Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stop 9 year old eating all the time

184 replies

Pineapplestropical · 20/12/2022 20:26

9 year old dd is overweight. She eats far too much and exercises too little. Started putting on weight in year 2 now in year 5 and kids have started to call her fat at school. Bloods been done all normal. No medical issue to explain why she should be eating too much. Constantly grazing and looking for meals. Yesterday example;

9am 2 scrambled eggs and 1 toast
1130 am Small bowl of rice
Orange
4pm Another small bowl of rice
6pm A small bowl of pasta bake
French francie
7pm; 2 thin slices of rolypoly cake.
9pm; a grilled cheese sandwich.

I know i shouldn't have the junk available. I do have 3 other kids all healthy. Find it a bit unfair that none of us can have treats Coz of her but maybe that's a sacrifice we have to make. She hates exercise, will do less than 2 minutes then sit down.

We did a timetable yesterday to say we need to stick to these times for eating (3 times with 2 snacks) she agreed and was happy with healthy ideas. Fast forward to today and she's gone downstairs by herself to make a grilled cheese sandwich again. She's definitely not hungry as had a good dinner of chicken soup and garlic bread. Im Losing it with her and have said you are getting overweight , you need to get healthier, im worried about ur health. Feel bad about this but i just can't stop her eating or get significant exercise out of her. She helps herself to food if i say no and im with the other kids. AIBU for pointing out she is overweight?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Glasgowgal200 · 22/09/2023 18:38

How about getting or watching some dance DVDs and doing them with her - should be more fun than actual exercise, walking etc.

schnausages · 13/04/2023 21:42

Are you trying to ensure your kid ends up with an eating disorder?

OMG12 · 22/12/2022 07:52

Have you got to the bottom of why she wants more food? All too easy to give advice eat less/differently and run round more.

what is often missing is the psychological angle. Is she eating to try and fill a void caused by self esteem issues, does she think she’s hungry because her stomach is churning with anxiety. Is she bored? Does she not feel she’s getting enough attention and realise that food gets your attention, even asking seconds gets some interaction. Is it her way of rebelling? Is she trying to dull pain from bullying? Is she well connected to her body? You mention she doesn’t like exercise, is this because she doesn’t feel comfortable in her own body and exercise causes her what she perceived as unbearable feelings in her body? You need to address the bullying at school this will certainly not help.

overeating/weight gain etc is very complicated the mind/body connection and often disconnection is often overlooked. It’s why diets aren’t sustainable, exercise plans short lived - they don’t address the underlying cause. Look at being overweight/obese as an illness you need to get to the root cause not just look at the symptoms because once you stop treating the symptoms they will just come back if the underlying cause still there. Does she spend a lot of time by herself, prefer escapist activities like reading, imaginative play? What is her relationship with her friends? If the rest of the family are fit and active, how well does she fit into the family? Is she a happy child?

Maybe sit down with her without any of the other kids around once a week at a set time and start to explore some of these things. Simply cutting out food and enforcing exercise might simply add to the issue. It might be removing a coping mechanism. In the meantime find some healthy snacks the family can enjoy, eg small packs of raisins, chopped carrots in a box in the fridge.

WiddlinDiddlin · 22/12/2022 04:57

Haven't seen any carb police, just people pointing out it will spike BG levels and the crashes do make you feel hungry which in adults is hard to then exercise willpower and not eat... in a child who has the freedom to make cheese toasties etc, they will over eat.

I even said, carbs and sugars should form part of a kids diet... just, not like this.

Poinsettas · 21/12/2022 23:25

Chocolate23 · 21/12/2022 11:58

I wondered when the carb police would come out in force.

Carbs don't make you fat. Overeating makes you fat.

Carbs alone don’t make you fat but carbs (white especially) spike insulin production which makes you feel hungrier faster, than eating protein/good fats. No one said ‘no carbs’, they said too many and too few proteins/veg.

Notyetacatlady · 21/12/2022 13:26

I really feel for you op as you have been flamed on here and it can’t be nice. Some kids are hard work when it comes to food despite what parents do. My dd has mild arfrid. She is a healthy weight but is a nightmare to feed and has been underweight at times. It takes real effort and creativity by me and dh to get her to eat a balanced diet. She has interception difficulties too so has no off switch. If left to her own devices she would just eat junk till she was sick. We do have to regulate her but we do it in a way that does not make it obvious or an issue.
Despite this and I mean this from a supportive place she has a better diet than your dd, that is down to us putting work in. You will find creative ways to include protine and veg in to her diet without making it an issue online. I’d also ask for help from your gp at this stage. Don’t feel bad about this, you are clearly a good parent or you wouldn’t care.

Like I mentioned, despite my dds difficulties she is very thin which makes me wonder if your dd is sneaking food or if she is unconsciously grazing without you realising. Grabbing a handful of sweets as she passes the kitchen for example. I’d keep a close eye to see if this is the case.

One of the things I’m eternally grateful to my mum for is her teaching us how to cook and eat healthily without causing issues. She never had much junk in, it wasn’t restricted it was just never on our radar. We had it at parties or occasions or if we went to the shop now and then but it was never thought about in between. We grew up snacking on carrot sticks for example and never knew or questioned any difference. Meals were well balanced and at set times. My mum worked long hours so if we wanted a healthy meal cooked for us we ate with her at the table. I have been slim all my life only gaining weight with pregnancy. My mum has been slim all her life. These are things I try I still in my dc. It’s not hard and you can start today.

exercise is important but you can’t outrun a bad diet.

Theoldwoman · 21/12/2022 13:22

Please don’t ever tell your child they are overweight.

This could lead to a life long eating disorder.

zingally · 21/12/2022 13:19

Where's her meals?

She's not having proper structured meals, and eating at really weird times. No wonder she's looking to graze all evening.

bellac11 · 21/12/2022 13:10

Chocolate23 · 21/12/2022 11:58

I wondered when the carb police would come out in force.

Carbs don't make you fat. Overeating makes you fat.

Certain foods can make you ravenous which leads to overeating, not sure why that needs spelling out its common knowledge. Bread is the worst of them but rice and pasta is pretty bad for me, potatoes arent too bad

OopsAnotherOne · 21/12/2022 12:09

As others have said - what she's eating isn't healthy. Too many carbs (which will spike and then lower her blood sugar, causing her to be hungry again), very little protein and no fruit/veg.

What she needs is healthier, balanced meals, where you can pile on the veg because it will fill her tummy up, provide her with nutrients and vitamins but also won't cause her to gain weight.

Things such as nuts and bananas release energy slowly, preventing hunger between meals.

No one "needs" junk food so you can remove these from the house completely for the time being.

Increased activity is necessary, not only for contributing to a healthy weight but also for healthy joints, development and promoting good habits. If a child has been used to doing regular activity, they will be more likely to continue this into their adult life. I'm forever going for walks with my DP because I was always out on walks with my parents as a child. They weren't optional when I was very young, but as I grew into a teen and had much more freedom, I still chose to go on walks with my parents as I had learnt to really enjoy and appreciate the outdoors, the fresh air and the exercise.

At this age, telling your child she's overweight could contribute to issues with her weight/mental health as she grows older, which could last into adulthood with negative consequences. You need her to have a healthy relationship with food and to understand how to create a balanced diet. However while she is this young, it's solely down to you to ensure she's getting this mix of protein, veg, fruit etc and full meals. She cannot be responsible for her weight or her eating habits at this age, she is too young and needs you as the adult to ensure she gets the food she needs to be healthy.

While you're improving your daughter's diet, it's important to implement and encourage healthy lifestyle behaviours which she will then continue to follow as she gets older.

Chocolate23 · 21/12/2022 11:58

I wondered when the carb police would come out in force.

Carbs don't make you fat. Overeating makes you fat.

RatherBeRiding · 21/12/2022 11:48

More protein, more veg, more fruit, less carbs and stick to mealtimes. Absolutely stick to them. And why is a 9 year old taking herself off to make her own food? I think she needs firm boundaries around helping herself and only eating what everyone else is eating and yes she won't like it but as her parent it is up to you what she eats I'm afraid.

As for the exercise - start small. It isn't going to be easy for an overweight child to go from doing nothing to doing a lot. Does she walk to school? Does she have a bike? Keep exercise sessions short to begin with and try to then lengthen them and find something she might actually enjoy, or at least not actually hate.

emmathedilemma · 21/12/2022 11:41

Seriously, that’s more carbs in one day than I’d “load” to run a marathon!! Poor child needs lean protein and fruit and veg. It’s a wonder she isn’t bouncing off the walls.

Virginiaplain · 21/12/2022 11:18

I can’t believe the lack of comment about exercise - do you leave your DCs to lounge about or not if they want.
Two minutes exercise before stopping is unbelievable. She would I’m sure enjoy something -dance, football, running, cycling but not if she gets tired after 2minutes. Perhaps get her heart checked as that is not good.

Madamecastafiore · 21/12/2022 10:25

Her diet is so incredibly carb heavy. Give her more protein based meals and then maybe fruit or veggie sticks and hummus if she's still hungry. Carbs fill you up quickly but then you crash into hunger just as quickly, concentrate on higher protein meals and whole grain complex carbs which will fill her up more and take longer to digest. At 9 she's too young herself to understand and do much about her diet, it all needs to come from you.

Murdoch1949 · 21/12/2022 10:23

Weird, unbalanced menu of food. If you really are concerned about this child then you need to put your money where your mouth is. 3 balanced plates a day with vegetables and fruit playing a major role. No junk food, cakes etc except maybe once a week. Eat together as a family, with all eating the same, at the same time, no snacking between meals except fruit or vegetables.

livingthegoodlife · 21/12/2022 10:20

I think you've had a lot of advice already. Clearly she needs proper balanced meals not just snacks. Do you prepare her meals or does she just help herself all the time?

Here is what my 9 year old ate yesterday. Definitely not perfect but my child is ideal weight:

Breakfast: Porridge with jam & glass milk & soft boiled egg
Lunch: scrambled egg. Piece of fruit. Small choc bar/penguin type thing.
Dinner: steak pie, mash, peas. Yoghurt.
Evening snack: mini cheddars & grapes & mini packet haribo.

MamaFirst · 21/12/2022 10:03

Why is a 9 year old child getting up and preparing food for themself at 9pm at night? This would just be a flat out no to me.

Schnooze · 21/12/2022 09:37

Our dc had to ask for everything except fruit too.

Virginiaplain · 21/12/2022 09:32

Imv no sport or exercise is enjoyable unless you are fit.
Start with fast walking for 10 mins, 15 mins, 20 mins build it up to an hour. I imagine you'll have to do it with her - or another family member.

JoyBeorge · 21/12/2022 09:27

Pineapplestropical · 20/12/2022 23:29

Thanks for all your replies even the nasty ones. Im glad people have told me it's my fault so i can actually take responsibility for changing this rather than put the emphasis on her to control herself with her eating. It's just very hard when the others are full on the meals I give them (usually more balanced than the ones mentioned) and she's not. Will definitely take on board suggestions here. And for the record, i apologised to her before bed and reassured her that we are all going to get healthy together.

I think the key thing is your children are all different individuals metabolically and they all process different foods differently. Just because the others can eat the same things without weight gain isn't the point. Exercise is a tough one but find what motivates her if she's bored after less than two minutes of exercise then it's not motivating her. Exercise with her walk, get dvds you can both have fun working out with. Certainly just carbs won't be helping so with that knowledge you can now look into foods that will keep her full longer. There's no reason you can't all have treats but look at the types of treats. High sugar treats with a high carb low protein diet is not going to be keeping her feeling full.

There's lots of useful tips on the thread if you scan through, just take the helpful advice and build on that. My biggest tip, and the largest eye opener where we can sometimes go wrong with diet is to start reading food labels. Once you realise how much unsaturated fat there is in some of your favourite foods you start to think differently about what you are eating and how much is not useful nutrition. The biggest thing you you can do to help motivate her to want to exercise and eat well is not just do it with her but more comments about weight. It's emotionally damaging enough that her friends comment on it without coming home to it. Take the lead and show her how to eat well.

At 9 years old we weren't just helping ourselves to rubbish if we were told no and my family had terrible diets growing up. She her what she can have rather than just letting her stuff herself with fat and sugar at night time when she isn't going to burn it off, so think about the times she eats junk as well. Get yourself some cookery books from a charity shop and learn to cook wholesome meals she will enjoy and want to eat, you can also make wholesome deserts that are filling cheaply too. You'll probably find most of this is easily resolved if you apply yourself to the problem and make yourself an active part of the solution.

I think your focus has been on the symptom rather than the cause. Yes you're a busy mum, but this is about small changes. Theres a lot you can self learn about the basics of nutrition. Soup would usually be a starter to a meal but on its own with carbs, fat and sugar either side is not going to be a good meal keeping anyone full, and remember just because your others would be full on that is not a guide to use because they will all process it differently.

Paq · 21/12/2022 07:57

Well, it's a snapshot of one day and OP has clarified that the bowl of rice was actually chicken, chickpeas and rice. So I won't jump to the same conclusions as others about her overall diet.

However, agree with others. More protein, less carbs, more activity and water. Weight loss will be gradual as she's still growing and emphasis should be on fun, health and fitness.

If she's raiding the kitchen at random times is she actually just bored?

Whiskers4 · 21/12/2022 07:47

Forgot to say, if she likes rice, could it be egg fried rice maybe with a few peas mixed in, so it's more nutritious.

Whiskers4 · 21/12/2022 07:45

At that age DD was offered three main meals and a couple of snacks, all offered/prepared by us. Only thing that she could help herself to was fruit

BabyOnBoard90 · 21/12/2022 07:39

YABU - not for wanting her to eat less, but for making unhealthy foods so accessible in the first place.