Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you spend alot or lose half?!

135 replies

MenCanGetInTheBin · 20/12/2022 13:33

I am looking for somewhere to vent..

So me and my BF have been seeing each other since March.

He is a member of a drinks society and they have monthly member get togethers, christmas, new year parties etc.

He usually goes to the new year party every year as he really enjoys it and would usually go with ex (she isnt a member, so wont be there). He asked if I wanted to go this year, I said yes. I was a bit annoyed when I found out him and his ex went every year but he assures me it wasnt their thing, its his thing, he likes the event, and wants to share that with me.

So he purchased the tickets. I assumed, probably very wrongly of me, that he would pay for these tickets but he has told me the tickets are £150 each and to pay him back when I can. He also said we could get a taxi there and back (for reference, this company is in Edinburgh which will be swarmed with the big street party). He just got a taxi quote for £180 one way!! So we will have to bus it there and taxi back (The buses stop early).

He said it finishes at 1am (I thought it would go on longer given the price!!) and we can either walk the streets until 6am for the bus, or go to a club.. but that would mean walking the streets for 2 hours afterwards as clubs close at 3/4am).

I didnt sound keen after this ... £300 each for a 3 course dinner (a drink or two) and a taxi sounds crazy expensive. Thats not even taking into account if we buy more drinks, which of course we will. I simply cannot justfiy spending between £300-£400 on one night. He is a big earner but I am not and although I could spend this money it would mean budgeting the rest of the month which I dont want to do.

He has said he can enquire into cancelling but what if he can't? then I still need to fork out half the money and not attend.. I dont know what to do.

He is very much everything should be split 50/50 which I get but when someone is earning double, I think it changes things slightly.

What would you do?? I feel really annoyed when I should be excited that its our first new year together.

x

OP posts:
RandomPerson42 · 20/12/2022 20:59

I may be old-fashioned but he invited you without telling you you’d have to pay for anything so he should have paid for it all imho.

LimeCheesecake · 20/12/2022 20:50

OP - you have two choices really, either you just end it now, or you tell him what you earn. And even a “and after rent and bills paid, I have x left over each month for fun money”. Be clear if he wants to go halves on things, they need to be affordable to you, not just him. He can’t both be determined to stop you being after his money, while also spending yours for you.

but he doesn’t sound very nice overall.

MrsTerryPratchett · 20/12/2022 20:47

He keeps saying money isnt important to him, equality is.

I once dated a bloke who earned high 6 figures when I was working in homeless shelters. His idea of equality was great. I'd take him out somewhere nice I could afford (Pizza Express). He'd take be out someone nice he could affrord (The Ivy). We both treated, we both picked up the bill, we were both thoughtful and kind. But he paid more because he earned more.

Yours should either only date wealthy women, or assume he's at Pizza Express with you. There is no middle ground without you worrying endlessly about money.

Also he sounds mean so he's probably shit in bed. Make sure you add up the number of orgasms and keep a tally for later.

Ilovetea33 · 20/12/2022 20:40

New year, new beginnings - get rid of him, this won't get any better. And just the idea that he wanted you to traipse round the cold streets for at least two hours instead of booking a nice room somewhere - completely ridiculous.

DinaFox · 20/12/2022 20:21

@musingsinmidlife I think you're projecting quite a bit here. Surely the point is that if you want your partner to have the same level of disposable income as you then you would date somebody who earned a similar amount so that things could be split 50/50? That is not the case in the OP's situation. Her partner knows that she earns less than him, and he still attempted to get her to pay for a very expensive night out of his choosing without even giving her details of the full cost upfront so she could make an informed decision.

That's unfair and not the actions of a person who cares about you. I would never presume that someone can just afford to pay £400 for something and go ahead and make bookings without checking with them-never mind my partner who earns less than me.

declutteringmymind · 20/12/2022 20:14

Tbh I think you and him don't share the same values. He doesn't appreciate equitable agreements and doesn't value your relationship above valuing the cost of everything. Job titles and shit seem to matter to him whereas they don't for you.

This will likely lead to him
Holding his earnings over you all the time.

It's always going to be a sticking point I'm afraid.

musingsinmidlife · 20/12/2022 19:46

DreamingOfAGreenChristmas · 20/12/2022 18:29

Does this mean you are happy to peg the quality of your life that is affordable to a partner who earns less? Stay in a Travelodge because that is their budget when you would normally book something 5*?

Or would you only date someone of similar means and willingness to spend?

I wouldn't date anyone who wasn't a financially independent adult with sufficient disposable cash to be able to afford a similar lifestyle to mine. I don't live lavishly and put most in savings so it doesn't have to be the same income. More important is the attitude for me. I don't care that much about the money itself or how much something costs but I have no interest in being with someone whose attitude is well you have more so you should pay for me. I am not interested in a relationship with a financial dependent or someone who sees me as a wallet. I often happily pay for others - but not because they expect me to because I have money and therefore there is the assumption that I foot the bills. I also have no interest in being with anyone with a much higher income who thinks I should be financially dependent on them or who won't let me pay or who doesn't see me as an equal.

NoelNoNoel · 20/12/2022 19:40

He must have known the expensive taxi situation but he chose not to mention this when he invited you.

courgettigreensadwater · 20/12/2022 19:12

With all the extra bits you've added he does sound like a twat and I'd bin him off. Calling you and HR manager when he knows you're not. Is he embarrassed?! Nob.

forrestgreen · 20/12/2022 18:42

I think he's tight, he wanted his ex and you to go so you can share his taxi costs.

If the relationship is worth the effort, tell him next time he suggests something to tell you the costs in full so you can make a judgement call. Or if he ever treats you, to also let you know...

Stopthebusplease · 20/12/2022 18:42

I'd dump the tight git OP! He should have told you he expected you to pay half when he invited you, not just bought the tickets and then told you how much it was all going to cost! As for not giving you bank details and letting what you owe him build up, and then asking for money for things he'd said he'll pay for, .......... well, to me that's just absolutely tight and disgusting. Dump him, before the event, and then he can either lose his money or find some one else who earns mega bucks and can afford to go with him. What an arse!

DreamingOfAGreenChristmas · 20/12/2022 18:29

musingsinmidlife · 20/12/2022 17:17

You didn't live within your means, you lived above your means but he paid for it.

I make a good salary and not a chance I am bankrolling any guy I date who doesn't make as much money. I don't care how much he (or this board) complains I am a walking red flag because I don't pay for everything for him since I have more...he can pay for himself or leave. If I want a dependent for me to look after and take care of, there are plants, pets, and children. In a partner, I want an equal who takes on adult responsibilities.

Does this mean you are happy to peg the quality of your life that is affordable to a partner who earns less? Stay in a Travelodge because that is their budget when you would normally book something 5*?

Or would you only date someone of similar means and willingness to spend?

BelaBartok · 20/12/2022 18:20

So, he has told you what he earns but you haven't told him how much you earn? You mentioned upthread that he earns twice as much as you do.

My DH's friend works for a charity - he earns £200K/yr (this isn't the kind of charity that gets donations from the public but it is still a charity). Do you think there is any chance he thinks you earn about the same as him and has therefore overestimated your disposable income?

The doesn't affect how I read his invitation to his event though - I've invited people to things that are 'my events' and I have paid for their tickets (despite earning less in some cases).

SomethingOriginal2 · 20/12/2022 18:12

MenCanGetInTheBin · 20/12/2022 17:30

Exactly. I would have remembered that amount, definitely. When he told me a few weeks ago I was very surprised. But, opinion is mixed and I agree with both. I should have asked about the costs beforehand but I thought it was more of an invite without cost being mentioned. If I found out the cost later on, I would have felt bad and would probably have offered to pay for my ticket. If I invite anyone anywhere and expect them to pay their ticket / meal whatever, I mention cost up front and see if they are happy with it.
Yes, the taxi comment has annoyed me. He said he would have paid if I really wanted to go but refused to cancel or give the ticket to someone else when I said I didnt want to go a few weeks back as I felt a bit annoyed (maybe jealous) that him and his ex went all the time. If he wanted to pay for the taxi, he would have and wouldnt have cancelled the event. I havent told him what I earn but reminded him that I work in a charity in an HR department - so not earning mega bucks. I also told him to stop calling me "an HR manager" as he is bigging up my title and it probably makes him think I get paid more than what I do. To confirm, I have never once called myself the HR Manager - I am an advisor, he tells people I am the manager as he said he doesnt know the difference and I couldbe manager if I wanted (erm.. okay).

I reckon he tells people you're a manager because he thinks your actual job is beneath him.

anotherdayanotheralias · 20/12/2022 18:00

He doesn't know the difference between a lower paid advisor and a well paid manager? Well, that's either dense or a lie. Sounds like he'd prefer a higher earning girlfriend so he doesn't have to ever subsidise her and keep it strictly 50/50. However, if he wants to date you and include you in the expensive events he wants to attend then he'll have to be kinder (and more honest) about it.

Are you spending Christmas with him?

everydayisthesame · 20/12/2022 17:57

Sounds to me like he has been used for money previously so is cautious, I was the same when I first met DH. I would explain your financial situation and suggest a night in with a take away, which will not have too much of an impact and see what he says. If he wants equality he will be happy with the suggestion as it doesn't put one party, you, in financial hardship. If he still wants to go, or do something extravagant then it's not about equality, it's about him protecting his money but living to his means without you, which is fair enough but you will need to discuss if a future is realistic given the difference in earnings.

2bazookas · 20/12/2022 17:55

Whoah there. This is his event that he invited you to. He asked you on a date , you're only going to please him; he pays for you.

He pays for a hotel too. so after the do, you go to the hotel for the rest of the night and travel home the next day. No taxi required.

If that doesn't suit him, just say you changed your mind and won't be going.

Magenta82 · 20/12/2022 17:46

OP I really can't see a future in this, if I were you I would be seriously considering breaking up with him

janeeyreair · 20/12/2022 17:42

So now he is suddenly saying he would have paid for a taxi? Convenient now the whole thing is cancelled.

I can't believe he expected the pair of you to walk around in the freezing cold for 5 hours! He sounds tight, that sounds absolutely nuts. Even 2 hours walking round is 2 hours too much.

Purplecatshopaholic · 20/12/2022 17:40

Sounds very money and status oriented op, and that’s before we get onto the gaslighting and tight wad attitude. People like this are not nice people. He’s not a keeper

XanaduKira · 20/12/2022 17:36

I agree @Iwantamarshmallowman

Op he sounds worse and worse the more you write - total snob trying to imply that your own role isn't good enough & so he has to give you a more senior job title. Unbelievable!

emptythelitterbox · 20/12/2022 17:34

I'm really curious about how much money this high roller earns?

Iwantamarshmallowman · 20/12/2022 17:30

What happends if you end up staying with him and maybe having kids? Will it all be 50/50 then? what about when you go on maternity or what if you get sick and can't work, would he support you?
There are loads of threads on here atm where men are exspecting woman to pay half of eveything dispite earing much less due to childcare. On a recent thred he was a high earner and pissing his money away but she could bearly afford to feed herself or her child becuase she was only working part-time and he demanded she pay half of eveything and refused to contribute to childcare.
it's not equality at all. Relationships are about supporting each other not about keeping count. personally I think he sounds horrible.

MenCanGetInTheBin · 20/12/2022 17:30

rookiemere · 20/12/2022 17:14

And I bet any amount of money- say £150 - that he never told the OP the price of the tickets originally, it's not an amount that you're likely to forget, so more gaslighting there.

Exactly. I would have remembered that amount, definitely. When he told me a few weeks ago I was very surprised. But, opinion is mixed and I agree with both. I should have asked about the costs beforehand but I thought it was more of an invite without cost being mentioned. If I found out the cost later on, I would have felt bad and would probably have offered to pay for my ticket. If I invite anyone anywhere and expect them to pay their ticket / meal whatever, I mention cost up front and see if they are happy with it.
Yes, the taxi comment has annoyed me. He said he would have paid if I really wanted to go but refused to cancel or give the ticket to someone else when I said I didnt want to go a few weeks back as I felt a bit annoyed (maybe jealous) that him and his ex went all the time. If he wanted to pay for the taxi, he would have and wouldnt have cancelled the event. I havent told him what I earn but reminded him that I work in a charity in an HR department - so not earning mega bucks. I also told him to stop calling me "an HR manager" as he is bigging up my title and it probably makes him think I get paid more than what I do. To confirm, I have never once called myself the HR Manager - I am an advisor, he tells people I am the manager as he said he doesnt know the difference and I couldbe manager if I wanted (erm.. okay).

OP posts:
CherrySmiler · 20/12/2022 17:22

Treat yourself to a Christmas present - leave him. I can only echo what others have said. What a stingy individual. You deserve better. Someone that would be happy to spend all they had on you even if you’re not expecting it. Best of luck. I hope you put yourself first. There are much better people out there.