Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell you iPads are actually good for kids

107 replies

PennyRa · 19/12/2022 00:04

This is something I researched extensively for my thesis in technology and education. iPads, tablets, phones, they all show positive effects on their development. Yes, including social.

I've seen a lot of anti screens on here recently but there is nothing wrong with kids in buggys on tablets, kids in cafes on iPads.

There are obviously caveats, some content is bad. It's on a scale but it's easy to see; a child playing Duolingo is vastly better than candy crush, a child watching How it's made is vastly better than cocomelon. Also the content needs to be locked and monitored for safety. However, tailored content can be better than a teacher.

OP posts:
Ocrumbs · 19/12/2022 06:13

Is your thesis published? Could you share a link? Or a link to any of the research.

Itsthewhitehat · 19/12/2022 06:09

Of course they are great for kids. But it all about the context.

I don’t believe that hours and hours of anything on a tablet is great for a child. They need lots of different forms of interactions, including in person interaction.

The content obviously matters. But then does keeping an eye on how they are when they can’t have it or come off it.

Tablets can be good or bad and it’s down to the adults supervising it and supervising it properly.

Ylvamoon · 19/12/2022 06:05

It's reassuring that OP thinks children should be glued to a screen instead of engaging with the world around them.

...

curiouslycinnamon · 19/12/2022 06:05

This reply has been deleted

Post withdrawn at author's request

😂This!

What you're saying is not revolutionary at all. Back when TV first became a thing and kids were told they would get 'square eyes', there were plenty of people advocating that TV was great if they watched the correct educational material instead of cartoons.

Of course watching documentaries and learning languages is 'good', however it's not what they're doing!

So how does your research recommend getting kids away from cocomelon and onto 'how it's made'?

hopeisathingwithfeathersx · 19/12/2022 06:04

Please could you link to the research?

Pastash · 19/12/2022 05:58

I’ve relaxed on having the tv on when my one year old is in the room but that’s because she doesn’t sit glued to it. She loves Kevin from Grand Designs and laughs every time he comes on screen. I don’t think screens are inherently bad and in of themselves.
However it’s opportunity cost. Maybe when my daughter is watching Kevin she is missing out on concentrating on advancing her skills with her toys.
That child in the cafe on the iPad is not learning how to interact with others in a public setting, and is losing out on the language and social skills development that would otherwise occur.

You can tell me I’m really smug but when my baby is on the tram into town with me she sits on my knee/stands in front of me, looks around, points out doggies, has a look out the window whilst I comment on anything interesting, and waves bye at people who are getting off. Each trip is a tiny snippet of learning and experience as opposed to being sat in her buggy with a phone and learning nothing.

Idratherbepaddleboarding · 19/12/2022 05:53

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

PorridgewithQuark · 19/12/2022 05:44

PennyRa we had iPads donated to work (special needs facility) and all the available learning apps seem to only be free in an extremely limited trial version (literally the first two letters of the alphabet for a reading app type thing) and then extremely expensive.

They're therefore essentially useless bricks.

Can you recommend free apps on iPad?

Ideally ones available in base languages other than English (ones which either work with the language selected for the device or where you can change the user language).

Android seems vastly better for free content but it's iPads we've been donated, without a single penny for software/ apps.

Sirzy · 19/12/2022 05:35

It’s not as black or white as good or bad though. There are certainly bonuses and I don’t think in the modern world parents do any good by trying to completely avoid technology use but it has to be balanced and appropriate.

ds is autistic and for him his iPad is a godsend both as a calming tool and a way for him to further research his areas of special interest but as with anything it’s about balance.

an iPad alone, even with tailored content, certainly can’t come close to being better than a teacher

RambamThankyouMam · 19/12/2022 05:30

Who funded your thesis?

BeanieTeen · 19/12/2022 05:10

But anything that’s a ‘pro’ about a device can be achieved without a device for the most part - that doesn’t make the device good, just the activity itself. On the whole, devices are just way to stimulating and addictive for children, especially young ones. And adults. I can’t sleep and here I am scrolling MN, it’s not going to help… goes off to put down phone and pick up book…

sashh · 19/12/2022 04:45

I don't think anything is as simple as good or bad.

The way we take in information changes but it is the information that is important. Some things you can only learn by doing such as riding a bike or learning to walk.

I'm currently studying with the OU, my resources are sent to me in the form of books, the same information is sent to me on blue paper because I'm dyslexic and it is also available online.

It's the same information.

ichundich · 19/12/2022 02:52

Wow, how long did it take you to come up with these findings?

NumberTheory · 19/12/2022 02:21

AnneLovesGilbert · 19/12/2022 00:07

The bosses in Silicon Valley who have kids disagree with you. But I hope you enjoyed your “research”.

It’s easy to find articles with the few that are vocal about not wanting their kids on screens, but plenty of the bosses (and even more of the front line coders) encourage their kids to use tech.

EarringsandLipstick · 19/12/2022 02:14

Hours of Royal institution lecturers yes,

That's not how learning works. It's not as simple as the quality of the content - it's about the medium, and the suitability of that medium for the content, purpose & audience.

So a child looking at a screen with the content you mention will gain no benefit at all, as pedagogically, they won't have an opportunity to interact or engage with it in a way that will make sense for them.

Screens have their benefits; and their drawbacks.

Please share your 'research'? 🙂

Waitingfordecember · 19/12/2022 02:14

I’d be really interested to read your research? Me and DH were just talking today about how, in the past, reading fiction novels (especially romances like Pride and Prejudice) was seen as something that would rot your brain… now we all want children to read. I wonder what people in the future will think about screens?

vodkaredbullgirl · 19/12/2022 02:04
Hmm
thisusernameisnotavailablepleasetryanother · 19/12/2022 01:37

Not great for eyesight though!

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/12/2022 01:15

Ooh this should be good!

People on MN get fiercely upset about kids they don’t know being in an iPad. I’ll grab the popcorn.

Walkwithmetonight · 19/12/2022 01:12

Link to your thesis please! This is also my research area and I’d be… surprised if the conclusion you’ve written here is actually what the data demonstrates.

if what you meant to write was:
”in an otherwise enriched environment, children who watch small amounts of educational screen time achieve well.”
then fine - I’ll buy it.

TheFrozenCanal · 19/12/2022 01:10

No. Whatever it's showing, when it becomes a fight to remove it, there's a problem.
Then there's the environmental impact of every child having a tablet.

PennyRa · 19/12/2022 01:08

ElspethTascioni · 19/12/2022 00:07

In small doses, with educational content, I’m sure that’s true. Hours of YouTube, not so much…

It depends. Hours of Royal institution lecturers yes, hours of a kid unboxing toys not so much

OP posts:
Itsallyellow22 · 19/12/2022 00:29

I call bullshit 😅

GoldenCagedBird · 19/12/2022 00:26

PennyRa · 19/12/2022 00:04

This is something I researched extensively for my thesis in technology and education. iPads, tablets, phones, they all show positive effects on their development. Yes, including social.

I've seen a lot of anti screens on here recently but there is nothing wrong with kids in buggys on tablets, kids in cafes on iPads.

There are obviously caveats, some content is bad. It's on a scale but it's easy to see; a child playing Duolingo is vastly better than candy crush, a child watching How it's made is vastly better than cocomelon. Also the content needs to be locked and monitored for safety. However, tailored content can be better than a teacher.

Can you link to the research please?

123woop · 19/12/2022 00:13

...are you on Tim Cook's payroll? 🤨😂

Swipe left for the next trending thread