Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandparents 'beat us'to give 'the big gift'

265 replies

Notahappyelf · 20/12/2022 22:20

I'm just heartbroken. Ever since a friend got one in January this year,
all my little boy has asked for for Christmas is a remote controll monster truck. We've ummed and erred but it's the only thing he asked for this year so we got him one from the same series as his friends. It was £70 but having seen his ability to control his friends truck and how well its lasted this year we decoded it was worth it. Its a full on rc truck not a 'toy' one of that makes sense and we've been so excited to fufulill this year long dream for him.

We've just come back from my inlaws having an early Christmas and they gave him books, Christmas pajamas and... a cheap dinosaur themed 'toy' remote controll monster truck!!

I'm heartbroken. I'm not sure I can be cross with them as they aren't the sort to ask what to get him or what we're getting him the way his other grandparents or relatives do. But they've taken that special gift away from us, or am I being ungrateful here? I'm sure they knew that's what he wants, although possibly haven't been told directly that we were getting it. They haven't asked my husband what they should get but I'd hope they'd think we were handling the one thing on his official letter to Santa?

He even commented at bed time that we don't need to get him one now as he has a truck now :(

I just feel he's going to be so disappointed with our gift, and due to its value there's only stocking stuffers from us to go with it. Our son is too young to appreciate that our truck is of much better quality etc. I just feel that, possibly unintentionally, they've stolen a magical Christmas morning from us. I know grandparents like to spoil their grandkids, its lovely, but not to get 'the big gift '?

I want to ask them in future to at least run their gift ideas by us if they're not going to ask what to get him??

Am I over reacting?

OP posts:
Strawblue · 21/12/2022 07:34

Challenge DC to a RC truck race at the local park or on the garden - make it fun to have two RC cars because you can’t have a race with just one.

However, better to say you are disappointed rather than heartbroken - leave the latter word for people who are truly heartbroken through bereavement and so on, and not over a duplicate Christmas present.

teezletangler · 21/12/2022 07:34

I think it's quite strange to not coordinate gifts. My mum and MIL always ask what the DC want and always make sure they're not duplicating gifts. That's what I would do in future. And I don't think you're wrong to be disappointed and sad about this, I would be too.

Glitterpens · 21/12/2022 07:27

It's far more joyless for a child to receive duplicate gifts, or something way too babyish. My dcs grandparents would still buy paw patrol for an 8 year old if we didn't guide them.

DisforDarkChocolate · 21/12/2022 07:26

Yes, he can have two. He'll still love having one that's the same series as his friends.

If this was really important to you then you tell grandparents what your main present will be.

Untitledsquatboulder · 21/12/2022 07:17

ThePoshUns · 21/12/2022 07:03

I get where you are coming from OP, my parents were like this when mine were small.
I found it undermining as it took away some of those special, albeit small moments.
In the end I had to tell them to stop and to just buy what was asked of them, but was a difficult conversation as they were only doing it out of love.

You told them what to buy? How fucking joyless. "No you will not be allowed to use your knowledge of you grandchild, or your imagination, to chose something you know she'll love. You will just.buy.this."

Glitterpens · 21/12/2022 07:16

Goodness me people are so horrible on this and other threads. Also so many stupid replies. Questioning op as to why the child knows who the presents are from, why he opened presents early. Telling op to just give her toy away??

Why are people so mean to parents of young children on here over Christmas. Can people not understand that it IS magical seeing your child open their much wanted gift and the grandparents have bought a cheap version of the child's main present. That must be really disappointing.

Sure, it's not the worst thing going on in the world but for the op this is really disappointing.

ThePoshUns · 21/12/2022 07:03

I get where you are coming from OP, my parents were like this when mine were small.
I found it undermining as it took away some of those special, albeit small moments.
In the end I had to tell them to stop and to just buy what was asked of them, but was a difficult conversation as they were only doing it out of love.

Scoobygang7 · 21/12/2022 06:52

ElspethTascioni · 20/12/2022 22:24

I don’t think it’s unreasonable to feel upset. But I bet on Christmas morning, he’ll be delighted, and will be able to tell yours is better! Plus, cheap remote control vehicles last really badly, so theirs probably won’t work by the end of January and yours will come into its own!

From experience, it'll probably crap out before Christmas day.

emotionallyfragile · 21/12/2022 06:50

I can't really understand as I've never been in that situation.

All I can think of when I read this is how I wish my children had grandparents in their lives. Not to give gifts. Just to be there.

AuntieMaggie · 21/12/2022 06:38

Honestly I get you're upset, and I would be too but I also wish my DC had grandparents who cared enough to do this.

Kids don't put the same value on this sort of stuff and he will still be excited and happy on Christmas day.

raspberrytinsel · 21/12/2022 06:34

it will be fine, he will love both and probably crush the cheaper version playing races! really don't worry about it.

Cosmos123 · 21/12/2022 06:28

You are heartbroken over this???

Gosh you have had a blessed life OP.

tackling · 21/12/2022 06:26

I'm surprised that so many people wouldn't be bothered by this. I don't have children but I think I'd be upset if I'd scrimped and saved for a special present, to have the shine taken off like that.

Having said that, how lovely that he has so many people in his life, that's incredible. He'll have such a special childhood just because of that, and won't remember the gifts many years from now.

Ocrumbs · 21/12/2022 06:14

No more presents at early Christmas. That is ridiculous.

Mrsuntidy · 21/12/2022 06:09

YABU these are a common gift for this age group. We got our son a monster jam one but I think two people had bought him cheaper ones earlier in the year. The monster jam one has outlived the others so don't worry!

Unifolorn · 21/12/2022 05:58

He will still be super excited for your present, as it wasn't an intention undermining or upstaging glad to see you're letting it go. And hey, isn't it wonderful that he has engaged grandparents that know what he likes :) he will enjoy playing with both.

Soontobe60 · 21/12/2022 05:58

Heartshappedsunglasses · 21/12/2022 05:43

I don’t think YABU . My boys have both asked for expensive Lego sets that have been discontinued from Jurassic Park. They have consistently asked for months, part of the appeal is the dinosaur figure. If MIL turned up with cheap replicas of the dinosaur knowing that I’d bought these sets I would be livid. They literally have these as there main present and then stockings from Santa . I can’t wait to see there faces on Sunday when they open them. if they had the knock off dinosaurs a few days earlier then it would absolutely take away the magic.

Get a grip! Children don’t know the cost of toys, nor do they mind if they get more of one type.

HollyDollyChristmas · 21/12/2022 05:56

You lost me at early Christmas, opening gifts on 20 Dec.

Soontobe60 · 21/12/2022 05:56

Those who’ve suggested removing the batteries - what a nasty thing to do! That’s just pathetic that you’d rather upset a child by ‘breaking’ his toy than be happy that he’s delighted with the gift.

OP, my 4 yr old grandson has several monster trucks - he loves them! The most expensive one is the one that he broke first though. Paying so much for a toy is risky imo.
For next year, to avoid duplicates, give his grandparents suggestions as to what gifts he would like. That’s what we do with our grandchildren - that way, no one gets them duplicates.

lipstickwoman · 21/12/2022 05:52

You don't understand what heartbroken really is.

WiddlinDiddlin · 21/12/2022 05:47

There is a very strong chance that when he sees the better RC truck, he is going to like it far more, particularly once he takes it to play and race with his friends. The cheaper one will not compare and he will quickly realise this (Just read this to DP who is a RC truck/boat/plane sort of person).

Stock up on good batteries for both though, having one conk out is no fun, racing two IS fun, and the expensive one will eat batteries too (get more, rechargeables, and a charger!).

If he seems confused at having two, tell him Santa (if you do that) thought that two would be more fun at home when he isn't racing with his friend who has a truck, but obviously two high end RC cars is a bit much for Santa.

Heartshappedsunglasses · 21/12/2022 05:43

I don’t think YABU . My boys have both asked for expensive Lego sets that have been discontinued from Jurassic Park. They have consistently asked for months, part of the appeal is the dinosaur figure. If MIL turned up with cheap replicas of the dinosaur knowing that I’d bought these sets I would be livid. They literally have these as there main present and then stockings from Santa . I can’t wait to see there faces on Sunday when they open them. if they had the knock off dinosaurs a few days earlier then it would absolutely take away the magic.

springerspanielpuppy · 21/12/2022 05:24

8 grandparents, 9 Aunts and Uncles and well over 50 presents for a 5 year old who is writing lists? ffs there's bound to be some overlap much more sensible to open a savings account for him and have everyone put the money to good use.

We all do this collectively for our nieces and nephews they absolutely love seeing the money grow and when they need something expensive like a tablet they dip in to it. Plus they are a whole lot more careful in deciding what they want when spending their 'own' money. Xmas Grin

Outtasteamandluck · 21/12/2022 05:07

Completely

yoyo1234 · 21/12/2022 05:05

DS loves having 2 similar toys . It means he can race/play with his best friend 😁. Less arguments if one of each. I would do Christmas presents from grandparents after the actual day to stop this occurring.