Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you spend alot or lose half?!

135 replies

MenCanGetInTheBin · 20/12/2022 13:33

I am looking for somewhere to vent..

So me and my BF have been seeing each other since March.

He is a member of a drinks society and they have monthly member get togethers, christmas, new year parties etc.

He usually goes to the new year party every year as he really enjoys it and would usually go with ex (she isnt a member, so wont be there). He asked if I wanted to go this year, I said yes. I was a bit annoyed when I found out him and his ex went every year but he assures me it wasnt their thing, its his thing, he likes the event, and wants to share that with me.

So he purchased the tickets. I assumed, probably very wrongly of me, that he would pay for these tickets but he has told me the tickets are £150 each and to pay him back when I can. He also said we could get a taxi there and back (for reference, this company is in Edinburgh which will be swarmed with the big street party). He just got a taxi quote for £180 one way!! So we will have to bus it there and taxi back (The buses stop early).

He said it finishes at 1am (I thought it would go on longer given the price!!) and we can either walk the streets until 6am for the bus, or go to a club.. but that would mean walking the streets for 2 hours afterwards as clubs close at 3/4am).

I didnt sound keen after this ... £300 each for a 3 course dinner (a drink or two) and a taxi sounds crazy expensive. Thats not even taking into account if we buy more drinks, which of course we will. I simply cannot justfiy spending between £300-£400 on one night. He is a big earner but I am not and although I could spend this money it would mean budgeting the rest of the month which I dont want to do.

He has said he can enquire into cancelling but what if he can't? then I still need to fork out half the money and not attend.. I dont know what to do.

He is very much everything should be split 50/50 which I get but when someone is earning double, I think it changes things slightly.

What would you do?? I feel really annoyed when I should be excited that its our first new year together.

x

OP posts:
musingsinmidlife · 20/12/2022 17:17

SHNBV · 20/12/2022 17:09

You should be rethinking this relationship. If he wants things to be equal costs should be split in relation to what you earn.

My OH earnt more than double what I did when we started dating. It was important to both of us that we lived within our means, so I tended to pay for smaller items and he paid for the more expensive things, such as weekends away. We always knew upfront who was paying for what.

You didn't live within your means, you lived above your means but he paid for it.

I make a good salary and not a chance I am bankrolling any guy I date who doesn't make as much money. I don't care how much he (or this board) complains I am a walking red flag because I don't pay for everything for him since I have more...he can pay for himself or leave. If I want a dependent for me to look after and take care of, there are plants, pets, and children. In a partner, I want an equal who takes on adult responsibilities.

XanaduKira · 20/12/2022 17:15

The more you update Op, the more it sounds like he is a gaslighter. I'd say run for the hills, sorry!

You deserve better.

rookiemere · 20/12/2022 17:14

SomethingOriginal2 · 20/12/2022 17:00

He said he would have paid for the taxi - this really got my back up, he didnt offer that at the time and is now saying that.

Ah gotta love a gasslighting mf.

And I bet any amount of money- say £150 - that he never told the OP the price of the tickets originally, it's not an amount that you're likely to forget, so more gaslighting there.

XanaduKira · 20/12/2022 17:12

StickyCricket · 20/12/2022 13:46

It sounds shit, traipsing the streets for hours to save a cab fare. Grim.

I’d cancel, making it clear that “I didn’t expect the tickets to be so expensive and to be honest I have no interest in spending New Year’s Eve hanging around on the streets for several hours to save money on a ride home. I’m afraid I’ll have to give it a miss. I hope you’re able to get a refund or find someone to take your spare ticket”.

Bet you he doesn’t go in his own. He clearly just wants someone to split the cost of a taxi with. Cheapskate.

I think you're spot on here.

Choconut · 20/12/2022 17:11

I think he's constantly testing you to make sure you're not after his money. He keeps talking about splitting big costs and you paying for your ticket but it seems to be 'when you can' - very vague. Like he's not really bothered about you paying him back but wants to make sure that you would be prepared to pay him back.

No one wants to be constantly tested and it's very confusing when he says it's not about money - when he's clearly obsessed about money. I think you need a big conversation about this but it could be an ongoing issue that's difficult to resolve.

SHNBV · 20/12/2022 17:09

You should be rethinking this relationship. If he wants things to be equal costs should be split in relation to what you earn.

My OH earnt more than double what I did when we started dating. It was important to both of us that we lived within our means, so I tended to pay for smaller items and he paid for the more expensive things, such as weekends away. We always knew upfront who was paying for what.

Vimto1 · 20/12/2022 17:05

I think you should have confirmed the price before agreeing. It does sound like you were just expecting him to pay - how would upu have felt if he did pay and then you found out the costs? That's a lot of money and I wouldn't be comfortable not contributing.

Having Said that, the travel and logistics sound awful. I'd explain your mistaken assumption and pull out.

misskatamari · 20/12/2022 17:03

So many red flags with this one. I’d be seriously rethinking the relationship

SomethingOriginal2 · 20/12/2022 17:00

He said he would have paid for the taxi - this really got my back up, he didnt offer that at the time and is now saying that.

Ah gotta love a gasslighting mf.

babyjellyfish · 20/12/2022 16:59

MenCanGetInTheBin · 20/12/2022 16:50

Tickets have been cancelled.
He said he would have paid for the taxi - this really got my back up, he didnt offer that at the time and is now saying that. He then said he would happily rebook the tickets, pay for taxi back if it was something I was really interested in but it isnt.. I asked why he didnt cancel this a few weeks ago when I wasnt too happy about the event in the first place.
Now we are having a heated discussion about what is fair / 50/50% / equality etc. I've told him if I was interested in only his money then I would have gone way back as he doesnt pay for everything nor buy me stuff so I dont like that he said he isnt a "bottomless pit".

Wow, what a charmer.

I would bin him off, OP, it sounds like you're completely incompatible.

SomethingOriginal2 · 20/12/2022 16:59

He said he would have paid for the taxi - this really got my back up, he didnt offer that at the time and is now saying that.

Valhalla17 · 20/12/2022 16:54

Not sure why you both didn't book a b&b for the night....or if this is an annual members event that he's goes to each year he must "know people". So he could have arranged an air bnb or something for a group of you to keep costs down etc. Xmas Confused

skeemee · 20/12/2022 16:54

Or the doubletree Hilton at the airport is £130 ish? If West edinburgh is better?

gemsgv · 20/12/2022 16:54

Premier inn £107 Edinburgh new years eve

NoelNoNoel · 20/12/2022 16:51

I bet he wouldn’t have paid for the taxi, he had plenty of opportunity to tell you if that was his intention.

MenCanGetInTheBin · 20/12/2022 16:50

Tickets have been cancelled.
He said he would have paid for the taxi - this really got my back up, he didnt offer that at the time and is now saying that. He then said he would happily rebook the tickets, pay for taxi back if it was something I was really interested in but it isnt.. I asked why he didnt cancel this a few weeks ago when I wasnt too happy about the event in the first place.
Now we are having a heated discussion about what is fair / 50/50% / equality etc. I've told him if I was interested in only his money then I would have gone way back as he doesnt pay for everything nor buy me stuff so I dont like that he said he isnt a "bottomless pit".

OP posts:
skeemee · 20/12/2022 16:44

Hi @MenCanGetInTheBin
i live in Edinburgh. You could book the premier inn at Newhaven for £100 ish. The Hogmanay buses seem to be running til 4am for £5.
Definitely cheaper than a taxi home! You can do the loony dook in the morning. Brrr

Would you spend alot or lose half?!
ApocalypseNowt · 20/12/2022 16:39

Blurgh, he sounds like a complete dud. Get rid OP & don't look back.

YoBeaches · 20/12/2022 16:39

He sounds like a bit of a div to be honest. Especially given equality doesn't mean split everything 50/50. what a twat.

OP you sure you don't wanna start the new year without this loser?!

rookiemere · 20/12/2022 16:37

OP if it wasn't for the fact DH would think I was somewhat weird extending the offer to a random mumsnetter I've never met, I'd happily let you crash at our Edinburgh pad for free.

Not sure about your stingy arse BF though.

BelaBartok · 20/12/2022 16:36

wow!!! @Movinghouseatlast

This sounds like my friends brother. She is a teacher, he is extremely wealthy- worth 20 million plus. When their dad died he chose some flowers for the funeral from a high society London florist. He sent her a bill for half despite not consulting her on the cost or choice of flowers. He is a cunt and so is your boyfriend.

I hope she didn't pay or only gave him half of what a reasonable amount would've been to spend. What a class A !!

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 20/12/2022 16:33

@SomethingOriginal2 agree with what you have said. OP break up with him before he drains you out of your money. You shouldve asked for the cost, but after reading all your posts, it coms across that he is tight and is deliberately using you. He mustve got used in his last relationship, he is now taking it out on you. He is not ready for a relationship. You deserve better.

pocketvenuss · 20/12/2022 16:30

I think it's healthy to share costs but I also think it's nice to be taken out sometimes. I would have assumed this would have been his treat as it's his thing he is inviting you to. No way would I assume he would expect you to pay. If you were inviting him to an event of yours I would think you would pay. If you two were going out together to something that is neither his or yours, like the theatre or a holiday then I would expect to split costs but it would seem natural that as a much higher earner. That he would cover a little more than you

mcmooberry · 20/12/2022 16:21

Glad to hear you can cancel the tickets. I would have lost the £150 rather than paying all that for one (miserable sounding with the walking around in the cold) night out. He sounds very ungenerous though.

babyjellyfish · 20/12/2022 16:19

MenCanGetInTheBin · 20/12/2022 14:05

So have said I find its unreasonable etc he is insisting he told me costs - so either I am just creating a drama or I've forgotten the convo. He is cancelling the tickets. He keeps saying money isnt important to him, equality is.

Well it's good that he's cancelling the tickets. That solves your NYE problem at least.

In the longer term, I'd be doing some soul searching about how compatible you really are. It sounds like his idea of equality is splitting every expense 50/50 down to the last penny.

Well, that's fine in the short term, but then he needs to accept that as a couple you can only do things which are within your budget, not his.

And in the longer term, he needs to understand that splitting everything 50/50 when one person has a much higher income than the other doesn't result in equality, it results in the lower earning partner having much less disposable income as they struggle to keep up with the higher earning partner's spending habits.

What happens if and when you want to buy a house together? Will he be content to live somewhere that is within the budget of a couple both earning what you earn?

What happens if and when you have children together? Will he still expect you to contribute 50/50 if you experience a loss in income due to taking maternity leave? Or will you go back to work as soon as your maternity pay drops to a lower level to ensure you don't lose any income and ensure he pays 50% of your joint childcare costs?

Will you ever get married? What happens if one of you gets ill or becomes disabled? What happens if you have a disabled child which means that one of you has to be a stay at home parent?

As I said, splitting everything 50/50 when you're in a relatively new relationship is fine as long as it isn't putting the lower earning partner in a position of undue hardship trying to keep up. But it's worth thinking about how his attitude towards money would play out in the long term, if you decide to commit to shared home ownership, marriage and/or kids. In my experience, dividing everything down to the last penny just doesn't work, and the lower earning partner ends up massively worse off.

Swipe left for the next trending thread