Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD16 yrs finally diagnosed ADHD . A.I.B.U to complain to her school for not referring earlier, or should i be grateful that they did?

109 replies

Quirkyones · 20/12/2022 19:53

It was not for the want of trying to get dd diagnosed; i had a feeling since early primary but was met with brick wall , or told, 'everyone's looking for a label'. DD passed 5 G.C.S.Es at C level, so did well but I am really sad to think that maybe with added support or understanding, then she may have done better and her self esteem might not have been as low as it has been.

I am thinking of complaining , with the intention of making girls with A.d.h.d noticed earlier. I would also now like other screening done to see if she has mild autism /dyslexia as she has traits of both. Or would this become a set back for DD in sixth form?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Itisbetter · 22/12/2022 11:48

You’ve always been able to seek an ehcp assessment (or previously statement of Sen). If a parent does it you can appeal if refused, school I believe have to wait and ask again. You will find info on how to start the process at your LA. Phone or go on line to check the process.

Shinyandnew1 · 22/12/2022 09:36

Ursuladevine · 21/12/2022 14:56

Pretty sure the “big fat complaint” was directed at me.

i was quivering with fear when I read that

Ah! Interesting that @Quirkyones told me to ‘read the thread’ before saying she’d like to complain about me to my school, having not read the thread properly herself.

Aroloruns · 21/12/2022 17:21

Up until last year the process was always go to the GP- GP refers- school gets assessment paperwork and then this gets sent back to CAMHS (for some reason some GPs would refuse even though the process was clear as day on the NHS website). Therefore I don't think it is fair to blame schools. ADHD is present from birth and runs in families so I strongly believe parents should be looking to identify this not schools. More recently, CAMHS have cut out the need for a GP referral and a parent or the school can refer directly. I think there is no excuse for primary schools not to pick this up as one teacher spends every day over the academic year with their pupils. They might not diagnose but they could give you a list of concerns to take to the gp.It's more difficult in secondary where they have so many teachers. Girls also mask significantly. I also think up until recently, there has been so little information on ADHD in girls and in general, there is NO teacher training on it, so it becomes luck of the draw really as to whether teachers have experience in it. I hope this will improve over time. It's fantastic you have a diagnosis now, some kids are still waiting 3 or 4 years on. I hope your daughter thrives on the right treatment. All the best.

Nevermindthesquirrels · 21/12/2022 17:04

@Ursuladevine and just to add, it doesn't matter if the LA doesn't think the report is worth the paper written on, because if you're using it for the EHCP process, there's a very clear legal route to challenge them. You just appeal their decision. You can do so at every point.
There's not a single way to appeal the CAMHS decision, not even a second opinion.
Same thing when they reject a referral form a GP. No way of appealing it. It's a joke.

Nevermindthesquirrels · 21/12/2022 16:55

@Ursuladevine No this isn't the reports we had done for her plan. DD already has her EHCP which she had private reports for 5 years ago. I don't want to give too much detail as this is quite outing.
We sent the following to CAMHS:
Reports form 5 years ago that were used for EHCP
EHCP which includes ADD as a diagnosis on it, the LA had no problem including this once we had the private diagnosis.
Camhs appt came recently, about a year after her private diagnosis so we sent all the above plus
the reports I already described.

LA's are a bit different I feel to this whole CAMHS thing because they have a lot in the game when it comes to reports. A well written, very specified report is going to cost a lot of money to fund once that's used to write up an EHCP. An LA report thats not specific and in my experience often wooly, isn't going to feed a well specified report. You can't put something that's not on the report, into an EHCP so if the report isn't specific and detailed, you'll have a hard time making your plan specific and detailed.
I can understand why CAMHS doesn't accept some private assessments, as I said, it worries me how rushed some of these are. I feel in our area maybe they see so much of this, they've just decided to not even bother reading all the evidence we provided as it's a blank no for private assessments. They didn't even know my DD had an EHCP even though I supplied it as part of evidence.

Ursuladevine · 21/12/2022 16:30

Nevermindthesquirrels · 21/12/2022 16:22

@Ursuladevine Best part of £8k probably for it all but the latest one we did last year was £5k and some change, and included the EP and SALT reassessing DD, as well as the psychiatrist assessing her and doing an in lesson observation. We are in London though and use a clinic, so I'm assuming most places will be cheaper although for all of that it wasn't bad. It's a lot more now.
I'm sure you could find someone individually who would be cheaper but we wanted a multi disciplinary team to look at the situation. Saying that, we found the prices just out of London more expensive as there isn't as much competition.

And after all that… not worth the paper it was written on in the eyes of LA?

Nevermindthesquirrels · 21/12/2022 16:22

@Ursuladevine Best part of £8k probably for it all but the latest one we did last year was £5k and some change, and included the EP and SALT reassessing DD, as well as the psychiatrist assessing her and doing an in lesson observation. We are in London though and use a clinic, so I'm assuming most places will be cheaper although for all of that it wasn't bad. It's a lot more now.
I'm sure you could find someone individually who would be cheaper but we wanted a multi disciplinary team to look at the situation. Saying that, we found the prices just out of London more expensive as there isn't as much competition.

Nevermindthesquirrels · 21/12/2022 16:17

@Nimbostratus100 A child is not allowed to be assessed on the same thing within a 6 month period. It's unethical. When we got private reports, they were very specific and the LA didn't like that. They wanted their own reports but the LA EP couldn't test DD on the same things the private on had as it was less than 6 months prior.
These parents must've not been divulging it but than that comment wouldn't have made sense.

Ursuladevine · 21/12/2022 16:16

Nevermindthesquirrels · 21/12/2022 16:09

@Ursuladevine Our psychiatrist is also an NHS one. The vast vast majority of consultants who are doing private work, work for the NHS too.

Out of interest how much did you pay?

Nevermindthesquirrels · 21/12/2022 16:14

@Oblomov22 I'm not sure that's entirely correct. When things first became a worry with DD, we approached out GP with issues first. He was very understanding and did all the referring he could. Camhs actually rejected it and said it needs to come from school. Same with the speech and lang services. Once school referred, speech and Lang said they don't see kids above 7, you need an EHCP. LA said not enough evidence for EHCP. So we got private reports and tribunals aplenty.
It's really mind boggling and often a mystery what processes are used where, even within one borough people often have very different experiences.

Nevermindthesquirrels · 21/12/2022 16:09

@Ursuladevine Our psychiatrist is also an NHS one. The vast vast majority of consultants who are doing private work, work for the NHS too.

LakieLady · 21/12/2022 16:06

Ursuladevine · 21/12/2022 15:42

Between 11 and 16, if he hasn’t been attending school, what has he been doing? Has the LA been providing any education or have you been HE?

He's not my son, but the son of a friend.

The LA were doing precious little, apart from insisting that friend had to get him to school, resulting in massive meltdowns every time she tried. He now attends a teaching centre, he's supposed to go twice a week, but more often than not he goes once or not at all. Friend was a teacher, so has been doing some HE.

It's so sad, he's a lovely young man and very bright. The system has really failed him.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 21/12/2022 15:47

Blendandmix · 20/12/2022 20:40

You could have taken the initiative and taken her to the GP but you didn't. That's on you not the school

My DS has been referred for assessment for ASD by the school. It was only by combining what we were seeing at home with what the school were seeing that the referral was made. I don't think we'd have got anywhere with the GP at that point.

They also got the camhs referral made by the GP re-triaged after it was initially refused and got the ND Pathway referral sped up so we don't have to wait over two years - this is because of how things have escalated, but the help and support of the school has been invaluable and I think we'd have struggled to get this far through the GP, as just seeing a GP is a struggle while we've had regular meetings with the school, been in pretty much daily contact with them.

Oblomov22 · 21/12/2022 15:46

It was your GP who let you down by not referring, the reasoning of school needing to raise an issue, is utter nonsense.

Nimbostratus100 · 21/12/2022 15:44

cortisolqueen · 21/12/2022 14:39

In our area it's fairly common to not have private assessments accepted. It's really frustrating.

I sympathise, and I am sure it must be incredibly frustrating. I'm sure many private assessments are high quality, and reliable.

Just to put the other side though, in school, we can get deluged by private assessments, and have no way of evaluating their quality. The most extreme example was a year 8 girl I once had to buy a new filing cabinet for, becasue she had so many private assessments. The parents just kept on and on buying them until they got one that said what they wanted it to say. The one line that stands out to me in the literally thousands of pages I had on this girl was " is suffering from an excess of time spent in assessments"

Hankunamatata · 21/12/2022 15:44

The gp and the school will bat back and forth as each wants the other to deal with it. Ultimately its a medical issue and should be handle by GP/nhs route.

Ursuladevine · 21/12/2022 15:43

Rather your friend

Ursuladevine · 21/12/2022 15:42

LakieLady · 21/12/2022 15:34

My friend tried that, and the GP dismissed it offhand, saying that if her son was neurodivergent, the school would have picked up on it and referred him for assessment. Her DS was eight at the time.

Within the next 2-3 years, he got much worse, was referred to CAMHS, diagnosed with significant MH problems (PTSD, GAD, depression, social anxiety disorder) and after a couple of years, CAMHS decided his mother might not be talking bollocks and that he might have ASD.

He's been waiting for his ASD assessment for nearly 3 years now. He's now 16, and she's starting to think that he'll have to start again with the adult MH service. He hasn't been to school since he was 11.

Between 11 and 16, if he hasn’t been attending school, what has he been doing? Has the LA been providing any education or have you been HE?

Andsoforth · 21/12/2022 15:39

If you have the bandwidth then I think there is great value in going in and discussing this because it is a HUGE problem and especially so for girls.

But complaining won’t achieve anything - you might think it would at least make you feel good but it won’t.

I feel like I spend my life advocating for ds with teachers, doctors etc because when he masks he is just amazing. Looking back, the fact that nearly all his parent teacher meetings began with gushing of “he’s absolutely wonderful” was a sign that something was astray but he was my eldest and I thought that was standard settling into the meeting talk.

I was lucky to get the diagnosis ball rolling before school was a factor because it was just not obvious at all in primary that there was an issue.

And I’ve just been incredibly lucky that the SEN coordinator in secondary is open to listening and and thinking about things a little bit differently.

But it is miles easier to breakthrough these barriers for boys. Everything we can do as parents to educate and raise awareness of how ND presents is genuinely vital work.

Ursuladevine · 21/12/2022 15:36

Maybe makes a difference that the private assessment my son had from a consultant paediatric psychiatrist is also and NHS one and performs NHS assessments too

LakieLady · 21/12/2022 15:34

RitaSueandBobtwo · 20/12/2022 20:00

This, you could also have picked it up too and gone down the GP route.

If it is a large Secondary School she is likely to have stayed under the radar.

My friend tried that, and the GP dismissed it offhand, saying that if her son was neurodivergent, the school would have picked up on it and referred him for assessment. Her DS was eight at the time.

Within the next 2-3 years, he got much worse, was referred to CAMHS, diagnosed with significant MH problems (PTSD, GAD, depression, social anxiety disorder) and after a couple of years, CAMHS decided his mother might not be talking bollocks and that he might have ASD.

He's been waiting for his ASD assessment for nearly 3 years now. He's now 16, and she's starting to think that he'll have to start again with the adult MH service. He hasn't been to school since he was 11.

Nevermindthesquirrels · 21/12/2022 15:19

@alloalloallo Accepted for what though? The only time the private assessments weren't accepted for us were for CAMHS. They were accepted at tribunal when we fought for an EHCP and were accepted by multiple other agencies that support DD. The tribunal actually used a foreign report as the main evidence, this report wasn't even accepted by the school.
The LA said that private reports wouldn't be accepted by them but thats BS. At tribunal it doesn't matter as long as it's a medical professional. The LA reports have never been as thorough or specific as the private ones so I understand why they don't like the private ones. If not for the private reports that specify exactly how much support DD needs on a level and hour basis, she would have nothing in place.

Ursuladevine · 21/12/2022 14:56

Shinyandnew1 · 21/12/2022 14:24

What exactly would you complain about me for?

Pretty sure the “big fat complaint” was directed at me.

i was quivering with fear when I read that

alloalloallo · 21/12/2022 14:46

cortisolqueen · 21/12/2022 14:39

In our area it's fairly common to not have private assessments accepted. It's really frustrating.

Yes, same here.

Back when we first started investigating DD’s issues, we looked at a private assessment and were going to use the same EP that the LA uses, but in a private capacity.

We were told point blank, it wouldn’t be accepted.

Nevermindthesquirrels · 21/12/2022 14:46

@cortisolqueen We may live near each other lol. I can understand all sides to it to be honest. It makes me extremely uncomfortable that a child is being medicated after a 30 min zoom assessment. Saying that, I don't know how much more thorough the CAMHS assessments are. I just know that we turned every stone before my DD took her first meds and we are extremely lucky we could do that. We are not well off, DD is in a state school and we had to use savings to pay for all our reports and the clinic allowed us to pay some off in instalments. I accept that CAMHS is over stretched but my DD would probably have attempted suicide now if we hadn't got her help when we did.
I just don't see the point in her being on that waiting list. She will likely be 18 by the time it's her turn and there will be another child who will need it much more desperately. It is very frustrating to also not have a valid reason as to why we are being turned away.