Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think buying a teacher gift but not a TA one is a dick move?

184 replies

Wannakisstheteacher · 21/12/2022 10:48

Last day of school today. Standing waiting for the gates to open and see lots of children holding gift bags etc. One child showing the other children all the things she has for the teacher but doesn’t mention the TA. Another parent says she’s bought in chocolates for the teacher but again nothing for the TA - seems like the common theme from general chat.

AIBU to think it’s really low to bring in something for the teacher but nothing for the TA? They are so incredibly badly paid and have to do so much more than ever before so to bring in a full bag of stuff for the teacher but not even a small box of chocolates for the TA just seems like a dick move.

OP posts:
Jenasaurus · 21/12/2022 13:29

Also it can happen the other way round a while ago, My DD previously worked at a school as a TA and had a small group of SEN DC assigned to her, they had a special bond with her, the parents were grateful and showed it at Christmas and again when she left to train to be a teacher. I think some parents are very aware and appreciative of the role TAs play in school, especially when their DC speak repeatedly and happily about them at the end of the day. My DC now regularly babysits for one of the DC she used to work with as a TA.

FilthyforFirth · 21/12/2022 13:29

DS1 has a job share, so two teachers, two TAs and a student teacher. I got his two teachers a gift and then chocs and bsicuits and a card for the other three.

Didnt occur to me I was being mean not spending the same on all of them. That is 5 gifts!

FancyFanny · 21/12/2022 13:27

Nimbostratus100 · 21/12/2022 13:23

But then you are getting into very complicated and time consuming tax situations. Please don't!

You don't need to pay tax on a gift unless it is a very significant amount.

MessiTheGoat · 21/12/2022 13:27

I don't understand this idea that we need to buy gifts for people to make them feel valued. Surely there are other ways, and not just at Christmas/end of year.

I can't believe the amount of people saying that they would like a gift to feel acknowledged. I am a teacher and I expect no gifts from anyone.

Bedtimeforever · 21/12/2022 13:27

WifeMotherWorker · 21/12/2022 10:56

A TA doesn’t have the pressure or expectation to plan, mark, spend evenings in meetings and weekends on school work! I think if the TA or LA is assigned to a child then yes a gift is appropriate. I have only ever given to teachers as the TA have had no impact on my children’s schooling. I think a lot of people feel like this.

I think you will find that they do mark, they do plan (for certain groups) and they provide a lot of pastoral support too. All at an extremely low wage.

As a TA, not receiving a gift wouldn't bother me, but attitudes like this did. A lot. I am surprised I lasted 6 months to be honest.

Also, when working as a supply teacher (across many schools) I have always found the TA’s to be so helpful and hands on, great rapports with the kids and it is so unfair to say they don’t have an impact on children’s schooling because they have a huge impact.

Nimbostratus100 · 21/12/2022 13:23

Luana1 · 21/12/2022 13:15

Our class does a monetary collection instead of individual gifts and this is split equally between the teacher and the TA - as it should be.

But then you are getting into very complicated and time consuming tax situations. Please don't!

Jenasaurus · 21/12/2022 13:22

Just asked my DD, shes a student teacher, and said, herself, the TA and the teacher all receive equal gifts from the DC, so not all schools are the same. :)

SleepingStandingUp · 21/12/2022 13:22

DS's Yr 3 class has a main class teacher, a second class teacher who's deputy head, a TA who's technically my sons 121 but she gets shared and a second ful like TA. Equal presents all round.

Individewl · 21/12/2022 13:20

This year a bought a small gift for the class teacher. My DC doesn’t have a fixed TA to their class (Y2) and I’ve never actually seen the TA’s when they are in, my DC doesn’t ever mention the TA’s tbh.

In contrast to this when in reception they had a fixed TA and DC mentioned them at home. We saw the TA on drop off and pick up etc. that year I bought for both.

I used to be a TA myself - teachers have far more work IMO however sometimes it is the TA that develops better relationships with certain children maybe SEN or more sensitive children. Some children do not require lots of support from a TA especially as they move up the years at primary so won’t have much interaction with TA’s.

I was never offended when I didn’t receive presents from parents and actually the children who needed more help from the TA were the ones who bought the presents in - which makes sense.

FancyFanny · 21/12/2022 13:19

TAs don't just help children who struggle academically. If the teacher is using their TA correctly then they will also be used to further challenge the most able. TAs also support the whole class by supporting the teacher- getting resources ready for lessons, taking groups out for baking and art/DT activities, supervising the whole class to allow the teacher to focus on a particular group of children without interruption, listening to children read, undertaking reading assessments, marking test papers, putting up classrooms dispalys- (these are for every child to use)

The re isn't a single child in my that doesn't benefit from TA support

CaptainCallisto · 21/12/2022 13:19

I'm a TA, and echo PP's to say that our role is significantly bigger/more complex than most parents believe.

I'm in at least 30m before I'm scheduled to start each morning, and stay at least 30m after I'm supposed to finish so I can plan/mark my interventions. I run after school sport clubs twice a week, I run speech and language sessions, take a phonics group every morning, support the less able learners in every lesson (usually groups of 8-10, all of whom need differing levels of support), run handwriting boosters, run maths intervention groups three times a week and literacy interventions twice a week during assemblies, I'm on duty every break time and every lunchtime, administer first aid, am our class pastoral support... the list goes on. This is all in addition to the reading books/homework/photocopying/displays etc that people seem to think make up the whole of our job.

I don't expect presents, though those I receive are always much appreciated. I do, however, find posts insisting that TAs have no impact on children, or aren't important, incredibly demoralising.

This year, a boy in my class drew me a picture of Santa, with a message to say: "To Mrs Callisto, you help me a lot and give the best cuddles. I love you lots. From Name". That meant more to me than any amount of chocolates or wine!

SleepingStandingUp · 21/12/2022 13:18

GerardusMercator · 21/12/2022 13:05

The TA in my kids classes only work with one or two children with special educational needs. There is not a general class TA. I do get equal gifts for the teacher / TA regardless but I don't think that the TAs impact my children's learning as much as the teachers do. I'm not even sure why that is remotely controversial unless you are looking to take offence. The TAs obviously have a massive impact on the children that they work closely with.

What do you imagine would happen to your child's learning if that TA didn't exist to look after the other kids the teacher is there for?

LovelyRachel · 21/12/2022 13:17

YANBU

But the poster who said "try being a midday assistant" is BU..... 🤣

TrickyD · 21/12/2022 13:16

This giving gifts to teachers seems a new phenomenon, like Christmas Eve boxes and Elves on shelves.
It certainly never happened when I was a child (1950s) or when my DSs were young (1970/80s) nor when DH was a teacher and certainly not when he was a headteacher nor was it expected.
Some posts here suggest or involve ridiculous expenditure.

Ponderingthemeaningoflife · 21/12/2022 13:16

Dick move. My DC class had really generous contributions this year for a whole class gift, and it was split 50/50 between the TA and teacher.

Luana1 · 21/12/2022 13:15

Our class does a monetary collection instead of individual gifts and this is split equally between the teacher and the TA - as it should be.

Nimbostratus100 · 21/12/2022 13:15

I do disagree that TAs are worse paid than teachers. Having been both, I earnt more per hour as a TA.

I do disagree that anyone needs to give both the teacher and the TA a gift - no gift to any school staff should be automatic - I don't like getting gifts really, and I would rather parents didn't, but it should only happen at all in cases where there is a particular relationship, not just generically

For example, I got a gift at the end of the year from a student I had gone above and beyond for, repeatedly, not just taught him in lessons. I appreciated the sentiment behind the gift, and also that it was a small token only, which is by far my preference

I think gifts to individual staff should be banned - a box of biscuits for the staff room, a thoughtful thank you note- these are lovely - but it shouldn't go any further

I have been in schools where taking a gift off the premises was banned, so edible gifts were eaten there, and non edible gifts donated to the summer fayre

SleepingStandingUp · 21/12/2022 13:15

WifeMotherWorker · 21/12/2022 10:56

A TA doesn’t have the pressure or expectation to plan, mark, spend evenings in meetings and weekends on school work! I think if the TA or LA is assigned to a child then yes a gift is appropriate. I have only ever given to teachers as the TA have had no impact on my children’s schooling. I think a lot of people feel like this.

If you have a class TA I can guarantee they do have an impact on your child's schooling. Whether it's helping your child out whilst the teacher is busy or dealing with children with higher needs so the teacher doesn't have to etc., they're not there for ornamental purposes!

spiderlight · 21/12/2022 13:13

I always bought for the TAs. It might not have been exactly the same gift as the teacher got, as I tried to get things I knew they'd like, but I wouldn't have dreamed of buying for one and not the other.

Xmasbaby11 · 21/12/2022 13:13

Depends on the set up with the TA. My Y6 DD gets support from the TA as she has ASD. The TA is shared between quite a few but she definitely has a role with DD. I bought her a present and wrote a nice card. My Y4 DD's TA, well I don't even know who it is and she doesn't have contact with her AFAIK, so I haven't acknowledged her this year.

There are all sorts of staff at the school who support my DC and I can't give presents to all of them. It's fair enough to just focus on the teacher, who is the main adult responsible and usually the main one who matters to the kids.

Treeeeeeee · 21/12/2022 13:12

Completely agree op - even a small £2 box of chocolates (a carton of roses bought when on offer etc) makes all the difference. Personally I buy them the same gift but if not possible at least buy the TA something

EskSmith · 21/12/2022 13:10

TheNinthLock · 21/12/2022 11:30

The TA has no impact on your child’s schooling?

I am a TA.
I work with lower ability groups to enable teacher to concentrate on your child.
I take disruptive pupils for a run around the playground to enable your child to continue working undisturbed.
I look over your child’s work and support in class (all children, no matter their ability seek reassurance, guidance, praise from a TA on a regular basis)
I help your child look for their lost water bottle, missing lunch box, misplaced jumper.
I help your child open wrappers and packets at lunchtime.
I wipe the tables in the lunch hall so your child has somewhere clean to sit and eat.
I help your child tie their shoe laces and zip up their coat.
I help your child negotiate playground squabbles and friendship issues.
I listen to your child read.
I cheer on your child during sports competitions and on sports day.
I accompany your child on trips to ensure all have a good time and no one gets lost.
I make costumes and props for your child’s Christmas performance and help them learn their lines and songs.
I admire your child’s artwork.
I am always there for your child.

I don’t want gifts.

I do however want a bit of recognition - I exist. Your child benefits.

Absolutely well said.

To the poster who said t the TA has no impact for your child, take a closer look.

FancyFanny · 21/12/2022 13:09

I'm a TA and some children bring equal gifts for both me and the teacher, some give me a smaller gift than the teacher and some just bring a gift for the teacher.

If the class decide to do a collection instead of gift they usually split it unevenly so the teacher gets double what I get.

Little do parents know, that often, as a very experienced TA and ex teacher myself I have literally carried the teacher! Covered up their laziness in front of senior management to save their ass, planned intervention sessions myself when the teacher fails to provide planning as they should, warned them that what they've taught is factually incorrect before it's picked up in the kids books by ofsted, been on a residential trip for a week doing exactly the same job as the teacher for less half their pay etc.

I don't think many parents realise what the role of a TA is and how school literally can't function without us. All the TAs in my school do an amazing job!

caringcarer · 21/12/2022 13:08

I just send a couple of tins of shortbread for staff room. Seems to go down well.

RudsyFarmer · 21/12/2022 13:06

I’m a TA and I’m not upset in the least about presents. I was more made up about a lovely handwritten card to be honest.