Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandparents 'beat us'to give 'the big gift'

265 replies

Notahappyelf · 20/12/2022 22:20

I'm just heartbroken. Ever since a friend got one in January this year,
all my little boy has asked for for Christmas is a remote controll monster truck. We've ummed and erred but it's the only thing he asked for this year so we got him one from the same series as his friends. It was £70 but having seen his ability to control his friends truck and how well its lasted this year we decoded it was worth it. Its a full on rc truck not a 'toy' one of that makes sense and we've been so excited to fufulill this year long dream for him.

We've just come back from my inlaws having an early Christmas and they gave him books, Christmas pajamas and... a cheap dinosaur themed 'toy' remote controll monster truck!!

I'm heartbroken. I'm not sure I can be cross with them as they aren't the sort to ask what to get him or what we're getting him the way his other grandparents or relatives do. But they've taken that special gift away from us, or am I being ungrateful here? I'm sure they knew that's what he wants, although possibly haven't been told directly that we were getting it. They haven't asked my husband what they should get but I'd hope they'd think we were handling the one thing on his official letter to Santa?

He even commented at bed time that we don't need to get him one now as he has a truck now :(

I just feel he's going to be so disappointed with our gift, and due to its value there's only stocking stuffers from us to go with it. Our son is too young to appreciate that our truck is of much better quality etc. I just feel that, possibly unintentionally, they've stolen a magical Christmas morning from us. I know grandparents like to spoil their grandkids, its lovely, but not to get 'the big gift '?

I want to ask them in future to at least run their gift ideas by us if they're not going to ask what to get him??

Am I over reacting?

OP posts:
00100001 · 22/12/2022 07:24

Letthekidsplay · 21/12/2022 23:39

Because it makes you happy to see somebody sad that they don’t get to see their little ones face light up Christmas morning??? Ok you do you…. Op I totally u set stand why you’re sad because you’re a lovely parent who loves to see their child happy.

🙄

Letthekidsplay · 21/12/2022 23:39

LubaLuca · 20/12/2022 22:26

'...they've stolen a magical Christmas morning from us.'

This is the best thing I've read on here for a long time. Thank you.

Because it makes you happy to see somebody sad that they don’t get to see their little ones face light up Christmas morning??? Ok you do you…. Op I totally u set stand why you’re sad because you’re a lovely parent who loves to see their child happy.

blubberyboo · 21/12/2022 23:29

umm massive overreaction

your son will be delighted with your truck and now he and dad can have monster truck races. The thing about boys is that they love loads of things of the same type so that they can have competitions

not just one nerf gun! 5 nerf guns makes a team shooting event

not just one wrestler… 2 wrestlers can have a fight

not just one RC truck… 2 trucks make a race

Tempyname · 21/12/2022 23:07

Simple, give him yours, keep the one from Grandparents at their house. We have a Gs and have some stuff at our house eg he got 2 scooters, one for each home, saves parents transporting them plus he has his favourite toys whichever house he is at.

Sigma33 · 21/12/2022 19:50

Your parents cared enough about your child to realise what they would like for Xmas, and then were in a position to get it for them.

Give up on competing, and focus on enjoying spending time together. I can't remember many specific Xmas gifts from childhood - I do remember the year it snowed and we went out for a walk together in the snow, the year the electricity went down just as the turkey went in the over, playing board games and laughing until I couldn't breathe, and 101 other wonderful moments.

Obviously I get DD things I think she would like, but if someone else has a brilliant idea and gets something that is amazing for her I am glad that she has people who love her enough to take the time and trouble to chose something amazing. It doesn't undermine me.

thegreenlight · 21/12/2022 18:06

Get a grip. My DS’s grandad, my dad, died today after sitting by his bedside for a week. How on earth do you cope when things are actually heartbreaking? Appreciate that they are still here to be with your children and buy gifts. My dad isn’t.

Itloggedmeoutagain · 21/12/2022 17:46

ZoeCM · 21/12/2022 17:34

Why are so many posters on MN "heartbroken", "devastated" or "grieving" over completely insignificant matters?

Because they don't have the life experience to understand what those words really mean

ZoeCM · 21/12/2022 17:34

Why are so many posters on MN "heartbroken", "devastated" or "grieving" over completely insignificant matters?

Sugarfree23 · 21/12/2022 15:13

It's not about equating love with material gifts.

It's about taking a moment, parents have saved money to make Christmas special for their kids, looking forward to seeing the excitement in their face when they get up on Christmas morning.
But the main present no long seems quite so special and exciting when it's a better / different version of something the child already has.

Lot of Christmas is about the excitement in the lead up, the count down with the advent calender, the Elf on the Shelf the Christmas parties, the Santa visits, pantos, Christmas markets, decorating trees etc huge build up.
And you don't want kids feeling I've already got one a new one of these.

While I'm sure Op will pull it together and say Oh look we can race them etc really kid can only play with one at a time

meetmynewusername · 21/12/2022 14:16

It’s actually startling how many parents here seem to be equating love with material gifts.

As if by giving your child their favourite toy others are stealing from you.

Your child’s joy is what matters, not where or who it comes from.

Parents like this become in-laws-from-hell, because they can’t stand that somebody else is making their child equally or (gasp) more happy than they do! It’s competitive and it’s toxic.

meetmynewusername · 21/12/2022 14:12

Hopelessacademic · 21/12/2022 10:00

This is the solution!

No, it’s f*cking manipulative and cruel.

Namechangedforthis12456 · 21/12/2022 13:10

Cheap rc vehicles last all of two minutes before developing faults so there’s every chance it won’t be working by Christmas anyway.

If you’ve bought your son one of the monster jam ones they are worth the money. My son went through a phase of collecting them and they just will not die. Trust me I’ve tried… rc meglodon I’m looking at you 😒
Stunt Grave Digger is particularly amazing if you’ve bought him that one!

budgiegirl · 21/12/2022 12:55

You're not unreasonable to feel disappointed, as you were so excited to give your little boy his present, and I can understand that this has taken the shine off it. But it sounds like it was unintentional, perhaps in future let grandparents know what you will be getting from his list to stop this happening again.

My MIL has form for this sort of thing, but intentionally! When my DD was about 4, the only thing she wanted for Christmas was some pyjamas for her teddy bear. She very desperately wanted them. So I got teddy bear sized pyjamas, slippers and a dressing gown, and I was very excited to give them to her on Christmas morning. I told my MIL that this is what we were getting her.

A few days before Christmas, my MIL presented my DD with all the exact same things. It was infuriating, but my DD was delighted. They weren't even given as a Christmas present, as we were seeing my ILs on Christmas Day. I was so annoyed, and my MIL pretended she didn't realise, but she did, and, to be honest, it has soured my relationship with her.

Even now, with my now grown up children, she's constantly giving them gifts in the run up to Christmas, it's all very odd, but I've given up caring, and I don't tell her what we are getting them now, so she can't jump the gun!

MRex · 21/12/2022 12:41

Franticbutterfly · 21/12/2022 10:38

I think it is a bit sad actually. My MIL is always giving gifts earlier than Xmas so she can get in first. I've asked to return things a few times and she was very put out, but it was exactly the same thing as I'd already bought and wrapped.

I would say still give your truck as it's likely to last longer.

Why didn't you return your unopened one and get something else? What on earth for your poor child think being given a gift and made to give it back unopened only to unwrap the same thing a few days later? It's such a baffling scenario that I can't believe this one.

Even if it's sentiment rather than something that actually happened, some of you seem like really hard work to be honest. Why is it so hard to say thank you and just appreciate people were nice to your kid?

ThePoshUns · 21/12/2022 12:31

Hear hear!

WinterDeWinter · 21/12/2022 12:13

Op, just want to say that your responses have been brilliant and you sound like a really decent and self aware person. Ignore the arseholes on here.

AzerJoon · 21/12/2022 12:04

Yabu you should have got him the cheap version back in January or his birthday...

Notahappyelf · 21/12/2022 11:02

I think this will be my last reply, thank you all for your opinions, I needed them.

As for all the thoughts on how we manage Christmas presents, I can't imagine him opening all this gifts Christmas day. He's awake for 13 hours ish a day and honestly receives so kuchen with such a large double blended family he'd have about 10 mins per gift with so little time to appreciate any. We spread it out to make it manageable and let gift givers see him open/enjoy his toys. This is what works for us, usually, just backfired a little this time.

I very much over reacted and feel better about it today, as in my previous update I'm just going to be thankful he is surrounded by so much love.

OP posts:
ShirleyPhallus · 21/12/2022 10:56

Really enjoying all the competitive “wooden toys are better than plastic toys” on this thread when in reality most kids much prefer the cheap plastic tat 🤣

Franticbutterfly · 21/12/2022 10:38

I think it is a bit sad actually. My MIL is always giving gifts earlier than Xmas so she can get in first. I've asked to return things a few times and she was very put out, but it was exactly the same thing as I'd already bought and wrapped.

I would say still give your truck as it's likely to last longer.

lightisnotwhite · 21/12/2022 10:36

caringcarer · 21/12/2022 10:09

Many years ago when my 2 dnephews were 4 and 6 they wanted a Castle Greyskull. They love in Jersey and my sister said there were none left on the island so she begged me to come to her for Xmas and bring the Castle for her son's to be given to them by Santa. I queued for hours but got a castle which was in the most enormous box ever. I wrapped it using the extra long wrapping paper and took it over on a ferry. I was very sea sick on the way so arrived feeling shit. Got to their house and dsister came out and took castle into garage so boys did not see it. Xmas Eve BiL' sister arrived from Australia and gave boys Castle Greyskull. My sister and BiL had no idea. We managed to solve problem though as my sister rang a close friend who's son also wanted one and she swapped the castle I had brought for toys her friends son was going to have. Xmas morning my nephew's were playing with their castle and friends came over so excited he had a castle too. My sister's friend was so grateful to me for lugging it across on ferry.

Great story! Fabulous that both kids got one.
What a great auntie. Have you told your DNephew the story?

MsRosley · 21/12/2022 10:20

YABU. Take your one back for a refund and get him something else. He'll be bored of the truck in ten minutes anyway.

caringcarer · 21/12/2022 10:09

Many years ago when my 2 dnephews were 4 and 6 they wanted a Castle Greyskull. They love in Jersey and my sister said there were none left on the island so she begged me to come to her for Xmas and bring the Castle for her son's to be given to them by Santa. I queued for hours but got a castle which was in the most enormous box ever. I wrapped it using the extra long wrapping paper and took it over on a ferry. I was very sea sick on the way so arrived feeling shit. Got to their house and dsister came out and took castle into garage so boys did not see it. Xmas Eve BiL' sister arrived from Australia and gave boys Castle Greyskull. My sister and BiL had no idea. We managed to solve problem though as my sister rang a close friend who's son also wanted one and she swapped the castle I had brought for toys her friends son was going to have. Xmas morning my nephew's were playing with their castle and friends came over so excited he had a castle too. My sister's friend was so grateful to me for lugging it across on ferry.

Jellycats4life · 21/12/2022 10:07

It’s OK to be annoyed/upset. It really is. Lesson learned: you need to communicate better when it comes to who is buying what at Christmas. Easier said than done sometimes, I know.

The PP who said that grandparent gift giving has changed over the years is spot on. When my children were little we’d turn up at my parents’ house to find a bigger spread of gifts than we gave 😳 And it all comes from a place of love obviously, but in reality, it was a bunch of toys they had no interest in and was a massive waste of money.

My in laws don’t really “do” Christmas in a particularly enthusiastic way (different culture) so thankfully I didn’t have to deal with any competitive gift-giving from that side of the family.

lollipoprainbow · 21/12/2022 10:01

pinkstripeycat · 20/12/2022 22:56

I told my MIL that my own DM was getting my DS a castle for Xmas (as she asked). DM bought a beautiful, big wooden castle with soldiers and horses.
MIL got DS a tiny, cheap, flimsy castle and gave it first encouraging DS to open it before Xmas despite us seeing MIL at Xmas time knowing he had one coming from DM.
DM was gutted as MIL took away the surprise from DS as when he opened DM castle he said “I already have one of these”
Got rid of MIL castle as soon as DS forgot about it. We still have DM castle but he’s a teen now.
MIL spoilt it for DM and DS

How sneering of you