Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell you iPads are actually good for kids

107 replies

PennyRa · 19/12/2022 00:04

This is something I researched extensively for my thesis in technology and education. iPads, tablets, phones, they all show positive effects on their development. Yes, including social.

I've seen a lot of anti screens on here recently but there is nothing wrong with kids in buggys on tablets, kids in cafes on iPads.

There are obviously caveats, some content is bad. It's on a scale but it's easy to see; a child playing Duolingo is vastly better than candy crush, a child watching How it's made is vastly better than cocomelon. Also the content needs to be locked and monitored for safety. However, tailored content can be better than a teacher.

OP posts:
Beanbagtrap · 19/12/2022 22:09

I got stuck on a train with DS today. All I had was my phone so let him play a puzzle game..he's 3 so this involved dragging and dropping puzzle pieces into an area of the screen. In comparison to the physical dexterity required to do a proper puzzle, the app was shit.

PennyRa · 19/12/2022 22:09

Duttercup · 19/12/2022 17:38

No, no, darling, you can't have Peppa again but there's a perfectly lovely lecture on the science of gun shot residue analysis.

Yeah, I was a little surprised they chose forensic science this year. I guess we'll find out how they managed to make it child friendly next week 😅

OP posts:
elephantmarchingin · 19/12/2022 22:05

We found that getting DS his iPad and having things on there such as number blocks and alpha locks has brought on his speaking and maths leaps and bounds.
I don't think it is intrinsically bad

Nordix · 19/12/2022 21:56

Before I was a parent, I thought the anti-ipad brigade were so judgemental and old fashioned. It was surely impossible to parent without an ipad some of the time, etc etc.

Now I have kids, I’ve realised that’s bollocks for most children (the exception being SEN). My kids have an ipad, it doesn’t get turned on for months at a time. At home - they play with toys or draw/colour. In the car/buggy/cafes, they play with toys, watch the world go by or we talk to them. They are fine.

There is no way that 0-6 aged children being on an ipad for an hour or more a day is in anyway beneficial or even neutral. Their brains are being formed. Older children for educational games etc - yes. Young children - no. Also your research sounds rubbish.

PennyRa · 19/12/2022 21:52

curiouslycinnamon · 19/12/2022 06:05

😂This!

What you're saying is not revolutionary at all. Back when TV first became a thing and kids were told they would get 'square eyes', there were plenty of people advocating that TV was great if they watched the correct educational material instead of cartoons.

Of course watching documentaries and learning languages is 'good', however it's not what they're doing!

So how does your research recommend getting kids away from cocomelon and onto 'how it's made'?

Just don't put cocomelon and the like on the tablet

OP posts:
DeeCeeCherry · 19/12/2022 21:47

Not sure about that. When a friend's DS was 5 he was addicted to ipad. One day she caught him using iPad in bed when he should have been asleep. She took it off him and he started trembling from head to toe, + head jerking all over the place, because he couldn't have his iPad. Perhaps try books...

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 19/12/2022 21:14

I’m not surprised.
I think IPADS are a tool, much like computers, books, lectures, CDS etc. it’s the content and how people engage with them that is important.

Also important to mention that many children use iPad or similar devices to communicate in ways that might not have been possible without technology due to their needs.

TumbleFryer · 19/12/2022 20:50

I’m not sure how you expected anyone to agree with you OP. We’ve all experienced the opposite. It’s even more far fetched when you refuse to tell us what you were studying, where and to what level. Anyone can write a thesis.

NamelessTemptress01 · 19/12/2022 20:34

Greatly · 19/12/2022 00:09

No, just regular analogue books made of paper. Never had an ipad, don't see the point of them.

How are you posting on MN without a device?

user1497207191 · 19/12/2022 20:09

There's no such thing as them being "good" or "bad". It all depends. It depends basically on what they're being used for, how the user uses them, etc. If someone is spending hours per day watching inane youtube videos of fluffy cats or playing mindless games like Candy Crush, then clearly that's not good.

But lots of games have very valuable educational value, such as Minecraft which is very creative and educational, especially when you come to create your own Worlds, create your own interactive games, etc. No one would whinge if your son spent a few hours playing with Lego, but Minecraft is basically the same virtually, in fact it's better as you have unlimited "bricks", world sizes, etc.

Even the likes of FIFA can be useful in terms of "managing" your money (coins), to earn them, strategically buy/sell players, etc. My son used to spent more time on playing the transfer market than actually playing football on it - identifying players who may increase in value over the year, etc.

As for googling, etc., he was always looking at different things, just out of curiosity/nosiness.

We've always been a bit worried about his screen time, but we've always made sure we know what he was doing on it, had comprehensive parental controls in place so he couldn't watch unsuitable content, buy things with real money, etc. and insist on him playing/watching in a room with us instead of being in his bedroom alone.

We needn't have worried. He's just about to graduate with a first degree in Mathematics, and is a mature and well rounded adult now, already secured a good job in a blue chip firm that he starts in the Summer. All his online activity/gaming has given him a massive amount of knowledge and he is his Uni college quiz team captain in inter-college quizzes.

By the way, he's not read a book since primary school, yet still got grade 9's in his GCSE English Language and Literature, as well as grade 9s in History and Geography - all "traditional" subjects where you'd think reading books was essential - he got those grades by watching online videos!

PayPennies · 19/12/2022 19:31

Don’t know where to start. Communications scholars have long de bunked screen time myths and drawn out the nuances of our relationships with media and technology. Evidence is complex, neither suited for euphoria nor panic - and decades of evidence in communication studies show that media “effects” aren’t linear nor causal.

iPads are neither “good” nor “bad”. That’s not how our relationships with tech works. The context of use; the content being consumed; the broad overall contexts of the child all matter.

id love to link to my faculty staff page but I obviously can’t. So - instead May I suggest reading Parenting for a Digital Future and work by Sonia Livingstone and colleagues on the Global Kids Online project?

MilkyYay · 19/12/2022 19:30

Positive effects on development compared to what, sitting doing nothing?

Or are you trying to claim that watching How It's Made is as positive for a child's development as building a lego model from instructions, or creating a den in the garden, or riding a bike in the woods.

Most young children only consume media on tablets. They don't often create anything, solve a problem, work out how do something, take turns with peers, exercise, socialise, or build gross & fine motor skills.

Older children who can play more complex games may employ & develop some useful skills but the flip side is screen addiction.

titchy · 19/12/2022 19:25

ZeroFuchsGiven · 19/12/2022 18:48

Ah, Its You Grin

The poster who homeschools their incredibly gifted primary school child, 7 days a week. The child that is far to clever to ever do GCSE's because to them it would be 'pointless'.

Careful op, You are giving all your homeschooling secrets away now thhrow them in front of an ipad

Oh one of those! GrinGrinGrin

MadeForThis · 19/12/2022 19:15

PorridgewithQuark · 19/12/2022 05:44

PennyRa we had iPads donated to work (special needs facility) and all the available learning apps seem to only be free in an extremely limited trial version (literally the first two letters of the alphabet for a reading app type thing) and then extremely expensive.

They're therefore essentially useless bricks.

Can you recommend free apps on iPad?

Ideally ones available in base languages other than English (ones which either work with the language selected for the device or where you can change the user language).

Android seems vastly better for free content but it's iPads we've been donated, without a single penny for software/ apps.

Khan Academy kids is a free app for iPad. Loads of content. Pretty sure you can change language too.

Alloftheusernamesaretakenn · 19/12/2022 18:53

I’d be interested to hear what level of degree your thesis was submitted for, OP. Was it Bachelors/Masters/Doctorate? And the title of the course too, please?

ZeroFuchsGiven · 19/12/2022 18:48

Ah, Its You Grin

The poster who homeschools their incredibly gifted primary school child, 7 days a week. The child that is far to clever to ever do GCSE's because to them it would be 'pointless'.

Careful op, You are giving all your homeschooling secrets away now thhrow them in front of an ipad

Kanaloa · 19/12/2022 18:42

PennyRa · 19/12/2022 16:43

You think watching a lecture that you are interested in has NO educational benefits‽ What on earth do you think education is?

A child watching Royal Institute lectures has basically no educational benefits. I mean look at uni - we have primary and secondary reading assigned, then we attend the lecture, including opportunities for questions at the end, then we attend seminars to discuss and understand the information. Sitting staring at a iPad lectures you couldn’t possibly access? No, that has no educational benefits. Otherwise teachers would just stick a video of a lecture on and sit behind their desk relaxing.

Kanaloa · 19/12/2022 18:36

I’d also be really interested to see how that thesis research looked - it ‘can be’ better than a teacher, hours of lectures are better than hours of unboxing videos, phones are good for all types of development. How did you undertake this type of research?

titchy · 19/12/2022 18:36

TerraNostra · 19/12/2022 18:18

Not sure why you are worried about “doxxing” yourself- I thought that the whole point of PhD theses was that they had to be published?

Given OP's lack of supporting evidence I don't think she'll be publishing any time soon!

TerraNostra · 19/12/2022 18:35

napody · 19/12/2022 18:32

Well, 18 hours after posting and still nothing. How incredibly surprising.

Loved 'I'm not going to dox myself' 😂
Imagine the thesis, with 'an old paper' and 'lots of people' in place of actual citations. Couldn't be putting names to research, could we, that's doxxing!

Maybe OP learned how to do research from a You Tube video?

Kanaloa · 19/12/2022 18:33

You know what’s even better than iPads though? Minding your business. You buy your kid an iPad and enjoy your research knowing you’ve done the ‘good’ thing. And I’ll just talk to my kids when we go out to eat together. We’ll both be doing what we think is good.

napody · 19/12/2022 18:32

titchy · 19/12/2022 16:31

I'm obviously no going to dox myself but there are a lot of papers out there in this area

Then link to some Hmm

Well, 18 hours after posting and still nothing. How incredibly surprising.

Loved 'I'm not going to dox myself' 😂
Imagine the thesis, with 'an old paper' and 'lots of people' in place of actual citations. Couldn't be putting names to research, could we, that's doxxing!

TerraNostra · 19/12/2022 18:18

Not sure why you are worried about “doxxing” yourself- I thought that the whole point of PhD theses was that they had to be published?

SparkyBlue · 19/12/2022 18:09

I've a DC with autism and at some of the parenting courses I've done in relation to asd this comes up time and time again. Many parents of children on the spectrum have found that screen time has really helped their children with speech and communication skills.

Duttercup · 19/12/2022 17:38

PennyRa · 19/12/2022 01:08

It depends. Hours of Royal institution lecturers yes, hours of a kid unboxing toys not so much

No, no, darling, you can't have Peppa again but there's a perfectly lovely lecture on the science of gun shot residue analysis.

Swipe left for the next trending thread