Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Another dog kills. When is something going to be done?

261 replies

ofwarren · 20/12/2022 15:15

AIBU to think that there needs to be a dog licence or at least SOMETHING put in place to try and prevent deaths by these dogs?
I was not at all surprised to read the breed..
"The dog, a large black XL bully cross cane corso breed, was seized by officers and has been destroyed."

metro.co.uk/2022/12/20/woman-dies-after-being-mauled-in-dog-attack-in-her-own-home-17970433/?ito=socialmetrouktwitter

OP posts:
Atethehalloweenchocs · 23/12/2022 21:22

Too often people come out with the 'love my animals more than I love other people' nonsense, especially where needy humans like children or asylum-seekers are concerned.

What the actual fuck?

surreygirl1987 · 23/12/2022 19:42

Oh gosh how awful.

ThisGirlNever · 23/12/2022 17:29

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-lincolnshire-64078112

Husky killed a 3 month old baby.

ElephantInTheKitchen · 22/12/2022 17:36

I agree that dog v dog attacks should be taken more seriously, at least when they cause actual injury (a bit of a scuffle / handbags at dawn with no actual biting or other injury is probably more common than people realise, and while undesirable it's within the boundaries of normal dog behaviour).

Dogs are entirely capable of telling the difference between a human and a dog though. Mine can tell the difference between a husky (absolutely fine) and a German shepherd (horrid, bark at it until it goes away).

WiddlinDiddlin · 22/12/2022 16:01

I do agree that dog on dog attacks should be taken more seriously, there is no evidence that aggression towards other dogs is related to aggression towards humans.

Dog owners are at higher risk of being bitten when splitting up a dog fight but this is accidental bites and they're as likely to be bitten by their own dog as by the other.

lieselotte · 22/12/2022 15:09

Another thing that might help is the police taking proper notice of dog on dog attacks. A dog that attacks other dogs may well go on to have a go at a human at some point. However, the police don't care (and to be fair probably don't have the resources. But that's another reason why we need dog wardens back).

OllytheCollie · 22/12/2022 13:40

@kc431 that argument doesn't quite work. We all know what is being licensed when you acquire a driving license - responsible driving behaviour. A license can only be acquired after you have a sat a test to show you can drive competently and you can lose your license if you either drive dangerously OR you fail to meet an objective standard which suggests you might drive dangerously e.g. you develop a medical condition which causes loss of consciousness or sight loss. In any situation where you drive a car without a license you are committing a criminal offence, easy to check by the police. It's true the law gets broken a lot but its easy to see a) why it is a good idea and b) how it can be enforced and is therefore a deterrent to non-licensed wannabe drivers. The difficulty with a dog 'license' is that showing everyone why it is a good idea and enforcing it are both hard. E.g. are you licensing that someone is a responsible dog owner? Or that they have just some minimal knowledge of animal welfare necessary before acquiring a dog? Mandatory training for dogs isn't like driving. Dogs are specific i.e. you build a relationship with one dog. I have a trained collie, but no idea how to handle my neighbours Jack Russell. In fact people thinking they can 'drive' dogs in general is a big part of the problem.

And once licensed how do you enforce it? Do you have strict liability that only people trained on that dog can walk it outside the house? Or is there a class of other professionals? Whatabout wider family members with whom the dog has a relationship? Can they all be licensed? There are some over the top suggestions on this thread re dogs never being walked off lead or without muzzles which I appreciate come from a place of fear which is understandable given the events of this year but disproportionate to the level of harm shown by most dogs. The difficulty with making licensing restrictions too stringent is it won't get popular support - which means in a country of dog-lovers a) it would never get legislated for and b) even if legislated will end up being the kind of minimal mandatory training requirement (watch this online workshop) which I fear could be worse than useless.

Don't get me wrong I am absolutely in favour of training for dog-owners and think it is irresponsible dog ownership not to get training advice. I have gone to a lot of training classes myself and would say whenever you get a new dog go to classes or get a trainer involved, even if you have done it all before lots of time, each dog is different and there is always more to learn. But I don't see the driving training metaphor mapping to dogs.

Mandatory training after any event - dog getting loose, dog bite, dog causing excessive barking - is brought to the attn of the police or local authority is sensible as at that point you have an owner with a motivation to do some work and like a speed awareness course there might be engagement.

Licenses just to ensure the owner knows they have duties to the animal add little to the duties all pet owners already have under the Animal Act. The law as it stands just isn't enforced well, but in the era of the internet we don't need a license to bring to people's attention the minimum level of welfare needs dogs have. People aren't keeping their dogs chained up outside or failing to exercise them out of ignorance, but indifference. Like any animal lover I would love to see the current law more severely enforced, but the small number of prosecutions taken against the large number of cases of abuse is because the police don't have time. That said perhaps if people could see how closely animal welfare and human welfare is aligned and if we prosecuted abusers more harshly we might deter some of the outcomes (distressed dogs, poor breeding) which increase the risks to humans in the future maybe public support for prosecutions would grow - this isn't just about saving ickle puppies, but also ensuring people don't unwittingly buy reactive, anxious dogs as pets, or that neighbourhoods don't live in fear of neglected, aggressive dogs who want to escape their conditions.

That and everything @WiddlinDiddlin said.

FrostyPaws · 22/12/2022 13:38

So tragic and needless.

I don’t get why anyone would own an animal that had the power to literally turn around and kill them if it wanted to. I don’t even really like Staffies for this reason although I know they are popular on here.

I have a dog, so I’m not anti them at all in general, but he is small and if he ever turned on a person I’m confident I could overpower him easily. Can anyone say the same for a bully/German Shepard/mastiff type dog?

Regardless of how ‘friendly’ you think your dog is, it’s an animal at the end of the day and you can’t say for certain that if it gets spooked or unwell it won’t turn aggressive so for me it’s about whether or not you could deal with that if you had to.

Soothsayer1 · 22/12/2022 13:09

kc431 · 22/12/2022 12:52

“Licenses won’t do anything because the bad people won’t get one” is a stupid argument - should we get rid of driving licenses because there’s loads of criminals speeding around uninsured with no license? Imagine how much WORSE the roads would be without licenses and insurance requirements. I don’t see why we don’t have the same for dogs. Not only can they injure, they leave shit everywhere and are generally a nuisance if badly trained.

I agree with you, the UK has a serious dog problem which needs to be addressed.
I also totally get your point about licences but I think one added problem is that the bad people with the bad dogs will keep them hidden away in a way that drivers can't keep cars hidden away...
if you take your car out on the road you are picked up on the ANPR but it's possible to keep a dog hidden away from authorities and they can still be a danger.
I don't know what the answer is but I think I would definitely support licencing.

kc431 · 22/12/2022 12:52

“Licenses won’t do anything because the bad people won’t get one” is a stupid argument - should we get rid of driving licenses because there’s loads of criminals speeding around uninsured with no license? Imagine how much WORSE the roads would be without licenses and insurance requirements. I don’t see why we don’t have the same for dogs. Not only can they injure, they leave shit everywhere and are generally a nuisance if badly trained.

Soothsayer1 · 22/12/2022 12:35

Tyrantosaurus · 20/12/2022 19:07

Think dogs like XL bullies should be banned.

But like someone else said, there's still other breeds like German shepherds so this problem can never fully be avoided. A complete ban on bigger breeds would be very unpopular

Anything which restricts dog ownership will reduce the profits of the pet industry and they will lobby hard to stop this
We should not be keeping large powerful predators as domestic pets

WiddlinDiddlin · 22/12/2022 12:28

We have a big problem with inaccurate and incomplete data on dog related injury/death here.

Hospitals do not record such things in a standardized manner so in some places all dog related injuries are recorded as dog bites.

Doesn't matter if the dog tried to remove your arm, or you fell over the family yorkie whilst drunkenly dancing round the room at 3am.

We also do next to no investigation on the dog (ie the dog as evidence) - so the dog is typically destroyed and then the most that will happen is a vet examines the body and a DLO will determine whether the dog was an illegal breed or not.

If we could *remove dogs (where safe to do so, and that depends on the right people on scene at the time...) to an assessment facility and treat them as evidence whilst alive, we might find out more useful information.

Lots of people scoff at that, because they don't grasp the depth of information that can be found.

Dogs who were starved ...
Dogs who following bite pattern examination, were found NOT to be the dog that inflicted the bite at all
Dogs found to be suffering injury
Dogs found to have ingested drugs
Dogs used to cover human abuse of other humans (usually children, not always)

Dogs are often used as a scapegoat: going out equipped with a knife, could show intent to harm someone - going out with a dog, theres wiggle room there. If it can be shown to a court that the dog was intentionally used as a weapon (rather than simply 'allowed to be out of control') sentencing could be very different.

Dogs take the blame for shitty parenting: where a parent would be considered negligent, neglectful, dangerous... for leaving a loaded gun in a childs reach, or leaving them sat next to an open fire... for example, having a dog taught to behave in a dangerous manner, neglected, untrained, abused to the point of exhibiting dangerous behaviour, tends not to result in the same conclusion, and people consider punishment delivered in the dog being destroyed, whilst the person has 'suffered enough'...

If people could just stop being dicks...

( * For the lunatics who will now state I want to save all the savage killer beasties who eat small children - no. I do mean remove, assess, euthanise where appropriate which for fatalities is almost always the case.)

OllytheCollie · 22/12/2022 12:06

@Isleoftights I think that's the wikipedia data based on reprted inquests. It's a problematic source as most inquests aren't reported (they are public but a publication of the outcome will only be reported if a journalist attends) meaning the reason you get fewer inquest reported deaths from the 80s is only that we don't have web-based newspaper files to collate for that period. There may have been many more death certificates filed which list biting as a possible cause of death, but equally a person may be bitten and then die of related trauma or heart attack meaning only those causes end up on the death certificate. It's only really for the last two decades we have any good data on the prevalence of deaths caused by dogs, but it's unlikely they have been going up as much as that list suggests. That doesn't mean the current level of deaths and more worryingly biting is OK at all obviously and it may well be getting worse - this year has been especially tragic and it does look like more than a statistical blip. Just that sadly there were probably a lot more deaths in the 80s than are counted there.

lieselotte · 22/12/2022 11:26

Florenz · 21/12/2022 17:05

Just ban the keeping of dogs as pets. There's no reason for it to be allowed. People can have cats or goldfish or hamsters or gerbils but not dogs as they cause too many problems.

Not stupid at all.
But unrealistic - at least until the prevailing opinion that pet ownership is acceptable changes (and it will).
However, it needs to be made a lot more difficult and only one per household.
Too many people have more dogs than they can reasonably cope with.
And there need to be strict rules about them being in public spaces (and private spaces open to the public like shops).
You don't need to take dogs into shops but people with allergies need to shop there - also those who work there shouldn't have to deal with dogs.
Dogs in offices is even more unreasonable.

£150 for a dog licence doesn't seem very expensive to me, especially for Switzerland.

C4tastrophe · 22/12/2022 11:15

I’m in Switzerland and they outlawed a large number of dogs after some maulings. In my kanton, there are a few borderline breeds that require a license issued by the police, like Rotties. But all pit derivatives are illegal and my kanton have sadly included staffs in that, though other Kantons haven’t.
We also pay for a dog license witch funds the ample bins and free poo bags everywhere. It’s chf165 a year, @£150. Expensive? Yes, but there’s hardly any shite around.

Redebs · 22/12/2022 11:03

luckylavender · 21/12/2022 07:09

I've found my people!

Yes, absolutely.
It's easy to get sentimental over animals. Pet animals are selectively bred to be sycophantic and neotenous. Too often people come out with the 'love my animals more than I love other people' nonsense, especially where needy humans like children or asylum-seekers are concerned.
When murders or disasters happen, there's always some twit asking if the family dog was traumatised too.
Keeping carnivorous pets has a massive impact on the environment as well, but no politician dares to go near yhe issue.
I would class myself as an animal lover, but that extends to the creatures that go through hell to end up in tins of petfood.
Animals are wonderful, fascinating creatures, but I don't flatter myself with their enforced capitvity in my home.

caramac04 · 22/12/2022 07:19

Florenz · 21/12/2022 17:05

Just ban the keeping of dogs as pets. There's no reason for it to be allowed. People can have cats or goldfish or hamsters or gerbils but not dogs as they cause too many problems.

You have won the award for the most stupid response

WiddlinDiddlin · 21/12/2022 23:14

ElephantInTheKitchen · 21/12/2022 19:50

Mandatory training classes perhaps, including a 'before you get your puppy'... though that still won't catch those that buy from dodgy mates,

A catch up programme would be entirely appropriate, for people who find themselves owning a dog - for instance because an elderly parent has died / gone into a care home, or (as in my case) a friend could no longer look after their adult dog. There's no point penalising such people.

These schemes always have a few that slip through the net - just as some drive without a driving licence. But on the whole such a scheme would improve things.

It's hard to know how you'd catch people without a licence though - you don't want to create a system where vets are enforcing it so some people avoid the vets. A lot of the enforcement would have to be around making it illegal to sell dog to someone unlicenced (where any money changing hands, including adoption fees, counts as a sale, but not to criminalise Doris with dementia going into a care home and giving the dog to her friend).

Yes, something like that, pre puppy classes/getting a rescue or second hand dog classes - of course regulation of trainers has to happen first.

There are places where you have to pass a national test to train, and where you have to pass one to own a dog (not sure where now, too much pain today for that).

We'd have to put the onus on buyers to ensure they're buying from a legal seller AND sellers to ensure they're selling to a legal owner - if you do it just one way (for example, it is illegal to sell a cropped dog but it is not illegal to buy one, you just claim you had no idea it was done in this country/say it is a rescue... all's well...)... then theres wiggle room!

It needs careful thought and input from actual dog people, unfortunately this government is not remotely good at listening to anyone, never mind dog people, and we are trying!

healthadvice123 · 21/12/2022 22:19

@Florenz i remember you from other dog threads
You think dogs should all just be killed and got rid off
Ridiculous

kc431 · 21/12/2022 20:45

Too many absolute bloody idiots are buying dogs (mainly since covid). I had a friend who bought a border collie off a dodgy breeder on a whim. She wanted to take it on long hikes. Obviously the dog spent the first 2 weeks biting her and being hyper. When she hired a trainer, the trainer basically told her off for doing NO research, and told her a puppy can’t do long walks because of their bones and also needs to sleep for many hours a day in a solid routine. Also that border collies need mental stimulation.

My friend came round my house whinging that the trainer was mean and “who does research before buying a dog anyway?!” 😂 I research before buying a new facewash!!! And she said if she’d known all that she wouldn’t have bought a dog.

After a few months she couldn’t cope with the dog (also her boyfriend was being aggressive to it) and rehomed it. Dog bit a child and got put down. Absolutely ridiculous story but sadly true. And my friend’s not an idiot on drugs and benefits, she has a PHD and a professional senior job.

I’m allergic to dogs and don’t feel comfortable around them. I hate that now every time I go to town they’re in every shop/cafe. I had a sneezing attack the other day after leaving a charity shop full of dogs, and some rude woman was like “I’ll avoid you, don’t want to catch whatever you have!”. It’s not Covid, it’s all the bloody dogs!

iolaus · 21/12/2022 20:33

emptythelitterbox · 20/12/2022 18:56

An 83 year old pensioner!
I wonder who the dog belonged to?
Said her son was injured and several in their 20s were arrested.
Her grandkids?

Story said it happened in Caterpilly just a mile from where the little boy was killed.
Is Caterpilly a trashy area?

It's less than a mile - the two streets are two streets apart from each other - they practically intersect (there's about 10 houses of another street between the two, which has the chip shop and corner shop)

Penyrheol - the area of Caerphilly - is a fairly deprived area but a very close knit community, the families probably would have known each other and it wouldn't surprise me if the dogs didn't come from the same breeder

ElephantInTheKitchen · 21/12/2022 19:50

Mandatory training classes perhaps, including a 'before you get your puppy'... though that still won't catch those that buy from dodgy mates,

A catch up programme would be entirely appropriate, for people who find themselves owning a dog - for instance because an elderly parent has died / gone into a care home, or (as in my case) a friend could no longer look after their adult dog. There's no point penalising such people.

These schemes always have a few that slip through the net - just as some drive without a driving licence. But on the whole such a scheme would improve things.

It's hard to know how you'd catch people without a licence though - you don't want to create a system where vets are enforcing it so some people avoid the vets. A lot of the enforcement would have to be around making it illegal to sell dog to someone unlicenced (where any money changing hands, including adoption fees, counts as a sale, but not to criminalise Doris with dementia going into a care home and giving the dog to her friend).

WiddlinDiddlin · 21/12/2022 18:35

I really wish I knew and its something me and my colleagues/other dog professionals have been debating and discussing for the last 20 years really.

Banning other breeds also doesn't help, you have to ban crossbreeds, DNA testing is not yet there so you have to go on appearances, hence the 'type' issue... (not an issue with the other three breeds banned because they didn't exist here at the time of the original ban).

As soon as you determine 'type' based on measurements, you are into territory where people buy a perfectly legal puppy.. and then it hits 6 months to 12 months old and suddenly has grown into illegal dog territory! In no other aspect of UK law can you become a criminal overnight like this!

Then you get dogs seized in the street who have never done anything wrong, with perfectly responsible owners, and the suffering goes on (dogs in secure secret kennels, not being handled or exercised, behaviour suffers, mental health suffers, physical health suffers, costs the taxpayer and the owner a fortune IF they actually get the dog back at all..).

Then off the baddies go, get another breed, turn that into a lethal weapon!

Regulating dog training/behaviour practitioners would help.
Banning (or legislating out via welfare requirements, say puppy farms need 1 employed person per 3 adult dogs, would cost too much to do, easy to check) puppy farms.
Mandatory training classes perhaps, including a 'before you get your puppy'... though that still won't catch those that buy from dodgy mates, it would give the legit people access to good information/education and something (certificate) to use to prove legit ownership, perhaps get a discount on insurance or some other 'carrot'...

Bingbangbongbash · 21/12/2022 18:19

Yes, but a swift kick and they’re not a problem anymore.

I don’t think you’ll be able to get rid of a cane corso as easily.

The owners are obviously to blame, but we can’t get rid of them, unfortunately.

Bingbangbongbash · 21/12/2022 18:17

I see your point - I hadn’t thought about this additional behaviour. But then what is the solution? I’d certainly feel happier for my dog if large, aggressive breeds were muzzled, if not for my kids.

And I’m a lifelong dog exploiter, with experience of several breeds (although never a dick extension breed).

Maybe we need to extend the banned breed list to include all bull / fighting dogs. There are plenty of animals it’s illegal to keep in residential areas, so why are dogs exempt?

I know not all bullies / akitas / cane corsos etc are nasty, but I’d wager that the crossover between these breeds and contemptible scum owners is pretty high. We (sadly) can’t do anything to the owners, so can’t we control the problem by getting rid of the dogs?