Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Any police about? Need input

178 replies

MolliciousIntent · 19/12/2022 21:30

Need some information about what rights people have vis a vis the police... If they ask to question you in relation to a crime, are you allowed to say no? What can they do if you say no? What happens if you refuse to answer their questions? Can you be arrested for not cooperating?

OP posts:
Twiglets1 · 20/12/2022 10:43

FrenchFancie · 20/12/2022 07:12

I have to say I’m quite surprised by the vitriol aimed at the police here!
I’ve two dealings with the police in the last year, both were very cordial. I was the last person to see someone alive and gave details to the police about time, date and apparent state of mind of that person (it’s going to coroners court in the new year). Second was my next door neighbour being burgled where the guy had come up our drive and bunked over our fence - they were asking for the footage from our camera at the back.
both times the police have been polite, I gave a statement in the first incident and they were not good cop / bad cop like some bad TV drama but kind, polite and just went over the facts a few times to make sure my recollection was correct. I then got a follow up call after the person was found dead, to let me know and to ask if I needed any help (I did not).

i obviously don’t live in a rough area because I would always help the police if I knew something! I’m not sure where the fear of the police comes from to be honest!

I have no fear of the police. I’ve never been in trouble with them but I have just found them to be totally unhelpful when I had my car damaged, when my husband witnessed a man physically abusing a woman outside a pub and when a police officer reversed into my car, apologised profusely and then denied liability once the insurance companies got involved. And all the stories I hear from family & friends are equally negative. So I don’t trust them.

AlisonDonut · 20/12/2022 09:49

gogohmm · 20/12/2022 09:39

If you have done nothing wrong why would you be concerned?

I've given witness statements, they were very friendly and helpful, even picked me up and took me home once, entertaining the kids who had to come with me ... but I was innocent and had witnessed a crime (thankfully the person pleaded guilty so I didn't have to give evidence in court).

If you have done something illegal then either own up or speak to a solicitor

When not posting a meme is apparently enough to get arrested and have all your and your family's IT siezed and not returned for months, I think I'd advise caution on ever speaking to the police.

fruitbrewhaha · 20/12/2022 09:48

RaggedBlousedPhilanthropist · 19/12/2022 22:08

To those saying “don’t trust the police”, what is the alternative? Take the law into your own hands?

Just as there are some bad apples in every organisation and institution doesn’t mean that the Police as a whole are not to be trusted.

They are damned if they do and damned if they don’t.

People want the police and courts to help them but then don’t want to give statements because they don’t want to be seen as a “grass”.

How do you expect justice if you won’t speak out? How do you expect the police to try and protect you if you won’t tell them what’s happened or happening?

Too many scumbags get away with sex
crimes and domestic violence because people won’t speak out, and then it’s always the police’s fault for letting the perpetrator go.

The Police is just part of the system. Once a case gets to Court it’s in the hands of magistrates (less serious) or a jury (more serious) who are ordinary people who decide if someone is guilty or not. The police don’t get to decide if someone is guilty or not.

There’s a lot of crap going around about the justice system in this country but it’s far better than you would get in most places.

No The alternative is to have a properly funded well run criminal justice system from the police to the courts to the probation service. As it currently stands the system is fucked. Years and years of underfunding means it takes years for anything to go to court and by then witnesses have disappeared, dropped off the radar or got over it.

The police will more likely arrest a women for tweets she didn't even write than investigate a burglary.

AlisonDonut · 20/12/2022 09:43

Dennis Kavanagh did a video for Mumsnet for just this issue.

What women who have been threatened with a 'voluntary interview' AKA 'drop yourself in it whilst we fish for some crime that may have been committed' have found is that if they have evidence they will arrest you. If they don't have evidence then the voluntary interview is where they might get it. So get legal advice if this is offered to you.

And still laughing at the shock horror of the police that a police officer might lie as that's illegal.

MrsMorton · 20/12/2022 09:42

gogohmm · 20/12/2022 09:39

If you have done nothing wrong why would you be concerned?

I've given witness statements, they were very friendly and helpful, even picked me up and took me home once, entertaining the kids who had to come with me ... but I was innocent and had witnessed a crime (thankfully the person pleaded guilty so I didn't have to give evidence in court).

If you have done something illegal then either own up or speak to a solicitor

Lol. Charming naïveté.

gogohmm · 20/12/2022 09:39

If you have done nothing wrong why would you be concerned?

I've given witness statements, they were very friendly and helpful, even picked me up and took me home once, entertaining the kids who had to come with me ... but I was innocent and had witnessed a crime (thankfully the person pleaded guilty so I didn't have to give evidence in court).

If you have done something illegal then either own up or speak to a solicitor

RudsyFarmer · 20/12/2022 09:34

If they arrest you you have the right to remain silent. Assuming you are the suspect they will use your words to help build a case against you. So get a solicitor abd keep your mouth shut.

Womencanlift · 20/12/2022 09:27

MolliciousIntent · 19/12/2022 21:51

I thought that was in America?

Have you never watched any British tv programmes when someone gets arrested?

Anyway we need more context to answer your question. In some cases I would agree beat not to say anything, in others I would but have no idea what your situation is in order to give you a reply

WilsonMilson · 20/12/2022 09:21

This is not a question for the police, it is one for a criminal defence solicitor.

My advice is to say absolutely nothing without legal representation present.

It is your right to say nothing.

Depending on the situation you may be arrested on suspicion of a crime and will be taken into custody for questioning. You cannot refuse this, but you can remain silent and ask for details of a solicitor to contact - they will have a duty solicitor if you do not have your own.
Your solicitor will ask for a disclosure from the police as to why you have been arrested and the evidence against you. Only your solicitor can do this, you cannot.

In other cases you may be asked to attend an interview - which you can decline.

In either case say absolutely nothing and wait for your solicitor to arrive. I cannot tell you how many times people talk themselves into a world of trouble because they start talking without legal representation.

mam0918 · 20/12/2022 09:16

Well as a witness there is things that can be done, they can 'force' you with a subpoena where you could be cross examined under oath.

If you are found to be deliberately witholding important infomation they can charge you with 'perverting the course of justice' or depending on how involved you are with the suspect possibly even 'accessory' to to crime.

It really depends on the crime, the situation and what you know... if your boyfriend is a suspected murder and you are hiding his whereabouts its obviously going to be much more serious than if you where buying your morning newspaper and spotted a group of 3 local teen troublemakers shoplift some alcohol and told the security gaurd but don't want to be anymore involved.

Verbena17 · 20/12/2022 09:11

FOJN · 19/12/2022 21:44

You have to give them your name and address and nothing more.

If they arrest you and want to question you as a suspect make sure you have legal representation. Don't say a single word without a solicitor.

These days I wouldn't trust them as far as I could throw them.

I thought under common law, you don’t have to give them your name and address 🤔

Talia99 · 20/12/2022 08:45

stillvicarinatutu · 20/12/2022 08:10

Who the hell said police can lie to get a confession ?

Maybe in the movies. Certainly not in real life!

If it’s an American movie, the police in the US can apparently tell as many lies as they like in interview so that may be where the disconnect comes from.

ohioriver · 20/12/2022 08:44

Who do you report it to when the policemen and their superiors are big mates with the person who called them? When you know they already told you that no one would believe you (about something else) because who were you when the other person was a "fine upstanding member of the community".

I think you don't realise what it's like not to automatically have the police be fair. Not to have the police be impartial.

stillvicarinatutu · 20/12/2022 08:39

ohioriver · 20/12/2022 08:23

So you don't believe me.

I have no proof. I was standing there by myself with two policemen.

It wasn't a matter of hearing what I didn't want to hear. The "offence" of which I was being accused was not actionable by the police. It wasn't a criminal offence.

No I'm not saying I don't believe you at all .

The more I hear the more I think I'm in the wrong job .

Any wrong doing needs to be reported and acted on .

ohioriver · 20/12/2022 08:31

Oh and I also had a police officer sit in my house and tell me that an unprovoked physical assault in school wasn't assault and wouldn't be prosecuted as such because it happened in school and our "only option" was to go through the school anti bullying procedure.

But I recorded that one and sat my arse in a police station for a whole day and refused to leave until the duty inspector came to see me. It took almost 6 hours.

ohioriver · 20/12/2022 08:25

I was told I would be arrested for something that isn't an offence.

How was I supposed to prove that vicar when there was me and a policeman there?

I didn't have my phone on me and recording because I trusted the police. Now. I would. Because I don't trust them as far as I could throw them and I would always protect myself from them.

ohioriver · 20/12/2022 08:23

So you don't believe me.

I have no proof. I was standing there by myself with two policemen.

It wasn't a matter of hearing what I didn't want to hear. The "offence" of which I was being accused was not actionable by the police. It wasn't a criminal offence.

stillvicarinatutu · 20/12/2022 08:19

So if you have had a police officer lie to you - you confront it and challenge it .

Confessions cannot be taken under duress . They wouldn't stand up in court .

That was the accusation- that police lie to get a confession.

If you've been lied to - report it . Ask for the officers details . Speak to their Sgt . But have proof - were you lied to or did you hear something you didn't like ? There is a difference- and people lie to police all the time so if an officer was recounting something they've been told - or you've been accused of - that's not a lie - that's an allegation- and it needs investigation to prove OR disprove.

Police aren't psychic. They go on what people tell them. Then have to try to pick the truth out - people lie all the time to us . Us recounting that allegation to the suspect is standard procedure- you need to know what your accused of whether it's true or a pack of porkies .

Cherryblossoms85 · 20/12/2022 08:19

My only experience of the police was a very poor one, and it did not involve a crime. So I would always consult a lawyer before engaging with the police.

ohioriver · 20/12/2022 08:12

stillvicarinatutu · 20/12/2022 08:10

Who the hell said police can lie to get a confession ?

Maybe in the movies. Certainly not in real life!

This isn't true vicar. It's just not.

some Police lie all the time. I've had a policeman stand in front of me and lie to my face (as I now know) to dissuade me from taking action.

stillvicarinatutu · 20/12/2022 08:10

Who the hell said police can lie to get a confession ?

Maybe in the movies. Certainly not in real life!

OneFrenchEgg · 20/12/2022 08:08

Bluebottl · 20/12/2022 06:44

I think the thing to remember is there are sadly ‘bad’ (for want of a better word) people/corruption in all professions. Including professions we trust also in public sector. For example Harold Shipman and Lucy Letby weren’t a great representation of the NHS however that’s not to say everyone is like them. And the same applies for the Police. I’ve been an officer for almost 13 years and still believe in the work that I do. I’m a detective and have specialised in sexual offences and murder/attempted murder in my career. I know I’ve helped some people and helped change some peoples lives. And that’s why 99% of us do it. There are bad eggs, but there are everywhere, there’s no getting away from that.

Lucy Letby trial is ongoing and she hasn't been found guilty of anything at the moment

Givemyheadpiece · 20/12/2022 08:07

‘In the UK they are most definitely NOT allowed to lie and if they do and get a confession as a result, the defence solicitor can apply to have the confession thrown out.’

They absolutely are allowed to make it seem like they know more than they do, that there is implicating evidence, that your buddy is blabbing etc
yes a defence lawyer could say a full confession drawn out by a blatant lie should not be admissible - but it’s more subtle than that. Police interviewing aren’t that stupid, they’re experienced officers who know the boundaries.

Givemyheadpiece · 20/12/2022 08:04

A good friend witnessed a very violent crime. Immediately after they gave a witness statement, while still in shock - literally covered in blood of the victim- at the scene.

later transpired that the police were involved and friend was given hell on the witness stand over inconsistencies’ in the on the scene witness statement versus the one they gave later when it was calmer and non-police were there for support.
friend - who had zero connection to the victim, crime or police - was made out to be a liar.
Thenpolice treated her appallingly.
The jury did believe friend, and other witnesses however and the police office involved was held to acct.

I wouldn’t not voluntarily speak with police without a solicitor or another adult witness present. And that’s before you bring in the institutional racism, homophobia and misogyny.

Talia99 · 20/12/2022 08:01

DriftwoodOnTheShore · 20/12/2022 06:46

Say nothing without a solicitor present. Our neighbour's nephew was almost bullied into making a false confession on the promise of being allowed home.

Apparently they are allowed to lie. They said they had him on CCTV. He knew they couldn't have but thought the person must be his double. He was young and frightened and almost did a silly thing in confessing to something he didn't do.

In the UK they are most definitely NOT allowed to lie and if they do and get a confession as a result, the defence solicitor can apply to have the confession thrown out.

Swipe left for the next trending thread