Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do violinists make decent money?

115 replies

Jazz12 · 19/12/2022 14:59

DS (15) is a bright child. Academically strong and a very passionate violinist.

DH and I have always encouraged him to do well in STEM subjects. We’ve gently steered him in that direction since early childhood. He enjoys computer science, is a decent programmer and also likes biology. He wants to get into Tech (DH and I are in this field), he is also considering Medicine. However, I know he is very passionate about violin.

I understand it’ll be amazing to find a career you enjoy. It’s also equally important to make decent money to afford a good quality of life. House prices, bills everything is out of reach for many people (at least where I live) now. Unfortunately, only some fields pay well.

Do violinists earn well?

Just wanted to hear some perspectives before I talk to DS about it.

OP posts:
highfidelity · 19/12/2022 16:54

PS. Should have said they're a violinist and are two years or so into their career. They have only ever played with one orchestra.

highfidelity · 19/12/2022 16:53

Not entirely true re. orchestra salaries.
But it does depend on what kind of orchestra.

A close friend has a salaried position in a world famous orchestra and makes a large amount of money.
Not only is she paid per performance, and the orchestra tours all over the world, they also record soundtracks etc and play on various other things too, all of which are paid and can get royalties too.
She also does a little freelance work too, most recently for a singer who did an audience with type thing on tv.

However, roles in orchestras are hard to come by and competitive to get.
Once someone is hired, they tend to stay for their entire working life.
Often, those whom play in orchestras aren't necessarily the best players either.
This was a shock to find out.

It's also worth nothing that playing in an orchestra is very different from being a lead violinist, so those who tend to gravitate to playing in an orchestra do not want or need to progress.

Wilkolampshade · 19/12/2022 16:51

Good to hear from some pro's....been a long old journey for DD and every year that goes by I'm astonished at another of her friends or peers dropping out. They're always amazingly talented but it's just. such. a. hard. slog...

Changingmynameyetagain · 19/12/2022 16:48

I have a family member who is a classically trained opera singer, studied to MA level at RNCM and then struggled to find regular work as it’s so competitive, she’s now retrained as a music teacher and sings on the weekends.

littlepeas · 19/12/2022 16:43

Another though op - does he play the piano? It's worth being at least reasonably proficient, as many professional musicians also teach, conduct, accompany.

Siriusmuggle · 19/12/2022 16:42

It depends. Violin is one of the more popular instruments to play so there’s a lot of competition. If you get an orchestral place it’ll pay the bills but you won’t be rich. My friend was a professional musician, one of his instruments was violin but he wasn’t in an orchestra. He made a living out of it, loved it but it was hard work. He toured constantly and taught and ran a choir.
Having said all that my child is at conservatoire and wants to be a pro (not violin). For him it was the obvious option as he’s terrible at STEM and it’s all he’s ever wanted to do. With music you have to love it and be prepared for it to be hard work and competitive.

dementedma · 19/12/2022 16:42

Its a tough world in the performing arts. DS plays bass and picks up work as a pit musician in musical theatre and panto ( Oh yes he does) but its sporadic. He 's looking at a stint on Cruise ships to earn a bit more. I doubt he will make a full time career out of it but he tells me I'll eat my words when he picks up his first Grammy!
We shall see....

ProMusician · 19/12/2022 16:42

@Reedplayer the usual musicalchairs and muvac for orchestral positions. I have close ties to the West End and its equivalent in Germany (although much, much smaller) is Stuttgart. However I’m not quite sure how it all works over here as I’m based in another area.

As far as I know, Germany will invite you to audition regardless of passport and will then sponsor a visa if you’re hired.

You do have the complication of the German system being required on certain instruments such as the clarinet or a certain brand oh French horn in extra/A category orchestras.

blackandwhitecat123 · 19/12/2022 16:42

ProMusician · 19/12/2022 16:14

Gosh he's only 15, does he really need to decide one way or the other yet?

If he’s dead set on music then yes, it would be smart to decide now. Musicians start building their CVs in primary school, it’s a bit like professional sportspeople.

If he genuinely doesn’t mind one way or another, and isn’t aspiring to the LSO or BBCSO, then he’s got time.

Agreed. I was doing hours of practise every day in secondary school, my parents couldn't afford the type of teaching I needed so my mum (who was a talented pianist) did her best to help me practise in a concentrated way alongside my school violin teacher. We spent hours shut in the dining room together, it was lovely to spend that time together but I was woefully unprepared at music college.

15 is late to decide to pursue a career as a violinist, all my peers had been, as PP said, building a CV from being young children. I agree that following your passions is important but that can't always be professionally, without experiencing it it is hard to appreciate just how elitist and pressured conservatoire training is.

I'm making it sound all bad- it wasn't, it was an excellent environment for the people who had the right preparation and the talent. It might also be ok for someone who wanted to give it a bash and was happy to become a peri teacher if it didn't work out- I wasn't, and would have trained for four years for a career I had no hope of succeeding in if I hadn't left.

I was (not blowing my own trumpet 😆) very good and even my mum and peri teacher who were both reasonably knowledgeable were shocked that I wasn't up to par. The standard of kids at these places is absolutely stellar. Meanwhile, my primary school friend who was not as committed as I was pursued a totally different career but loves her violin, plays in amateur orchestras and gets significantly more joy out of doing it as a hobby than I ever did during professional training. I think she made the better choice, unless you're completely exceptional.

littlepeas · 19/12/2022 16:40

yodaforpresident · 19/12/2022 16:24

@littlepeas when you say building a CV, do you mean listing concerts sung in, solos, choirs etc?

Yes - it builds like a CV - sang in this choir with dates, performed this here, worked with this person, awarded this scholarship, did workshop with so and so, went on this tour, etc. Then music qualifications, etc.

I just keep a rough record of everything for when it's time to do her personal statement!

Reedplayer · 19/12/2022 16:32

Also name changed for this thread, as this is a topic close to my heart. I’m what’s known as a reed player - someone who plays all the wind instruments and I make my living largely in musical theatre. At £200 a night for a show in the west end, it can be reasonably lucrative (and leaves you time during the day for other activities) but pit orchestras are getting smaller. And there are no auditions, ever. It’s all about networking and who you know.

@ProMusician that’s very interesting about Germany. Are there places to look for adverts for jobs? And has Brexit made it more difficult?

littlepeas · 19/12/2022 16:31

ProMusician · 19/12/2022 16:14

Gosh he's only 15, does he really need to decide one way or the other yet?

If he’s dead set on music then yes, it would be smart to decide now. Musicians start building their CVs in primary school, it’s a bit like professional sportspeople.

If he genuinely doesn’t mind one way or another, and isn’t aspiring to the LSO or BBCSO, then he’s got time.

Sadly this is absolutely true. I remember being horrified that I was basically writing a CV for my dd and networking - I'm used to it now and it is essential if you want to pursue music. You need to get a bit pointy elbowed too, which is not naturally in my character at all. Get him auditioning for stuff - I don't know much about violin, as it's all about singing for us, but look for scholarships, residential courses, youth orchestras (local and national), junior conservatoire.

TheKeatingFive · 19/12/2022 16:30

God no. It's not something you'd do for the money.

I know someone who went into arts administration though and did pretty well. They are mega ambitious and focused though.

yodaforpresident · 19/12/2022 16:24

@littlepeas when you say building a CV, do you mean listing concerts sung in, solos, choirs etc?

rippleraspberry · 19/12/2022 16:19

ErrolTheDragon · 19/12/2022 15:46

He enjoys computer science, is a decent programmer and also likes biology. He wants to get into Tech (DH and I are in this field), he is also considering Medicine.

There's nothing here to suggest he'd hate doing a STEM degree or career, or that the parents are coercing him in this direction. Many multi-talented youngsters study and have careers in these areas while maintaining a strong interest in music or other artistic areas. My db was a doctor (now retired) - he was, and still is, an excellent organist. But one with an exceptionally good pension.

That's great for your brother, but it all depends on what you prioritise in life really, doesn't it?

Some people have a deep need to throw themselves into their passion, and for it to be their whole life. They would not be content doing it on the side as a 'strong interest' or a hobby, like your brother does.

I know artists and musicians who do this, and they may not have much money, but they are some of the richest people I know in terms of the life they live and being fulfilled. Truly.

Some people want/ need more material things and that is OK too. It sounds like your brother has a very good balance and that works for him.

But as for the OP, I don't think you can really know what type of person your child is going to become at 15 years old, and what they might prioritise. I don't think parents should make that decision for their children. I think the parents' job is to equip the child with all the knowledge/ wisdom they have, and then support them as a young adult in whatever decisions they make with that knowledge, and their own experience/ understanding of the world and themselves.

It's also good to remember that life is long and mistakes are not usually irreversible. If he makes a decision he regrets, he will be able to change down the line.

Giggorata · 19/12/2022 16:15

My little brother wasn’t paid much in the orchestra and was also in a folk band on the side.
But busking in our local cathedral city was generally an excellent earner for him, whether in a string quartet or alone.
You have to be a particular personality to live like that, I think, not a worrier. And if you have a family, I think your partner might need to have a regular salary coming in.

Wilkolampshade · 19/12/2022 16:15

From DD's experience, I'd add everything @ProMusician says is true btw.

ProMusician · 19/12/2022 16:14

Gosh he's only 15, does he really need to decide one way or the other yet?

If he’s dead set on music then yes, it would be smart to decide now. Musicians start building their CVs in primary school, it’s a bit like professional sportspeople.

If he genuinely doesn’t mind one way or another, and isn’t aspiring to the LSO or BBCSO, then he’s got time.

maxelly · 19/12/2022 16:13

Gosh he's only 15, does he really need to decide one way or the other yet? Yes music is a tough field to go into for various reasons but so is medicine, so are a lot of careers. And actually if you're purely thinking in monetary terms, for the hours put in/level of academic attainment required to get there, I'm not sure medicine is the best bet either, not in the UK anyway, certain specialisms have the opportunity to earn the megabucks in private practice but even for the higher earners it would be a very long hard slog (20 years + probably of very hard work) to get there and absolutely miserable if you didn't at least feel drawn to the work and enjoy it in some regards. I really think it's such a mistake to pin your teens down to a career path so early on (different of course if they feel a strong passion for something of their own accord), they grow and change so much into their early adulthood and the world of work and the multitude of different options open to them is evolving quicker than ever too.

At his age I'd focus on working hard at school, getting the best GCSE results he can and picking for A Levels the subjects he enjoys and does best in. He should certainly continue playing the violin and working hard at that too, it will be a good stress reliever and diversion from academic work if nothing else, playing in orchestras and bands is great socially for teens and the confidence boost from performing is nice too. And as others have said Music A Level can be a really nice choice alongside sciences and this would keep his options well open for a multitude of different university options and career paths later down the line...

Wilkolampshade · 19/12/2022 16:12

DD2 string player at Royal College Music having attended a specialist Music School from age of 9, v good player, perfectly likely to do well, but unlikely to ever earn more than 30k for a good few years and that would only be if she was very very very lucky and landed a seat in a good orchestra. She might be able to top up with teaching, session work and small ensemble but the effort required to keep all that in the air is immense. There are plenty of Conservatoire grads sitting behind desks doing Arts Admin jobs, 20-30k. Some of them were very good musicians too, but competition is fierce and you still need to keep practicing -it's really hard....
Back at her music school there were house assistants on barely above minimum wage all Conservatoire trained, all BMus, MA etc etc.... They were there because it came rent included and there were practice rooms I guess.
It's all a worry... but it was pretty obviously what she was going to do from the first time she picked up a violin. 🤷‍♀️

oviraptor21 · 19/12/2022 16:11

@Towcester After grade 8 you can do the music college diplomas and associate diplomas.

EasterIsland · 19/12/2022 16:11

I come from a family of live performers across a number of fields.

DO NOT underestimate how exceptionally good you have to be to attain an orchestra position.

I work in an adjacent field, and I see a lot of young people who are passionate, and pretty talented, and well-trained. That is not enough. For the performing arts, to make a decent, secure living, you have to be in the 1% of the 1%

If your DS has the ability to study medicine, encourage that. It'll be far, far easier to get into a medicine degree at university (as opposed to a conservatoire) and then to get a job.

ProMusician · 19/12/2022 16:08

PS and wherever you are in the world, hours are brutal, mental health declines rapidly if you don’t learn early enough how to deal with it all, and if you want a family you have to seriously reconsider what and how you are doing your job.

I started competing internationally at 9 which is part of what allowed me to become top of my field. I also work non-stop (albeit paid, which I wouldn’t be in the UK until the age of 28-30) and I’ve had two weekends off in the last 5 months. I travel a lot, which I like, but it’s tiring. I am regularly rehearsing 9am-1pm, then playing 6-11pm. I absolutely love it, but it’s exhausting and most people need lots of therapy because it’s not an easy life, and a very competitive industry.

Mincepiethief · 19/12/2022 16:08

NC for this as it’s going to be very outing!
You’ve had lots of good opinions here, especially from @Alittlenonsensenowandthen who is right to bring up the level your DS should be at to seriously consider a career in music.
I’m going to go slightly against some of the more negative posts and say that while being a professional musician very rarely pays well, it can pay well enough to have a decent standard of living.

I’m a section violinist in one of the BBC orchestras and we make between 34,000 and 50,000 in a massively generalised way - obviously it depends on London weighting, position, time in job etc. It’s not an enormous salary but it is all right. We can also freelance and teach on the side. As a pp said teaching can pay very well if you have a good reputation - my old teacher charges upwards of £150 for an hour and I know some who charge £300! But even a normal player with a conservatoire education could look at £40ph minimum.

Famous soloists like Vengerov or Ehnes can obviously choose their rate, but I suspect the lower level soloists often struggle as do many chamber musicians. What kind of playing does your son enjoy? Does he want to play in an orchestra or a quartet? Unfortunately if his ambitions are to a solo career it’s probably unlikely to happen - at this stage he would’ve been in international competitions etc.

Sorry this has been a bit scattered, but essentially I would first look at whether your DS would be able to make it in the industry, which can be brutally competitive, and then start thinking about whether it’s a wise decision. PM me if you have any questions!

curiouslycinnamon · 19/12/2022 16:07

@blackandwhitecat123 Yes I have heard similar as well from friends who are musicians. Sorry you went through that as well! :(

OP, you have two stories there from me and @blackandwhitecat123 from people who went in opposite directions with the arts and it didn't work out great for either of us.

I think the conclusion is that you should support your child in what he decides to do, after giving him all the information you know/ can find out.

The important thing is that it is your son's decision. My experience of blaming my parents has been really unpleasant. I think I would have found it easier to live with having gone to art school and it not worked out, knowing that it had been my own decision. Feeling pushed by my parents for it to then not work out just results in feelings of resentment and blame.

Talk it all through with him, tell him what you know, but support him in what he decides.