Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not have sympathy for my friend?

242 replies

lurkinglittleladybug · 20/12/2022 22:50

I have an old school friend who’s been complaining about her partner taking zero interest in their children. She’s a stay at home mum and her partner works full time and is in a well paid job. He pays the bills and for anything her and the children need but she complains he’s not emotionally present with them. He doesn’t spend any time with them or help out at all with childcare.

I would normally have a low opinion of a man who can’t be arsed to spend time with his kids, and it is a shame for the children. But it’s so difficult to be sympathetic with my friend. I kind of feel like she made her own bed with this situation.

After a year of her being with her partner (at this point they had a really good relationship and lived together) , she knew he was strictly childfree and had no interest in children. So I was surprised when she announced her pregnancy but congratulated her as she was clearly happy about having a baby. She later told me that she knew her partner wouldn’t want to start a family so she just stopped taking the pill without telling him. He stays with her but becomes somewhat emotionally distant, I expect he was in shock. Friend was confident he would change his mind once their baby arrived.

After the baby is born he just takes zero interest, but she has lots of support from family. Nothing changes for a couple of years and then she announces she’s expecting her second child. I congratulate her, again I’m surprised, I had no idea they were trying. She then confides in me that she sabotaged the birth control again, this time the condoms they were using. At this point I make it clear I disapprove of her doing this. She becomes tearful saying what choice did she have and that her child needed a sibling. So I let the subject drop. Not wanting to be the asshole making my pregnant friend cry even though I think it’s a shitty thing to do.

Anyway now she has 2 children and she is complaining about how her partner has just emotionally checked out, not just with her children but also with her. He’s not interested in intimacy and is just going through the motions. It looks like their relationship is well and truly headed for the rocks this time.

I just find it so hard to be sympathetic with her, I mean what did she expect would happen? 🙄… Although obviously I’m very sad for the 2 children who face growing up with an emotionally distant dad…

Am I a terrible friend for not having sympathy for her?

I’m really struggling to stay friends with her knowing what I know, I just feel like I have lost respect for her. Although its difficult to end the friendship because we have known each other for such a long time.

OP posts:
drpet49 · 21/12/2022 03:14

DuplicateUserName · 20/12/2022 23:42

Am I a terrible friend for not having sympathy for her?

No, what makes you a terrible friend is starting this thread about her on a public forum.

Oh go away, anyone can post anything

dolor · 21/12/2022 03:12

Nope, I honestly wouldn't have much sympathy there.

None at all, in fact.

stayathomer · 21/12/2022 03:05

If you’re someone’s friend you can not be happy about a situation they’re in, and perhaps totally disapprove BUT the friendship part is where you hate seeing them unhappy and be there to listen to her. This is a long term thing, not a once off thing, so you’re either in or out, this is baggage that comes with her (imo)

Starrylight · 21/12/2022 03:04

ClarathecrosseyedLioness · 21/12/2022 02:48

@Millie2008 Also... why didn't he get a vasectomy if he was that adamant about being child free? Especially after the first pregnancy!

This ^

Bit shutting the stable gate if he wasn't aware the first pregnancy was likely to be happening though? Or are we supposed to raise our sons to assume any woman they enter a long term, loving relationship with might be lying?

Pretty hard to get a vasectomy above what 35? In the UK on the NHS? Of course he could have funded it privately, but then again maybe he assumed his partner was on the same wavelength as him?

My Dd had to massively push for her tubes tied at 24 after 3 pregnancies with the same partner, and they only reason she had it done was because she needed a c section due to her 1st pregnancy being an emergency one, so all others followed. She stated numerous times that the many, many contraceptives they tried didn't suit her. And believe me other than abstaining they tried. Her partner is 28, and they still refused to give him a vasectomy. It's not always that clear cut.

MangyInseam · 21/12/2022 02:54

DuchessofSandwich · 21/12/2022 02:50

Why? I know of at least two women that deceived their partners to get pregnant. It's hardly an outing thread, is it?

Sadly I think it is a lot more common than many people realize.

DuchessofSandwich · 21/12/2022 02:50

DuplicateUserName · 20/12/2022 23:42

Am I a terrible friend for not having sympathy for her?

No, what makes you a terrible friend is starting this thread about her on a public forum.

Why? I know of at least two women that deceived their partners to get pregnant. It's hardly an outing thread, is it?

ClarathecrosseyedLioness · 21/12/2022 02:48

@Millie2008 Also... why didn't he get a vasectomy if he was that adamant about being child free? Especially after the first pregnancy!

This ^

TheMatriarchy · 21/12/2022 02:37

Poor kids, they are the true victims in this situation.

The relationship is over, trust gone for good, its just a matter of time before it implodes. He probably thinks he is doing his best by staying with her under the circumstances, and is grappling with the ethics of what to do after being put in such a position by someone you trusted and loved. I hope for the children he can find it in himself to do his best by them. Personally I think he has a better chance of doing that away from the person who abused his trust.

KettrickenSmiled · 21/12/2022 02:32

Nimbostratus100 · 21/12/2022 00:11

you can never really guarantee that you will remain child free if you have sex, can you? Unless you are far more proactive about it than he appears to have been

You can never guarantee you're not going to die in a motorway crash either, but you can't be blamed if your co-pilot wrenches the wheel from you & drives you both into a truck.

Dervel · 21/12/2022 02:31

I’m a man who had the first scenario play out, in that birth control pills were in place but my then partner came off them prior to conception. Despite me checking in at the time did I need condoms? I was lied to. Needless to say I dumped her immediately.

Where I differ from the OPs partner is I have always very much wanted to be a father, so am a very proud and happy one. I also now have sole custody of my child, as my ex has been a nightmare ever since I left her, this of course unfortunately bled over into efforts to co-parent with her effectively.

I would caution anyone making too direct a parallel between this sort of contraceptive fraud, and the “stealthing” that men do to women. It was a violation sure, and maybe even in principle should be similarly illegal, but I didn’t have the potential physical ramifications on the table from actually being pregnant, which can be life changing and severe. This I believe makes it a simply more severe crime when it happens to a woman.

What I would say however is I would challenge the victim blaming language on this thread, and those who use it should be ashamed of themselves. The man in question entered into a relationship in good faith. Even stating up front he never wanted children, we all know contraception has a very small risk of failure and he was willing to take that small risk. He was not however willing to assume the risks attendant to entirely unprotected sex which by his wife’s deception he was unknowingly taking. Thus his consent was violated. He is the victim here.

I would ask the question to the OP and forgive me if I missed it. Does the husband even know of these two deceptions? Were they revealed to him at any stage? If not I’d say everyone who knew and did not tell him have ultimately condoned what this woman did, and by preserving the first deception allowed his wife to perpetrate the second. If he doesn’t know I believe it is high time he is informed so he can finally make an informed choice with regards to his own future.

Finally the wretched circumstances for these two poor children. None of us are “owed” children, and obviously children thrive when they are wanted dearly by both parents. I’m not even sure the mother was really discharging her responsibilities for the first child by throwing a second into the mix in an already tenuous situation. I very much worry for the outcomes for these two little ones. At least my ex had the wit to perpetrate her deception on someone who actually wanted children.

KettrickenSmiled · 21/12/2022 02:26

I’m really struggling to stay friends with her knowing what I know, I just feel like I have lost respect for her.
Struggling in what way? Because you want to drop her but feel guilty for it, or because you want to stay friends but she;s making it hard for you?

Although its difficult to end the friendship because we have known each other for such a long time.
It's doable, you;d just need to bite the bullet, also maybe wait it out until next time she settles in for a moaning session, so it's not out of the blue, it's a response to a specific behaviour.

If you don't want to end it:
"Mate, I can't keep hearing about this. It makes me uncomfortable to know damaging secrets your husband doesn't, & I need you to keep it to yourself or find a therapist, because I'm not qualified to deal with it."

If you do want to end it:
"Mate, I can't keep hearing about this. It makes me uncomfortable to know damaging secrets your husband doesn't, & I need you to keep it to yourself or find a therapist, because I'm not qualified to deal with it.
I'm going to take a step back because I'm burnt out from constantly hearing how dissatisfied you are that it didn't go quite the way you planned, & your expectation that I wouldn't empathise with the predicament you caused your H. Sorry, can't do it any more, I'll be in touch when I've had some space."

Then don't get in touch.

allthelittlelights · 21/12/2022 02:25

There should be trust. My H didn't want more children. I wanted one more. I respected his decision and didn't sabotage contraception or lie.

NumberTheory · 21/12/2022 02:23

I don't see what's wrong with posting about it anonymously on a public forum. This is one of the best way for people to discuss the ins and outs of real life behaviour. The alternatives are naming and shaming people, absolute silence and a lack of engagement on a significant ethical issue that touches us all, or a sanitized discussion about a pretend scenario no one has any stake in or feels any emotional connection to and so people parroting what they think others expect them to say.

There's a place for the last of those within academic and professional circles, but it doesn't help the general public wrestle with the issues involved.

MangyInseam · 21/12/2022 02:03

There's some truth to the idea that if you have sex, you should realize that pregnancy, and a child, is a possible outcome. For both men and women, and even with sterilization procedures. It's rare, but there are pregnancies that happen after people are supposedly sterilized, I know of one that happened after both partners were sterilized.

So to some extent, if you want 100% assurance of no pregnancy, celibacy is the only option. But I think most of us realize that lots of people won't do that. Especially since in our culture we are generally taught to believe that having sex without pregnancy is a sort of right we should expect.

That being said, there is a huge difference when you talk about an individual purposefully sabotaging agreed upon attempts at birth control. And if the husband in this case came to suspect the wife had become pregnant on purpose, maybe after the second pregnancy, I am not surprised he'd be emotionally distant. It would be very difficult to overcome that kind of distrust and I think it could easily affect the relationship to the kids as well, as much as it shouldn't. And then, if the relationship functions at a level where the wife felt justified in that kind of betrayal, it may well be that there are other problems in the marriage that affect his ability to engage. Being a workaholic could easily be a coping mechanism because he feels a duty to stay in the marriage, it is very hard to be married to someone you neither like nor trust.

parsniiips · 21/12/2022 01:58

At the end of the day, if you have sex you must take on the responsibility that you could end up with a pregnancy and subsequently a baby, regardless of the contraceptive you use. Nothing is 100% effective. Even a vasectomy.

But that doesn't take away the malicious behaviour of lying about taking the pill, and damaging condoms. That's seriously evil and cruel to the person who was clear they don't want a child and did take preventive measures before having sex, and to the children that were born out of that situation.

He needs to have a vasectomy, leave this woman and step up for the children whether he wanted them or not because they exist and he is their father. I feel for them all having a wife and mother capable of doing this.

I wouldn't be friends with her going forward because we'd have completely different morals and I'd worry how she would treat other people in her life if she didn't get her own way.

user1471457751 · 21/12/2022 01:57

GLADragss · 21/12/2022 01:52

Look, vasectomies exist. He’s not an innocent angel here, condoms are never 100% effective against pregnancy. He’s continuing to engage in sex which shockingly runs the risk of pregnancy. He’s allowed himself to be fooled twice here. She’s proven herself to be devious once, yet he’s continued having sex with her so therefore accepted that risk. If he truly wanted to be child free, he could have considered sterilisation

Would you say that to a woman who had been repeatedly sexually assaulted, that she 'allowed herself to be fooled?'

Weatherwax13 · 21/12/2022 01:56

I truly don't understand why she risked telling anyone. I'd be taking that secret to the grave personally.
I don't know that I'd cut her out if she's a good friend, but she wouldn't be someone I'd confide in as she's capable of being untrustworthy and self centred. And I wouldn't be offering tea and sympathy if she were rumbled by her DH.

user1471457751 · 21/12/2022 01:55

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

kateandme · 21/12/2022 01:53

If this was a woman we'd be saying she's been abused,needs to be told and to get away from him fast.

GLADragss · 21/12/2022 01:52

Look, vasectomies exist. He’s not an innocent angel here, condoms are never 100% effective against pregnancy. He’s continuing to engage in sex which shockingly runs the risk of pregnancy. He’s allowed himself to be fooled twice here. She’s proven herself to be devious once, yet he’s continued having sex with her so therefore accepted that risk. If he truly wanted to be child free, he could have considered sterilisation

midsomermurderess · 21/12/2022 01:45

I’ve never come across such weird, dysfunctional, nasty relationships masquerading under the name ‘friend’ anywhere but on this site.

WhatTheHellIsAQuasar · 21/12/2022 01:42

GLADragss · 21/12/2022 01:30

To be fair, he could have used a condom or taken other steps to prevent pregnancy himself if he truly never wanted to conceive. I’m not denying that your friend was devious, but she can’t impregnate herself. I think after the first unexpected pregnancy, he should have changed his MO

Read the thread properly - he was using condoms and the woman was sabotaging them

KettrickenSmiled · 21/12/2022 01:41

Alstoybarn · 21/12/2022 01:15

Answer is yes, your clearly a terrible friend.

How so? Are you able to explain your reasoning, or were you just feeling like having a pop?

Morestrangethings · 21/12/2022 01:41

NameChagaiiiin · 21/12/2022 01:34

Why can't people read?

After the 1st 'accident' with the pill, he swapped to condoms. Which she sabotaged.

condoms prevent 98% of pregnancies if used correctly. So, 2% chance they don’t work. Low pregnancy rate but still a real possibility. Surely no bloke thinks they are 100% protective, and if you don’t want kids, enough to be emotionally distant from them, you need to be absolutely failsafe.

KettrickenSmiled · 21/12/2022 01:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What's spiteful about feeling that tricking a man into having DC he absolutely does not want is morally bankrupt?

Spiteful is lying about being on the pill, poking holes in your unwitting husband's condoms, sitting back & taking the money he manfully stumps up to keep you & 2 unwished-for children housed, fed & all the rest of it, & then moaning because he's - amazingly! - now emotionally uninvested.

Manipulating a man into being an unwilling sperm donor is an abhorrent thing to do. It's as selfish & abusive as stealthing a woman.
Both acts are basically non-consensual sex - the tricked party did NOT agree to take unnecessary pregnancy risks.