Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think buying a teacher gift but not a TA one is a dick move?

184 replies

Wannakisstheteacher · 21/12/2022 10:48

Last day of school today. Standing waiting for the gates to open and see lots of children holding gift bags etc. One child showing the other children all the things she has for the teacher but doesn’t mention the TA. Another parent says she’s bought in chocolates for the teacher but again nothing for the TA - seems like the common theme from general chat.

AIBU to think it’s really low to bring in something for the teacher but nothing for the TA? They are so incredibly badly paid and have to do so much more than ever before so to bring in a full bag of stuff for the teacher but not even a small box of chocolates for the TA just seems like a dick move.

OP posts:
aintnothinbutagstring · 21/12/2022 14:33

It's all very well saying TAs and LSAs could earn more in a supermarket but that would also come with the obligation to, potentially, work unsociable hours, weekends, of course school holidays, Xmas, new year, mothers day, Easter. Not to mention a lot of supermarket work is heavylifting and repetitive so you're prone to injury - the light duties are usually given to long serving employees who can't do the heavy stuff because they've already got a work related long term injury. I've yet to see a mass migration of school staff to supermarkets - perhaps a few until they see the hours/working conditions.

SirSamVimesCityWatch · 21/12/2022 14:28

My DD has two teachers (job share) plus one full day with a third teacher to cover PPA.
There are three TAs connected to the class, one is a 1:1 and always used as such (significant difficulties of the child concerned mean she really is 1:1, all the time) and then another two part time TAs.
DD is one of the oldest in a mixed year class, bright, hardworking, well behaved. The TAs who aren't 1:1 are mainly used to support those with lower academic ability. DD has read to a TA four times over the winter term - that's the entirety of her contact with them.
In previous years where it has been 1 teacher and 1 TA I have bought equal (and decent) gifts for both. This year, no way. The two main teachers and the PPA cover teacher got a cheap bottle of mulled wine each, that's all.

WifeMotherWorker · 21/12/2022 14:15

GerardusMercator · 21/12/2022 13:57

@SleepingStandingUp I don't think anything much would change for my children- funnily enough when I was at school (in an extremely deprived area) we had bigger classes and no TAs and the sky didn't fall down. I have nothing against TAs and as I said in my previous post, buy equal gifts for teachers / TAs but I think the teachers impact my kids education more than the TA and frankly don't think this is even controversial - it's mine / my kids experience. Others experiences may vary 😉

That is also my experience. All my schools (20 years ago) were in deprived inner city areas and we didn’t have a single TA in any of my classes throughout First, Middle and Secondary! My children in more recent years didn’t have TAs and if they did they didn’t mention them, nor did I see them in parents evenings.

Wisteriaroundthedoor · 21/12/2022 14:13

It’s weird, in my daughters primary school the teachers gave the kids presents. Chocolates, little key rings etc, it was a private school. But it was the other way round, it was the children who got gifts. Not the adults.

I think this whole thing has got quite entitled and grabby now and can’t believe how adults behave

SnowyGiveAway · 21/12/2022 14:12

Individual hand written cards for whomever your child wants. This will generally be the teacher and the TA.

If you can and want to, £5 box of biscuits or chocolates for the staff room, clearly labelled 'for all the staff at XXX, Merry Christmas'.

Minimal waste, minimal expense, kids and teaching staff all happy

WifeMotherWorker · 21/12/2022 14:12

crisscrosscringle · 21/12/2022 12:24

I suspect you have no idea what a TA does.

I know they do considerably less than a classroom teacher in terms of responsibility, output and hours on the job!

Todayissunny · 21/12/2022 13:59

I'm a primary teacher (one subject) not in the UK. I am very happy that there is not a culture of giving teachers Christmas presents here. Itvis ridiculous. I don't need presents. I do appreciate a personal card or a note from children as and when a child wants to give one (not necessarilyat Christmas).
At the school where I work at the moment I don't get a special thank you (card or present) from the class going up to high school at the end of the school year. I would appreciate this particularly as I teach them for 4 years.

GerardusMercator · 21/12/2022 13:57

@SleepingStandingUp I don't think anything much would change for my children- funnily enough when I was at school (in an extremely deprived area) we had bigger classes and no TAs and the sky didn't fall down. I have nothing against TAs and as I said in my previous post, buy equal gifts for teachers / TAs but I think the teachers impact my kids education more than the TA and frankly don't think this is even controversial - it's mine / my kids experience. Others experiences may vary 😉

VioletLemon · 21/12/2022 13:54

It's not judged. What teachers appreciate is a paper picture the child has made of them and a handwritten card from parent saying thank you for how their child has been helped. That means much more than a pricey gift.

MRex · 21/12/2022 13:53

I really don't understand this individual gifting, surely it's just given cheap tat. Our class gave together, so we gave all our class TAs vouchers; slightly less than for teachers as realistically they do fewer hours, plus small gifts for support staff. Realistically, it's hard even across a class of 30 to amass enough cash for all support staff in the school.

Wannakisstheteacher · 21/12/2022 13:50

To clarify at our school each class does have a dedicated TA, and no they don’t just work with “lower ability” children 🙄It’s not even about the actual gift, it’s about sending your child in with a gift for one person who is in the class full time and completely ignoring the other person. I just think it sends the message that you value one but not the other. And to the poster asking if I’d like 30 identical £5 gifts… yes, when they are the red Lindt chocolate balls I’d be thrilled with 30 😁

OP posts:
Panama2 · 21/12/2022 13:42

I have a friend who is a supply teacher she says it’s great she goes in and the TA does everything so yes they should get something

EileenAdler · 21/12/2022 13:37

I used to give the same gift I got for doing my job.

PennyRa · 21/12/2022 13:36

ApproachingTheBig40 · 21/12/2022 13:32

The ta works with all children in a class not just some
Sometimes they take the class for a bit.

Doesn't mean every child has formed a relationship with the ta. They may also be a terrible ta or useless. Some tas are great others absolutely not

Laszlomydarling · 21/12/2022 13:35

WifeMotherWorker · 21/12/2022 10:56

A TA doesn’t have the pressure or expectation to plan, mark, spend evenings in meetings and weekends on school work! I think if the TA or LA is assigned to a child then yes a gift is appropriate. I have only ever given to teachers as the TA have had no impact on my children’s schooling. I think a lot of people feel like this.

Oh my word you think a TA has no impact on your child's schooling!? That's one of the most ridiculous things I've ever read on here. Having said that, I know very well that neither teachers nor TAs expect to receive gifts. Most of them don't want families to spend on them, especially during these financially stressful times.

WishIhadacrystalball · 21/12/2022 13:33

TheNinthLock · 21/12/2022 11:30

The TA has no impact on your child’s schooling?

I am a TA.
I work with lower ability groups to enable teacher to concentrate on your child.
I take disruptive pupils for a run around the playground to enable your child to continue working undisturbed.
I look over your child’s work and support in class (all children, no matter their ability seek reassurance, guidance, praise from a TA on a regular basis)
I help your child look for their lost water bottle, missing lunch box, misplaced jumper.
I help your child open wrappers and packets at lunchtime.
I wipe the tables in the lunch hall so your child has somewhere clean to sit and eat.
I help your child tie their shoe laces and zip up their coat.
I help your child negotiate playground squabbles and friendship issues.
I listen to your child read.
I cheer on your child during sports competitions and on sports day.
I accompany your child on trips to ensure all have a good time and no one gets lost.
I make costumes and props for your child’s Christmas performance and help them learn their lines and songs.
I admire your child’s artwork.
I am always there for your child.

I don’t want gifts.

I do however want a bit of recognition - I exist. Your child benefits.

This couldn’t be put any better. They are an integral part of the school and education system. Underpaid and undervalued.
I couldn’t do my job without them. They not only support our children but teachers too.

On the gift front, I don’t think anyone should feel any pressure at all. I can’t speak for anyone but I certainly don’t expect a gift for teaching your child, working with children is a gift in itself. Trusting me each day with your most precious being is my gift.

In all my years of teaching the things I have been given and valued the most, often bringing a year to my eye, are cards. Handmade cards by children with funny pictures or sweet notes. Notes from grateful parents who have been amazed at their child’s progress or happy they are enjoying school so much. I have every single one of these in a folder in my desk at home. Whenever work is hard and I’m struggling I read them to remind me of exactly why I do this job.

musicalfrog · 21/12/2022 13:33

Honeyroar · 21/12/2022 12:48

I run a café and do various charity events over the year. Most of my raffle prizes are donated by my teacher friends, and are chocolates, wine and bits and bobs they’ve been given by students. It would be better to just divide the class presents up between the staff, or just to not bother giving presents at all, particularly in this climate.

But then how would you raise money for charity? You didn't think that one through did you!

Tiredmum100 · 21/12/2022 13:32

Also to add, I've always bought the teacher and TAs the same presents.

Sartre · 21/12/2022 13:32

Not everyone has money to splurge on both the TA and teacher, some classes also have more than one TA. Some parents more than one child so this could end up being 6 or even 9 gifts compared to the 2-3 they’d otherwise have to purchase.

I don’t buy teachers Christmas gifts but do buy end of year gifts and I only ever buy for the teacher. This is largely because the TA’s have very little contact with my DC (most tend to spend time with the SEN children) but also because at one point I had 3 DC in primary and I couldn’t afford a gift for 9 members of staff.

ApproachingTheBig40 · 21/12/2022 13:32

PennyRa · 21/12/2022 13:29

Unless the child has a relationship with the ta why would they?

The ta works with all children in a class not just some
Sometimes they take the class for a bit.

Pandapop101 · 21/12/2022 13:31

WifeMotherWorker · 21/12/2022 10:56

A TA doesn’t have the pressure or expectation to plan, mark, spend evenings in meetings and weekends on school work! I think if the TA or LA is assigned to a child then yes a gift is appropriate. I have only ever given to teachers as the TA have had no impact on my children’s schooling. I think a lot of people feel like this.

Gifts aside, to say a TA has no impact on your children’s schooling I find hard to believe unless there is no TA in your child’s class.
It is an insulting thing to say.

LovelyRachel · 21/12/2022 13:31

Tbh when I was a HLTA, the gifting made me feel overwhelmed and awkward.

I've kept all the beautiful cards though 😍

Tiredmum100 · 21/12/2022 13:31

TheNinthLock · 21/12/2022 11:30

The TA has no impact on your child’s schooling?

I am a TA.
I work with lower ability groups to enable teacher to concentrate on your child.
I take disruptive pupils for a run around the playground to enable your child to continue working undisturbed.
I look over your child’s work and support in class (all children, no matter their ability seek reassurance, guidance, praise from a TA on a regular basis)
I help your child look for their lost water bottle, missing lunch box, misplaced jumper.
I help your child open wrappers and packets at lunchtime.
I wipe the tables in the lunch hall so your child has somewhere clean to sit and eat.
I help your child tie their shoe laces and zip up their coat.
I help your child negotiate playground squabbles and friendship issues.
I listen to your child read.
I cheer on your child during sports competitions and on sports day.
I accompany your child on trips to ensure all have a good time and no one gets lost.
I make costumes and props for your child’s Christmas performance and help them learn their lines and songs.
I admire your child’s artwork.
I am always there for your child.

I don’t want gifts.

I do however want a bit of recognition - I exist. Your child benefits.

I agree with you completely! All TAs deserve recognition. You all do amazing jobs. My children are primary age, the TAs do so much for them! I also think TA deserve much more than they are paid.

Nimbostratus100 · 21/12/2022 13:30

FancyFanny · 21/12/2022 13:27

You don't need to pay tax on a gift unless it is a very significant amount.

I honestly dont know what it is now, but the last time I did know, it was if gifts added up to a value of over £60 in a financial year

PennyRa · 21/12/2022 13:29

Unless the child has a relationship with the ta why would they?