Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SIL and presents.

31 replies

FleeceDuvet · 21/12/2022 10:36

This would be very outing if I added details
of the gifts so I’ll keep it vague.

It’s my birthday today.

I don’t have much of a relationship with SIL (DH brothers wife) after 15 odd years of weirdness from her. She’s a bit of a shopaholic and goes mad for buying presents. One year when DD was small she presented her with three bin bag sized sacks of gifts at her party at my parents house, it was embarrassing and awkward. It’s only really got worse over the years. We get a giant gift bag each for Christmas (family of five). my birthday bag this year was a normal sized gift bag and I was relieved. Until I opened it.

Quite often the gifts are things she would love but very not me. (think nick nacks or candles or gin liqueur)

This years gifts are lovely. But too lovely. One of the items in particular is something high-ish end and perfect for me but far too expensive. Even if that was the only thing. The total of all the gifts in the bag is easily in the hundreds. We haven’t actually spoken for a year because I called her out on some shocking behaviour and she ghosted me. DH and his brother are fine. I’m embarrassed and weirded out. DH says I’m overreacting (and she probably got it in a chazzer, I don’t believe this for a second).

We definitely don’t have the sort of relationship where expensive thoughtful gifts would be appropriate. I have never ever reciprocated in kind, I buy either what she directly asks for or something I know she likes but always around the £25-30 level that I spend on other adults in the family.

I don’t know how to deal with this. I know some of you will think it’s a non problem but it clouds my birthday every year. i find it embarrassing and uncomfortable to be given so much, and so much value. Weirdly it’s somehow worse that this particular thing is something I wanted (she wouldn’t have known that) and will use. Previous gifts have been unused and ended up at the charity shop.

i have addressed this with her and her DH several times over the years btw. Her DH says she is a great bargain hunter and she claims to stick to a £25 per adult budget. I think he’s completely fucking deluded but ok.

OP posts:
RunLolaRun102 · 21/12/2022 10:45

She’s probably reaching out

RegularNameChangerVersion21 · 21/12/2022 10:45

YANBU to feel uncomfortable op. Without knowing your sil it's impossible to say why she's doing it.

I know someone who overbuys gifts but in her case she has ADHD and also low self esteem due to issues in her past. She finds it difficult to connect and tries to compensate with gifts, combined with poor impulse control it tends to be not even well chosen gifts. It probably makes people feel awkward but is well intentioned.

Someone else I know has a mil who will use gifts as an act of aggression (eg knowing that the parents want to buy a certain model railway for their child she'll arrive two days before Christmas with a huge model railway in an alternative brand which isn't compatible). In her case it's definitely NOT well intentioned.

No idea what you should do about it apart from not engage. Thank her politely as of she'd sent an appropriate gift and move on. The gift giving, whatever the motivation, is clearly more about her than you. It sounds like she's a difficult character generally who might have wider issues so I'd be inclined to be sympathetic while acknowledging that her issues aren't yours to solve.

RedPandaFluff · 21/12/2022 10:45

Gosh this is a strange one. I think I'd be uncomfortable too. It sounds like she has a bit of an addiction - is she well-off? Can she actually afford to spend this money? If she can, maybe it makes her happy to give extravagant gifts?

Cherrysoup · 21/12/2022 10:45

Just give it back and say no more presents, you’re trying to cut down on clutter.

User135792468 · 21/12/2022 10:44

Maybe it’s her way of reaching out and making amends?

FleeceDuvet · 21/12/2022 10:43

I know this is a ridiculous problem to have by the way.

OP posts: