Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know IABU, blatantly using this for traffic. Emergency situation, no ambulance still, and need advice

765 replies

TheChinkOfaGlass · 19/12/2022 16:35

Hi everyone

My Auntie had a fall this morning and has seriously hurt her hip. Luckily she was close enough to the bed to get herself up on it.

999 said it is not an emergency and to contact 111, she was in severe agony and is 78 years old. I rang 111 who after assessing her, decided she did indeed need an ambulance.

I had originally offered to take her to the hospital but she lives on the top floor of a maisonette, and is unable to sit up (so a car journey would be no good and I would be unable to carry her to the car anyway. I did get help but she declined due to the inability to even sit up).

Her husband is disabled so isn't much use (I mean this in the nicest possible way, he is trying his best) other than keeping an eye on her.

So we could be waiting hours for an ambulance but in the meantime she is soaked through on the bed due to urinating on herself. I am going there in the next 30 minutes.

Is it safe to roll her to change the sheets to make her more comfortable? I don't like the idea of her lying in a soaking bed while she waits. I am also scared of causing more pain/damage by moving her. We do not know what's wrong, she thinks it may he her hip. I just don't know what to do. I have never experienced this kind of thing.

Her partner has managed to change her underwear but when the bed is so wet, it wouldn't really make a difference.

OP posts:
Ediealone · 21/12/2022 00:41

There is another elderly lady in the paper aged 93 and ambulance took 25.5 hours for a broken hip

Ediealone · 21/12/2022 00:40

antelopevalley · 20/12/2022 21:03

Category 4 are less urgent medical issues that should really be dealt with by a GP. I am not surprised that during a strike they are taking so long.

Not exactly. This lady’s aunt is category 4 yet can’t move, she lives in a top floor maisonette so difficult to move. What could a GP do for her if she’s broken a hip and can’t leave her home?

BlippiIsAnnoying · 21/12/2022 00:39

God this is horrendous, is paying privately for an ambulance a possibility? Local councillors, MPs media etc.

Ediealone · 21/12/2022 00:37

BatshitBanshee · 20/12/2022 20:43

Category 3: Person having seizures, diabetic hypos, woman in late stage of labour
ETA 2-6 hours

2-6 hours?! I had a very rare and totally unforeseen traumatic birth on my last baby. Both my DD and I would be dead if we were waiting that long for an ambulance in these circumstances. Jesus Christ. That is shocking.

Yes, I copied and pasted the message my friend sent to our girls WhatsApp group as she’s so dismayed at the situation

endlesscraziness · 21/12/2022 00:36

@nolongersurprised I work in the NHS and spent 3 years working in US emergency care. I've been saying for a while we need to look at Germany and Australia and completely overhaul the NHS into a similar format. The US system is horrific and I wouldn't wish it on anyone but as a country we seem blinded with that being the only option when other countries use a different model very well and that's what is needed. The NHS is completely broken, it doesn't help that social care is too but simply there's not enough resources for the numbers of sick patients we are seeing. Whilst I support strike action, with how broken the ambulance service is, there's no way of reducing the service to strike without causing patient harm.

We have a community falls service that would go out, assess, lift her up and get her comfortable but there's still a long wait for an ambulance. Falls at home aren't covered in the derogations, but we have been told long lies will eventually be moved. Honestly, id move her, but I am ex ambulance staff and know how to do it moderately safely, but on the balance of risk you're still better moving her with how long it's been. Good luck, I'm so sorry

justgettingthroughtheday · 21/12/2022 00:35

Pelo22 · 20/12/2022 21:44

@justgettingthroughtheday what you said is technically what it should be, what was quoted is the times at the minute Sad

I wasn't talking about the times - I know they are way off. I was correcting what categories different things fell into!

MingeofDeath · 21/12/2022 00:35

Dont really want to hijack OP's thread so I will be brief. GPs do not have any appts, many surgeries are no longer answering the phone. Parents are panicking about strep A, there are many unwell elderly people, suicide attempts and overdoses. Plus you have people with mental illness who phone us because they are unable to/dont want to access out of hours MH services, which, TBH are not that good. People with MH problems are massively neglected. Then you have your usual drunks and timewasters.

Idbetternamechange · 21/12/2022 00:34

this is unbelievable. I hope you get some help soon.

DuchessDandelion · 21/12/2022 00:25

@TheChinkOfaGlass someone local to me got to a&e with the help of neighbours and first responders when they were badly injured today, after they posted on their local Facebook group for help. Do reach out locally - there will be off duty medically trainee personal who may be able to help.

3luckystars · 21/12/2022 00:24

Unbelievable.

ScrabbleRabbler · 21/12/2022 00:21

wishing you and your aunt the strength and support to get through this xxx

Bluekerfuffle · 21/12/2022 00:17

How unprofessional and arseholish for the hospital to hang up on her. I don’t care how hard done by the hospital staff feel, they should not be in the job if they can’t understand how upset someone in a lot of pain and unable to move for days feels. There are some utter gobshites in these roles and everyone is at their mercy.

SnowlayRoundabout · 21/12/2022 00:12

Goodness, @SkyView, that Amazon analogy is sobering - not least because it would actually work, and would be quicker than calling an ambulance.

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 21/12/2022 00:12

You need to call the ambulance again because it is likely she will deteriorate and die from this if not seen soon, surely?

EricNorthmanYesPlease · 21/12/2022 00:10

That sounds like a great system!

I do believe if there were minimal.fees put on A and E visits, it would put off alot of the time wasters. Same for ambulance trips. Even £25 call out if you weren't actually in need of one would stop people using them as a taxi service.

The whole system needs a business brain to take over and get rid of ridiculous sytems, long term (stress) sick admin staff, unnecessary training (trans and equality or the benefit of ypur colleagurs, not patients) costing hundreds of thousands per hospital trust.and reduce the HUGE number of managers and admin agency staff.
Also, why on earth they cant purchase their own equipment without having to putit out to tender is beyond me.
The money that is wasted to unscrupulous companies winning these contracts is appaling.

Mental health needs a team of their own around the country, as they do in parts of London. Ambulances shouldn't be called to suicides/suicide attempts. Its not what its for.

Surely people who have had a stroke need treatment in the golden hour too?

So much about it boils my blood.

katesbushh · 21/12/2022 00:10

If I was closer I'd help.
I honestly think most hcp would.

I'd definitely be putting a call out on Facebook now for help to move her with people who know how.

I've seen a patient being brought into ED on a door before (because they thought they could avoid police involvement)

Ideally it needs to be something rigid to support her hip and keep it still
If you can't get any help perhaps youtube how to move someone with an unstable hip fracture.
I was very much don't move yesterday
But " long lies" Can be just as bad for an elderly patient.

musicalkittens · 21/12/2022 00:07

Not read whole thread, but these might be worth contacting, if you haven't already.

St John Ambulance Cymru- has ambulances and will be appropriately trained, and even though you can't access the falls and frailty service without 999 doing it for you, you can contact patient transport:
www.sjacymru.org.uk/en/page/patient-transport-services

Private Emergency Ambulance - all Wales, will offer emergency patient transport which most private ambulance services don't. You will need to pay for it though.
awas.co.uk/ambulance/private-ambulance/private-emergency-patient-transport/

Pavementfaller · 21/12/2022 00:07

MingeofDeath · 20/12/2022 23:50

Just finished another shift at an ambulance Trust. All I can say is wow. In all the years I have been a HCP, I have never had a shift like it. We are broken.

Very sorry to hear this, but not surprised. Something really seems to have changed in terms of emergency health services over the last year or so, and not for the good.

I'm moderately ancient so have a few decades' worth of experience of visiting A&E. It's not somewhere I've haunted, but it's difficult to avoid with three children.

I went there last week after the pavement encounter giving rise to my username, and was quite taken aback by how different it was from my previous experience. It was early on a weekday evening, and A&E was absolutely heaving. Obviously sick and injured people were unable to get a seat and the crowded, noisy conditions were certainly not going to help them. When I eventually got to the triage nurse she said it was like that all day every day now.

I was moved through to what they called the Urgent Treatment department w
hre there was at least a bit more space, but that also filled up as time went on. There was only one very tired-looking doctor and one nurse working there, which meant they were having to waste time doing loads of non-medical jobs like fighting with the printer, showing people where X-ray was, etc.

It was pretty clear that the problems were down to lack of staff, probably combined with the well-known difficulty of moving patients to wards resulting from delays in sending patients home due to lack of care facilities.

This is ultimately down to a major government failure. It's a mystery to me why we continue to put up with these utter incompetents.

justasking111 · 21/12/2022 00:01

Private healthcare works for referrals, MRI ultrasound, consultant diagnosis. BUT not emergency care. That's something the NHS have to do. You can have scheduled surgeries but urgent catastrophic cases the NHS.

Convalescent hospital I think we've gone backwards. Cottage hospital two of ours sold off. One donated by a wealthy mill owning family many moons ago. There's a caveat in the trust if the health board give it up it reverts back to the family.

Once upon a time they were used for minor surgeries and recuperating. That would help uswith bed blocking. That and getting individual departments social services hospital managers to agree at the meetings. They fight like ferrets in a sack at times

SkyView · 21/12/2022 00:00

This is such a sad & sobering read Op. Your poor, poor Auntie.Sad You & her husband must be shattered by now. I hope you can both get a little rest.

Slightly alarmed at all the current failures in the ambulance service, we were discussing our strategies earlier of what to do if we needed one, as I'm disabled. We realised that an Amazon* intervention may actually be quicker than an ambulance! In some parts of the country.

You obviously wouldn't get trained medical care or medication, but within 24 hours on Prime (although not at Christmas Hmm) you could buy a stretcher, plus bandages, splints, etc. Then you just need some strong neighbours & someone with a van or estate to drive you to the hospital. (I'm not recommending that for you obviously).

I'm keeping my fingers crossed for a swift resolution for you all.

*Not an endorsement. Other delivery companies available. I detest Amazon & avoid them as much as I can.

Bepis · 20/12/2022 23:54

MingeofDeath · 20/12/2022 23:50

Just finished another shift at an ambulance Trust. All I can say is wow. In all the years I have been a HCP, I have never had a shift like it. We are broken.

Are you able to share how it has been?

MingeofDeath · 20/12/2022 23:50

Just finished another shift at an ambulance Trust. All I can say is wow. In all the years I have been a HCP, I have never had a shift like it. We are broken.

lanadelgrey · 20/12/2022 23:49

Private medicine in the UK does the easy chronic stuff but not the acute emergency things. When there is an emergency you are transferred to the NHS.

FixTheBone · 20/12/2022 23:46

IneedanewTV · 20/12/2022 22:22

So the very rich wait for an ambulance and go to A&E?

Don't worry, nobody here could afford it.

I treated a chap last yest who fell off a ladder and sustained several major injuries. On the day of his discharge, he said he had no family to inherit his estate and would like to dinate the cost of his care to the hospital.

Soon changed his mind when I told him the 5 week stay was around £340,000.

That's why there's no private ED in the UK, too expensive, and no profit in it.

nolongersurprised · 20/12/2022 23:42

EricNorthmanYesPlease · 20/12/2022 22:27

I think more employers need to provide private medical insurance to help ease the burden.

Hopefully with the military drafted in, they may get round to patients quicker. Its absolutely appaling.

private medical insurance won’t help that much without private infrastructure and systems though.

In Australia the hybrid private/public system is facilitated by government funding the private services.

The public hospitals are the same as the NHS, free ED, inpatients, outpatients, therapy and outpatient mental health.

private insurance only gives access to inpatient admissions to private hospitals - you still need to pay to see private therapists (occupational therapy, speech, physio, psychology etc) and private clinicians including GPs. There are also private labs and radiology providers.

The government pays for all of these services through Medicare, a provider can charge on top of this and the patient will pay the “gap.” I took my daughter to a private dermatologist for her acne (now gone!), I can’t remember the fee but was 320ish, of which I paid about 170 dollars. Follow ups are much cheaper and also subsidised.

Some GPs will bulk bill, ie just be paid the government amount so there is no gap to the patient. Most private lab tests are bill billed, most imaging, but not all.

You pay a part cost for prescriptions, cheaper if you have a chronic condition or are low income. The governments subsidises the cost of the medications and you pay the same gap, irrespective of whether it was prescribed by a GP, private specialist or through the hospital.

I don’t think any of this would be acceptable to people in the UK though, because there are some costs.

i have recently tried to illustrate how well it can work by giving the example of a 7 year old boy with ASD/ADHD/gross motor delay and Anxiety.

He could see a public paed (no cost), bulk billing GP (no cost), have private blood tests looking for nutritional deficiencies due to picky diet (no cost), private X-rays when GP suspected a fracture (no cost) and go to public ED with a chest infection (no cost).

Fortnightly OT, physio, psychology and speech are paid for by the government though the National Disability Insurance Scheme, due to his disorders (no cost)

The parents would have to pay for his long acting stimulant medications, with the cost down to, say, 8 Australian dollars because his meds are subsidised because of his disorder and/or his parents are low income.

I’ve posted this before on MN and a typical response is, “I can’t believe you have to pay the equivalent of a few pounds a month for medications. I’ll stick to our wonderful NHS, thanks”.

There will be no appetite, I think, for an accessible private system unless the public accepts that everything won’t be “free”.