Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do violinists make decent money?

115 replies

Jazz12 · 19/12/2022 14:59

DS (15) is a bright child. Academically strong and a very passionate violinist.

DH and I have always encouraged him to do well in STEM subjects. We’ve gently steered him in that direction since early childhood. He enjoys computer science, is a decent programmer and also likes biology. He wants to get into Tech (DH and I are in this field), he is also considering Medicine. However, I know he is very passionate about violin.

I understand it’ll be amazing to find a career you enjoy. It’s also equally important to make decent money to afford a good quality of life. House prices, bills everything is out of reach for many people (at least where I live) now. Unfortunately, only some fields pay well.

Do violinists earn well?

Just wanted to hear some perspectives before I talk to DS about it.

OP posts:
Towcester · 19/12/2022 16:07

Wondered the same. I am not musical but my son is working towards grade 7 and been playing violin for 3 years. He is in a youth orchestra. I must say, it's great to attend the youth orchestra concerts - it is like a professional show to me.

Something like BBC Philharmonic is probably 30 to 50k a year depending if they are 1st, 2nd, 3rd violinist. But to get to that level must be extremely competitive.

Does anyone know what happens after grade 8 if the player is still a child? Do they just play with their orchestra, learn new pieces and refine their skills off their own back.

My son has done some compositions. My wife seems to think this can be profitable but I guess it's like any musician, you could compose something that will make you a millionaire any day but it probably doesn't happen for many.

NerrSnerr · 19/12/2022 16:06

Only one person from my school year went down the music career route (northern comprehensive school). A couple of years ago he got an Oscar for composing a movie score. He does well for himself!

He went down music technology route at university.

Woodandsky · 19/12/2022 16:05

It's totally possible to love music without playing professionally.

I have a 'boring' professional job but am a good enough musician to play recreationally with many pro and ex-professional players. I'm glad that music is my passion and not my job, I can enjoy it without struggling to make ends meet like many of the pros I know.

That said if music had been my only interest / talent I think it would have been a really interesting job and I'd have found a way to manage.

ProMusician · 19/12/2022 16:05

I’m a professional musican (NC). I don’t play violin but another orchestral instrument.

Yes and no.

First of all, it depends on what exactly your DS wants to / will end up doing. You can charge £40+ an hour for private tutoring. Weddings and other background music events easily pay £300 for an afternoon, and it’s ‘easy’ work. But, none of this are regular, steady sources of income, especially not in the UK. Keep reading for details.

Classical music is incredibly competitive. You have to be really good to get into a conservatoire. You have to be really amazing to graduate with top marks. You have to be exceptional to then make it to the top of your instrument.

If you aspire to be in a professional orchestra, you need to be one of the best in your generation, and make contacts from day one of your degree. If you want to be a soloist and make a living from it, you need to be the best in the world.

In the UK, only the BBC orchestras are salaried (and maybe Covent Garden, they’ve undergone some changes recently). The rest (LSO, LPO, Royal Philharmonic etc) only pay you when you work. Which might be every night for a month, then nothing for two. You’re technically a member of those ensembles but have no salary.

I do earn a decent living and I only graduated a couple of years ago. How do I make a decent living? I had to move abroad. The sad truth is, in the UK it is almost impossible to earn a decent living, play at the level you are/aspire to be at, and have a life, and a half-decent one at that.

My friends in England are doing a mixture of teaching, performing for various corporate events and weddings, occasional gigs with semi-professional orchestras, the odd LPO/Opera North sub-in. These are extremely talented people who should be working as professionals, full-time. They aren’t, because there is not enough work, and what they do get offered, is often not paid enough.

It is gruelling, they have almost no free time and are constantly underpaid. One friend just worked two full months at a Christmas show for less than £8 an hour. It’s actually depressing. He’s one of the best in his field in the country.

My colleagues and friends in the UK are working constantly. Since Brexit, conditions have become worse. Covid made it all a lot worse too. Many are doing side jobs on the side. Full-time orchestral positions are rare. When they come up, hundreds of applicants sign up - from all over the world. The chances of getting the job are minuscule.

I moved to Germany. This country has 165 full-time professional orchestras, all state-funded and independently-run. This is before we count choirs, theatres, touring companies, musicals, jazz and ballet companies etc. Germany is a country which values and invests in the arts.

I am still in training and earning around €25-30k a year already. Once I get a full time position, this will increase to anything between 45 and 80-90k a year, before extra work on the side (teaching and solo/chamber performing). I am valued, my job is valued in the society and I have time for an actual life too, occasionally. Cost of living is lower, working conditions are so much better, and regulated by law.

So to sum up - yes, music pays well. No, not in the UK, unless you’re willing to work at a different level than your own and eg spend 60 hours a week teaching primary school aged kids, when you’re actually good enough to be playing with the Concertgebouw in Amsterdam or in the ranks of the Opéra de Paris. (Nothing wrong with this, I’m just pointing out the frustrations of many musicians who are unable to make ends meet by doing what they’re good at and what they trained for - because of a lack of opportunities, even paid opportunities at that).

Is your son great? Is your son willing to move at some point in his life? Or would your son be happy doing a music degree and then working in whatever capacity he finds that allows him to pay the bills? Might not be as performing violinist, mind you.

’Professional classical musician’ sounds glamorous but it rarely is. Not in the UK at the current moment, that’s for sure.

TheTurn0fTheScrew · 19/12/2022 16:04

most musicians don't make great money. or even have enough reliable work to perform full time without taking on teaching or other bits and pieces in between.

My eldest is seriously considering going to a conservatoire despite 8/9 predictions for everything at GCSE, so lots of other choices available. Her choice ultimately, but I have made sure she knows being a professional musician is precarious, not well paid, and also unsociable hours.
I also worry that even though she's at junior conservatoire she's very firmly in the middle of the pack there. I think she'd have a more fulfilled life doing a decently paid job and keeping up her music on a amateur level but she's 15 so she knows best

Vermin · 19/12/2022 16:03

@IndigoC actually AI created music is all over eg Spotify.
best way to make money as a violinist is to quit and then become an agent for other violinists with the relationships and knowledge of fixers / orchestras / promoters / venues picked up along the way

TortillaChipAddict · 19/12/2022 16:01

I’m a professional string player, conservatoire trained. Out of my close group of ten friends at music college only two of us are still making money from music. I could make a decent wage from it if I wasn’t working part time - (I think I could earn between £40-£50k full time) due to my kids but my work is very niche - when I’m performing I specialise in a particular type of music that pays well, and the majority of my income comes from working in community settings as a musician. This is the thing I am passionate about but has taken me years to build up to a sustainable level. I used to work in professional orchestras but really disliked the hours and culture. I also had to leave England and move to a different part of the uk where the competition is less fierce to get regular work.

BlackForestCake · 19/12/2022 15:57

Someone who is bright, works hard and a decent person will do well in any field.

Do you still believe in Santa too?

blackandwhitecat123 · 19/12/2022 15:54

curiouslycinnamon · 19/12/2022 15:36

I was extremely artistic as a young person and hugely passionate about (and good at) visual arts.

My parents steered me away from it, thinking I would not make good money from it and would struggle to afford things. They had good intentions so I don't really blamed them, but as a result, my twenties were a bit of a mess.

I did an MSc in something that I was vaguely interested in and let to a good career, but I wasn't all that passionate about, mostly to keep them happy.

I suffered from years of mental health issues, identity crisis, beating myself up about not being able to be what my parents wanted me to be, really struggling with the 9-5 etc.

I ended up not being able to cope with the pressure of that career, but also not having the skills I needed to get a careeer in visual arts. So I got a low paid (minimum wage) job which was unrelated to both sectors, and for several years I was earning next to nothing in something that I had no interest in.

I have now wound my way back to art and make a good living doing something I like.

Please don't discourage your children from doing what they love. You can encourage him to keep his options open and do some STEM subjects at school/ college, but the truth is that people who are passionate about the arts can and do make a good living! It might be that he has to supplement his income with some teaching or something else, but he will be OK.

And the truth is, if he loves it anyway, then he will inevitably wind his way back to it in the end like I did with my art. If you support him he might be able to avoid an identity crisis like mine!

I'm sorry you had that experience Sad from the other side of the coin though, studying the violin at a conservatoire can have the opposite effect of completely curbing your enthusiasm. I spent the first term having my technique completely re-wired, involving hours of practising playing open strings with an even tone 😆 I was a hugely enthusiastic player before I went (and very disciplined) and haven't picked up my instrument in years now.

I can only speak from my experience, but music college is an exacting and gruelling process at times. My friends who did well were the ones who did vast amount of youth orchestra stuff, had really excellent teaching from a junior conservatoire and were at an absolutely exceptionally high standard when they started. The rest of us who were also really good players struggled.

IndigoC · 19/12/2022 15:54

At least if he becomes a violinist he’s unlikely to be made irrelevant/redundant by AI.

Lastqueenofscotland2 · 19/12/2022 15:52

I know a violinist who plays with a big orchestra. It’s a reasonable living but not high earning by any means. She supplements by teaching privately about 7-10 hours a week

littlepeas · 19/12/2022 15:47

It's quite rare for musicians to earn well - I know quite a few of them and the vast majority have their fingers in various pies in order to make ends meet. Most, as a minimum, teach alongside performing. My dd is a talented (classical) singer and hopes to make a go of it - it's not an easy route and is highly competitive. We are building what is essentially a CV already (she's 13...). Is he involved in any youth orchestral programmes? Junior Conservatoire, National Youth Orchestra, etc. A back up plan is also a good idea.

ErrolTheDragon · 19/12/2022 15:46

He enjoys computer science, is a decent programmer and also likes biology. He wants to get into Tech (DH and I are in this field), he is also considering Medicine.

There's nothing here to suggest he'd hate doing a STEM degree or career, or that the parents are coercing him in this direction. Many multi-talented youngsters study and have careers in these areas while maintaining a strong interest in music or other artistic areas. My db was a doctor (now retired) - he was, and still is, an excellent organist. But one with an exceptionally good pension.

MilkyYay · 19/12/2022 15:41

They can make a living if they are among the best of their generation. Is he in the NYO?

A friend led a string section of the NYO some years ago and has a career in that instrument. They survive on it but are not well off, plus its insecure, a mixture of quartets, some soloist work, some orchestral playing, some teaching/education based work.

curiouslycinnamon · 19/12/2022 15:36

I was extremely artistic as a young person and hugely passionate about (and good at) visual arts.

My parents steered me away from it, thinking I would not make good money from it and would struggle to afford things. They had good intentions so I don't really blamed them, but as a result, my twenties were a bit of a mess.

I did an MSc in something that I was vaguely interested in and let to a good career, but I wasn't all that passionate about, mostly to keep them happy.

I suffered from years of mental health issues, identity crisis, beating myself up about not being able to be what my parents wanted me to be, really struggling with the 9-5 etc.

I ended up not being able to cope with the pressure of that career, but also not having the skills I needed to get a careeer in visual arts. So I got a low paid (minimum wage) job which was unrelated to both sectors, and for several years I was earning next to nothing in something that I had no interest in.

I have now wound my way back to art and make a good living doing something I like.

Please don't discourage your children from doing what they love. You can encourage him to keep his options open and do some STEM subjects at school/ college, but the truth is that people who are passionate about the arts can and do make a good living! It might be that he has to supplement his income with some teaching or something else, but he will be OK.

And the truth is, if he loves it anyway, then he will inevitably wind his way back to it in the end like I did with my art. If you support him he might be able to avoid an identity crisis like mine!

FetlocksBlowingInTheWind · 19/12/2022 15:33

Would your DS be interested in something like this?

www.surrey.ac.uk/undergraduate/music-and-sound-recording-tonmeister

Excellent, very highly esteemed degree that combines music and STEM subjects.

Kanaloa · 19/12/2022 15:33

They probably don’t, but neither to STEM graduates who did the degree because their parents made them, because the likelihood is that the person then wouldn’t try hard as they’d have no interest in the topic.

I’d ask him what he wants to actually do and what his backup is and support him with those.

Winter2020 · 19/12/2022 15:28

My son is music mad and my husband showed me this meme which struck a chord

Do violinists make decent money?
greenacrylicpaint · 19/12/2022 15:27

if they get an engagement with a big orchestea it's ok.

if not he might need to supplement income for example by teaching.

he could look into sound engineering - mixing both passions.

AdelaideRo · 19/12/2022 15:24

The professional musician I know supplements her income working in Poundland.

She has a stellar CV - prestigious institutions/ fellowships/ training places/ prizes at open competitions but has really struggled to make it as a professional.
it’s a gig economy, with crap pay and lots of travel.

stopbeeping · 19/12/2022 15:22

Lol this really made me laugh

What about teaching?

Anonymous48 · 19/12/2022 15:22

My daughter is pursuing a career in the arts, and is currently at university studying this subject. It has been something she has been passionate about since she was very young, and we have never "encouraged' or "gently steered" her away from this passion towards those STEM subjects that she also did well in but didn't enjoy. She has worked incredibly hard up until this point and continues to do so. She is also realistic about her chances of making a good living purely doing this, and accepts that she will likely have to supplement her income by teaching or other roles in the industry.

If she hadn't been so driven and put so much blood, sweat and tears into her chosen field, perhaps we would have suggested that she consider a more lucrative one, but I can't imagine actively trying to guide your child away from something they love and which they are good at, and adds to our society.

blackandwhitecat123 · 19/12/2022 15:21

I tried to become a violinist and went to conservatoire. It was a huge shock- practically everyone else had done junior conservatoire etc and a huge amount of orchestral experience. It was enormously pressured and I went from feeling like it was my 'thing' to being the absolute bottom of the pile. I worked very hard but just couldn't keep up with the expected standard and dropped out. Even my friends who were the most talented and able in my cohort don't earn much and do a lot of peri work. A large proportion have gone on to do PGCEs and become secondary music teachers.

My advice would be only to go for it if he has an incredible drive to practise and likes the sound of the alternative career paths after graduating, because there's a good chance that he won't be able to make a living as a violinist. I didn't even consider this (switched to a university and completed a music degree) and came out of the whole experience wishing I'd done something else. I don't mean to be discouraging because some of my friends loved it, but it is important to have a plan B from that type of study that he's enthusiastic about if things don't work out.

Proteinpudding · 19/12/2022 15:21

I house shared with a woman who was a very good violinist, had studied to a high level and had played in an orchestra when she was at uni age I think (she had studied music at uni and she was still involved in some projects with people from that network)

She did part time jobs in the week and was self employed at weekends playing at weddings. She occasionally taught violin in schools but they were short contracts. The wedding gigs were good pay for the number of hours worked, but not enough to live on and obviously required working Saturday nights most commonly so wouldn't have suited everyone. She loved being a musician but was very clear that she had made sacrifices for what was her passion.

Alarae · 19/12/2022 15:20

I had a client who played violin (or something similar) at a big London hospital as part of play therapy for children.

I think it paid around 30k, but I'm not sure if that was for full time or not.

Swipe left for the next trending thread