Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this might be it for the UK and will never get better?

185 replies

Desperado40 · 19/12/2022 06:37

I am sorry for a very pessimistic view, but I feel we are stuck in a downward spiral in the UK. Is it just me, or does anyone else think that we will be stuck in this loop with the effects of Brexit and a decade of austerity taking decades to ever recover from (if ever?).
If anyone has a better outlook, please let me know.

OP posts:
pumpkincivilisation · 19/12/2022 09:34

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/12/2022 07:52

I think its a combination of cyclical and structural stuff. We are at the bottom of the trough of a particularly bad economic cycle at the moment. That will inevitably come to an end... it always does. I'm old enough to remember several previous recessions and it always feels a bit apocalyptic but we always come out of it.

That said, I think there are some structural things going on with the UK system which make it worse. Our political parties don't really reflect our views and needs as a nation, our political institutions don't function properly and our infrastructure, much of which was set up in the post-war period of political consensus, doesn't work (NHS being the most obvious example). Against that there's the continual decline of the UK's relevance. We used to be a powerful empire and increasingly are an irrelevant, moderately affluent but quite dysfunctional country not affiliated to any particular power and with ideas above its station.

The Brexit delusion is just the last dying fart of these dreams of empire and its failure will demonstrate to future generations how delusional we were as a nation around this period. That said I'm optimistic that future generations will have a more pragmatic view of Britain (possibly a different shape of Britain) and adjust their expectations to create a more sustainable and grown-up nation state. It will get better but probably not in the way some people are hoping.

This... we have political parties which don't represent our interests as a nation...

MintJulia · 19/12/2022 09:32

@helford "Net zero? seriously, how do you think we can afford to upgrade insulation or buy an EV ?"

Given that a record amount was spent on Black Friday, that holiday companies were flat out this summer, yes, people do have money to spend. Not everyone of course but some do. Look at how many people spent £200 on an air frier.

And B&Q was sold out of loft insulation at the weekend. People are taking sensible steps to help themselves.

I don't have money at the moment, but the soaring gas price has prompted me to get a quote for a GSHP. I can't afford it but I now know what I need and it's in the 10 year plan for when my gas boiler dies.

Thereisnolight · 19/12/2022 09:22

Ylvamoon · 19/12/2022 07:11

I think what is currently happening is a huge adjustment.

We had it reasonably good over the last few decades.

Cheap goods, cheap food cheap energy,... you name it we had it.
Consumerism is on its knees as economies can't supply the stuff cheply anymore. Reasons are the shortages of raw materials and other emerging economies wanting the same consumer goods as us. Add politics and war and here we are.

Generally we need to learn to consume less and be more self reliant as a country/ continent. This will take time, decades? Maybe, who knows.

I think so too.

Hopefully the global population will come down or at least stop going up so that we won’t have to keep building accommodation on every single green space. There will be cleaner and cheaper energy. Less pollution, less landfill, less chopping down of forests, less killing of animals. Educated women, leading to fewer, more-valued and better looked-after children.

Less tolerance for the narcissists in each and every country who hoard resources by violence or trickery, then dole them out at a high price, and start or perpetuate wars to keep themselves on top.

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/12/2022 09:21

Sarahcoggles · 19/12/2022 09:14

Those who think the UK is the worst place - please tell me why more people than ever are risking their lives to come here? Why would that be, if most other countries in Europe are in a better state? No one ever answers that question. If so many people in the UK want to leave because it's so dreadful, why do so many other people want to come here?
Maybe, just maybe, people here are moaning too much, and they should try living elsewhere. Perhaps they'd find out how it feels to be so desperate that you're prepared to cross the channel in a tiny boat.

Someone always comes up with this total canard.

The fact that people are risking their lives to come to the UK doesn't mean that the UK is a uniquely special or charmed place. These are absolutely desperate people who are either being persecuted in their home countries or who cannot generate enough wealth to support their families in their home countries or both. They are not only coming to the UK, they are trying to come to many other relatively affluent countries because they perceive it to be a choice between that and destitution and/or death.

No one is saying the UK is worse than Syria or Afghanistan, as you well know. The question posed by the OP is whether the UK has reached the bottom point of its relatively strong historical trajectory and will it will ever get better and plenty of people have posed well thought out answers to this question.

Of course the UK is still a relatively affluent country compared to Syria or Afghanistan (as are most countries in Europe) and has a relatively stable government and civil society. That doesn't mean things are getting better here.

Your silly whataboutery doesn't begin to answer this question.

MarshaBradyo · 19/12/2022 09:21

BadShepherd · 19/12/2022 08:50

Tbh - all of you quacking on about range rovers and distribution of wealth for social care/NHS/etc probably need to nip over to scotsnet to see the folk running away from the new tax obligations imposed by the Scottish government to fund them.

Everyone wants more - until the bill arrives.

Yep often the answer is tax everything more - but it’s not in reality

Ncgirlseriously · 19/12/2022 09:18

Well if the Tories get in again I think I give up.
There’s this weird attitude that anyone who wants to improve the UK in any way is unpatriotic or should leave, and that’s just fucking bizarre to me. Yes, we love moaning, but that doesn’t mean that we have no genuine complaints. And we’re so used to the government being fucking corrupt and useless that people act like expecting them to do ANYTHING this unreasonable.

bellac11 · 19/12/2022 09:16

Sarahcoggles · 19/12/2022 09:14

Those who think the UK is the worst place - please tell me why more people than ever are risking their lives to come here? Why would that be, if most other countries in Europe are in a better state? No one ever answers that question. If so many people in the UK want to leave because it's so dreadful, why do so many other people want to come here?
Maybe, just maybe, people here are moaning too much, and they should try living elsewhere. Perhaps they'd find out how it feels to be so desperate that you're prepared to cross the channel in a tiny boat.

Most asylum seekers go to other european countries and every single time this sort of question is asked that answer is given. Look at the numbers yourself if you dont believe me

So its not accurate to say that no one ever answers this question

We take in a very very small number of refugees/asylum seekers

Sarahcoggles · 19/12/2022 09:14

Those who think the UK is the worst place - please tell me why more people than ever are risking their lives to come here? Why would that be, if most other countries in Europe are in a better state? No one ever answers that question. If so many people in the UK want to leave because it's so dreadful, why do so many other people want to come here?
Maybe, just maybe, people here are moaning too much, and they should try living elsewhere. Perhaps they'd find out how it feels to be so desperate that you're prepared to cross the channel in a tiny boat.

atotalshambles · 19/12/2022 09:10

I think it is everywhere , OP. There are big issues facing the world currently and I'm not sure that it is possible to escape them wherever you go. Each separate country has its own extra issues - for us Brexit, NHS etc.. I think you have to remain optimistic and do what you can to make the world a better place. I think it is good for everyone to experience life in another country - so if you want to live overseas then go for it! Nowhere is perfect but it puts perspective by experiencing different things.

helford · 19/12/2022 09:04

MintJulia · 19/12/2022 08:42

Anyone who remembers the 70s, will know that this is cyclical. We'll have a few tough years and then we'll bounce back.

In a way, the fuel crisis is a good thing because it will force governments to stop fannying around and commit more effort towards net zero, in the same way it will force more home owners to upgrade their insulation, heating systems, cars etc to more economic, greener versions.

How? in the 70s, we had North Sea coming on stream, not now.

Net zero? seriously, how do you think we can afford to upgrade insulation or buy an EV ?

Energy price support ends in April, meaning prices would have trebled in 12 months.

Not all is bad of course but to dismiss it as "part of global eco cycle" is foolish, UK has specific issues, not least Brexit, out of science and tech programs and loss of EU essential workers eg carers & dentists, wrecking the NHS & our teeth.

Getoff · 19/12/2022 09:04

RoseAndRose · 19/12/2022 08:46

We are still rather an outlier though.

Because although people aren't dying of it so much, the impact isn't just death. Even with end of widespread testing, we still have the highest rates per 000 population in Europe

That's more people ill, more lost work days, more in hospital, more long covid.

I had no reason to doubt you about our current rates of covid, and don't even particularly care, but when I googled, the first data that came up said we were something like 25th highest, and Germany had five times our rate, and France had 15 times our rate.

www.statista.com/statistics/1139048/coronavirus-case-rates-in-the-past-7-days-in-europe-by-country/

Echobelly · 19/12/2022 08:59

Not just UK - I am generally an optimist, honest, but I do feel like I've been lucky to live my life in a period of unprecedented relative peace, stability and prosperity, but that's now peaked. The environment's screwed and we're going to see mass displacement of people are war because more places will become uninhabitable. Inequality is at a ridiculous point with far too few people having far too much money and not caring to do anything with it for other people and so on.

Abra1t · 19/12/2022 08:57

Unifolorn · 19/12/2022 07:50

Lots or countries have a hybrid model and it works very well. Something has to change to have a chance at any sort of functioning health service, I think people grasping on to the crumbling NHS model as is isn't helping. I also love the ethos of a free at point of use heslthcare service, but at the moment it's if you're lucky you'll recieve medical care but it'll be sub standard and realistically people are dying needlessly; I'd be scared to be one of out patients currently. It is an issue globally though so I suspect the solution is not an easy one.

Exactly. Outcomes for poorer people seem to be much better in countries where there are other health systems. Germany, France, Australia, Spain.

Why does everyone jump to the US as the default?

upfucked · 19/12/2022 08:52

Yep even some pro Brexit politicians like Rees Mog said it would take a generation for this things to improve post Brexit.

BadShepherd · 19/12/2022 08:50

Tbh - all of you quacking on about range rovers and distribution of wealth for social care/NHS/etc probably need to nip over to scotsnet to see the folk running away from the new tax obligations imposed by the Scottish government to fund them.

Everyone wants more - until the bill arrives.

stonebrambleboy · 19/12/2022 08:50

Fairyliz · 19/12/2022 07:19

Stop being so dramatic. I’m in my 60’s and have experienced both good and bad times over the years.
The thing I’ve realised is that generally the bad things had nothing to do with the government/economy/environment.
Eg cheating partner, dead babies and a house fire would have happened irrespective of which party was in power.
You have to plan for the worst, grit your teeth and get through it and then enjoy the good times when they come.

Well said.

The 1930s (Depression) 1940s (War) 1950s (Rebuilding after the War) were far harder in this country.

felulageller · 19/12/2022 08:50

The west/ developed world is in a terminal relative decline.

The GDP per capita still isn't back at 2006 levels in the UK, not even taking into account inflation!

When they say the economy is growing it's only because the population is growing. Of course more people = more money but it's not more per person. We are all getting poorer, that's why we feel poorer.

This was all the case even before Brexit COVID Ukraine.

Brexit and the decade of austerity were Tory policies, which have damaged the economy. They are responsible for these and the UK has performed worse than it should have because of these.

But there are global issues too. (Global birth rates rapidly declining being the biggest long term issue)

If you look at the top countries by population and total GDP in 2100 it's very different g7/ G20 from today.

The new power will be in Asia/ Africa not Europe/ USA.

G7 2100: India, China, Nigeria, Pakistan, USA, Indonesia, Ethiopia.

RoseAndRose · 19/12/2022 08:46

Getoff · 19/12/2022 08:30

The appalling state of the NHS is not global, that has been a very conscious decision by the government.

And yet a large majority of the globe would be better off if they had the NHS, even in it's present state.

Brexit is not global

The vast majority of the globe are not in the EU, or anything like it, and never will be, and don't see that as a problem.

The government's behaviour during the pandemic is not global

Remember when everyone was moaning about the death statistics, how badly the UK was doing? I've looked at the cumulative figures recently, we are now middling for large European countries. We're not an outlier any more, things have equalised.

We are still rather an outlier though.

Because although people aren't dying of it so much, the impact isn't just death. Even with end of widespread testing, we still have the highest rates per 000 population in Europe

That's more people ill, more lost work days, more in hospital, more long covid.

MintJulia · 19/12/2022 08:42

Anyone who remembers the 70s, will know that this is cyclical. We'll have a few tough years and then we'll bounce back.

In a way, the fuel crisis is a good thing because it will force governments to stop fannying around and commit more effort towards net zero, in the same way it will force more home owners to upgrade their insulation, heating systems, cars etc to more economic, greener versions.

TheKeatingFive · 19/12/2022 08:37

It isn't global though. There are global issues, but all the stats show the U.K. to be particularly badly affected.

And that's because of self inflicted issues like Brexit, lack of political reform, failing to tackle nhs issues.

Im in ROI and we have our own problems, but the mood of the country is far more positive than I see from my friends in the U.K.

Getoff · 19/12/2022 08:30

The appalling state of the NHS is not global, that has been a very conscious decision by the government.

And yet a large majority of the globe would be better off if they had the NHS, even in it's present state.

Brexit is not global

The vast majority of the globe are not in the EU, or anything like it, and never will be, and don't see that as a problem.

The government's behaviour during the pandemic is not global

Remember when everyone was moaning about the death statistics, how badly the UK was doing? I've looked at the cumulative figures recently, we are now middling for large European countries. We're not an outlier any more, things have equalised.

MangyInseam · 19/12/2022 08:25

There is a larger global adjustment going on. The problems with supply, health services, etc, are by no means limited to the UK.

To some extent we've all been living for the past 100 years with expectations of more and more which have never been really sustainable, and which have been fueled by very cheap energy. There has also been a long push to global economic integration, and we are now all seeing the downsides of this in a real way. But this was not something that only the UK did, it was pushed by all the higher economic bodies, the banks, the stock market, the World Bank, IMF, etc. So far no one has figured out how to really start devolving that and creating a more resilient economy.

It's also true that there have been series of economic booms and busts for decades, as well as social or cultural fluctuations. Right now the cultural patrimony of the west is under attack in many ways so it should not be a huge surprise that people feel kind of depressed.

One of the things that concerns me most right now is how drugs have come to play such a huge role in social breakdown. It's difficult to see how we could put that genie back in the bottle. But it drives so much crime, homlessness, etc.

TheKeatingFive · 19/12/2022 08:24

Of course it will get better, but the country needs to grow up, take stock and take responsibility.

Brexit was a disaster, because it tapped into fantasies about what people wished was wrong with the country, rather than what was actually wrong. Naturally it didn't solve anything, it made the situation worse.

So many things need reform. The political system, the nhs, social care, education, welfare. The U.K. needs people willing to grasp those very difficult problems and make the better. The country also needs a plan for growth and development.

Decline can only be stopped by working through the problems.

bellac11 · 19/12/2022 08:22

MilkyYay · 19/12/2022 08:19

Globalisation, consumerisation & digitalisation was sold to us as a way we could access cheap stuff made abroad. It bought us a few decades where

Actually what it really was, was a way for capital owners to access cheap labour abroad, create markets for products we don't need, and generate a lot of waste.

The benefits of it in terms of profits were never distributed fairly, all it has done is concentrate wealth driven by labour and value creation, into the hands of an ever smaller pool of individuals, who are able to hide behind corporate structures.

In a village centuries ago, if one or two individuals were accruing more than their share of the local wealth it was obvious and easily redressed, in a global economy its easier to hide the inequality for longer.

Your final paragraph is a joke surely?

Do you know anything about history and how society was divided up pre and post industrialisation?

Swissnotswiss · 19/12/2022 08:22

Whilst it is a global problem, I do think that the UK is going to have to face reality , namely that we are not an empire, we are a relatively small island with great swathes of the population living in poverty. And we have deliberately made it hard to trade with our closest neighbours. As someone said recently we are the only nation to have declared a trade war on ourselves! Unless we stop lying to ourselves things are not going to improve.

Swipe left for the next trending thread