Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think buying a teacher gift but not a TA one is a dick move?

184 replies

Wannakisstheteacher · 21/12/2022 10:48

Last day of school today. Standing waiting for the gates to open and see lots of children holding gift bags etc. One child showing the other children all the things she has for the teacher but doesn’t mention the TA. Another parent says she’s bought in chocolates for the teacher but again nothing for the TA - seems like the common theme from general chat.

AIBU to think it’s really low to bring in something for the teacher but nothing for the TA? They are so incredibly badly paid and have to do so much more than ever before so to bring in a full bag of stuff for the teacher but not even a small box of chocolates for the TA just seems like a dick move.

OP posts:
DoubleGauze · 21/12/2022 12:33

I guess a simple way of explaining the job is to say that most of the tasks that a teacher doesn't have time to do (due to the ridiculous amount of extra work that is piled onto them daily) is given to the class ta. So they do that , and also their own work such as supervising at lunch and break and doing first aid and running clubs.

Thindog · 21/12/2022 12:31

I never felt comfortable with taking gifts from children when I taught. Parents were often quite hard up and needed the money for their children.I did, however, really value notes or cards that said things like how well their child had done or how happy they were in my class.

twelly · 21/12/2022 12:31

I think gifts are a choice - your child might have little to do with the teaching assistant in which case you might not even know they are in the class. On the other hand if the TA was specifically attached to your child then you would probably be well aware of their importance or role.

At the end of the day it is a gift and children/parents are not expected or required to give anything to either

Nordix · 21/12/2022 12:29

WifeMotherWorker · 21/12/2022 10:56

A TA doesn’t have the pressure or expectation to plan, mark, spend evenings in meetings and weekends on school work! I think if the TA or LA is assigned to a child then yes a gift is appropriate. I have only ever given to teachers as the TA have had no impact on my children’s schooling. I think a lot of people feel like this.

TAs have lots of pressure - dealing with pastoral issues, staying late to run clubs. TAs do some marking too (or eg inputting marking onto the system, and filling reading books). The TA has impacted your child’s schooling - the teacher wouldn’t be able to run the classroom without them. Ignorant comment.

Thankfully a lot of people don’t feel like that - my relative who is a TA gets a Christmas gift from every child in the class.

amonsteronthehill · 21/12/2022 12:27

WifeMotherWorker · 21/12/2022 10:56

A TA doesn’t have the pressure or expectation to plan, mark, spend evenings in meetings and weekends on school work! I think if the TA or LA is assigned to a child then yes a gift is appropriate. I have only ever given to teachers as the TA have had no impact on my children’s schooling. I think a lot of people feel like this.

You clearly have no idea how much TAs take on that allow your children's schooling to be gotten on with, frankly.

SleeplessWB · 21/12/2022 12:26

saveforthat · 21/12/2022 12:18

Who would want 30 odd £5 gifts though. I don't think you should buy teachers, TAs or anyone else a gift. It's strange how some people are given gifts just for doing their job and some not. Say thank you if you think they have done a good job.

Is it about being given a gift for doing your job though? For me, giving a gift to DC's teacher and TA is about recognising their importance to my children and therefore giving a gift as I would to anyone else important to us. I also give a gift to the childminder and cleaner... It isn't for their job, I pay them for that, it is to wish merry Christmas to someone important to our family.

amonsteronthehill · 21/12/2022 12:24

It's a massive dick move. TAs do so much of the heavy lifting so teachers can get on with teaching: all the 1:1 reading, group reading, all the interventions which they're usually required to plan themselves these day, usually supporting the children who struggle the most; dealing with upset children, sick children, poorly behaved children, handling the first aid, the playground cover, going in when unwell, are the first to be moved if help is needed elsewhere in the school, etc. And they're not paid very well for the privilege.

crisscrosscringle · 21/12/2022 12:24

WifeMotherWorker · 21/12/2022 10:56

A TA doesn’t have the pressure or expectation to plan, mark, spend evenings in meetings and weekends on school work! I think if the TA or LA is assigned to a child then yes a gift is appropriate. I have only ever given to teachers as the TA have had no impact on my children’s schooling. I think a lot of people feel like this.

I suspect you have no idea what a TA does.

Nordix · 21/12/2022 12:23

Watsername · 21/12/2022 11:11

I genuinely think people don’t understand the role of the TA.

I am a TA. You might be surprised to know that I teach - I have my own Maths and Phonics groups. In previous years I have supported every single child in the year group (a sight difference in my role this year). I am also a midday supervisor- so support every single child at lunchtime.

Quite honestly, it’s usually the TAs that children go to when they are upset, so we are dealing with the pastoral issues, not the teachers. It’s us who do the first aid, not the teachers. I think the TAs know the children better than anyone else.

Please don’t discount us. Morale is low at the moment - we could earn so much more in supermarkets, and that’s just not right.

Agreed with all of this. Plus many TAs act as substitute teachers and teach the whole class for half-days or days at a time (without TA support…). For example while
the teacher does their planning.

We give equal gifts to the teacher and TA. A little giftbag with chocs, booze and a card each.

candleadvent · 21/12/2022 12:23

I have 3 children and between their classes there are 15 TAs and more that cover/do the odd session! The vast majority of TAs at our school are part time. I really value them but I can't buy for all of them. I buy for the teacher and my sons 1:1. We do cards but even then I'm sure I'll forget someone at school! I spend a lot of time with the receptionist and head teacher too!

Should I buy no gifts because I can't afford to buy everyone one?!

saveforthat · 21/12/2022 12:18

Wannakisstheteacher · 21/12/2022 10:59

@RegularNameChangerVersion21 exactly! It’s the message that they are clearly not valued at all that I don’t like. It’s not about the value of the gift (I spent £5 on each of them) it’s the idea that the teacher is making a valuable contribution so is ‘worthy’ of a gift, but the TA isn’t, so doesn’t.

Who would want 30 odd £5 gifts though. I don't think you should buy teachers, TAs or anyone else a gift. It's strange how some people are given gifts just for doing their job and some not. Say thank you if you think they have done a good job.

TheNinthLock · 21/12/2022 12:17

Even as a 1:1 TA assigned to a specific child, I am part of the class and work with the whole class.
The aim of providing 1:1 support is to allow the specified child to function within the class, to be included.
The child and their 1:1 TA do not exist in isolation, shoved out in the corridor, unseen by the rest of the class.The child and their 1:1 are in the classroom as much as possible.
When working as a 1:1 I support my specific child with their work and behaviour. This includes group work. Within the class. With your child. As part of this, I naturally support your child with their work.

I scaffold the specified child’s task to foster independence. And when specified child is on task, I support the rest of the class.
Sometimes the teacher chooses to focus on my specified child and asks me to work with a different group or lead a whole class activity.
On top of that, I do everything outlined in my previous post.

A 1:1 TA will prioritise their specified child as per the EHCP, but that does not mean they are not aware of and involved with the rest of the class.

That said, I want to reiterate I don’t want gifts. My favourite gifts this year were some handbaked biscuits and some hand written cards / drawings.
I am a TA because I love the job.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 21/12/2022 12:17

So DS(6) has a main teacher, 3 TAs, a read write Inc teacher, PE TAs, forest school teacher and forest school assistant that I know of. He randomly mentions other teacher names who drop in for a session or drop teach them something once a week etc.

No way could I buy evenly for everyone even if I did have a full list of names. Way too expensive.

All the parents put money towards vouchers for the teachers, TA etc to use on their staff meal on the last night of term.
It's been this way for years so I'm told.

Ocrumbs · 21/12/2022 12:11

It's expensive enough as it is they should just do away without presents. I think TA's should be professional enough to not be thinking waaaaah wheres my present.

JodiePants · 21/12/2022 12:11

100% agree. I work twice as many hours as a TA but I get paid 4x the amount so I think it really should be equal in terms of gifts, not that they are a requirement at all.

OhhhhhhhhBiscuits · 21/12/2022 12:10

I always gave exactly the same present to teachers and TAs. TAs do so much for the children , and the pay they get for it is appalling for what they do.

When we did a class collection I had to ask if they were giving exactly the same to teachers and TAs otherwise I wouldn't have donated and would have done our own thing.

MyRiverThee · 21/12/2022 12:10

Maybe they can’t afford to buy teacher and teaching assistant. At one point one of my children had 2 teachers and 2 assistants, due to part time/job shares.

I just bought the ones that my kids and I liked, that could be only the teacher, only the TA or sometimes both.

None of them are entitled to presents. My friend is a teacher, the homemade food goes in the bin, the tat goes to the charity shop as she’d have a house full of it. She wishes parents saved their money or bought some resources for the class if they did buy things.

User837463839 · 21/12/2022 12:09

Watsername · 21/12/2022 11:11

I genuinely think people don’t understand the role of the TA.

I am a TA. You might be surprised to know that I teach - I have my own Maths and Phonics groups. In previous years I have supported every single child in the year group (a sight difference in my role this year). I am also a midday supervisor- so support every single child at lunchtime.

Quite honestly, it’s usually the TAs that children go to when they are upset, so we are dealing with the pastoral issues, not the teachers. It’s us who do the first aid, not the teachers. I think the TAs know the children better than anyone else.

Please don’t discount us. Morale is low at the moment - we could earn so much more in supermarkets, and that’s just not right.

I absolutely agree with this. Both my DC go to the TA before the teacher about most stuff.

Dacadactyl · 21/12/2022 12:08

DoubleGauze · 21/12/2022 12:06

@Dacadactyl

So your child has never wet themselves , recieved a wrapped gift from school , had a book changed , read with an adult , hurt themselves , had a problem within their friendship group , been taught phonics , had a spelling test marked etc.

I'm not saying that staff deserve presents , but you are wrong to say that the ta does nothing for your kid.

I'm not saying the TA doesn't deserve a present, just that my child never mentions her so she's not on my radar iyswim.

He talks about the class teacher. I only know who the TA in his class is because she was mentioned recently in the newsletter.

BrutusMcDogface · 21/12/2022 12:07

Grimreapers · 21/12/2022 10:56

Wish there wasn't pressure or competition to buy anyone anything. I can't afford either, my kid took nothing for anyone. I hope that's not judged.

Absolutely not! 💐

BrutusMcDogface · 21/12/2022 12:06

springbabydays · 21/12/2022 10:57

Try being a midday assistant!

🙄

DoubleGauze · 21/12/2022 12:06

@Dacadactyl

So your child has never wet themselves , recieved a wrapped gift from school , had a book changed , read with an adult , hurt themselves , had a problem within their friendship group , been taught phonics , had a spelling test marked etc.

I'm not saying that staff deserve presents , but you are wrong to say that the ta does nothing for your kid.

BrutusMcDogface · 21/12/2022 12:04

This is ridiculous. In all my years as a mainstream teacher with one LSA (usually only a part time LSA, mornings only or shared with another class) we had some parents who just bought for me, some who bought for both of us and some who bought nothing for either of us.

We get paid to do a job. We don’t need or expect presents (well I don’t, anyway, but I can see I might be in the minority!) This year in particular, people have NO MONEY. Perhaps they want to thank the teachers for the hours of extra work they put in, the responsibility etc. but can’t afford two presents. In the case of multiple children, it’s going to cost even more. I have four and bought four presents for their teachers. A decent LSA is worth their weight in gold, which is why I always got/get mine a nice present to say thank you for all their hard work. But unless your child has a special bond/does lots of work with the LSA then a present from a child isn’t necessary in my opinion.

I now work in special education and our LSAs have a much bigger job. We are a team of four (when my team doesn’t get stolen off me for other classes!) I have utmost responsibility for the class and do all the planning, paperwork, annual reviews, meetings with professionals etc but the day-to-day is done by all of us. Our children (the ones who can afford it; we only got presents from 3 of our 12 but I’m not complaining in the slightest) get each one of us a present.

KatherineofGaunt · 21/12/2022 12:04

If the TA is a 1:1 then the impact they have on the rest of the class will be minimal. They're there for one child and should not be used as a general class TA unless the child they are usually with is ill.

I work in SEN and some classes have deaf children who have 1:1 support workers who are there to sign for them. Very occasionally they will do more whole-class support, eg. have another child or two in their group for a trip, help with a display in the classroom at a time they're not needed (like end-of-term colouring), share visuals in class with other pupils who may benefit etc. The Deaf children can sometimes have 2 or 3 different adults in a week. Should parents of pupils in that class also give these adults a gift as they may have a very small impact on the schooling of those pupils?

I know one class with about 8 different adults supporting various children 1:1 over the week. Should they all be bought a gift by the parents of the class? I suppose it would be nice, but as gifts are not necessary even for teachers, a card for every adult who has worked with your child is enough, if you really want to say thank you.

Catmum2022 · 21/12/2022 12:03

My youngest has 2 x teachers, 1 x day teaching per week from the deputy head and 2 x TA’s so lots to buy for! I bought them something each and just got a private message from one TA thanking me for remembering her and that she loved her gift.