Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP fussy eater

186 replies

Superiorsweet16 · 19/12/2022 17:22

I think I'm in bit of a funk today as i've not been feeling well recently and more than likely creating a mountain out of a mole hill.

DP is an extremely fussy eater (he has an older sibling with ASD who has a very select beige diet but DP has no other signs of being ND) and it's started to bring me down.

We moved into our first home in the beginning of summer and he is honestly the greatest man I have ever met and I cannot wait to marry him in 2024. DP is very caring and tries his hardest to not let it affect me. He doesn't want to be this way, is embarrassed and is trying but his diet is similar to a four-year-old.

DP will not eat vegetables or anything in source. His diet before meeting me was essentially meat, white carbs, beige frozen food and chips. The last year he's started to eat pizza (never wanted the tomato source), potatoes (not just chips) and meat in non dairy/veg source. He won't have anything with dairy (rules out pasta bakes), or anything that seasoned (roasted potatoes with herbs/garlic etc). When I cook he'll eat meat with certain veg as long as he doesn't know it's there i.e. Sausage with sage/garlic or onions blended into the mince.

There's only a few restaurants we can go to that he can actually eat in but he'll never put up a fuss. A couple of weeks ago we didn't have much choice apart from a pub lunch and as there wasn't anything on the menu he wanted to eat he just had three desserts.

It's just becoming difficult to attempt to eat a similar meal and I feel that I'm becoming deficient trying to meet us half way. DP has always offered to cook his own meals, or as it's literally just plain meat and pasta I can just cook his separately. I've noticed that i'm feeling more run down more often but it's because i'm eating similar to him 75% of the week just as it's easier. Food shops are costing a fortune as meat isn't cheap and i've noticed that i'm barely bothering to buy myself veg as the small handfuls i'm throwing on the side of my plate is just meaning so much is getting wasted. I don't bother buying myself treats I used to enjoy like salsa/cheese/stuffed peppers as we're already spending a fortune on the weekly shop i'll just tuck into biscuits with him. Same with there's not much point buying myself a seeded loaf when we can both just eat white bread.

Before we moved in together I used to meal prep for myself and I could easily go back to that to ensure i'm eating well (I don't quite see the point in spending an hour cooking just for me) but it's that I feel like we're having separate meals. I'm craving some Moroccan style couscous, roasted veg with maybe some lemon chicken and maybe I could tell DP to sort himself out... probably just plain chicken and rice.

AIBU to feel down about DPs fussy eating or shall I just pull myself together as there's bigger issues in this world.

OP posts:
Paq · 21/12/2022 06:56

OP you mentioned money a few times. It's so sad you're prioritising his eating disorder over your healthy diet when it comes to food shopping.

If I were you I'd experiment shopping and cooking separately. He can buy his own food, you buy yours.

But think really, really hard whether this is something you can cope with long term, and how it would work should you decide to have children...

FurAndFeathers · 21/12/2022 06:44

yadaya · 20/12/2022 22:47

can you genuinely not see the difference between not wanting something and actively discounting it?

I can, but that wasn't the issue I was addressing. I responded to a PP who said no women would ever want to date a man who was a fussy eater..... like they felt they could respond on behalf of all women. Which is clearly bullshit.

Of course people don't generally seek out partners with eating disorders.... I mean, I would bloody love not to have an eating disorder!! But most normal people would be understanding and not declare that nobody will ever want to date you!! 😂😂

We were responding to the same post and discussing the same issue.
i think it sounds like we both actually broadly agree with the poster - no woman wants to date a fussy eater.

which is not the same as saying no woman would ever date a fussy eater, or that no woman would ever overlook fussy eating in a relationship on a balance of characteristics. Of course that would be bullshit but it’s not what was said.

There haven’t been any posters on this thread with the exception of one, who have said they actively want to date fussy eaters (and I think they’re looking for an argument more than anything else)

FurAndFeathers · 21/12/2022 06:35

Marths · 20/12/2022 22:36

I don't think I'm misunderstanding anything. Simply saying that the PPs statement about what all women would or would not do is false. No need to be so aggressive about it.

And I'm not sure why you keep bringing up fetishises but they have nothing to do with anything. If your so desperate to discuss fetishes maybe try a different board.

You find shrugging an act of aggression?!?
that’s also unusual 😁

yadaya · 20/12/2022 22:47

can you genuinely not see the difference between not wanting something and actively discounting it?

I can, but that wasn't the issue I was addressing. I responded to a PP who said no women would ever want to date a man who was a fussy eater..... like they felt they could respond on behalf of all women. Which is clearly bullshit.

Of course people don't generally seek out partners with eating disorders.... I mean, I would bloody love not to have an eating disorder!! But most normal people would be understanding and not declare that nobody will ever want to date you!! 😂😂

Marths · 20/12/2022 22:36

I don't think I'm misunderstanding anything. Simply saying that the PPs statement about what all women would or would not do is false. No need to be so aggressive about it.

And I'm not sure why you keep bringing up fetishises but they have nothing to do with anything. If your so desperate to discuss fetishes maybe try a different board.

FurAndFeathers · 20/12/2022 21:07

Dumle · 20/12/2022 20:49

Eating vegetables that are hidden in food is very different from eating them as they are. Issues with food or food preferences can be very hard to change so I'm still saying that it's not his fault.

Did you just latch onto the part of that post that confirmed your own preconceptions and ignored the rest (including the fact OP says he will eat veg and other foods but generally doesn’t want to as it’s not his preferred foods) Confused

or do you think you know the op’s DP better than the OP?

Dumle · 20/12/2022 20:49

FurAndFeathers · 20/12/2022 06:22

Except that he will eat veg he just prefers not to, won’t try peas cos he didn’t like them when he was 6 and happily eats veg when it is hidden in other foods.

all of which indicates it isn’t that he can’t eat these foods, he simply doesn’t want to. so yes, that is his ‘fault’

Eating vegetables that are hidden in food is very different from eating them as they are. Issues with food or food preferences can be very hard to change so I'm still saying that it's not his fault.

FurAndFeathers · 20/12/2022 20:40

Marths · 20/12/2022 20:34

My point is that the previous posters statement is objectively wrong. There is at least one woman who wants to date a man who is a fussy eater.

Only if you insist on deliberately misunderstanding it I guess 🤷‍♀️

or have a fussy-eater fetish

Marths · 20/12/2022 20:34

FurAndFeathers · 20/12/2022 18:52

You want to date him (your partner)
you don’t want to date any/a man who’s a fussy eater

that was the point.
unless fussy eating is a specific characteristic you look for in a man?

My point is that the previous posters statement is objectively wrong. There is at least one woman who wants to date a man who is a fussy eater.

LimeCheesecake · 20/12/2022 19:58

@IndieK1d - but the OP has said he has tried more vegetables with her, was able to eat them but doesn’t like them. That’s rather different to the situation you are describing. It seems the Ops DPs sibling might have been unable to eat some foods for sensory issues, but the DP doesn’t have that.

FurAndFeathers · 20/12/2022 19:36

IndieK1d · 20/12/2022 19:30

It's not fussy eating though. I've got a restricted diet, partly due to (not allergy / intolerance; something else) not being able to have cows milk and partly because of similar issues mentioned in this thread. It's not a bloody choice. I'd rather not have to have such a restricted diet due to not being able to stand the texture of things.

are you the OP’s DP?

because your situation sounds nothing like hers (which is a DP who is fussy)

IndieK1d · 20/12/2022 19:30

SwingandaPrayer · 20/12/2022 19:10

Absolutely this. No way would I want the father of my kids setting this example. Overly fussy eating is a massive turn off so this would be a total deal-breaker for me.

It's not fussy eating though. I've got a restricted diet, partly due to (not allergy / intolerance; something else) not being able to have cows milk and partly because of similar issues mentioned in this thread. It's not a bloody choice. I'd rather not have to have such a restricted diet due to not being able to stand the texture of things.

SwingandaPrayer · 20/12/2022 19:10

LimeCheesecake · 19/12/2022 20:07

So does he understand how unhealthy his diet is? He’s not a child now - so if he’s tried some veg and can cope with eating them, does he understand he needs to eat them even if they aren’t his preferred foods?

I am not sure long term it’s a good idea to set up life with a man child who doesn’t take responsibility for his health.

Absolutely this. No way would I want the father of my kids setting this example. Overly fussy eating is a massive turn off so this would be a total deal-breaker for me.

Surreality22 · 20/12/2022 18:53

My stbx DH is a very fussy eater. He's on the spectrum. Wouldn't eat certain meats, no seafood, very few types of vegetables in tiny pieces. Funny enough he was a bit less fussy when eating out, he'd be a little more adventureous due to more options on a menu. I would try to cook for myself at least once a week but even so it drove me nuts, trying to work out which foods we could both eat and pull something together. And I felt like my diet was suffering. He'd cook burgers, or pasta. We'd have a takeaway once a week too. He did try bless him, but I'm so glad that I can please myself again now. He once told me he could just eat nothing but eggs and potatoes every day.

FurAndFeathers · 20/12/2022 18:52

Marths · 20/12/2022 18:46

The poster said that no woman would want to date a man who is a fussy eater. He is a fussy eater, and I want to date him. Therefore the poster is wrong, and quite ignorant too.

You want to date him (your partner)
you don’t want to date any/a man who’s a fussy eater

that was the point.
unless fussy eating is a specific characteristic you look for in a man?

Marths · 20/12/2022 18:46

FurAndFeathers · 20/12/2022 18:34

And are they attractive to you specifically because they eat a restricted diet?

perhaps I’m wrong and there are restricted-diet fetishists out there?

but I suspect it’s more that you’re attracted to them because of their many positive non-dietary characteristics than because you want to date someone who eats a restricted diet

The poster said that no woman would want to date a man who is a fussy eater. He is a fussy eater, and I want to date him. Therefore the poster is wrong, and quite ignorant too.

BowiesJumper · 20/12/2022 18:41

I had an ex like this, but he’s autistic. It drove me loopy. He would only eat meat, pasta, potatoes or onions. Very limited sauces. And sweets. It made going out to a restaurant realllllly difficult. It wasn’t the reason we split but didn’t help!

FurAndFeathers · 20/12/2022 18:34

Marths · 20/12/2022 18:20

I'm a woman, and my partner (who has ASD) had similar eating habits and is very attractive to me. So yes when they said "no woman ever wants to" they were wrong.

And are they attractive to you specifically because they eat a restricted diet?

perhaps I’m wrong and there are restricted-diet fetishists out there?

but I suspect it’s more that you’re attracted to them because of their many positive non-dietary characteristics than because you want to date someone who eats a restricted diet

FurAndFeathers · 20/12/2022 18:31

yadaya · 20/12/2022 17:49

fussy eater is hardly a desirable characteristic that folk look for in a partner

Well, thankfully I found a partner who isn't so narrow minded.

I had friends like you, they treated me like a child due to my restricted eating. Even when I was diagnosed with ARFID (a recognised eating disorder) they still refused to acknowledge that it was largely out of my control.

I find it strange that people are unable or unwilling to be compassionate about this issue and inevitably these threads always go the same way, I wonder if you'd discount a partner because they had a phobia or spiders, height or water?

you’re clearly projecting

did your partner seek you out because they specifically wanted a partner with ARFID? I doubt it. They clearly love you regardless but I doubt it was a criteria they wanted and were actively looking for which is the point being made.

FWIW I’m coeliac and also have a restricted diet. I’m also self-aware enough to recognise that this isn’t something folk actively look for in a partner and that doesn’t make them lacking in compassion or any other personal slur you want to name-call Confused.

I’ve literally never met anyone seeking to date someone with a restricted diet. It’s odd that you think it’s a desirable trait! The pp didn’t say the OP should discount/get rid of their partner only that it’s not something people want

can you genuinely not see the difference between not wanting something and actively discounting it? Hmm

Marths · 20/12/2022 18:20

FurAndFeathers · 20/12/2022 16:50

I mean it’s unlikely they’re wrong…

fussy eater is hardly a desirable characteristic that folk look for in a partner

I'm a woman, and my partner (who has ASD) had similar eating habits and is very attractive to me. So yes when they said "no woman ever wants to" they were wrong.

BeanieTeen · 20/12/2022 17:56

It sounds so mean but this would be a deal breaker for me. I’m sure it’s not his fault and he can’t help it, but he’d need to make an effort to get over this. I’d find a grown man with such babyish eating habits to be an absolute turn off.

yadaya · 20/12/2022 17:49

fussy eater is hardly a desirable characteristic that folk look for in a partner

Well, thankfully I found a partner who isn't so narrow minded.

I had friends like you, they treated me like a child due to my restricted eating. Even when I was diagnosed with ARFID (a recognised eating disorder) they still refused to acknowledge that it was largely out of my control.

I find it strange that people are unable or unwilling to be compassionate about this issue and inevitably these threads always go the same way, I wonder if you'd discount a partner because they had a phobia or spiders, height or water?

FurAndFeathers · 20/12/2022 16:50

yadaya · 20/12/2022 16:14

And you feel you can speak for all women because.......

I mean it’s unlikely they’re wrong…

fussy eater is hardly a desirable characteristic that folk look for in a partner

Dalekjastninerels · 20/12/2022 16:24

I would be called fussy by some; I like most foods aside from cold hard boiled eggs (slimy- revolting) and potato salad (cold potato- are you insane?) lamb (dislike the taste) and certain foods touching.

I will actually vomit if I eat food I dislike

I consider this to be my issue and would prepare an alternative for myself if I were your husband.

yadaya · 20/12/2022 16:14

whattodo1975 · 20/12/2022 10:37

Absolutely no woman ever wants to date a man who is a fussy eater.

And you feel you can speak for all women because.......