Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think they could have found something else to put in DD’s report?

33 replies

FrustratedandFestive · 20/12/2022 17:51

Feeling a bit sad. I probably am being unreasonable, but it’s been a hard few months.

DD is dyslexic. She struggles with spelling and writing but is however good at music - she’s a chorister at our local cathedral, plays a couple of instruments, etc.

We’ve just received her school report. I knew it might make for quite tricky reading this year as she is finding things quite hard at the moment. I’m a bit sad, though, that her music teacher has spent almost the whole music report talking about her spelling of various musical instruments and her handwriting, and has marked her down as a result.

AIBU to think that they could have found something else to talk about in relation to music, given that this is an area which she does love and where we are trying to build her confidence? It has left me feeling as through even the things she can do well are always going to be assessed through the filter of this disability. Why does her spelling matter when she’s playing the flute really well..?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Notanotheruser111 · 21/12/2022 21:12

on the other end of the spectrum I’m not in the uk and the teachers here can’t write anything that isn’t positive. It effectively makes the report useless as the comments don’t really match the measurement scale they use and your left with no real idea of what you should be helping your child with.

FrustratedandFestive · 21/12/2022 21:00

Cansu, I don’t think anyone is arguing otherwise - as I say, DH has never let it hold him back and actually, he’s been far more successful in his career than I have in mine. But surely it’s possible to talk about the things a student does well, to encourage them and give them confidence, as well as go on about the thing which realistically they will always find challenging, even with hard work?

DD works so, so hard to overcome these difficulties. She’s probably worked harder today, in the Christmas holidays, on spelling apps and typing programmes and music practice for her exams than many kids do in a school day. I can’t help but feel sad that even with all this hard work, she is still criticised for something she simply cannot control. Honestly, I just can’t ask her to work any harder.

OP posts:
cansu · 21/12/2022 10:58

I think the difficulty in many cases is that the area of difficulty does need to be acknowledged as it can be a barrier to improving or gaining a qualification at a certain level. In french the gcse exam does require students to write accurately. A student who struggles with dyslexia will need to work on their spelling to get a good grade. Finding something very challenging doesn't mean not working on it or not seeking to use strategies to improve. It may be that using a laptop can help but in many cases the spelling and grammar checks have to be turned off to comply with exam requirements. This is the case in the ks2 sats for writing for example.

Kanaloa · 21/12/2022 10:50

So maybe it’s just an overall push to improve written work for the class in preparation for getting exam ready. Maybe you could speak about what adjustments are being made so your daughter doesn’t fall short in the written aspect of her work. For example, typing up work on the computer where possible. Maybe stamps of the musical notes/an app where she can note her music and print it out for homework. That way she can show her working clearly so she isn’t losing marks she deserves to get for simple lack of clarity.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 20/12/2022 22:38

I would be disappointed too - it is so important to acknowledge the things they are doing well at, especially when they are struggling in other areas.

Luredbyapomegranate · 20/12/2022 22:36

The teacher doesn’t get it.

Book a review with their boss. It isn’t good enough.

AdventuringAway · 20/12/2022 22:19

Even more important to bring it up if he’s taking the shortcut of saying the same thing to everyone!

Its very different scenario, but I had one subject I excelled in as a teenager. But I was really rubbish at getting my homework in on time. The teacher for that subject only ever commented - in reports and parent evenings - about me being late. Never noted my achievements. Totally killed my love for it.

FrustratedandFestive · 20/12/2022 22:09

Withonelook, I completely agree. DH has it also and he sailed through Cambridge and doesn’t even think about it in adult life.

And I feel it’s my job to make sure that her life turns out to be the same as it would have been without dyslexia - that she still has all the same opportunities open to her as she would have had. It will be harder, and that’s where she is now, but it’s definitely not an insurmountable obstacle.

I have also just heard that the teacher said the same about her best friend, so possibly the whole class can’t spell and he’s perhaps just cut and pasted the same report for all of them. In which case I feel
a bit silly.

OP posts:
WithOneLook · 20/12/2022 21:49

Hi I'm a music teacher who is also dyslexic and I think the most important thing is to reassure your daughter that being dyslexic doesn't mean that she can't achieve academically. I have a PhD. I am fairly flippant with my students in regards to dyslexia though because so very many students believe they 'can't' do something (usually read) because they are dyslexic, which a few posters have also alluded too but that's not true. Dyslexia makes things more difficult and you have to develop different strategies to get by but they very much CAN do things with the right support.

I think I'd be ask for clarification on what was meant by 'copying' as that might be for example notes on a stave rather than words which absolutely would down grade a student. I do always try to be positive in my students reports but actually playing the flute often has little to do with a mainstream curriculum which might well be more theory based (but don't write theory off for your daughter because of the dyslexia.....a love for the flute can absolutely drive theoretical prowess although it often comes a bit later!)

FrustratedandFestive · 20/12/2022 20:28

Thanks to everyone who’s replied. I’m glad to know it’s not that I’m being oversensitive. It is an independent school - a large one, so possibly he has forgotten that she’s dyslexic, even though he was asked to contribute comments for the dyslexia assessment earlier this term.

Her target for next term is to write her work more neatly. As the dyslexia report (a copy of which school has, of course) also mentioned that she might have possible dysgraphia, it seems unlikely that this is going to miraculously happen by January. She is pretty much spending the holiday learning to type. This just feels pretty tough for her.

OP posts:
L1ttledrummergirl · 20/12/2022 18:50

One of ds1s reports in primary school interchanged he/she all the way through. The comments were bland and generic and very much a copy and paste job.

Ds2 has dyslexia. His French teacher once told us at a GCSE choice information evening that he struggled with French spellings. My reply " no shit Sherlock he has dyslexia and struggles to spell in English meaning it's not exactly a surprise that he can't spell in French either" was a bit of a shock to her as she had no idea. Her relief on being told he wouldn't be taking French was rather apparent.Grin

I wouldn't worry about that sort of crap in school reports. If you are happy with where they are day to day, with no meetings with teachers outside of the usual parents evenings then the report is just to give you an idea of what's happening. I would check that all of your dc teachers are aware of the dyslexia though.

Galarunner · 20/12/2022 18:33

It's very rare to actually get comments in reports these days, due to teacher workload. Mine just a grade for a progress against a fairly meaningless target and a score for attitude to learning.

Aquasulis · 20/12/2022 18:27

DariaMorgendorffer · 20/12/2022 17:56

YADNBU

I'd be getting in touch with teacher after Xmas to 'remind' them of your daughter's dyslexia diagnosis.

This.

My son was told at primary that the reason he got working below in RE was that he didn’t put his hands together to pray in assembly 😂🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️

My daughter with her foot in a cast for 6 months after surgery for a medical foot issue had a PE report that said ‘she struggles to maintain her balance when running’ I did take both of those to the head.

Nat6999 · 20/12/2022 18:19

Ds has hypotonia & even after school had been notified that he would never progress with handwriting & must use a laptop in school, all that was ever on his reports was that his writing was bad even though he had come top in at least 5 subjects.

Kanaloa · 20/12/2022 18:18

MilkyYay · 20/12/2022 18:09

@kanaloa Generally when I write reports much of the focus is on improvements and next steps - I usually would write only a very short sentence on what the child does now, moving into what are areas for improvement and gaps in learning, because they’re really the important things.

When do you share your positive comments then, do you do that somewhere else? If children's achievements are never acknowledged and celebrated they will think its not worth bothering. Parents want to hear what their child does well, not just where they need to improve. How sad.

Well as I said ‘much of the focus’ is on improvement. I do also of course mention the positives and strengths in the child’s work. Which is why I said I would reserve fury/kicking off etc since op hasn’t actually shared what the report said fully.

pinneddownbytabbies · 20/12/2022 18:15

It wouldn't surprise me at all if it turns out that the music teacher has not been advised of her dyslexia, or at least is not up to speed on how dyslexic students should be supported.

To continually go on about spelling mistakes when someone is unable to do anything about it is akin to mentioning that a student with hearing difficulties doesn't always listen to instructions properly.

Mosaic123 · 20/12/2022 18:15

No retakes!

Mosaic123 · 20/12/2022 18:14

I had this when dyslexic DC was younger. Mostly each teacher was highly critical of the areas he struggled in.

Never mind that he was amazing at maths and physics.

As he got older and could give subjects up things got far better and his many abilities were appreciated.

Good spelling and handwriting are nice to have but not so important now there are superior spelling checkers built into computers.

He got 1sts in his degree and masters and passed tricky professional exams with no resets.

Defend your child to the teachers and try to boost the child''s confidence.

Pumperthepumper · 20/12/2022 18:12

That’s unfair, I’d speak to the school.

MilkyYay · 20/12/2022 18:09

@kanaloa Generally when I write reports much of the focus is on improvements and next steps - I usually would write only a very short sentence on what the child does now, moving into what are areas for improvement and gaps in learning, because they’re really the important things.

When do you share your positive comments then, do you do that somewhere else? If children's achievements are never acknowledged and celebrated they will think its not worth bothering. Parents want to hear what their child does well, not just where they need to improve. How sad.

tsmainsqueeze · 20/12/2022 18:09

I would be feeling sad too , but i think this is more a reflection on the teacher , who must be lacking in enthusiasm and imagination if this is their focus, when music is their subject.
I think i would be reminding them of my child's difficulties too but none of this will matter in the future when your child is free to pursue their interests free from the one size fits all restraints of school.

Farcis · 20/12/2022 18:06

My DC is dyslexic so I know exactly where you're coming from. A couple of years ago a school report said they needed to work to avoid "silly" spelling mistakes. I wasn't pleased. I spoke to the teacher and pointed out that in any situation I thought the use of "silly" in a report wasn't wise, but in this instant, I thought it was completely inappropriate. They changed the report to include actual examples of where the kid could improve. I don't think you'll be in any way wrong to ask for that. Also, what adjustments does your daughter have in place? One of my children pretty much only types now - makes their life much much easier and has hugely improved their work.

MilkyYay · 20/12/2022 18:06

I'd be fuming about that OP.

They should be celebrating it as an area of strength for her!

MajorCarolDanvers · 20/12/2022 18:04

DariaMorgendorffer · 20/12/2022 17:56

YADNBU

I'd be getting in touch with teacher after Xmas to 'remind' them of your daughter's dyslexia diagnosis.

Absolutely this.

YellowTreeHouse · 20/12/2022 18:03

The teacher should have mentioned some positives or course, but the written aspect is very important too so it cannot be ignored.