Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do violinists make decent money?

115 replies

Jazz12 · 19/12/2022 14:59

DS (15) is a bright child. Academically strong and a very passionate violinist.

DH and I have always encouraged him to do well in STEM subjects. We’ve gently steered him in that direction since early childhood. He enjoys computer science, is a decent programmer and also likes biology. He wants to get into Tech (DH and I are in this field), he is also considering Medicine. However, I know he is very passionate about violin.

I understand it’ll be amazing to find a career you enjoy. It’s also equally important to make decent money to afford a good quality of life. House prices, bills everything is out of reach for many people (at least where I live) now. Unfortunately, only some fields pay well.

Do violinists earn well?

Just wanted to hear some perspectives before I talk to DS about it.

OP posts:
whoareyouinviting · 19/12/2022 18:48

I'm assuming you'd have to travel a lot. That's something to consider.

JonahAndTheSnail · 19/12/2022 18:48

Realistically, to make decent money as an orchestral violinist he'd need to be already moving in those circles and be building contacts.

There is a huge huge amount of luck involved in the industry, and also a good deal of nepotism still 100% this. I studied music composition to MA level, got the highest mark in my year at a RG university - my tutor very openly told me he felt I had the greatest potential and raw talent in my year group. The one guy who ended up with an academic career in the field had an academic father who had been networking on his behalf since he was a young teenager (apparently he even went through the appeals procees when he tried and failed to get him into University of Cambridge at 13 years old)! As well as being talented and well connected, you have to be quite willing to brown nose people (some of whom have quite offensive views).

I would continue with the approach you've taken. My Dad was always very pragmatic and encouraged me to study what I love, but to always have other ideas what I could do for work. As it happens, I went into an entirely unrelated field connected to my DH's interests and ended up earning well for our chosen lifestyle. We're planning to retire by the time we're early 50s and I'll hopefully go back to writing music in my spare time without the pressure of having to worry about paying bills.

londonmummy1966 · 19/12/2022 18:47

I always laugh when people bang on about STEM. Believe it or not the arts are the second biggest contributor to the UK economy after finance. There is also the risk that in 20 years time a lot of STEM jobs will be obsolete due to AI doing them better which is less likely for the arts. However, if he is able to combine Music, Computing and Music Tech then he could well end up in a decent career in music tech. Well worth looking at.

And no most violinists don't make much money although many can pay the bills by teaching part time and playing part time.

ErrolTheDragon · 19/12/2022 18:24

it all depends on what you prioritise in life really, doesn't it?

Yes, absolutely. That's why parents can provide information and a reality check but it's always got to be their child's decision. Some people have a 'passion', combined with the talent and determination to take one path, some won't. A STEM degree may not be second best for the youngster described, it may be incredibly creative and fulfilling!

HotChoxs · 19/12/2022 18:19

No
but we're all becoming poor so might as well play a violin

HowVeryLikeSibella · 19/12/2022 18:11

I know a handful of (classical and non-classical) musicians making a decent living from a combination of private school music teaching and miscellaneous performances (bands, weddings, pantos, musicals). What they have in common is outgoing likeable personalities which enable them to network and get gigs and also smooths their path as teachers.

Teaching is a good fallback source of income for many talented musicians who can't pay the bills by playing alone, but it's not for everyone.

The most important thing to do is to consult his teacher to get a realistic assessment of your son's potential. Is he top 1%, or top 0.01%?

greenacrylicpaint · 19/12/2022 17:55

another consideration: instrument makers are looking for apprentices

ZZTopp · 19/12/2022 17:53

Definitely. I am a freelance violinist. I split my time between teaching and performance. The professional performances such as string quartet work is not that well paid because obviously the fee is split four ways. I do however enjoy solo performances at weddings. I charge £35 per hour for 1-1 lessons privately/ online, but I make most of my money from group tuition in schools.

I charge parents only £6.50 for group violin lessons at school. The groups are 3-4 children and 20 minutes long. I therefore can see up to 12 children in 1 hour. 12 x £6.50 is £78 per hour.

I am self employed so don’t have any holiday or sick pay but I often clear at least £1k per week. Wouldn’t go back to working for the local music service for anything! They charge parents an absolute fortune for music lessons and won’t pay their tutors more than £27 per hour.

MechanicaHound · 19/12/2022 17:52

Very interesting thread. It's been fascinating hearing from the professional musicians.

My brother went to the Royal College of Music (pianist) but dropped out and completed a music degree in another university. He didn't want to do anything except music, and he is a professional musician but it's not been easy or straightforward. He has done a lot of music theatre, including being the musical director of shows (not West end but the equivalent in another big UK city). Its long, gruelling hours, not compatible with family life. And once the show is over he's looking for work. He has regular work accompanying a choir. And does weddings /funerals etc at weekends. He only taught during Covid because other work dried up, but was paid a pittance working in a music school.

Me on the other hand, I was as talented as him and studied piano and violin. But I did a degree in something else and got a steady salaried job. I'm in my forties now and I still play both instruments to a reasonable standard. Playing music still brings me much joy. I play in church and am in an amateur orchestra, and just really enjoy them. I have encouraged my children to learn musical instruments too and while they are doing well I am under no illusions as to them being professional musicians. But they may decide to teach music, which is also a very worthwhile career.

One thing others have said which is very true - he should be learning piano as well.

greenacrylicpaint · 19/12/2022 17:49

oh, and one became a physio therapist specialising in musician's posture issues.

greenacrylicpaint · 19/12/2022 17:47

have a couple of proffessional musicians in my family.

all studied their main instrument to soloist level

  1. secondary music/musicology teacher
  2. part time position & festival orchestras & freelance culture columnist
  3. freelance musician on cruise ships (was stuck on a boat for months in corona quarantine)
  4. part time orchestra & conservatoire teacher
  5. part time correpetitor (mad piano skills required) & 6th form musicology teacher
FetlocksBlowingInTheWind · 19/12/2022 17:45

@BootifulLoser fair enough, wasn't suggesting it as a back up plan though! Just another option for a DC who's interested in music and STEM subjects 🤷🏻‍♀️

Trivium4all · 19/12/2022 17:43

Most violinists I know (including ones in big-name ensembles, because as others have said, full-time salaried places are not the norm) have portfolio careers. Teaching (privately, at schools, or university/conservatoire), instrument making, music editing, translating, community music making, music-related admin, web design... and these are top-ability performers. Performing tends to be cobbled together of some orchestra work, chamber music (usually several regular ensembles), and occasion music such as weddings or ceilidhs. All of them have to be very good at life admin and time organisation. It's not impossible to make a living from music, but one should be realistic about the likelihood of getting that salaried position, and be prepared to be inventive about how to generate income streams. On the other hand, if no one were willing to go for it, there wouldn't be any violinists around.

BootifulLoser · 19/12/2022 17:39

All the professional classical musicians I know are teachers.
The playing is very much just a bit they do on the side. One is in an orchestra but the members all have to pay fees to belong! All the money from engagements goes toward the band's costs (rehearsals, etc).

@FetlocksBlowingInTheWind being a professional audio engineer (Tonnmeister course) is just as difficult as becoming a well-paid musician. Definitely not something to do as a backup plan!

EasterIsland · 19/12/2022 17:36

Nobody enters those orchestras, let alone pass their trial period, without being truly astonishing.

From what I know of German Stadttheater orchesters, @ProMusician is correct.

DivorcingEU · 19/12/2022 17:33

I know someone who did conservatoire in another orchestra instrument. Getting into professional orchestras is something insane. She is incredibly talented, but that's not enough. You don't just interview/audition for a position and get it - unless you're exceptional, and that's exceptional in relation to your cohort, not to the general public!

If you think of the number of professional orchestras out there, then think about all the music graduates every year, you can see there's a rather large bottleneck. That's before you get to the "traineeship" business a lot of the big orchestras seem to have.

I know quite a few adults who have professional jobs and do music (or drama) at the weekend for fun. They're really good. But they can afford to play for the love of it, rather than to eat. Unless DS is already playing solo with orchestras, then let him slide into STEM if he wants. It may be the best way for him to keep up a love of music, unless he wants to be a music teacher (who would then likely need to play another instrument anyway - quality same for conservatoires, everybody I know who went to one played piano to around Grade 5 too, if not higher).

highfidelity · 19/12/2022 17:22

Mincepiethief · 19/12/2022 17:14

It’s entirely possible that @highfidelity‘s friend has only been in one orchestra. I walked into my job straight from conservatoire (although I’ve freelanced with many others) but that was sheer luck and many people I studied with who are much better musicians than I am still haven’t landed salaried jobs.

There is a huge huge amount of luck involved in the industry, and also a good deal of nepotism still, so OP’s son needs to be prepared to deal with that if he decides to go for it. It can be brilliant if it works out.

Thank you for your post. I do agree it's down to luck rather than sheer talent. My friend has also spoken of diversity hiring to the detriment of talent, along with nepotism too, but they have said that talent now seems to be the focus once more. But, it is all about luck, like so much in life.

So, and to repeat - my friend has only ever been in one orchestra. They were incredibly single-minded about that particular orchestra, and no other orchestra was an option. They got in on their first try and will stay there until retirement.

HitMeWithAHotNoteAndWatchMeBounce · 19/12/2022 17:20

Unless he is prodigy-level exceptional, i.e. playing concertos from memory to a stunning standard, then he won’t be able to make a great living from it, and even then he’d have to be truly exceptional to make even vaguely decent money.

Certain instruments are also over-subscribed, which makes them even more competitive, and the violin is at the top of that list.

Most good musicians will have a day job, and then earn pin money by being in a professional orchestra and/or chamber group.

Mincepiethief · 19/12/2022 17:14

It’s entirely possible that @highfidelity‘s friend has only been in one orchestra. I walked into my job straight from conservatoire (although I’ve freelanced with many others) but that was sheer luck and many people I studied with who are much better musicians than I am still haven’t landed salaried jobs.

There is a huge huge amount of luck involved in the industry, and also a good deal of nepotism still, so OP’s son needs to be prepared to deal with that if he decides to go for it. It can be brilliant if it works out.

highfidelity · 19/12/2022 17:12

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/12/2022 17:12

A tiny handful of professional violinists can make serious money.

The vast majority make very little. A salaried job in an orchestra pays very little. Teaching pays slightly better but with very little creativity obviously.

Most serious classical musicians have other careers.

Jazz12 · 19/12/2022 17:12

Didiplanthis · 19/12/2022 16:56

If your DS has the ability to study medicine, encourage that. It'll be far, far easier to get into a medicine degree at university (as opposed to a conservatoire) and then to get a job.

Please please don't encourage him into medicine because he has the ability.... it has to be a passion too... I had the ability and the passion to medicine and was heavily encouraged to do it. I have been so horribly broken by doing it because I never had the emotional resilience i needed to protect myself...but I was really good at it. I have finally walked away after 20 years of being bloody miserable. Its a really tough gig if you are not strong enough..

Thanks for sharing this.

OP posts:
Jazz12 · 19/12/2022 17:09

BriteSparke · 19/12/2022 15:11

The romantic notion of ‘having a job you love, never mind about the money’ is outdated and ridiculous.

Unfortunately I'd agree this. Having a job based on your passion is a guaranteed way to kill that passion. It's very different doing something you love for fun and doing it to pay the bills. Pursue your passions with the pressure.

absolutely true, unfortunately.

I was into fine art big time and wanted to do an arts degree. My parents steered me and my siblings towards subjects that pay well. I’m extremely grateful for that today, so are my siblings.

OP posts:
ProMusician · 19/12/2022 17:06

highfidelity · 19/12/2022 16:54

PS. Should have said they're a violinist and are two years or so into their career. They have only ever played with one orchestra.

This is simply not true unless you mean ‘professional orchestra’. To win an audition in a world famous orchestra, you’ll have been playing in ensembles from a very early age. County, national youth, if none of those then at least your Conservatoire orchestra and then academies / guest appearances. No world famous orchestra will even invite you to audition unless you have a very strong orchestral portfolio.

Often, those whom play in orchestras aren't necessarily the best players either.
This was a shock to find out.

I’m a regular guest (abo concerts and tours) with Vienna Phil / Berlin Phil / MCO / Orchestre National de France and similar (glad I’ve NC’ed now…). Every single member of those ensembles is a world class musician and they are all incredible artists. Even the lady in the last stand of the 2nd violins who is 64 and a few months off retirement age. Nobody enters those orchestras, let alone pass their trial period, without being truly astonishing. So unless your friend is talking about smaller average orchestras who have a median age of 55+, I wouldn’t really believe them.

And yes, world famous orchestra members do make lots of money. A rank violinist can be paid upwards of 60k a year. Solo oboes and concertmasters will be earning £££k. There are a few hundred positions like these in the world. Only a handful of vacancies open each year. Most are not filled - first hand experience here - because none of them incredible hundreds of applicants have made the cut, in the eyes of these people.

Didiplanthis · 19/12/2022 16:56

If your DS has the ability to study medicine, encourage that. It'll be far, far easier to get into a medicine degree at university (as opposed to a conservatoire) and then to get a job.

Please please don't encourage him into medicine because he has the ability.... it has to be a passion too... I had the ability and the passion to medicine and was heavily encouraged to do it. I have been so horribly broken by doing it because I never had the emotional resilience i needed to protect myself...but I was really good at it. I have finally walked away after 20 years of being bloody miserable. Its a really tough gig if you are not strong enough..