workers will carry on regardless

Puzzledandpissedoff · 21/12/2022 15:36

Borrowing something from the previous thread, it was asked why the government "didn't prepare" for an increasingly aged population with the complex illnesses this involves

Rightly or not I believe the only real answer to this is for people to accept that not everyone can be cured of everything all the time, and that preserving life indefinitely is neither possible nor desirable; however I'm not convinced it's a message the wider population's prepared to take on board and until it is I see no answer to the mess we're in

Walkaround · 21/12/2022 15:35

Personally, I’d be raging if a relative of mine had died at any time in the last few years as a result of the problems in the NHS. If a relative of mine died today, I’d be even more bloody furious with Government for playing silly games. They have done fuck all to help resolve the crisis of ambulances being stuck outside overflowing hospitals and nobody being able to so their job properly any more. Why bring in the army now? Why pretend only today is a crisis, ffs? Wankers.

pointythings · 21/12/2022 15:35

The 'inflation death spiral' is simplistic economic thinking. Just like 'trickle down economics'.

Bottom line: if you keep cutting people's wages in an environment where prices keep rising, the shit is going to hit the fan and you have to deal with it.

Hurling cheap insults at those who think differently is typical of people who have no good arguments left.

noblegiraffe · 21/12/2022 15:35

My view is that it is unreasonable for any person in charge of a person's life to simply down tools regardless of pay issues. I wouldn't disagree pay is too low

So you agree pay is too low, but you don't want them to down tools by striking for a day to try to improve their pay.

Would you prefer that they downed tools on the NHS permanently and got higher pay by working in a different job?

Or how else would you like them to get higher pay, given that you agree that the pay is too low?

Theunamedcat · 21/12/2022 15:34

They shouldn't make Dr's and nurses pay for training it used to be done differently we had more people in then these days you can't afford to train as a nurse unless you have a financial backer and loads of support