Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Another dog kills. When is something going to be done?

261 replies

ofwarren · 20/12/2022 15:15

AIBU to think that there needs to be a dog licence or at least SOMETHING put in place to try and prevent deaths by these dogs?
I was not at all surprised to read the breed..
"The dog, a large black XL bully cross cane corso breed, was seized by officers and has been destroyed."

metro.co.uk/2022/12/20/woman-dies-after-being-mauled-in-dog-attack-in-her-own-home-17970433/?ito=socialmetrouktwitter

OP posts:
ColdHandsHotHead · 20/12/2022 16:42

The problem is the culture of male inadequacy that sees these dogs as their dicks on a string to parade in public.

I haven't got any solutions, either.

rubybelles · 20/12/2022 16:37

Another death! I remember the thread with petition not so long ago.

DysonSpheres · 20/12/2022 16:36

I live in XL Bully ghetto heaven. There's tons of them. Usually owned by young men who take them out and join up with other young men friends who also have them. So you'll see a group of 7 or so young men with around 2 or 3 XL Bully's between them just hanging out or 'training' them in the kids playground during the evening, or the local green in the park.

They tie things to the trees to train their bite. You'll see those useless community police wardens or whatever just walk past them without saying a thing.

And frankly too many dogs owners in general seem to think they own the public parks and will have their dogs off-lead running full tilt across the grass when young children are on it walking and playing. I've had to grab my toddler niece and put her on my shoulders and change direction for fear that someone's staffy will confuse her for something threatening. She'd have no chance. So often I see an owner who can't call their dog back. Why is it off the lead, if it doesn't listen to you??

I'd like to see mandatory dog licences with special certification for owning stronger more 'dangerous' breeds. Also a banning of ownership of some breeds if you have young children.

ElephantInTheKitchen · 20/12/2022 16:33

Knockagain · 20/12/2022 16:22

Agree with this - far too many dogs now since lockdown. I went out for a walk to my local shops the other day and I passed 2 separate owners who had reactive, temperamental dogs that were growling and snarling at other dogs and the owners having to hold them tightly to stop them attacking. These weren’t even aggressive breeds of dogs but clearly the problem is the owners and I see it far too often.

Please don't assume that the person who is holding the lead is the one responsible for the behaviour problems.

There are lots of ways a dog can become reactive without it being that person's fault

  • in some cases they have a bad experience as a youngster and develop a lifelong fear (e.g. being attacked by abother dog), which leads them to bark to keep the scary things away.
  • sometimes there's crap breeding - for example breeding a couple of nervous dogs together. In utero experiences (e.g. a stressed mum) and the experiences during the first 8 weeks of life with a breeder are also really important.
  • sometimes people do everything right and just get a dog that's not quite wired right. I'm sure we can all think of a family with good parents, entirely normal siblings and then one sibling who has major mental health issues for no obvious reason.
  • some people have rescue dogs that came with issues pre-installed

In many cases the person holding the lead is trying to do all they can to help the dog and its issues.

I definitely judge crap training methods - anyone yanking a lead, bleating "no" at their dog, prong collars, choke chains, shock collars and so on, but having rescued a dog with behaviour issues I do try and give the benefit of the doubt over dogs with behaviour issues.

Bobshhh · 20/12/2022 16:30

LolaButt · 20/12/2022 15:53

What is it about these types of dogs who seem to turn on their own owners/families? Is it the genetic disposition of the dog, lack of socialisation or both?

I'd hazard a guess that the people who are attracted to owning a XL bully x cane corso are not the kind of people that invest a lot of time, money and energy in training their dogs... That combined with a genetic predisposition towards guarding and protecting is a pretty dangerous combo.

surreygirl1987 · 20/12/2022 16:28

I have no idea what the answer is, but this is why I get so annoyed with the amount of people who walk their dogs off leads. I know most breeds are much lower risk than the bull breeds but, to me, any animal is a risk for small children especially and should be on leads unless in private land with warnings that dogs are off lead

I fully agree!

SirSniffsAlot · 20/12/2022 16:23

The theory of pack leadership has been thoroughly debunked, including by the man who did the original research (Mech). It was based on some very flawed research looking at capitve wolves in an unnatural grouping (unrelated adults not a family, which created conflict... like a dysfunctional house share), then applied to a totally different species (dogs) and their interspecies interactions with a third unrelated species (humans). Pack leadership theory proponents will have you thinking the dog wants to sleep on the sofa because it wants to outrank the humans... back in the real world they actually want to be up there because it's more comfortable than the floor.

Absolutely right.

Plus, of course, dogs are not wolves. They may share ancestry but there are numerous differences in social behaviour between the two animals that means you cannot view wolf behaviour as being entirely replicated in a domestic dog.

Knockagain · 20/12/2022 16:22

ginghamstarfish · 20/12/2022 16:17

Something should be done, but it won't. There are far too many dogs, far too many stupid and irresponsible owners, and few places to go without the manky things running about slobbering and jumping on people at best, attacking people at worst. There should be some regulations and hurdles to owning animals which are let loose in public areas and can kill, but it will never happen.

Agree with this - far too many dogs now since lockdown. I went out for a walk to my local shops the other day and I passed 2 separate owners who had reactive, temperamental dogs that were growling and snarling at other dogs and the owners having to hold them tightly to stop them attacking. These weren’t even aggressive breeds of dogs but clearly the problem is the owners and I see it far too often.

ElephantInTheKitchen · 20/12/2022 16:21

ClarathecrosseyedLioness · 20/12/2022 16:10

@LolaButt What is it about these types of dogs who seem to turn on their own owners/families? Is it the genetic disposition of the dog, lack of socialisation or both?

Various factors IMO.

Dogs are pack animals, in nature they have a hierachy so humans need to replicate that by making sure the dog knows that you are the pack leader.

The Cane Corso is not banned in UK but it is unsuitable for novice dog owners. If crossed with a BullyXL it can weigh up to 200 lbs.

It is a working dog so it needs to be worked. That means owners taking time out to devise games/training for these dogs to stop them getting bored..
Unfortunately, usually, the type of owners these dogs attract aren't really inclined to engage these activities.

The theory of pack leadership has been thoroughly debunked, including by the man who did the original research (Mech). It was based on some very flawed research looking at capitve wolves in an unnatural grouping (unrelated adults not a family, which created conflict... like a dysfunctional house share), then applied to a totally different species (dogs) and their interspecies interactions with a third unrelated species (humans). Pack leadership theory proponents will have you thinking the dog wants to sleep on the sofa because it wants to outrank the humans... back in the real world they actually want to be up there because it's more comfortable than the floor.

I'll agree with you that these dogs are unsuitable for the novice, and that they need a lot of physical and mental exercise which they often don't get enough of. Mine is a much smaller working breed and if he's underexercised he starts to go stir crazy and make a complete nuisance of himself, including being more prone to snapping - basically he just ends up on a shorter fuse. I can absolutely see the same happening with some of these dogs.

Oysterbabe · 20/12/2022 16:20

It's always this breed at the moment isn't it? They should be banned and destroyed, no one needs a dog like this.

ginghamstarfish · 20/12/2022 16:17

Something should be done, but it won't. There are far too many dogs, far too many stupid and irresponsible owners, and few places to go without the manky things running about slobbering and jumping on people at best, attacking people at worst. There should be some regulations and hurdles to owning animals which are let loose in public areas and can kill, but it will never happen.

DashboardConfessional · 20/12/2022 16:13

LolaButt · 20/12/2022 15:53

What is it about these types of dogs who seem to turn on their own owners/families? Is it the genetic disposition of the dog, lack of socialisation or both?

I've had a very bad-tempered rescue border terrier in the family but honestly smaller dogs don't tend to cause enough damage to make the news. I think it's a combination of the type of owner (buys them as a status symbol and then kicks them about), their size and genetics.

SirSniffsAlot · 20/12/2022 16:12

What is it about these types of dogs who seem to turn on their own owners/families? Is it the genetic disposition of the dog, lack of socialisation or both?

The biggest predictor of aggression in dogs is a history of neglect or abuse. It's not just lack of socialisation (though no doubt that was present) it is also a history of being hit or shouted at, threatened, or simply having their boundaries run over time and time again and no one in the home with enough knowledge to recognise the multiple warning signals given out until eventually the dog stops trying to warn anyone because no noe is listening anyway.

Breed traits do exists but when we look at dogs like this one, breed is hard to define. Not only are they a mixed breed, they will be a product of several generations of poorly discipliend breeding across multiple breeds and individuals. Each breeding pair 'selected' for the wrong reasons: resulting in dogs that can have a range of poor or unstable behavioural traits that are less dorectly connected to breed and more directly connected to a generational history of bad breeding choices.

ClarathecrosseyedLioness · 20/12/2022 16:10

@LolaButt What is it about these types of dogs who seem to turn on their own owners/families? Is it the genetic disposition of the dog, lack of socialisation or both?

Various factors IMO.

Dogs are pack animals, in nature they have a hierachy so humans need to replicate that by making sure the dog knows that you are the pack leader.

The Cane Corso is not banned in UK but it is unsuitable for novice dog owners. If crossed with a BullyXL it can weigh up to 200 lbs.

It is a working dog so it needs to be worked. That means owners taking time out to devise games/training for these dogs to stop them getting bored..
Unfortunately, usually, the type of owners these dogs attract aren't really inclined to engage these activities.

LolaButt · 20/12/2022 16:08

Thank you for the informative responses. I have a small dog, who I could never imagine turning on one of us as he reacts with a lot of licking etc if his teeth graze your arm by accident.

I think it just blows my mind that people deliberately train dogs to be aggressive.

TheLittlestLightOnTheXmasTree · 20/12/2022 16:06

Prescottdanni123 · 20/12/2022 15:51

While these attacks are very rare, I'd be happy to have dog licences introduced to prevent these things from happening. And I am saying that as a dog owner. .

It would also reduce the amount of animal abuse cases there are as well.

Yes me too!!

It used to be a thing

TheLittlestLightOnTheXmasTree · 20/12/2022 16:06

QuestionableMouse · 20/12/2022 15:50

Tougher rules or dog licences won't work, because the sort of people who have these types of dog won't adhere to them any more than they do the current rules now.

That's like saying there's no point in having police though

If it makes people think twice then it improves the situation slightly

ElephantInTheKitchen · 20/12/2022 16:05

Dog licences in the past have just been a fee which people paid, or didn't, much like a TV licence. Paying a sum of money does nothing to make people more responsible.

A dog licence run like a driving licence (education and a test) would improve matters but is hardly a panacea (look how many people drivers kill per year...)

If we're being honest though, it's not dogs in general, XL Bullies and American Bulldogs are vastly overrepresented in the figures - out of 16 fatal dog attacks in the UK 2020-22, 9 have included those breeds or crosses thereof
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fatal_dog_attacks_in_the_United_Kingdom

Those breeds have a nasty tendency to attract the sort of person who wants to intimidate others with their dog's presence. Betty, 86, who wants a companion, does not acquire an XL Bully, she gets a bichon frise.

Breed specific legislation has been really poorly implemented over the last 30 years, and has led to very young puppies and adult dogs alike being put down without having put a paw wrong. Compulsory sterilisation and a temperament test to determine if they should wear a muzzle in public... I could get behind that.

Dogs being off lead has fuck all to do with it either - all the dog attacks this decade involved a dog known to the person (invariably their own dog or a family members) and it usually happens in the house. The only exception this decade was someone killed by their neighbours dogs which escaped - again, it wouldn't have been helped by dogs being on lead in the local park.

YourApplePie · 20/12/2022 16:04

This isn't new - when I was a kid, people were worried about rottweilers and alsatians.

HashBrownandBeans · 20/12/2022 16:03

Iam4eels · 20/12/2022 15:22

I think any controls would need to be carefully applied to minimise the trade of black market dogs but I'd personally like to see minimum space requirements for dogs (all animals really) so you can't have big breeds in small spaces, restrictions on breeding, and restrictions on where/how you can buy a dog especially a dog that is being rehomed.

I’m not sure that space is the answer, I have giant dogs in a semi and they are lazy hounds who sleep 22 hours a day. They don’t have an aggressive bone in their bodies. Maybe controls relevant to the type of dog/the job they were bred for would be more apt

Kolakalia · 20/12/2022 16:00

LolaButt · 20/12/2022 15:53

What is it about these types of dogs who seem to turn on their own owners/families? Is it the genetic disposition of the dog, lack of socialisation or both?

Both.

Even the most well trained and raised dog has intrinsic traits due to years and years of breeding for those traits. And all of the training and love in the world won't eliminate every dog from snapping.

You should look into the anti-pitbull information online, very enlightening. You hear 'it's the human not the dog!' so often when it just isn't always the case. Even if you purchase a tiny puppy and raise them right there's still a chance of them snapping. They're animals. They operate on instinct some of the time.

I honestly think having one of these dogs (pitbulls, bullys, cane corsos etc.) in your house is like keeping a loaded gun around. Especially with children. I'd like to see possession of a dangerous dog as an automatic flag for social services involvement and it a condition of keeping the children to remove the risk. I know it'll never happen but when you see reports of toddlers and babies being killed again and again by these dogs it's just sickening to think their parents put them in that position.

Prescottdanni123 · 20/12/2022 15:59

@LolaButt

Being bred or trained to be aggressive can really mess up a dog's brain. A dog that has aggression trained into it are often deeply unhappy animals, which is understandable. Who wants to be grumpy and angry all the time? And the people who breed these animals to be this way are pretty unpleasant too otherwise they wouldn't do it. So they may use abusive methods of getting the dogs to act a certain way. And they qon't be properly socialised in some cases, they will be semi wild.

Newwardrobe · 20/12/2022 15:58

This is so sad . Unfortunately some owners have these dogs as a status symbol and do nothing to train their animals, they think it's funny when their dog goes for someone or another dog (we have a man near us who laughs when he's challenged about his aggressive dog) . It's the mindset of some owners that no amount of rules or licenses will change.

ILoveeCakes · 20/12/2022 15:55

Some people will always find a way to come to harm or to commit harm.

Remove the dog and they will just find other poor decisions to make to fill the void.

Naunet · 20/12/2022 15:55

LolaButt · 20/12/2022 15:53

What is it about these types of dogs who seem to turn on their own owners/families? Is it the genetic disposition of the dog, lack of socialisation or both?

Or bad ownership?! Humans are often not innocent in these attacks.

Swipe left for the next trending thread