Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you spend alot or lose half?!

135 replies

MenCanGetInTheBin · 20/12/2022 13:33

I am looking for somewhere to vent..

So me and my BF have been seeing each other since March.

He is a member of a drinks society and they have monthly member get togethers, christmas, new year parties etc.

He usually goes to the new year party every year as he really enjoys it and would usually go with ex (she isnt a member, so wont be there). He asked if I wanted to go this year, I said yes. I was a bit annoyed when I found out him and his ex went every year but he assures me it wasnt their thing, its his thing, he likes the event, and wants to share that with me.

So he purchased the tickets. I assumed, probably very wrongly of me, that he would pay for these tickets but he has told me the tickets are £150 each and to pay him back when I can. He also said we could get a taxi there and back (for reference, this company is in Edinburgh which will be swarmed with the big street party). He just got a taxi quote for £180 one way!! So we will have to bus it there and taxi back (The buses stop early).

He said it finishes at 1am (I thought it would go on longer given the price!!) and we can either walk the streets until 6am for the bus, or go to a club.. but that would mean walking the streets for 2 hours afterwards as clubs close at 3/4am).

I didnt sound keen after this ... £300 each for a 3 course dinner (a drink or two) and a taxi sounds crazy expensive. Thats not even taking into account if we buy more drinks, which of course we will. I simply cannot justfiy spending between £300-£400 on one night. He is a big earner but I am not and although I could spend this money it would mean budgeting the rest of the month which I dont want to do.

He has said he can enquire into cancelling but what if he can't? then I still need to fork out half the money and not attend.. I dont know what to do.

He is very much everything should be split 50/50 which I get but when someone is earning double, I think it changes things slightly.

What would you do?? I feel really annoyed when I should be excited that its our first new year together.

x

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DreamingOfAGreenChristmas · 21/12/2022 20:36

Well...his home made gifts could be bottles of flavoured vodka, and he might have bought great jewellery for the rest...

OP, some of it does sound like communication difficulties to me, and it might be that your ensuing long exchanges have helped sort some of it out. He did at least apologise. And gave some context about his ex.

'My treat' is a phrase, isn't it? Like 'my shout' in a pub? Is it different to him having invited you as his guest on the first place?

Tell him about the Spa day voucher and all - it's a true explanation.

This might be a speed hump, or you might have the permanent ick now. Onl;y you can know.

Nolosomi · 21/12/2022 16:50

Oh no OP, this is just awful. I could not be with someone like this, my ex was like this and it was so horrible. I much prefer an organic approach to finances when dating and once it starts being argued/discussed like this it ruins everything because you’ll never be able to relax without wondering if he’s mentally clocking up the pennies and pounds. The ‘I work harder’ comment is what my ex said when I’d used an earnings calculator (look online) to work out the percentage of what we should each pay based on our income for things (it was 60/40) he said it ‘wasn’t fair as he worked ‘harder’ than me’. Truly awful and demeaning.

He sounds like he has issues still about his ex, or is just a tight wad, or likes to control you with money issues. I would have to exit the relationship - all the joy gets sucked out of life with partners/people like this.

XanaduKira · 21/12/2022 16:08

LimeCheesecake · 21/12/2022 14:19

Darling, it’s not supposed to be this hard work at such an early stage of dating. You two aren’t really compatible, are at different life /career stages and he doesn’t seem to have got over his ex. Let this one go.

Well said! Sorry Op but you'd be much better off without him.

MenCanGetInTheBin · 21/12/2022 16:03

AdelaideRo · 21/12/2022 11:32

Did he actually invite you so you stay at your flat and avoid the travel costs?

If you live in Edinburgh you must know that most people end up walking long distances at Hogmanay?

(Thinks back pitifully to the year she walked home to Cramond from city centre, 2 years ago I ended up walking from Blackhall to Cramond because our cab cancelled and we couldn't get another one booked).

I dont live in Edinburgh if I did, I would be staying there and telling him to aswell!
I live in another City in Scotland, there is more than 1.

OP posts:
WinterDeWinter · 21/12/2022 15:23

Movinghouseatlast · 20/12/2022 15:24

This sounds like my friends brother. She is a teacher, he is extremely wealthy- worth 20 million plus. When their dad died he chose some flowers for the funeral from a high society London florist. He sent her a bill for half despite not consulting her on the cost or choice of flowers. He is a cunt and so is your boyfriend.

However, this Air BnB property is available and it would save you walking the streets waiting for the buses to start.
abnb.me/iKLSjzuPUvb

This poster is correct.

LimeCheesecake · 21/12/2022 14:19

Darling, it’s not supposed to be this hard work at such an early stage of dating. You two aren’t really compatible, are at different life /career stages and he doesn’t seem to have got over his ex. Let this one go.

rookiemere · 21/12/2022 13:30

He also chose a GF who is a good few years younger than him
(OP mentioned an age difference).

Bet he likes the cachet of dating a younger attractive GF, but seemingly not the entirely natural salary difference that comes with that.

Sorry OP but he doesn't seem like much of a keeper. I'd be very wary about having DC with someone like this.

mewkins · 21/12/2022 11:39

musingsinmidlife · 20/12/2022 14:56

It means he wants someone to date him for him, and not for his wallet. Someone who would respect him and want to be with him and see him as an equal - even if he made the same as them or less. He is looking for a girlfriend who respects him for him and isn't looking for someone to fund their life. He wants an equal partner, not a project or a dependent. He isn't looking to be a sugar daddy - he wants a partner who also assumes adult financial responsibilities and has their own financial stability and independence. It isn't that he cares about paying more or about the $ amount spend, it is that he doesn't want to be used and dated for his money.

How does he propose to do this when he has chosen a girlfriend who earns much less than him and he still wants to do expensive activities? Should she just take out a credit card or maybe not pay bills? She didn't force him to go out with her.

milamo · 21/12/2022 11:36

"He is very much everything should be split 50/50 which I get but when someone is earning double, I think it changes things slightly."

You think...?

AdelaideRo · 21/12/2022 11:32

Did he actually invite you so you stay at your flat and avoid the travel costs?

If you live in Edinburgh you must know that most people end up walking long distances at Hogmanay?

(Thinks back pitifully to the year she walked home to Cramond from city centre, 2 years ago I ended up walking from Blackhall to Cramond because our cab cancelled and we couldn't get another one booked).

Howyiz · 21/12/2022 11:24

StickyCricket · 20/12/2022 13:46

It sounds shit, traipsing the streets for hours to save a cab fare. Grim.

I’d cancel, making it clear that “I didn’t expect the tickets to be so expensive and to be honest I have no interest in spending New Year’s Eve hanging around on the streets for several hours to save money on a ride home. I’m afraid I’ll have to give it a miss. I hope you’re able to get a refund or find someone to take your spare ticket”.

Bet you he doesn’t go in his own. He clearly just wants someone to split the cost of a taxi with. Cheapskate.

100% this!
Then dump him! He says he is getting things then in retrospect wants 50% ......eh no!

mewkins · 21/12/2022 11:22

SomethingOriginal2 · 20/12/2022 13:53

Honestly, and this sounds a quite nasty, I really don't mean to. I kinda sounds like he's planning to break up with you and is trying to get as much money back from you as possible, to like reduce his losses.

He's said he's buying things then much later expecting money off you. That's not OK.

Yes. Like he was trying to impress you before but is now recouping costs. Call him out on it and say xxx was your choice to buy. You know how much I earn and that I wouldn't be able to buy it.

Stop comparing yourself to his ex. They obviously didn't see eye to eye either.

Lysianthus · 21/12/2022 11:18

You mention an age difference ? Is this an issue too? Frankly his back pedalling is a bit meh so I'd be out. He's shown you what the future will be like. Sorry, it's a rotten time of year for this to happen.

declutteringmymind · 21/12/2022 11:13

This man knows the price of everything but
the value of nothing.

Charliehaus · 21/12/2022 11:07

When you meet the right person your finances and earning discrepancies worn mean a thing

my husband earns x2.5 my wage and we’re both sensible with money but he’s also very generous and aware that he earns more. He’s happy to pay the majority outgoings such as the mortgage and bills and we do it by %
we discussed this early on and we’re on the same page with money
you have to be

Charliehaus · 21/12/2022 11:03

To me he’s got red flags 🚩
it reminds me of an ex who organised a trip to London for my birthday and my present was a gig for a band he wanted to see 🙄 that he’d books way before we were together
there were just elements of selfishness with him and it turned out in the end he was incredibly self centred and it was only ever about him.

it’s a horrible feeling when you like someone and this happens.
you have to see this as a sign. If this is how he behaves now imagine later down the line.

FlirtyMelons · 21/12/2022 10:43

I would just lose the ticket money and wouldn't be in this position with him again as I would dump him.

MessageToRudy · 21/12/2022 10:39

Tell him to fuck off with that attitude

I've always been the high earner in every relationship I've had and I've always paid for big events without making my partner feel shit about it

If you can't sort out money issues with him now, it will only get worse as it's one of the biggest areas for conflict in a relationship!

emptythelitterbox · 21/12/2022 10:36

He seems cheap, mean, and greedy.

What do you friends and family think about him?

MenCanGetInTheBin · 21/12/2022 10:30

My birthday is early next year.
I'm thinking that, I think a handmade gift would be cute but I feel a bit hurt that half of them are handmade, it was him that didnt want a present budget.

OP posts:
emptythelitterbox · 21/12/2022 10:27

I forgot to mention the Christmas gifts!
I just knew he'd be a cheap fuck with the holidays!

Take the ones you bought for him back. A card and a bottle of liquor is plenty for a newish relationship.

What has he done for your birthday?

emptythelitterbox · 21/12/2022 10:24

So he makes 6 figures. There's 6 figures as in 100k or 6 figures at 700k. What does he do?

I'm not sure why he'd be resentful about buying his ex out of the house?
It's not like he didn't get anything. He has the entire house (the 6-7 bedroom one). He would have had to do the same thing if it was a relative or business partner he'd bought a house with. Did he think his ex should have walked away from an investment she put money into with nothing? (I bet he does!)

MenCanGetInTheBin · 21/12/2022 10:11

Thank you everyone for your responses.

We had a few conversations and some texts here and there about this and overall expectations, finances etc.

He said we should agree a budget for events we want to go to - I can understand and see his logic but to me that just says "this is all you can afford" - I would have been able to pay for tickets / taxi, I just didnt want to budget rest of month. I challenged him why he is happy with budgets for events but not for christmas presents. He said this is presents and its the thought that counts, we agreed on a set number of presents - he has told me half of these are handmade by him.. I feel ungrateful for saying this but I've spent quite a bit on him and now I'm thinking of keeping some presents back. I cant think whats been handmade, he isnt artsy, I havent seen anything he had made except some shelving units (?!).

Anyway, he offered to rebook the whole new year thing and to pay for the lot, tickets and taxi, if I really wanted to go, and it would be his "treat" - I found this very patronising. I never want to tell / ask someone to treat me, so that left me feeling a bit :(

I then brought up my job and said he has to stop calling me a Manager because I am not and its coming across a bit snobby as if my job title is beneath him - he then challenged that with "but dont you manage this and that, etc." - I ended up getting really annoyed and telling me to NOT call me a manager full stop.

I then went out and he had texted me saying that I didnt mind spending XX amount on my spa days with my family - but this is annual, I know what the cost is upfront for this AND the spa voucher is a christmas present that my dad always buys for us, we (me, my mum and sis) split in for a hotel and get dinner (?!) - I havent said anything back to that. He then said that we dont think differently about finances and that maybe he is a bit sore about his ex, financially. They split last year and he bought her out of the house and she walked away with quite a hefty sum.

He then said sorry and he doesnt have an issue putting in more money if it means we get to do what we both want.

I just feel like it's bittered everything. I told him this would be an issue with our age difference but he just kept telling me I was overthinking. I dont know his exact salary but he lives in a 7 bedroom house out in the country and said in a passing comment months ago that he never thought he would be earning a 6 figure salary doing what we does.

Maybe the conversation needed to happen but I feel abit embarassed by it all - I've never mislead him with my finances. He kept saying that a high earner shouldnt be penalised for working harder or chosing a certain field. I understand that, however, I have "worked hard" - I studied HR at Uni and have double my salary since 2016.

I dont know what to do, feeling abit deflated - I cant work out if I have overreacted, if he has been an arse, or if its a big miscommunication. So I dont really know how to feel, I wish the convo didnt happen.

OP posts:
allboysherebutme · 20/12/2022 23:50

If he wanted me to go I'd expect him to pay otherwise I wouldn't go, same as if I invited him to the theatre id buy the tickets x

PeachCottonTree · 20/12/2022 20:59

He sounds like a charmer 😒

What sort of big purchases does he want you to pay him back for if you don’t live together?