Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not have sympathy for my friend?

242 replies

lurkinglittleladybug · 20/12/2022 22:50

I have an old school friend who’s been complaining about her partner taking zero interest in their children. She’s a stay at home mum and her partner works full time and is in a well paid job. He pays the bills and for anything her and the children need but she complains he’s not emotionally present with them. He doesn’t spend any time with them or help out at all with childcare.

I would normally have a low opinion of a man who can’t be arsed to spend time with his kids, and it is a shame for the children. But it’s so difficult to be sympathetic with my friend. I kind of feel like she made her own bed with this situation.

After a year of her being with her partner (at this point they had a really good relationship and lived together) , she knew he was strictly childfree and had no interest in children. So I was surprised when she announced her pregnancy but congratulated her as she was clearly happy about having a baby. She later told me that she knew her partner wouldn’t want to start a family so she just stopped taking the pill without telling him. He stays with her but becomes somewhat emotionally distant, I expect he was in shock. Friend was confident he would change his mind once their baby arrived.

After the baby is born he just takes zero interest, but she has lots of support from family. Nothing changes for a couple of years and then she announces she’s expecting her second child. I congratulate her, again I’m surprised, I had no idea they were trying. She then confides in me that she sabotaged the birth control again, this time the condoms they were using. At this point I make it clear I disapprove of her doing this. She becomes tearful saying what choice did she have and that her child needed a sibling. So I let the subject drop. Not wanting to be the asshole making my pregnant friend cry even though I think it’s a shitty thing to do.

Anyway now she has 2 children and she is complaining about how her partner has just emotionally checked out, not just with her children but also with her. He’s not interested in intimacy and is just going through the motions. It looks like their relationship is well and truly headed for the rocks this time.

I just find it so hard to be sympathetic with her, I mean what did she expect would happen? 🙄… Although obviously I’m very sad for the 2 children who face growing up with an emotionally distant dad…

Am I a terrible friend for not having sympathy for her?

I’m really struggling to stay friends with her knowing what I know, I just feel like I have lost respect for her. Although its difficult to end the friendship because we have known each other for such a long time.

OP posts:
lurkinglittleladybug · 22/12/2022 03:15

Sorry typo in that last message I said husband, although they are not legally married so just partners… So not a great situation, if this relationship ends not sure how much protection she will have regarding the house etc with not being married, I think it’s all in his name …

OP posts:
lurkinglittleladybug · 22/12/2022 03:10

Dervel · 21/12/2022 02:31

I’m a man who had the first scenario play out, in that birth control pills were in place but my then partner came off them prior to conception. Despite me checking in at the time did I need condoms? I was lied to. Needless to say I dumped her immediately.

Where I differ from the OPs partner is I have always very much wanted to be a father, so am a very proud and happy one. I also now have sole custody of my child, as my ex has been a nightmare ever since I left her, this of course unfortunately bled over into efforts to co-parent with her effectively.

I would caution anyone making too direct a parallel between this sort of contraceptive fraud, and the “stealthing” that men do to women. It was a violation sure, and maybe even in principle should be similarly illegal, but I didn’t have the potential physical ramifications on the table from actually being pregnant, which can be life changing and severe. This I believe makes it a simply more severe crime when it happens to a woman.

What I would say however is I would challenge the victim blaming language on this thread, and those who use it should be ashamed of themselves. The man in question entered into a relationship in good faith. Even stating up front he never wanted children, we all know contraception has a very small risk of failure and he was willing to take that small risk. He was not however willing to assume the risks attendant to entirely unprotected sex which by his wife’s deception he was unknowingly taking. Thus his consent was violated. He is the victim here.

I would ask the question to the OP and forgive me if I missed it. Does the husband even know of these two deceptions? Were they revealed to him at any stage? If not I’d say everyone who knew and did not tell him have ultimately condoned what this woman did, and by preserving the first deception allowed his wife to perpetrate the second. If he doesn’t know I believe it is high time he is informed so he can finally make an informed choice with regards to his own future.

Finally the wretched circumstances for these two poor children. None of us are “owed” children, and obviously children thrive when they are wanted dearly by both parents. I’m not even sure the mother was really discharging her responsibilities for the first child by throwing a second into the mix in an already tenuous situation. I very much worry for the outcomes for these two little ones. At least my ex had the wit to perpetrate her deception on someone who actually wanted children.

Interesting to read the man’s perspective in this situation… I’m sorry you experienced this though, it’s a really shitty thing to not be able to trust the person you’re in a relationship with.

To answer your question, no the husband doesn’t officially know, although I’m sure he has his suspicions after the second ‘accidental pregnancy’… I suspect if she’s told me that she will have also told her sister and her mum, they are very close.

I wouldn’t want to tell him, partly because it’s not my place to and partly because there’s 2 very innocent children who might suffer if the truth comes out and he chooses to leave. I wouldn’t want that on my conscience.

Im meeting my friend later today for coffee and to swap Christmas gifts, not sure if I will bring any of this up, might try to keep things pleasant with it being so close to Christmas and all, although will be difficult if she starts complaining about her relationship problems … I’m going to have to seriously bite my tongue if she does. Wish me luck!

OP posts:
KettrickenSmiled · 21/12/2022 23:40

BaddogGooddoggy · 21/12/2022 18:41

I agree with you there. I’m not sure I would cast her aside though, it would depend on how I felt about her DC as much as anything. If her DH does go on his way then the DC are left with just her, on her own.

Ouch, didn't think of that. Gawd, those poor mites. Whether their parents stay together or not, it's a blighted start to life.

kc431 · 21/12/2022 19:04

*have never

kc431 · 21/12/2022 19:04

No, this is just fucking awful and your friend is a scumbag. Laughing that the only way to be “truly” childfree is to get an operation 😂 I’m childfree and have haver wanted kids since age 10 but don’t want to get sterilised as I have been known to do a 180 on various views, and it feels weird to get an operation to remove a function of my body IYSWIM…

I’ve been having sex for 11 years, with DH for 7, only ever used condoms and never had a single accident with one (and this is all brands, Durex, Mates, Poundland’s own). I had a friend at uni who said they “always broke” on him. Methinks some people don’t know how to use them properly and are essentially making up all of the 2% failure rate.

If I was him I would have just changed my name, got plastic surgery and left the country. Can’t think of anything worse than being lumbered with 2 kids you never wanted.

BaddogGooddoggy · 21/12/2022 18:41

KettrickenSmiled · 21/12/2022 17:58

😂(Genuine laugh, not snark)

Point taken, I just find this a much more heinous action than most poor decisions & actions. I consider OP's friend to be a domestic abuser, & I don't hang out with DA perps.

I agree with you there. I’m not sure I would cast her aside though, it would depend on how I felt about her DC as much as anything. If her DH does go on his way then the DC are left with just her, on her own.

KimberleyClark · 21/12/2022 18:04

Imagine the uproar on here if there was such a thing as male contraceptive pill and a male partner had stopped taking it without telling his partner. And the woman In a case would have a choice over whether to become a mother, unlike the father in this scenario.

KettrickenSmiled · 21/12/2022 17:58

BaddogGooddoggy · 21/12/2022 17:27

I don’t agree that by not casting her aside I’m condoning her actions. Taken to its logical conclusion, I’d have no friends, as they’ve all made decisions I don’t condone. I’d even not be friends with myself!

😂(Genuine laugh, not snark)

Point taken, I just find this a much more heinous action than most poor decisions & actions. I consider OP's friend to be a domestic abuser, & I don't hang out with DA perps.

BaddogGooddoggy · 21/12/2022 17:27

KettrickenSmiled · 21/12/2022 16:29

I did bother, & it made no sense. Which is why I asked the question.
You said wouldn't condone it, but you'd stay friends with her. Sure - that's not explicitly condoning it. Just tacitly.

I don’t agree that by not casting her aside I’m condoning her actions. Taken to its logical conclusion, I’d have no friends, as they’ve all made decisions I don’t condone. I’d even not be friends with myself!

Blinki · 21/12/2022 17:03

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Untitledsquatboulder · 21/12/2022 16:42

Starrylight · 21/12/2022 00:45

We make our bed... And then we lie in it? Not sure how she thought the situation would improve the second time around? Potentially she just wanted to secure a second child if he's had no interest in the first, and 'being mum', seems her only outlet in life? All a bit bonkers really?! But dad really needs to get the snip at this point.

...or just stop sleeping with his cunt of a wife.

KettrickenSmiled · 21/12/2022 16:38

Whatdoyouthinkno · 21/12/2022 15:45

Of course it’s enormously difficult to ever prove but I do think the small minority of women who do this should be taken to court, it should be as illegal as stealthing is. She has removed his right to choose whether he has children or not, it’s out of order.

Christ on a bike NO!

Emotionally I'm with you all the way here Whatdo,
But logistically? Imagine the consequences of any legal precedent.

Women aren't believed as readily as men are. Look as any she said/he said statistics. We can't even obtain a rape conviction when we're bleeding & covered in bruises. Who would believe a woman who steadfastly stuck by her truthful assertion that SHE was not the party responsible for contraception sabotage?

Can you imagine what the incel brigade would make of that?
Women AS A CLASS would be stigmatised & undermined even further.
We can't inadvertently punish all women for the selfish & venal actions of a few bad female players.

KettrickenSmiled · 21/12/2022 16:29

BaddogGooddoggy · 21/12/2022 15:38

If you had bothered to read further I explained that I meant people were being harsh to the OP. I neither tacitly nor explicitly condone what her friend has done.

I did bother, & it made no sense. Which is why I asked the question.
You said wouldn't condone it, but you'd stay friends with her. Sure - that's not explicitly condoning it. Just tacitly.

KettrickenSmiled · 21/12/2022 16:18

Pothoswithasparkle · 21/12/2022 09:08

I learned on MN that nothing ever comes from our heads except cleaning that needs to be done. Everything is man's fault/thoughts/wants.
Shaving your legs? Cause patriarchy! Not shaving your legs? Cause patriarchy!

Except how to clean the sink well, we have no own thoughts or opinions. All our actions or inactions are caused and ruled by men.

Hence, i deduced that we need men otherwise we would all be just stuck in a loop of cleaning bathroom and kitchen and sitting in a corner not knowing whether we should shave armpits or not😔

😂😂😂😍You're well on form today Pothos 👏

KettrickenSmiled · 21/12/2022 16:13

Luckystar7jf · 21/12/2022 08:34

Hi op, I wonder if your friend’s situation may have triggered a particularly strong emotion within you. Do you have a partner/children ? Do your negative feelings towards her go deeper than just not liking what she has done ?
What your friend did to her partner is very wrong. Unfair to him and to their poor children but she has not personally hurt you only her actions have.
If I was you I would not distance myself but have a heart to heart. Explain how you feel, why you struggle with empathy. You can say is assertively.
You life your life she’s made her bed.

Distance yourself, but have a heart to heart.

Your feelings are too strong & Not Allowed, but simultaneously, your feeling of empathy is not strong enough, so you are Bad & Wrong.

Your FRIEND did not hurt you - that was her ACTIONS. Naughty actions, running around in the wild, independent of their human!

This list is subject to revision, depending on whether you have achieved parturition, & if you are single or not.

Thank you Luckystar, for bringing such searing insight & clarity to the thread.

KettrickenSmiled · 21/12/2022 16:05

Advise her to get a job and get her finances sorted out as I predict he will move on with a younger, child-free model who hasn't lied through her teeth to him.

Why younger?
Given all that's happened, he'd be way better off with a older, post-meno woman.

Also, I dislike this cliche of 'younger model'. What is this, tabloid hell, where women are not people, but just interchangeable variants of girlfriend-shaped object?

"Model" my arse. <<<chunters off to burn bra, muttering darkly >>>

NameChagaiiiin · 21/12/2022 16:00

ilovesushi · 21/12/2022 08:37

I feel sorry for your friend. What a hard situation for her. She must have thought that he would come around once the baby was born. I've known friends' DHs who were not keen on having a family but were smitten once their DC arrived and became the most devoted dads. It is a sad situation for all of them. Awful for the children to grow up feeling unloved. Hopefully as they get a bit older she can become financially independent and move on from him. It sounds horribly disfunctional.

I'm sorry. You feel sorry for HER???

You need your head looking at. Don't go poking holes in fucking condoms trying to trick a bloke into staying with you. Despicable.

On a side note. There's an awful lot if armchair medics on here who seem to think you can just pop to the Drs and pick up a vasectomy. You can't. Unless you pay to go private, there's restrictions and wait lists. That aside, he should have been 99.9% safe from having a child, SHE took that away. She should be reported.

KettrickenSmiled · 21/12/2022 15:58

Hopefully as they get a bit older she can become financially independent and move on from him.
Hmm

This reads as if he's the party in the wrong! - like he's compromised her financial independence by accepting her wish to be a SAHM despite him never have envisaged having to become the sole provider in a single-income family of 4.

Didn't you mean to say "hopefully, she will stop mooching off a man she stole sperm from & blackmailed into paying for the results, stop living a lie, & leave him to find a more deserving & honest woman" ?

Mentalpiece · 21/12/2022 15:52

If you can lie to and deceive your man about something as huge and life-changing as pregnancy, then I would wonder what else they had lied and deceived about.
Vasectomies.....just because a young man has said that he doesn't want children today, doesn't mean that he may not want children in the future. Having a vasectomy would put paid to that unless he goes through the reversal, not guaranteed to work, procedure.
Not many doctors will perform this procedure on a young man for that very reason.
If you can't trust your partner, then who can you trust? The man had taken reasonable steps to prevent a pregnancy, the woman took unreasonable steps to ensure a pregnancy happened.
Despicable.

Pothoswithasparkle · 21/12/2022 15:50

KettrickenSmiled · 21/12/2022 15:45

How is it naive to rely on contraception?
It's not naive, it's NORMAL. It's part of the social consciousness, in a way that vasectomy really isn't. It's just not part of the zeitgeist for the vast majority of people to think "well I don't want kids so I'd better sterilise myself."

Condoms are 98% reliable.
The 2% failure rate is usually down to user error.
That user error can be reduced further by educating yourself, not getting too pissed to be careful, not delaying putting it on during foreplay, etc.
Doing that can bring effectiveness so close to 100% it's almost indistinguishable.
As effective as a vasectomy - which are also not 100% reliable.

Within that 2% user error scope is an error that only one party can control though - sabotage.
So unless you're a stupid dick about how you use condoms, you are being entirely reasonable to assume your contraception is almost bulletproof.
UNLESS ... your girlfriend is a liar with access to pins.

Tbh I can see why someone on MN would think it's naive to rely on contraception since the failure rate seems to be 50%....

Soz

KettrickenSmiled · 21/12/2022 15:49

The desire to have a child can be so strong and it's not always easy to just go meet someone new.

My desire to rob a bank is so strong, because it's not easy to just go out & meet a million quid.

But instead of whipping out the balaclava, I resign myself to the fact that no bank has consented to my raid, & that while I may never have a million quid, I can be content with the cash I'm able to earn honestly.

Whatdoyouthinkno · 21/12/2022 15:45

Of course it’s enormously difficult to ever prove but I do think the small minority of women who do this should be taken to court, it should be as illegal as stealthing is. She has removed his right to choose whether he has children or not, it’s out of order.

KettrickenSmiled · 21/12/2022 15:45

Tinseltosser · 21/12/2022 08:26

Shit behaviour all round and it’s the dc who will suffer.

It’s not his fault he was deceived, but it was very naive of him to rely on contraception.

I get the motorway analogy, but it’s also the same as him knowing he had an option that would ensure this life changing thing that he didn’t want never happened, that he would never crash no matter what nutter was with him in the car. And he decided not only not to take it, but to also get back in the car with the nutter who made him crash last time.

I also have never subscribed to the belief that it’s totally fine for a dad to check out emotionally/physically if he never really wanted children but had risky sex anyway (I count risky as not having had a a vasectomy and all the relevant checks afterwards). Sex using any other method of contraception is risky if dc is such a huge dealbreaker for you that your life will be ruined and you will emotionally neglect them when they get here.

How is it naive to rely on contraception?
It's not naive, it's NORMAL. It's part of the social consciousness, in a way that vasectomy really isn't. It's just not part of the zeitgeist for the vast majority of people to think "well I don't want kids so I'd better sterilise myself."

Condoms are 98% reliable.
The 2% failure rate is usually down to user error.
That user error can be reduced further by educating yourself, not getting too pissed to be careful, not delaying putting it on during foreplay, etc.
Doing that can bring effectiveness so close to 100% it's almost indistinguishable.
As effective as a vasectomy - which are also not 100% reliable.

Within that 2% user error scope is an error that only one party can control though - sabotage.
So unless you're a stupid dick about how you use condoms, you are being entirely reasonable to assume your contraception is almost bulletproof.
UNLESS ... your girlfriend is a liar with access to pins.

CleopatrasBeautifulNose · 21/12/2022 15:41

@RamblingEclectic @KettrickenSmiled 👏👏👏👏👏

BaddogGooddoggy · 21/12/2022 15:38

KettrickenSmiled · 21/12/2022 15:12

So you'd tacitly condone what she did?

This man could have left her at any point. They're not married, he could have settled for a bare minimum mandated maintenance payment, & tolf her to fuck off & take her sabotaged condom stash with her.

She'd be up shit creek then, as she's also currently out of the workplace.

So she's not just a liar who stole a man's sperm as a way to get the DC she craved & keep her mitts in his wallet - she's amazingly dim. Or just plain venal, or both. I can't imagine what kind of psychological hold she has over him that keeps him plodding on with her.

He's doing a stand-up job, providing a home to 2 kids he didn't ask for, & their conniving mother. He'll have a sneaking suspicion of how it all came about. Yet here he is anyway, making sure everybody is taken care of, at least financially. I wouldn't be surprised if some fairly major depression is part of his emotional withdrawal.

If you had bothered to read further I explained that I meant people were being harsh to the OP. I neither tacitly nor explicitly condone what her friend has done.