Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Another dog kills. When is something going to be done?

261 replies

ofwarren · 20/12/2022 15:15

AIBU to think that there needs to be a dog licence or at least SOMETHING put in place to try and prevent deaths by these dogs?
I was not at all surprised to read the breed..
"The dog, a large black XL bully cross cane corso breed, was seized by officers and has been destroyed."

metro.co.uk/2022/12/20/woman-dies-after-being-mauled-in-dog-attack-in-her-own-home-17970433/?ito=socialmetrouktwitter

OP posts:
Insertusernamehere123 · 21/12/2022 12:11

An acquaintance of a friend of mine has just re homed one of these. Dog has been locked away for most of its life, only let out in the garden, and kept in an area no bigger than a downstairs cupboard.

The person who bought it has limited experience with dogs and has children. It's a tragedy waiting to happen.

So many people get dogs knowing fuck all about them. They buy into the whole mans best friend shit and never imagine it would happen to them.

People with that level of ignorance and stupidity cannot be helped. It's just a shame that it's usually innocent victims paying the price for thier bad decisions.

Stomacharmeleon · 21/12/2022 11:48

On a less cheery note I have just moved (thankfully) and the idiot next door had a huge xl bully. Never once walked. Killed next doors rabbits until they heightened the fences.
RSPCA not bothered. We had very small gardens and they said as long as it had water and shelter it was fine.
Never seen a vet.
The only time anyone showed any interest was the brief period it kept escaping out the back gate and the dog warden returned it. It was taking itself to the park :( eventually they told them they would fine them if they did it again.
There are eight children in that house. Including two new horns (mum and teenage daughter pregnant) and the dog is a time bomb. I Don't know why our standards are so low before we do anything.... same for social services but that's another story.
The only animals happy and thriving in their were the bed bugs!

Stomacharmeleon · 21/12/2022 11:41

@ElephantInTheKitchen I think we own the same dog. She is currently farting away next to me and debating exploiting the sausages I have cooked her... after a long exploitive walk at the beach.

tabulahrasa · 21/12/2022 11:33

Cocolapew · 21/12/2022 10:42

We have dog licences in Northern Ireland still, its all online now and we no longer get tags. I don't see what difference it makes, I'm sure there's still thousands ofpeople who don't have one. They will only be found out if the poilice or dog warden is called out for any reason.

Assuming it’s the same as what we used to have, it’s basically a tax on owning dogs not anything useful though.

I assume people mean useful licensing when they say they think we should have dog licences - that’s what I mean when I say it.

I think it should be along similar lines as driving licences tbh.

SirBale · 21/12/2022 11:32

As others have mentioned the biggest problems are bad breeders who breed dogs purely for money and poor traits are fed back into the gene pool.

People often moan about how difficult it is to get a dog from a rescue and rightly so but our society of instant gratification means people want everything right now so will buy from wherever is easiest. A good breeder would make it just as difficult to buy one of their pups in order to make sure it goes to the best possible home.

Too many people often get breeds completely unsuitable to their lifestyle and end up with inevitable problems. The decent owners will seek help but from who? I’ve done a 3 day dog trainer course and could probably now offer my services! My dog Walker calls herself a trainer and offers behaviour advice as she’s been around dogs all her life - both of us even with the best intentions would probably do more harm than good.
The rest at best watch a couple of TikTok videos from some dubiously qualified ‘trainers’ peddling some archaic training.

Get a grip of breeders and those who can genuinely call themselves trainers and behaviourist and we might go some way to reducing the problem.

Banning a couple more breeds won’t see long term change.

Cocolapew · 21/12/2022 10:42

We have dog licences in Northern Ireland still, its all online now and we no longer get tags. I don't see what difference it makes, I'm sure there's still thousands ofpeople who don't have one. They will only be found out if the poilice or dog warden is called out for any reason.

ElephantInTheKitchen · 21/12/2022 10:19

lieselotte · 21/12/2022 10:08

Pet ownership is exploitation. The so-called animal lovers don't really love them at all, they just want something to play with and keep on their own terms.

I keep trying to set my dog free in the park every day, and yet every day he follows me home.

Currently he's being exploited by napping under my duvet, when he bothers to get up I'll exploit him by serving breakfast to him, before he chooses whether to suffer his way through a nap on the sofa or his own bed. This afternoon I'll give him his 1500th opportunity to choose if he prefers life living on his own wits or a life of exploitation with me. Assuming he makes the same decision as on the last 1499 times it's back to his prison with dinner, a game of fetch and naps on the sofa with his captors.

But perhaps you'll tell me the dog has Stockholm Syndrome.

emptythelitterbox · 21/12/2022 10:12

Christmasbaubleswithtinselon · 21/12/2022 10:04

Have a scroll through Scumtree or similar. You will see pages and pages of XL bullies for sale - from £500-£5000k! You’ll also find listings for 6 month old- 12 month old xlbullies whose owner has had ‘a change of circumstance’ or the like. There are many. There are instantly available pups or dogs that need rehoming urgently.

This is where we need more control. People buying puppies like this aren’t interested in training or behavioural issues. With any dog the right environment is key. For this strong breeds it’s essential. Surely more checks need to be done by those breeding privately?

These people don't train their dogs.

They buy him or are gifted them on a whim. They put a collar on them and keep them either in a small kennel or let out the back garden to relieve themselves.
The attempts to walk them are like described above. Dog pulling at the lead all over the place. The novelty wears off and they are basically fed and that's about it. A friend lives in a trailer park and they're all over the place. I can't imagine keeping huge dogs in a trailer. They'd stake them out on a chain outside the trailer.

They don't spay or neuter them either.

lieselotte · 21/12/2022 10:10

leithreas · 20/12/2022 20:54

These accidents don't seem to be happening in 'public places' though do they? These are happening in private residences for the most part. It isn't Jane walking her bichon frise down the park without a muzzle that is the problem so why make it her problem? These threads are always so hysterical, it does no one any good.

The serious accidents don't usually happen in public places, but the more minor ones do. I wonder how much NHS time is used up dealing with dog bites and other indirect dog incidents (eg kids falling off their bikes because a dog has suddenly run at them). My DH was telling me this morning about a guy who died of sepsis because of a nip by his pet dog.

lieselotte · 21/12/2022 10:08

luckylavender · 21/12/2022 07:09

I've found my people!

Pet ownership is exploitation. The so-called animal lovers don't really love them at all, they just want something to play with and keep on their own terms.

lieselotte · 21/12/2022 10:06

One advantage of dog licences might be if the funds they raised were used to pay for dog wardens. My council and another local council have got rid of theirs, they need to bring them back but no doubt will say there's no money. So introduce dog licences and there will be money. It could be done retrospectively by charging people for the licence when owners next take their dogs to the vets.

he uses leash jerks, they are unpleasant for the dog

I have a neighbour who does this. I am not a dog fan but I think it's cruel.

Christmasbaubleswithtinselon · 21/12/2022 10:04

Have a scroll through Scumtree or similar. You will see pages and pages of XL bullies for sale - from £500-£5000k! You’ll also find listings for 6 month old- 12 month old xlbullies whose owner has had ‘a change of circumstance’ or the like. There are many. There are instantly available pups or dogs that need rehoming urgently.

This is where we need more control. People buying puppies like this aren’t interested in training or behavioural issues. With any dog the right environment is key. For this strong breeds it’s essential. Surely more checks need to be done by those breeding privately?

lieselotte · 21/12/2022 10:02

Fuuuuuckit · 20/12/2022 18:44

It's more about owners than dogs imo.

We went into a dog friendly garden centre yesterday, and in front of us was a couple with a 'safe' dog. But it was on a VERY long lead and allowed to wander all over, causing disruption amd knocking over a stand. Why oh why are people so naive to think that their precious little 'pup' is OK to behave like this?

I went to one near Dartmouth in Devon a few weeks ago and the garden centre had its own resident dogs which were allowed to roam around the centre, including the restaurant and sat right next to you begging for food. I don't like it at all, but no doubt if you said anything they'd just tell you to leave.

I wish there were more dog-free places. Parks should have different areas, some dog-free, some for dogs on leads and some for dogs to exercise off-lead.

Nogbreaks · 21/12/2022 09:59

‘While these attacks are very rare, I'd be happy to have dog licences introduced to prevent these things from happening. And I am saying that as a dog owner. .’

these exist where I’m from. They’re meaningless. People who are going to mistreat animals just don’t get them, unsurprising, and carry on regardless. People with illegal dogs certainly aren’t going to get them. People who breed for dog fights aren’t going to get them.
and there’s no really checks in them anyway. It’s not like the police or council stop dog walkers to check

SirSniffsAlot · 21/12/2022 09:53

A nice summary of the problems with Cesar Millan's methods and why - after 20 years - they are now considered greatly outdated and need reassessing. Link below.

medium.com/@vandanni.hadai/cesar-millan-the-problem-with-his-approach-and-the-future-of-dog-training-49dd8cddb391#:~:text=Instead%20of%20focusing%20on%20reinforcing,guide%20dogs%20into%20behaving%20differently.

There is a lot of disagreement about a lot of dog behaviour in the canine world but what there is universal agreement on among anyone with a science-based background or education, is that Cesar Millan has done more harm than he has done good.

His methods are aversive. They use punishment at their core, even though the punishment is fairly mild in a number of instances and so, to our eyes, may seem to be gentle. e.g. he uses leash jerks, they are unpleasant for the dog. He uses finger pokes, they are also unpleasant. He introduced the 'alpha roll' which is stressful and deeply scary for the dog.

To the dog they are punishment and that causes all kinds of risks and issues. Not least, dogs trained with punishments (even "gentle" punishments) are more likely to display aggressive behaviours than dogs trained without them. Taking a already aggressive dog and using punishment to train it, is a masive gamble. And one - in my opinion - it is never ethical to take.

BratzB · 21/12/2022 09:39

Caesar Milan is, however, dangerous and proof that you don't have to be any good at what you do to get a series. A lot of what he proposes are "quick fixes" that involve scaring the dog into submission, and have a nasty habit of unraveling once the cameras have stopped rolling.

I'm not a dog expert but o don't get this. Caesar doesn't scare the dogs, his point is to show them he's the leader. Not near them with a stick. So if they want X hell give it when he's ready, not when the dog jumps up.

And also, if the dogs go back to normal behaviour after the cameras, it could be argued that he does a better job than the owners. I'm sure it works for some and not others, there's many reasons why it could be that it's not working

ElephantInTheKitchen · 21/12/2022 09:30

ClarathecrosseyedLioness · 21/12/2022 03:48

@SirSniffsAlot @ElephantInTheKitchen

OK, so as you have rubbished Victoria Stillwell and Cesar Millan's dog training methods, and seem to know about dog pyschology, I'd be interested to hear your solution to the problem in UK of some 'dangerous' dogs. 🙂

Victoria Stillwell is pretty alright; she's probably the best dog trainer who has had a regular series on UK TV. She doesn't advocate anything involving pack leadership or alpha dog theories though - in fact she's spoken out against it
positively.com/dog-training/myths-truths/the-truth-about-dominance/

Caesar Milan is, however, dangerous and proof that you don't have to be any good at what you do to get a series. A lot of what he proposes are "quick fixes" that involve scaring the dog into submission, and have a nasty habit of unraveling once the cameras have stopped rolling.

Almost all dogs who bite with intent (i.e. not puppy mouthing or a sleep startle) are either
A) terrified, and want to make something go away, typically by barking, but will bite as a last resort, or sometimes out of sheer terror.
B) at the end of their tether, having used a variety of more polite ways to tell someone or something to leave it alone and being ignored. Over time if the more polite signals are consistently ignored you can create a dog that goes straight for a bite because they know that more polite signals are pointless.

The solution with dogs that are terrified is to work with a qualified behaviourist. I won't go into detail here, but behaviourists work to change the underlying emotions the dog has when it sees a trigger. This does require a committed owner who is willing to put the work in. Unfortunately at present literally any idiot can call themselves a behaviourist. I'd like to see better regulation of this, and some universities doing masters level qualifications to qualify people as clinical animal behaviourists, to increase the numbers of qualified ones as there aren't enough (currently the gold standard behaviourists are qualified by APBC and CCAB, which are essentially trade associations). I'd also like better awareness for the public of how and when to access a behaviourist.

The solution for the dogs at the end of their tether is education and prevention for owners. For instance, about the importance of allowing the dog safe spaces to get away from children and not letting them harass the dog. This is a really interesting video about the more polite signals I mentioned, but I find awareness of this really quite low even amongst a lot of dog owners.

Quveas · 21/12/2022 08:58

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 20/12/2022 19:16

@Greenginghamdress
👏🏼well said.

lots of people are apparently suspicious of someone who doesn’t like dogs. Personally I’m suspicious of someone who prefers a creature that is obedient, compliant and doesn’t answer back over that of a human.

I frankly don't care whether other people don't like dogs or not. It doesn't even appear on my radar. But I do find it odd that you are criticising dogs for being "obedient" or "compliant" (we call it well trained) when the thread is supposed to be about dogs behaving badly (we can't win, can we - we aren't allowed to have dogs that are out of control but they shouldn't be obedient or compliant??????). As for not answering back - you clearly haven't ever owned a dog, because they can and do! My dog is quite capable of expressing his opinion on a range of issues. But since he is well-trained (and an assistance dog) he knows not to argue too much, and sometimes he even wins the argument.

TantrumsAndBalloons · 21/12/2022 08:37

I don’t put him in situations where he would “flip”

just to clarify the above past- bullies are absolutely not instinctively aggressive. They are incredibly people friendly and as long as they are socialised correctly, it’s rare they are dog aggressive
because they are big and some of them are owned by idiots who WANT them to be aggressive they have a reputation for being attack dogs when this is very far from the truth, my Staffies were way more reactive then my bully

Jaipur · 21/12/2022 08:00

QuestionableMouse · 20/12/2022 15:50

Tougher rules or dog licences won't work, because the sort of people who have these types of dog won't adhere to them any more than they do the current rules now.

This. However I think there needs to be far tighter regulations around powerful breeds that could easily kill an adult, let alone a child. XL bullys for examples. Like another poster said, they are idiot magnets and yes, they are often naturally reactive have an instinctive aggression and high protection drive. This coupled by an ignorant, idiot owner is a lethal combination.

DysonSpheres · 21/12/2022 07:54

The above message is to @TantrumsAndBalloons

DysonSpheres · 21/12/2022 07:53

ThisGirlNever · 21/12/2022 07:29

Maybe you'll get lucky and the dog will OD on their stash.

🤣🤣🤣🤣

DysonSpheres · 21/12/2022 07:52

Your dog sounds lovely, but tell me, if he for some bolt of lightening chance did flip, how would you stop him? A dog that powerful isn't stoppable should they attack someone, in the stories I've read it's taken several people as well as the police. Children have zero chance of survival after an attack. Adults barely any.

Farmers living in areas with wolves and bears need them. In a residential, busy metropolitan area full of thousands of people at any one time a breed like this isn't necessary, is unsuitable, and potentially dangerous.

TantrumsAndBalloons · 21/12/2022 07:41

ThisGirlNever · 21/12/2022 07:19

I'm sure this guy felt exactly the same about his rescue dogs.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-tayside-central-59781502

Please be responsible and muzzle these potentially highly dangerous dogs in public.

I won’t muzzle him, thanks 🙄
as he doesn’t need to be muzzled in public given he is on a lead and has spot on recall that took time and patience to achieve

ThisGirlNever · 21/12/2022 07:29

Plingston · 21/12/2022 07:16

A couple in my street have recently acquired what seems to be a huge bully puppy. I'm very nervous about it. The woman has it on a lead and has no control whatsoever. It's dragging her everywhere and she is completely overpowered by it. Whenever it pulls her, she slaps and shouts at it.

This couple are drug addicts (or were - I don't see dealers so much these days) who had all their children removed, and have since had a couple more babies who were removed at birth. They are never, ever going to be suitable owners for a dog like that and I am quite worried about the dog getting loose or even managing to attack while on lead since they can't physically control it even as a puppy. They don't work so I have no idea how they can financially provide everything a dog of that size would need. It only seems to go for a short walk up and down the street. I'm hoping they'll lose interest or it will become too much hard work and they'll get rid of it. It's a disaster waiting to happen.

Maybe you'll get lucky and the dog will OD on their stash.

Swipe left for the next trending thread