Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Another dog kills. When is something going to be done?

261 replies

ofwarren · 20/12/2022 15:15

AIBU to think that there needs to be a dog licence or at least SOMETHING put in place to try and prevent deaths by these dogs?
I was not at all surprised to read the breed..
"The dog, a large black XL bully cross cane corso breed, was seized by officers and has been destroyed."

metro.co.uk/2022/12/20/woman-dies-after-being-mauled-in-dog-attack-in-her-own-home-17970433/?ito=socialmetrouktwitter

OP posts:
Saucery · 21/12/2022 18:15

Every single dog that has been aggressive to my dog in her 2 years on this earth has been a small or tiny breed. Stupid, ineffective owners.

WiddlinDiddlin · 21/12/2022 18:05

My experience with people muzzling dogs is that they then belief its perfectly safe to put those dogs into situations they would normally avoid if the dog were not muzzled.

This typically causes a deterioration in dog behaviour because the dog is more stressed, and eventually, management fails, dog gets loose, rips muzzle off (short of nailgunning them to certain breeds heads, there are no muzzles a dog cannot get off with relative ease once loose!) and now you have a stressed out unsocial, frustrated dog...

A big heavy dog wearing a muzzle can still do some serious damage, they tend to 'muzzle punch', attempting to bite, some can even push the muzzle hard up against something and bite, though obviously this is front teeth nippy type biting rather than the back slicing teeth or the canine puncturing teeth... A 60kg+ dog to the ribs then smashing its head into you as you lie on the ground is still going to kill the very small or very frail/elderly etc.

We would also likely see a sharp increase in small 'safe' breeds ie, those that don't need a muzzle, being allowed more freedom to run up to larger dogs and yap, bounce, bite, actively attack... and again, if you own a dog that this happens to regularly, you're going to see a deterioration in behaviour unless you can avoid walking your dog in places where this happens.

So ultimately we will have responsible owners of larger breeds unable to walk their dogs, more antisocial dogs, and still those who are actually the problem, will leave their dogs unmuzzled as and when it suits.

Bingbangbongbash · 21/12/2022 17:55

I’m a dog exploiter but I have to say, I’m quite into the idea of muzzles in public on anything larger than a certain size. Maybe 22kg?

I know most dogs are lovely, and most dog disagreements are pretty short lived and harmless, but I’m seeing so many people inadequately looking after giant, fighting dogs. Leaving aside how no one needs a bull or bear fighting breed in the UK, especially not a city, how can small women or kids hold on to 30kg+ of pure muscle if it decides to go? You regularly see them in pathetic collars, with weedy leashes. At least put them in a harness.

I love dogs but I will leave a park if I see a bully (XL or not) and cross the road to avoid them being walked on the pavement. I fear for my dog when we come across them in the park - although thankfully this is rare. My husband pointed out that the kind of people who have these dogs don’t exercise them, they parade them round the estate, shitting everywhere.

But more legislation isn’t the answer - there’s no point when there’s no capacity to enforce existing laws.

All dogs are supposed to be chipped - so why aren’t they? Breeders having more than 1 litter a year are supposed to be licensed. Are they all? Nope. Tail docking and ear clipping is illegal, yes you see it all over.

There’s no appetite to spend money on any enforcement, so on we go, with things getting worse and worse.

Isleoftights · 21/12/2022 17:29

There has certainly been a large increase in the number of such deaths.

People killed by dogs in the UK.
1980s - 3
1990s - 4
2000s - 16
2010s - 27
2020s - 16 (to date)

Saucery · 21/12/2022 17:29

I detest hamsters’ bottoms <shudder>

Therefore I wish them all to be banned. Or to be forced to wear little trews.

Saucery · 21/12/2022 17:28

I had a cat who made herself comfy on the towel shelf in the bathroom once. She blinked, the light from the landing caught her eyes and made them glow - cue me nearly falling backwards down the stairs. She would not have given the tiniest shit until the next mealtime, of that I am certain. So don’t tell me cats cause no harm….

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 21/12/2022 17:11

Florenz · 21/12/2022 17:05

Just ban the keeping of dogs as pets. There's no reason for it to be allowed. People can have cats or goldfish or hamsters or gerbils but not dogs as they cause too many problems.

And then you woke up

Florenz · 21/12/2022 17:05

Just ban the keeping of dogs as pets. There's no reason for it to be allowed. People can have cats or goldfish or hamsters or gerbils but not dogs as they cause too many problems.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 21/12/2022 17:01

ThisGirlNever · 21/12/2022 16:59

I'm sure 100% of bully XL dog owners would say they don't need muzzling and 100% of normal people would say they did.

Dog owners can't be trusted to make objective decisions about their precious pouches. They're never going to consider their dogs to be part of the problem.

I said random people. I know people who don't own dogs and have no interest in dogs who would agree they don't all need muzzling

ThisGirlNever · 21/12/2022 16:59

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 21/12/2022 16:44

If I went and asked 100 random people should all dogs be muzzled I'd be very surprised if any of them said all dogs need muzzling

I'm sure 100% of bully XL dog owners would say they don't need muzzling and 100% of normal people would say they did.

Dog owners can't be trusted to make objective decisions about their precious pouches. They're never going to consider their dogs to be part of the problem.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 21/12/2022 16:44

ThisGirlNever · 21/12/2022 16:31

Your dog isn't a person. The rest of society haven't signed up to the inherent danger that your dog poses.

Kids shouldn't tease dogs, but your dog couldn't bite a provocative child if it were muzzled. It is ultimately your job to ensure your dog never bites anybody, no matter what the circumstances.

That is why your dog should be muzzled.

If I went and asked 100 random people should all dogs be muzzled I'd be very surprised if any of them said all dogs need muzzling

ElephantInTheKitchen · 21/12/2022 16:38

lieselotte · 21/12/2022 15:18

@ElephantInTheKitchen @Stomacharmeleon my point is that people keep dogs for their own benefit, not the dogs' benefit. As you knew full well.

And dogs don't know any different. That doesn't make it right to keep one for your own purposes. Just as having children isn't for the good of society, it's because people want to. But if you do that, you make sure as far as you can that your pets and kids don't adversely affect others.

@lieselotte if the 'exploitation' of dog ownership is that high up your list of concerns, I do hope you're a vegan...

I did once have a lodger whose girlfriend refused to visit as keeping pets was, to her mind, a form of slavery and she couldn't bear to be around enslaved DDog. This particular DDog was accidentally acquired from a friend who couldn't keep him and no one else wanted him. He wasn't created for my benefit, though I like to think our ongoing life together is of mutual benefit, rather like all friendships.

@WiddlinDiddlin excellent post re Cesar Millan

healthadvice123 · 21/12/2022 16:35

@ThisGirlNever dogs need to be able to play and exercise too , they do have rights as well and a dog that is trained and doesn't bite etc will want to okay with a ball and sticks
My dog doesn't bite , he didn't bite said child either as a responsible owner I stepped in and averted any situation.
The issue isn't all dogs its some owners

healthadvice123 · 21/12/2022 16:33

@ThisGirlNever society does not expect all dogs to be muzzles though just you

ThisGirlNever · 21/12/2022 16:31

healthadvice123 · 21/12/2022 13:38

@ThisGirlNever lots of humans have attacked others but we don't all go around having to wear muzzles etc
People also need to teach children not to approach or tease dogs etc, a boy ran up to mine and went to whack him with a stick whilst his parent said oh hes playing
If my dog had bit , he would of been in trouble but the 8 ish year old kid no repercussions.
I agree more parks with fenced off for off lead running and more wardens to check owners are responsible etc
But an all out muzzle for all dogs etc , no
I

Your dog isn't a person. The rest of society haven't signed up to the inherent danger that your dog poses.

Kids shouldn't tease dogs, but your dog couldn't bite a provocative child if it were muzzled. It is ultimately your job to ensure your dog never bites anybody, no matter what the circumstances.

That is why your dog should be muzzled.

WiddlinDiddlin · 21/12/2022 16:03

Newwardrobe · 21/12/2022 15:11

I also think that some owners of these bully breeds don't actually want their dogs to be socialised or trained to be well behaved anyway.

Spot on.

For some people, a dog that requires physical strength to be held back, who they have to yell at and drag away, who is lunging and raving at people... is a massive ego boost in many ways.

Some of these people themselves feel really vulnerable, hence their choice of dog, and their appreciation of a dogs behaviour that keeps people away from them, and are just unaware of the issues. I have had a few cases like this and taught them to give the dog a hand cue to bark furiously, whilst on a loose lead. Because the behaviour is on cue, for treats, its totally safe, but still makes people keep their distance!.

Some of them just don't give a fuck, are too thick to realise that the person the dog ends up hurting or killing is not likely to be a 'bad guy', but instead themselves, their loved ones, or innocent parties.

WiddlinDiddlin · 21/12/2022 15:59

'I am not a dog expert, Cesar Milan doesn't scare dogs'...

That, right there, is a huge part of the problem. People don't understand what they are seeing when it comes to dog behaviour, or awful training methods.

Cesar relies very heavily on using intimidating, confrontational body language, and outright bullying, to force dogs to submit to him.

What you see on tv is the edited footage after several HOURS of working with the dog and Cesar specifically, works with dogs without the owner present for a few hours. They use a stooge dog to wind up the clients dog, and his magical 'tsst' and back-kick with his heel thing... I can reveal that the 'magic' here is several hours of pairing both of those with a harsh jerk of a prong, or super fine 'cheesewire' slip lead up at the most sensitive part of the neck, or a shock collar, until the 'tssst' or the heel kick results in an extreme response from the dog.

This is to ensure it looks like magic on tv and that the dog is absolutely raving with frustration and fear, to get the footage they want of Cesar 'calming' the beast.

But, to know that, you need to have a good education in canine body language, in how they learn, in what the various methods will do and why, and a good number of contacts within the TV production industry, to understand how this works, get first hand accounts of what goes on. (My description of what goes on above is from first hand accounts and behind the scenes video, its not opinion it is fact.)

When you address behaviour like pulling on the lead, lunging at people, growling at people.. by suppressing behaviour by pairing the action with an aversive like a prong correction or a shock or a yank on a slip lead or a kick or yell or whatever... The chances are, the dog pairs this with what they were focused on at the time.

Not on their actual behaviour.

So now they actually feel worse about being near the trigger, but they don't dare express that feeling so the chances are, the owner will now take them near children, believing their dog 'cured'...

And theres where we get these 'he bit out of the blue' and 'he bit without warning' and 'he just turned...' and 'it was totally unprovoked'... cases from.

lieselotte · 21/12/2022 15:18

Stomacharmeleon · 21/12/2022 11:41

@ElephantInTheKitchen I think we own the same dog. She is currently farting away next to me and debating exploiting the sausages I have cooked her... after a long exploitive walk at the beach.

@ElephantInTheKitchen @Stomacharmeleon my point is that people keep dogs for their own benefit, not the dogs' benefit. As you knew full well.

And dogs don't know any different. That doesn't make it right to keep one for your own purposes. Just as having children isn't for the good of society, it's because people want to. But if you do that, you make sure as far as you can that your pets and kids don't adversely affect others.

Newwardrobe · 21/12/2022 15:11

I also think that some owners of these bully breeds don't actually want their dogs to be socialised or trained to be well behaved anyway.

Leonberger · 21/12/2022 14:59

@Insertusernamehere123 this is the thing.
People buy into the lie of breed not deed. They truly believe that love and cuddles can fix all behavioural issues. That all dogs need is a chance and they can change, even ones with previous aggressive history.
That if they let the dogs run riot with others they will eventually learn to socialise with anything despite genetics, personality, previous learning, temperament.

Most are not educated enough to look at the science based evidence, sadly and so people and other animals are continuously killed by these type of dogs. People have over inflated egos and believe the shit spread all over the internet about dogs, maybe if they had more realistic ideas about their own capabilities then it wouldn’t happen! The majority of people do not need a dog bred to kill anything nor are they experienced enough to train it!

ElephantInTheKitchen · 21/12/2022 14:45

Newwardrobe · 21/12/2022 13:09

What will having a license actually do though? These dogs won't know they're licensed and so it won't make any difference to their behaviour.

There are two types of licence

  1. One where it's basically just a tax, like the TV licence, which would achieve nothing
  2. One where you have to put some effort into getting it and can lose it if you screw up, like a driving licence.

If it was the latter, and it included some compulsory education (theory lessons before you get the dog, a theory test, and some practical training sessions once you've got the dog) then it might have some impact.

Theory could cover things like positive reinforcement training, socialisation (a much misunderstood term), canine body language, etiquette, choosing the right dog breed for your family, how and when to seek a behaviourists support, nutrition and so on.

The practical sessions would be a typical puppy training class (with a different version for adult rescue dogs, and a one-to-one option for adults that don't cope in a group setting) to put some groundwork in place.

The implementation would be the tricky bit - I'm not sure there are enough properly qualified dog trainers out there to run such a scheme to an acceptable standard, and many of the existing ones might not want to become a government employee, preferring self employment.

healthadvice123 · 21/12/2022 13:38

@ThisGirlNever lots of humans have attacked others but we don't all go around having to wear muzzles etc
People also need to teach children not to approach or tease dogs etc, a boy ran up to mine and went to whack him with a stick whilst his parent said oh hes playing
If my dog had bit , he would of been in trouble but the 8 ish year old kid no repercussions.
I agree more parks with fenced off for off lead running and more wardens to check owners are responsible etc
But an all out muzzle for all dogs etc , no
I

healthadvice123 · 21/12/2022 13:20

@Dotjones well thats just stupid as same could be said about humans in general

Newwardrobe · 21/12/2022 13:09

What will having a license actually do though? These dogs won't know they're licensed and so it won't make any difference to their behaviour.

NotTooOldPaul · 21/12/2022 12:43

leithreas · 20/12/2022 21:04

These dogs are usually pretty much confined to their houses and yards because their owners cant be arsed. How will anyone even know if they display their disc on their collar when no one ever sees it? Where is the money going to cone from to police tax discs on dogs?

The licence fee should cover all costs involved ply more.