Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Another dog kills. When is something going to be done?

261 replies

ofwarren · 20/12/2022 15:15

AIBU to think that there needs to be a dog licence or at least SOMETHING put in place to try and prevent deaths by these dogs?
I was not at all surprised to read the breed..
"The dog, a large black XL bully cross cane corso breed, was seized by officers and has been destroyed."

metro.co.uk/2022/12/20/woman-dies-after-being-mauled-in-dog-attack-in-her-own-home-17970433/?ito=socialmetrouktwitter

OP posts:
ThisGirlNever · 21/12/2022 07:19

TantrumsAndBalloons · 21/12/2022 07:13

The bully breed is a super powerful dog but the majority have an amazing temperament
some are kept by owners that want people to be scared of them and that is the biggest issues but I actually hate the knee jerk reaction that the whole breed should be destroyed
we had 2 rescue Staffies over the last 15 years and now have a year old rescue xl who has a significantly better temperament than any of my staffies - he is well trained, 100% under control in public, is never walked off lead in the park etc as I am aware that people are very apprehensive of the breed but exercised both mentally and physically every single day so please don’t assume that everyone with this breed of dog is neglectful and just has the dog as a status symbol

I'm sure this guy felt exactly the same about his rescue dogs.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-tayside-central-59781502

Please be responsible and muzzle these potentially highly dangerous dogs in public.

Plingston · 21/12/2022 07:16

A couple in my street have recently acquired what seems to be a huge bully puppy. I'm very nervous about it. The woman has it on a lead and has no control whatsoever. It's dragging her everywhere and she is completely overpowered by it. Whenever it pulls her, she slaps and shouts at it.

This couple are drug addicts (or were - I don't see dealers so much these days) who had all their children removed, and have since had a couple more babies who were removed at birth. They are never, ever going to be suitable owners for a dog like that and I am quite worried about the dog getting loose or even managing to attack while on lead since they can't physically control it even as a puppy. They don't work so I have no idea how they can financially provide everything a dog of that size would need. It only seems to go for a short walk up and down the street. I'm hoping they'll lose interest or it will become too much hard work and they'll get rid of it. It's a disaster waiting to happen.

TantrumsAndBalloons · 21/12/2022 07:13

The bully breed is a super powerful dog but the majority have an amazing temperament
some are kept by owners that want people to be scared of them and that is the biggest issues but I actually hate the knee jerk reaction that the whole breed should be destroyed
we had 2 rescue Staffies over the last 15 years and now have a year old rescue xl who has a significantly better temperament than any of my staffies - he is well trained, 100% under control in public, is never walked off lead in the park etc as I am aware that people are very apprehensive of the breed but exercised both mentally and physically every single day so please don’t assume that everyone with this breed of dog is neglectful and just has the dog as a status symbol

SirSniffsAlot · 21/12/2022 07:12

ClarathecrosseyedLioness · 21/12/2022 03:48

@SirSniffsAlot @ElephantInTheKitchen

OK, so as you have rubbished Victoria Stillwell and Cesar Millan's dog training methods, and seem to know about dog pyschology, I'd be interested to hear your solution to the problem in UK of some 'dangerous' dogs. 🙂

I haven't rubbished anyone.

However, I could maybe guess that coments on pack theory might be seen as that if (though it was nnot stated directly, I don't think).

Cesar Milan is basically Jennifer Lopez's chaffeur with his own show. I will rubbish him all day long, given the chance Smile.

Victoria Stilwell's journey went a but like

  • liked dogs
  • got her own show about them
  • got slammed for her techniques
  • listened to the complaints
  • studied the science of dog behaviour
  • changed her approach and techniques to be more science based

So any pack stuff from her must come from the early days because these days she does not teach pack theory. See: positively.com/dog-training/myths-truths/pack-theory-debunked/

As for the solution, no one knows. Otherwise I suspect we'd have solved it. Because it's primarily a people problem so all the degrees on dog behaviour are not going to help me much here. However, I have already commented earlier to say:

  • the biggest predictor of aggression is abuse and neglect (not breed)
  • people who own dogs need better knowledge of dog behavioir because when they say the attack came with no warnings, this is never true
  • indiscriminate breeding is resulting in large, mentally unstable animals

I could bang on forever about insta-pets, unrealistic attitudes to pet ownership and more. But suspect I've typed enough and bored people enough already Smile

luckylavender · 21/12/2022 07:09

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 20/12/2022 19:16

@Greenginghamdress
👏🏼well said.

lots of people are apparently suspicious of someone who doesn’t like dogs. Personally I’m suspicious of someone who prefers a creature that is obedient, compliant and doesn’t answer back over that of a human.

I've found my people!

luckylavender · 21/12/2022 07:07

emptythelitterbox · 20/12/2022 18:56

An 83 year old pensioner!
I wonder who the dog belonged to?
Said her son was injured and several in their 20s were arrested.
Her grandkids?

Story said it happened in Caterpilly just a mile from where the little boy was killed.
Is Caterpilly a trashy area?

Caerphilly is not a trashy area, whatever that means. As I understand it her grandson lived with her and operated a dog walking service. The dog was one of his charges.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 21/12/2022 06:46

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 21/12/2022 06:45

What?

Ahh not mine! Pubic!

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 21/12/2022 06:45

Redebs · 21/12/2022 04:09

Laughing at the typo

What?

WiddlinDiddlin · 21/12/2022 05:33

We need dog training and behaviour professionals regulated.

It is no surprise to dog professionals that the rise in dog attacks ties in with the rise in short, highly attractive social media video trainers who use aversive methods, talk bollocks about pack leader, hierarchy, and use shock and prong collars, AND the huge rise in bully breeds being the in trend among young owners and owners in poorer areas/with lower education/money/who feel more vulnerable within society.

Some organisations are working hard to get this to happen, right now anyone can call themselves a trainer or behaviourist, and then advise someone to do highly dangerous things with their dog that actually maximise the chances of the dog hurting or killing someone - and they can do this on Tiktok and insta, where they've no idea who is watching or how they're interpreting what is said.

We still have very little control on who breeds dogs, what conditions are required for breeding, breeding licences are about commercial breeding not about increasing standards for small time breeders (who are the people who SHOULD be breeding dogs, those who take their time, know the breed, produce a litter every year or less) and it is regulated and actioned by local authorities who are notoriously corrupt and, have no relevant dog husbandry knowledge whatsoever.

We don't educated people, as a country, on how to source dogs ethically, the general public couldn't tell a puppy farm from an imported cropped, docked protection bred weaponised dog, from an illegally smuggled parvo and rabies ridden puppy half the age it's meant to be, from a well bred puppy.

We still permit anyone who fancies it to set up a rescue, so they may be fabulous and know dogs well, have up to date knowledge on dog behaviour and training or they may be back in teh dark ages rattling tins of stones and yarking on about pack leaders, and sending into homes dogs with no assessment (or a worthless assessment) who have bite histories, to unchecked homes who turn up with some cash. Does the general public know the difference... no.

Licencing ownership won't solve the problem, in fact its likely to make it worse as dodgy owners and breeders who will want to keep breeding and owning these animals will just go underground - so those dogs will NEVER access proper training, no chance - they will never come out during daylight, they will never go out in their own gardens in the day, they will be kept indoors, in basements, shitting on puppy pads in kitchens, untrained, unsocialised, needs not met... taught to be weapons... til they escape, or kill someones kid in the house.

Buildingthefuture · 21/12/2022 05:12

I’m a very experienced dog owner, but I wouldn’t be confident in handling or owning an XL Bully or similar. They are hugely powerful dogs and, in the wrong hands have the capacity to be lethal. But I do believe it’s the owners, rather than the dogs. The wrong owner, who doesn’t exercise, train, feed and stimulate their dog correctly, will always have a problem, irrespective of breed. Banning them won’t work I don’t think, as it will increase the “status” of these dogs to certain types of people. Maybe implement controls, similar to those for having a shotgun? So you need a licence to own or breed certain types of dog?
As for muzzling all dogs or preventing them going out in public? Big fat nope. My lot are well trained, obedient and very well socialised. They wouldn’t approach another person or another dog, because I’ve trained them that way. Having said that, I don’t walk them in places where there are lots of kids - my dogs do not enjoy their walk as much when it is punctuated by screaming children and their lackadaisical parents. They much prefer peace and quiet, as do I.

Suzi888 · 21/12/2022 04:16

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 20/12/2022 18:18

I wasn't going to post on this thread but I've just had to... Wtf have I just read 🙈🤣

Yes, what the fuck…. Gun laws work so well don’t they. 🙄

Redebs · 21/12/2022 04:09

Redebs · 21/12/2022 04:08

😄😁😆🤣😄

Laughing at the typo

Suzi888 · 21/12/2022 04:09

QuestionableMouse · 20/12/2022 15:50

Tougher rules or dog licences won't work, because the sort of people who have these types of dog won't adhere to them any more than they do the current rules now.

This. Humans need to take responsibility. These dogs don’t breed themselves. They don’t force people to buy them.

XL bullies and CC can be good family dogs- look up the breed info. But no, I wouldn’t have one. Idiots have them, they do weight work, play fight, it ends up going horribly wrong because most humans are twats.

Redebs · 21/12/2022 04:08

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 21/12/2022 02:21

Well my dog would find it very hard indeed to catch his ball with a muzzle on......

😄😁😆🤣😄

Redebs · 21/12/2022 04:06

There is a law in place against bully-type dogs, but it's not enforced. All sorts of them are paraded around the streets or up for rehoming by charities.
And what's with those selfish owners who suddenly decide their dog needs a walk at school going-home time? I think they actually enjoy the fear they create in parents and children

ClarathecrosseyedLioness · 21/12/2022 03:55

@Atethehalloweenchocs Why should dogs be allowed in pubic places without a muzzle?

If you adopted a (retired, racing) greyhound from a rescue you will be provided with a muzzle. This should be used whenever the dog is free-running.
greyhounds are 'sight-hounds' who have been trained to chase small furry creatures and can't differentiate between an electric 'hare' and someone's moggy.
I believe it should be used for 3 years after the animal has retired.

ClarathecrosseyedLioness · 21/12/2022 03:48

@SirSniffsAlot @ElephantInTheKitchen

OK, so as you have rubbished Victoria Stillwell and Cesar Millan's dog training methods, and seem to know about dog pyschology, I'd be interested to hear your solution to the problem in UK of some 'dangerous' dogs. 🙂

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 21/12/2022 02:21

ThisGirlNever · 20/12/2022 22:10

Why should dogs be allowed in pubic places without a muzzle?

Well my dog would find it very hard indeed to catch his ball with a muzzle on......

GLADragss · 21/12/2022 02:01

I don’t think there’s a perfect solution, unless the government clamps down on poor dog owners by imposing instant destruction of the dog, large fines, and prison for dog owners with a dangerous dog that goes on to kill someone. Might act as a deterrent. But then, you’ll get people saying that’s OTT and excuses being made for the dog.

I think some dog owners just have a “shit happens” mindset, they just don’t care. It’s a weird one as the UK is dog friendly to the extent that some owners place their dog as being more important than people eg will be offended if they’re asked to control their dog and won’t care about putting boundaries in place to prevent attacks. Even the way some dogs are trained and brought up, is bound to lead to issues as they are badly socialised, territorial, resource protective etc and will carry these behaviours outside the home.

DysonSpheres · 21/12/2022 01:48

leithreas · 20/12/2022 22:44

Exactly. I had a quick look through the past few years deaths from dog attacks and I think all but one happened on private property. There is no logical reason to muzzle Betty's pugs for a short waddle around the park for instance. Who would benefit from that?

Some stories of dog attacks in public places. At least one is fatal.

www.standard.co.uk/news/uk/new-malden-dog-attack-railway-police-crime-london-b1002020.html

www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/man-killed-dog-attack-fareham-hampshire-b2143814.html

www.richmondandtwickenhamtimes.co.uk/news/19231709.father-describes-horrific-bushy-park-dog-attack-easter/

www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/greater-manchester-news/mums-horror-after-bulldog-attacks-24673436

www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/breaking-girl-11-mauled-out-28116626

www.hulldailymail.co.uk/news/hull-east-yorkshire-news/dog-bite-left-five-year-7854029

www.edp24.co.uk/news/crime/20618674.dog-banned-city-parks-attacking-woman/

www.granthamjournal.co.uk/news/dog-attacks-22-month-old-girl-in-grantham-park-9083421/

The one just above wasn't this year, but happened as the toddler was exiting the children's area. The bruises are hortible There's a lot more stories.

If dog owners are neutral about risks to humans, there are a lot of stories of dangerous dog breeds maiming and killing other owners dogs (and other animals in the wild; deer, ducks, swans, etc) while they were being walked in public, with their owners not being able to help them for risk of getting attacked themselves. Those don't usually make headlines but the same sort of dogs are involved.

ThisGirlNever · 20/12/2022 22:49

Atethehalloweenchocs · 20/12/2022 22:37

Why should dogs be allowed in pubic places without a muzzle?

Why should they be? It is a tiny proportion of dogs who bite and most of these deaths happen in homes. This would be a ridiculous thing to do.

Dogs do bite strangers in pubic places. Why should any level of biting be tolerated? Dog owners have signed up to risks of dog ownership. The rest of the population haven't.

If all dogs were muzzled in public places, there would be zero dog bite victims in pubic places.

It seems ilogical to allow dog owners to inflict this danger on the rest of society.

I say this as somebody that likes (nice) dogs, but loves DC a shit load more.

leithreas · 20/12/2022 22:44

Atethehalloweenchocs · 20/12/2022 22:37

Why should dogs be allowed in pubic places without a muzzle?

Why should they be? It is a tiny proportion of dogs who bite and most of these deaths happen in homes. This would be a ridiculous thing to do.

Exactly. I had a quick look through the past few years deaths from dog attacks and I think all but one happened on private property. There is no logical reason to muzzle Betty's pugs for a short waddle around the park for instance. Who would benefit from that?

Atethehalloweenchocs · 20/12/2022 22:37

Why should dogs be allowed in pubic places without a muzzle?

Why should they be? It is a tiny proportion of dogs who bite and most of these deaths happen in homes. This would be a ridiculous thing to do.

holierthanthou73 · 20/12/2022 22:11

I hate to say it but there is no answer to prevent this happening as there will always be irresponsible wanker owners. I feel for the dogs, most of them are tied up in gardens going stir crazy. We can’t prevent puppy farms either, it’s hopeless. God it makes me so angry!

ThisGirlNever · 20/12/2022 22:10

leithreas · 20/12/2022 20:54

These accidents don't seem to be happening in 'public places' though do they? These are happening in private residences for the most part. It isn't Jane walking her bichon frise down the park without a muzzle that is the problem so why make it her problem? These threads are always so hysterical, it does no one any good.

Why should dogs be allowed in pubic places without a muzzle?