Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Another dog kills. When is something going to be done?

261 replies

ofwarren · 20/12/2022 15:15

AIBU to think that there needs to be a dog licence or at least SOMETHING put in place to try and prevent deaths by these dogs?
I was not at all surprised to read the breed..
"The dog, a large black XL bully cross cane corso breed, was seized by officers and has been destroyed."

metro.co.uk/2022/12/20/woman-dies-after-being-mauled-in-dog-attack-in-her-own-home-17970433/?ito=socialmetrouktwitter

OP posts:
thingumybob · 20/12/2022 18:08

YourApplePie · 20/12/2022 16:04

This isn't new - when I was a kid, people were worried about rottweilers and alsatians.

There has been a massive increase in dog attacks though:

www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2022/dec/12/lockdown-bad-breeds-or-just-poor-training-why-are-dog-bites-on-the-rise-in-britain

MatildaTheCat · 20/12/2022 18:08

Just out of curiosity I just googled this breed and was instantly informed what a gorgeous family pet this dog makes. Perfectly safe, ‘nanny dog’ and so, so much more total bollocks.

Im sure not many people rub their heads and think, ‘so shall we go cocker spaniel or XL Bully cross?’ but nonetheless there should be a ban on presenting this misinformation and not only on American sites either.

Poor woman, looks as if she took a couple of weeks to die. What a horrible end to her life.

TheMarzipanDildo · 20/12/2022 18:05

Dotjones · 20/12/2022 16:59

Dogs shouldn't be allowed in public, owners should only be able to exercise them on their own private property. If the dog needs to be transferred from one property to another it could be secured in a car or van for the journey.

There'd be exceptions obviously for things like police dogs and possibly guide dogs, but zero tolerance for dogs kept as pets.

I'd like to see dog laws to be somewhere between knife laws and gun laws. Like a knife, a dog should only be allowed in a public place where there is a legitimate reason to be in possession of one. Just as "feeling safer" is not a legal defence for carrying a knife, "taking it for a walk" shouldn't be a legal defence for having a dog in a public place.

The comparison to gun laws comes in with the idea that, like when someone wants to own a gun, first they should have to undergo tests to ensure that they are a suitable person to own a dog and that they have the facilities to ensure it is kept safely on private property away from the public.

even chihuahuas? Or shih tzus?

IrishMamaMia · 20/12/2022 18:02

I'd love to see more done especially more draconian laws. Let's face it, responsible dog owners take these measures anyway. Had a frightening encounter with an off lea, out of control dog during lockdown. There was a terrifying dog attack in Ireland recently where a 9 year old playing football in a public green space almost had his face ripped off by an out of control dog. We are all vulnerable to these attacks. More so kids.

Iam4eels · 20/12/2022 18:00

Sugarplumfairy65 · 20/12/2022 17:28

And people complain about how difficult it is to get a dog from a rescue centre.
It's a pity that anyone wanting to get a dog from anywhere doesnt have to be thoroughly vetted first.

My dog is a rescue.

Before being approved we had to do a walkthrough tour of our house and garden on a video call so they could see that we had sufficient space.

We had two meet-and-greet sessions at the rescue centre, one for just me and DH to meet the dog and see if we felt they were a good match. Once that was determined we took the DC and they had an hour long meet-and-greet session with the dog, observed by a member of staff to make sure the dog was coping, followed by a walk.

A few days later we brought the dog home for a month long foster placement. They called us every few days to check how it was going and it was made clear we could return the dog at any time for any reason if it wasn't working out. There was a 24hr contact number too for any emergencies, including vet care.

At the end of it we could proceed to adoption. It all felt quite robust and worlds away from a Gumtree ad and "free to good home".

janeeyreair · 20/12/2022 17:58

I knew before I opened the link it would be a Cane Corso or a Cane Corso crossed with similar. I love dogs but if I see one of these breeds I cross the road, if I see one of these breeds when im with my dog or with a child Im even more careful.

pd339 · 20/12/2022 17:55

I'd support dog licenses, but on animal welfare grounds rather than anything else.

Tragic as these deaths are they are far far fewer in number than (say) by car accidents, abusive parents etc. Laws that are introduced reactively and emotionally to protect against miniscule risks often have unforeseen consequences.

LlynTegid · 20/12/2022 17:50

To answer the question, I doubt if anything will be, at least in the near future. The Dangerous Dogs Act was a classic example of 'something must be done' but in reality very little was done.

I am with the person who suggested minimum space to keep a dog or at least certain breeds. Or charge the dog's keeper with manslaughter, as we should anyone who crashes a car and kills someone whilst under the influence of drink or drugs.

YellowTreeHouse · 20/12/2022 17:50

YANBU but nothing will be done. Dog owners are entitled and selfish and always have an excuse.

“He was just worked up.”
“He was just playing.”
”He’s so friendly!”

These people are the reason we have so many dog attacks and deaths. They are responsible for each and every one.

There was a thread on here recently where a child was bitten by a dog and the OP and all the people defending used those excuses.

If a dog bites it needs to be put down straight away. Because not doing so leads to things like this.

We should also be putting down and banning all XL bullies and other dangerous dogs. We all know the ones.

stbrandonsboat · 20/12/2022 17:46

Anything apart from a small poodle cross should be banned. Nobody needs a large, aggressive dog. With an increase in low IQ, lazy people around now, a small dog is all they're able to manage. The dog is probably more intelligent than they are.

Obviously working dogs would be exempt.

BMW6 · 20/12/2022 17:45

I wonder if all Bull breeds should be muzzled in public, and any caught not muzzled seized from the owner and removed or PTS.

BeanieTeen · 20/12/2022 17:44

And people complain about how difficult it is to get a dog from a rescue centre.
It's a pity that anyone wanting to get a dog from anywhere doesnt have to be thoroughly vetted first.

I think this is the main problem.
I think dog breeding and selling needs to be much more strictly controlled and monitored. Not every Tom, Dick and Harry should be able to sell dogs, but unfortunately at the moment that’s the case. They don’t care who they sell to. Idiots who buy bully breeds are able to do so because of irresponsible breeders and sellers. Unsafe but also often the breeding animals and puppies don’t come from homes where they are treated well. You should have a licence to sell dogs. You should need to comply with proper checks and inspections to make sure you are breeding and selling responsibly. And if three years down the line the dog you sold kills someone I think it’s fair that you should be investigated - it could be that all is above board, but if it turns out you can’t prove that you made a sensible assessment of the owner then you should be prosecuted. I think that is something that can be reasonably monitored, whereas licenses for dog owners is much more tricky to police.

Ijuststoodonlego · 20/12/2022 17:35

EmmaDilemma5 · 20/12/2022 15:34

I have no idea what the answer is, but this is why I get so annoyed with the amount of people who walk their dogs off leads. I know most breeds are much lower risk than the bull breeds but, to me, any animal is a risk for small children especially and should be on leads unless in private land with warnings that dogs are off lead.

There are so many useless dog owners out there. And yes, some who purposely have dangerous dogs - those people should have hefty prison sentencing whether the dog has attacked or not.

I refuse to take my children to the local park (I travel to a different one, where children out number dogs). The local park has more organised activity days for dogs than families.

There are too many dogs off leads. My toddler ran up to a dog and I chased my son, the owner started shouting at my child. She said you shouldn't run up to dogs (fair point but....)I said your dog isn't on the lead you have no right to shout at my child. My child doesn't require a lead. Your dog does.

It's put me off. Another dog ran up to my child (was on a lead thank god) and growled and barked and it was only time I've ever visibly shook. Owner said chill out she loves kids. The growling was awful, I thought, you what? Loves kids?

I love dogs but you never know.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 20/12/2022 17:28

And people complain about how difficult it is to get a dog from a rescue centre.
It's a pity that anyone wanting to get a dog from anywhere doesnt have to be thoroughly vetted first.

MontyK · 20/12/2022 17:25

LolaButt · 20/12/2022 15:53

What is it about these types of dogs who seem to turn on their own owners/families? Is it the genetic disposition of the dog, lack of socialisation or both?

I'm not saying a lot of these owners aren't clueless idiots. However, I believe that most of these breeds are predisposed to this type of behaviour. It's instinct to them.

Newwardrobe · 20/12/2022 17:20

Most of these attacks occur in the owners home , so how will this help?

YourApplePie · 20/12/2022 17:17

Saucery · 20/12/2022 17:03

<snort>

Today’s prize for most ridiculous post goes to you ⭐️

Men kill more people than dogs every year. Do you have a wildly unrealistic and reactionary solution for that, too Hmm

You may only own a man or a dog if you have sufficient space to exercise them at home :D

Saucery · 20/12/2022 17:03

Dotjones · 20/12/2022 16:59

Dogs shouldn't be allowed in public, owners should only be able to exercise them on their own private property. If the dog needs to be transferred from one property to another it could be secured in a car or van for the journey.

There'd be exceptions obviously for things like police dogs and possibly guide dogs, but zero tolerance for dogs kept as pets.

I'd like to see dog laws to be somewhere between knife laws and gun laws. Like a knife, a dog should only be allowed in a public place where there is a legitimate reason to be in possession of one. Just as "feeling safer" is not a legal defence for carrying a knife, "taking it for a walk" shouldn't be a legal defence for having a dog in a public place.

The comparison to gun laws comes in with the idea that, like when someone wants to own a gun, first they should have to undergo tests to ensure that they are a suitable person to own a dog and that they have the facilities to ensure it is kept safely on private property away from the public.

<snort>

Today’s prize for most ridiculous post goes to you ⭐️

Men kill more people than dogs every year. Do you have a wildly unrealistic and reactionary solution for that, too Hmm

Talapia · 20/12/2022 17:03

Problem is, the people who own these 'status' type dogs are highly unlikely to comply with any law and the breeding and ownership of these dogs would be pushed even further underground...

Dotjones · 20/12/2022 16:59

Dogs shouldn't be allowed in public, owners should only be able to exercise them on their own private property. If the dog needs to be transferred from one property to another it could be secured in a car or van for the journey.

There'd be exceptions obviously for things like police dogs and possibly guide dogs, but zero tolerance for dogs kept as pets.

I'd like to see dog laws to be somewhere between knife laws and gun laws. Like a knife, a dog should only be allowed in a public place where there is a legitimate reason to be in possession of one. Just as "feeling safer" is not a legal defence for carrying a knife, "taking it for a walk" shouldn't be a legal defence for having a dog in a public place.

The comparison to gun laws comes in with the idea that, like when someone wants to own a gun, first they should have to undergo tests to ensure that they are a suitable person to own a dog and that they have the facilities to ensure it is kept safely on private property away from the public.

tulips27 · 20/12/2022 16:59

Ban pitbulls, Staffies, XL Bullies and any dogs closely related to or resembling them as a minimum.

tabulahrasa · 20/12/2022 16:58

LolaButt · 20/12/2022 15:53

What is it about these types of dogs who seem to turn on their own owners/families? Is it the genetic disposition of the dog, lack of socialisation or both?

They don’t particularly tbh, fatal attacks tend to be extended family members ie not particularly familiar to the dog, visitors or dogs that have only been owned for a short period of time.

There have been studies and the three highest correlations for fatal attacks were - the dog had been abused/neglected at some point, the “owner” wasn’t present (I’m putting inverted commas because there have been a few where the legal owner was present but they’d only owned the dog for a week or 2) and bring unneutered. The breed was way down the list, because it rises in some breeds as they get more popular and decreases in others and you get the odd outlier like babies killed by small dogs.

Knockagain · 20/12/2022 16:48

ElephantInTheKitchen · 20/12/2022 16:33

Please don't assume that the person who is holding the lead is the one responsible for the behaviour problems.

There are lots of ways a dog can become reactive without it being that person's fault

  • in some cases they have a bad experience as a youngster and develop a lifelong fear (e.g. being attacked by abother dog), which leads them to bark to keep the scary things away.
  • sometimes there's crap breeding - for example breeding a couple of nervous dogs together. In utero experiences (e.g. a stressed mum) and the experiences during the first 8 weeks of life with a breeder are also really important.
  • sometimes people do everything right and just get a dog that's not quite wired right. I'm sure we can all think of a family with good parents, entirely normal siblings and then one sibling who has major mental health issues for no obvious reason.
  • some people have rescue dogs that came with issues pre-installed

In many cases the person holding the lead is trying to do all they can to help the dog and its issues.

I definitely judge crap training methods - anyone yanking a lead, bleating "no" at their dog, prong collars, choke chains, shock collars and so on, but having rescued a dog with behaviour issues I do try and give the benefit of the doubt over dogs with behaviour issues.

And that’s fair enough but what’s the answer then? Is it fair to take them out in public when theyre that reactive and aggressive? why should other people have to tolerate that? I certainly don’t feel safe or trust dogs that behave like that.

Iheartmysmart · 20/12/2022 16:46

Sadly it’s not possible to legislate against people being stupid and incapable of looking after a houseplant yet alone an animal that has the ability to kill and maim.

LynneBenfield · 20/12/2022 16:42

XL Bully x Cane Corso.

That’s one hell of a strong dog, add that to epigenetic factors and you have a recipe for disaster, as we see reported over and over. The owners will never learn because the thrill of owning these dogs comes from their aggression, the fear they instil in others and the (misplaced) idea that the ‘hard men’ owners are mastering these untameable beasts for their own ends. Of course the truth is usually that these dogs have no training at all, not even basic puppy manners.