Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD16 yrs finally diagnosed ADHD . A.I.B.U to complain to her school for not referring earlier, or should i be grateful that they did?

109 replies

Quirkyones · 20/12/2022 19:53

It was not for the want of trying to get dd diagnosed; i had a feeling since early primary but was met with brick wall , or told, 'everyone's looking for a label'. DD passed 5 G.C.S.Es at C level, so did well but I am really sad to think that maybe with added support or understanding, then she may have done better and her self esteem might not have been as low as it has been.

I am thinking of complaining , with the intention of making girls with A.d.h.d noticed earlier. I would also now like other screening done to see if she has mild autism /dyslexia as she has traits of both. Or would this become a set back for DD in sixth form?

OP posts:
cortisolqueen · 21/12/2022 14:39

In our area it's fairly common to not have private assessments accepted. It's really frustrating.

Shinyandnew1 · 21/12/2022 14:24

Quirkyones · 21/12/2022 14:18

There is so much useful advice though from lots of posters. Thank you all so much , it will be so useful and Merry Christmas.

What exactly would you complain about me for?

Nevermindthesquirrels · 21/12/2022 14:23

@Ursuladevine I'm still trying to figure that out really. We waited a year to be triaged by them and the poor admin person who did our interview couldn't put me in touch with the psychiatrist. When I asked for a second opinion he said they don't have the resources for that.
When I questioned why it's not been accepted he said the psychiatrist isn't satisfied with the evidence. I asked which evidence exactly and he said he can't divulge and gave me the details of where to complain. He did also mention that they do not normally accept private diagnosis as the psychiatrist finds them not thorough enough, which I respect, but in this instance I don't think the psychiatrist even looked at the evidence. It makes me livid that we've spent well over £2k on these reports and tried really really hard to have a holistic and thorough view of it, and CAMHS has just turned around and made us look like we're trying to drug DD for a trend.

spanieleyes · 21/12/2022 14:20

Schools cannot and do not diagnose. They can only provide evidence ( whether to the GP or the community paediatrics team or CAHMS- depending on the diagnosis route in different counties) on what they see in school. Many children, especially girls, do mask completely in school and so the " evidence " needed just isn't there. I have sent off many a referral with " Parents say that......" because I don't have anything else I can say! But when it comes to diagnostic questionnaires, we can't provide a narrative, just what is seen in schools. If experienced clinicians struggle to identify characteristics in a child, how easy do you think it is for a school?

Ursuladevine · 21/12/2022 14:19

Nevermindthesquirrels · 21/12/2022 14:17

@Ursuladevine We have a report from a consultant pediatric psychiatrist, who worked alongside an EP who conducted full psychometric testing. They also worked with a SALT to commission a full CELF -5 report to rule out speech difficulties being the cause. We also had hearing and up to date sight tests. The same EP also conducted an EP report 4 years prior and mentioned further need for ADHD testing. This was not pulled out if a hat at 13.
We were really, really thorough. It does make me quite uncomfortable how easily some kids are being given medication and that's just not something I was willing to do. We were offered a 30min appointment at Harley Street. That alongside the questionnaires is apparently enough. I just don't buy that.
Our private psychiatrist is retiring so we requested a medicine review with CAMHS so they could take over. It was like speaking to a wall.

On what grounds if you’d private assessment disregarded?

Quirkyones · 21/12/2022 14:18

There is so much useful advice though from lots of posters. Thank you all so much , it will be so useful and Merry Christmas.

OP posts:
Nevermindthesquirrels · 21/12/2022 14:17

@Ursuladevine We have a report from a consultant pediatric psychiatrist, who worked alongside an EP who conducted full psychometric testing. They also worked with a SALT to commission a full CELF -5 report to rule out speech difficulties being the cause. We also had hearing and up to date sight tests. The same EP also conducted an EP report 4 years prior and mentioned further need for ADHD testing. This was not pulled out if a hat at 13.
We were really, really thorough. It does make me quite uncomfortable how easily some kids are being given medication and that's just not something I was willing to do. We were offered a 30min appointment at Harley Street. That alongside the questionnaires is apparently enough. I just don't buy that.
Our private psychiatrist is retiring so we requested a medicine review with CAMHS so they could take over. It was like speaking to a wall.

megletthesecond · 21/12/2022 14:05

I don't blame you but I don't think it'll make any difference. I've spent a decade trying to get support from my DD. Now she has finally been referred for an ASD assessment as secondary school and our early help worker think she fits the bill.
I have no polite words for the fucking pediatrician who sent me packing a decade ago and told me to parent her better.

Ursuladevine · 21/12/2022 13:59

Nevermindthesquirrels · 21/12/2022 13:45

I'm conflicted to be honest. With ADHD the behaviour needs to manifest in both at home and school settings, so it's not really just the school to blame. My DD is diagnosed with ADD which is now called ADHD inattentive type. When the school was asked for a questionnaire, a lot of teachers thought we were mad. Very few are aware of the symptoms in girls and even the questionnaires are centred around symptoms classically exhibited by boys.
Schools get blamed for a lot but you've been failed by the very boy centred world of psychiatry, not your school.
CAMHS is also a joke. They still won't accept our private diagnosis, instead sticking DD on a waiting list that's 3 years long and wasting a space for a child that doesn't already have a (very thorough) diagnosis.
The whole system is broken OP, your school is not at fault here.

What type of professional did you get your private diagnosis with?

my son’s was with a consultant paediatric consultant costing and eye watering £2k, but accepted by all bodies without question

Cuppasoupmonster · 21/12/2022 13:49

I’m going to stick my head above the parapet and say when you look at the astronomical increase in kids being diagnosed with ASD or ADHD, it isn’t surprising resources haven’t yet caught up with the huge demand. I’m in my early 30s and it was a rare diagnosis when I was at school - some 12 years later and it just seems so, so many parents are pushing for diagnosis. It doesn’t surprise me it’s not a smooth and well oiled path.

Nevermindthesquirrels · 21/12/2022 13:45

I'm conflicted to be honest. With ADHD the behaviour needs to manifest in both at home and school settings, so it's not really just the school to blame. My DD is diagnosed with ADD which is now called ADHD inattentive type. When the school was asked for a questionnaire, a lot of teachers thought we were mad. Very few are aware of the symptoms in girls and even the questionnaires are centred around symptoms classically exhibited by boys.
Schools get blamed for a lot but you've been failed by the very boy centred world of psychiatry, not your school.
CAMHS is also a joke. They still won't accept our private diagnosis, instead sticking DD on a waiting list that's 3 years long and wasting a space for a child that doesn't already have a (very thorough) diagnosis.
The whole system is broken OP, your school is not at fault here.

Ursuladevine · 21/12/2022 13:34

A leading clinician said the daughter did not have adhd despite a wealth of tests

if they couldn’t, why blame the school?

Ursuladevine · 21/12/2022 13:33

*Read the thread and take in what other posters have said. If i knew the school you were at a big fat complaint would be going your way!*oh listen to yourself op 😂!

Shinyandnew1 · 21/12/2022 13:33

Yes I started a thread previously, well done for spotting that Sherlock

I didn’t. That was someone else.

Shinyandnew1 · 21/12/2022 13:33

Quirkyones · 21/12/2022 13:29

@Shinyandnew1 -you're exactly the reason I am talking about. Maybe you can read this thread and learn?

Yes I started a thread previously, well done for spotting that Sherlock. So she had been discharged, wrongly. Test redone and results overwhemingly ADHD. Is that actually alright with you or you have some weird conspiracy thing going on?It always helps to be open minded in this world i find. B.t.w she was always on the SEND register- just no strategies in place. Let's pray that she does not get your kind of support. We all know that worker that's been there for years.....zzz

Read the thread and take in what other posters have said. If i knew the school you were at a big fat complaint would be going your way!

Why was that directed at me? I was pointing out the referral process in my LEA. I will always support parents in seeking support but school cannot make the referrals themselves.

Quirkyones · 21/12/2022 13:29

@Shinyandnew1 -you're exactly the reason I am talking about. Maybe you can read this thread and learn?

Yes I started a thread previously, well done for spotting that Sherlock. So she had been discharged, wrongly. Test redone and results overwhemingly ADHD. Is that actually alright with you or you have some weird conspiracy thing going on?It always helps to be open minded in this world i find. B.t.w she was always on the SEND register- just no strategies in place. Let's pray that she does not get your kind of support. We all know that worker that's been there for years.....zzz

Read the thread and take in what other posters have said. If i knew the school you were at a big fat complaint would be going your way!

OP posts:
FatEaredFuck · 21/12/2022 13:25

GP does fuck all for ADHD/ASD in children.

I hope someone can tag all the snarky commentators.

Cuppasoupmonster · 21/12/2022 13:24

YABU.

People want schools to be all things to all people now. They can’t be.

Itisbetter · 21/12/2022 13:20

How many times did you attend GP surgery asking for assessment?
How many times did you seek support from school if that’s what the GP needed?
What other avenues did you look into?
How did you eventually get referee for assessment and how long did that process take?

bellac11 · 21/12/2022 13:15

Oher · 21/12/2022 13:05

If a parent asks the GP for a referral for ADHD, or even pays for one privately, then the assessor will say that they cannot diagnose ADHD without the opportunity to observe the child in their school setting, and will ask permission to visit the school. If (like my school) the head doesn’t want a diagnosis because they can’t afford to fund more SEN support, then the school will refuse to allow the assesor in and just say there is no problem so no need for assessment.

It’s basically impossible to get a ADHD diagnosis unless the school help.

OP you don’t need our permission to complain, go for it. But the head will ignore it unless the you escalate to governors and even then, they’ll just back up the head 😔

SEN suppot isnt based on diagnoses, its based on the need the child displays

In addition I have never known an assessor either for ADHD or aSD observe children in school

A huge proportion of the children I work wtih are not even in school, either waiting for a school place or having been excluded or parents withdrawn them and yet private and CAHMS assessors still manage to diagnose

Shinyandnew1 · 21/12/2022 13:11

If a parent asks the GP for a referral for ADHD, or even pays for one privately, then the assessor will say that they cannot diagnose ADHD without the opportunity to observe the child in their school setting, and will ask permission to visit the school. If (like my school) the head doesn’t want a diagnosis because they can’t afford to fund more SEN support, then the school will refuse to allow the assesor in and just say there is no problem so no need for assessment.

I have been a senco for a long time, I have never had anyone from paediatrics come into school to assess a child for ADHD.

Children also don’t need a diagnosis in order to be added to the SEND register.

Ursuladevine · 21/12/2022 13:10

Shinyandnew1 · 21/12/2022 13:03

Completely agree with this!

I suspect the OP, if she returns, won’t!

Oher · 21/12/2022 13:05

Soontobe60 · 20/12/2022 19:58

Can I ask what was stopping you asking your GP for a referral for assessment?

If a parent asks the GP for a referral for ADHD, or even pays for one privately, then the assessor will say that they cannot diagnose ADHD without the opportunity to observe the child in their school setting, and will ask permission to visit the school. If (like my school) the head doesn’t want a diagnosis because they can’t afford to fund more SEN support, then the school will refuse to allow the assesor in and just say there is no problem so no need for assessment.

It’s basically impossible to get a ADHD diagnosis unless the school help.

OP you don’t need our permission to complain, go for it. But the head will ignore it unless the you escalate to governors and even then, they’ll just back up the head 😔

Nimbostratus100 · 21/12/2022 13:03

bellac11 · 21/12/2022 11:29

The route in through the GP and you need to press this. Some children are home schooled or dont go to school so there may not be a school process.

Schools are not part of the health system, camhs and the diagnosis services are part of the health system.

I agree - I am an educator, not a health care professional. I have listed up to 60 separate diagnosis among children on my register at a time, some years.

How am I supposed to know about all these medical conditions? I dont. Not my area of expertise. Not only do I not remember the diagnostic criteria or the support guidelines for the vast majority of medical conditions I come across at school, but even if I did, it would be of little to no value, as no two children are the same, even with the same diagnosis, and very few are "text book" typical

I need to know the students I teach, what works or does not work for them as individuals. Yes, I will likely reread the basic guidlines for each condition when I get my new registers, but that is really just the starting point, and in any case, with the number of conditions I am dealing with each year well up into the dozens, I wont remember that much anyway.

I might remember something like - 11D is the class where a student wants a bright white back ground to power point slides, instead of the usual pale blue, or 9F has 6 children diagnosed with autism, or children J,K and L must never be allowed out of the room without an adult, etc. But not necessarily the diagnosis for each one - Maybe one had diabetes, one has attempted suicide, and one has specific bail conditions.....

You need to know how to teach and care for each child - you dont keep diagnosis or medical information in your head, particularly

Shinyandnew1 · 21/12/2022 13:03

Ursuladevine · 21/12/2022 12:52

To quote you Op

We have been through a very timely parent course, voice of the child test, parent history, and a leading clinician and nurse have decided that she is not a.d.h.d. inattentive and is discharged.

so I don’t think the school can accept any blame

Completely agree with this!