Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell you iPads are actually good for kids

107 replies

PennyRa · 19/12/2022 00:04

This is something I researched extensively for my thesis in technology and education. iPads, tablets, phones, they all show positive effects on their development. Yes, including social.

I've seen a lot of anti screens on here recently but there is nothing wrong with kids in buggys on tablets, kids in cafes on iPads.

There are obviously caveats, some content is bad. It's on a scale but it's easy to see; a child playing Duolingo is vastly better than candy crush, a child watching How it's made is vastly better than cocomelon. Also the content needs to be locked and monitored for safety. However, tailored content can be better than a teacher.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
buttercuplizzy · 22/12/2022 19:33

My son was in hospital just under a month with a broken leg and then immobile at home for a further 4 weeks. We relied on a phone for those 8 weeks to keep us all sane... however, at the end of it I could see how addicted he had become. We had huge tantrums and screaming fits. He stopped wanting to play as he used to and would be hunting around the house for the phone. We have since decided that we do not like the behaviour the devices caused and have now heavily restricted it. I do not see there benefit at all, apart from entertaining an immobile young child.

NumberTheory · 22/12/2022 19:04

Professor Przybylski at Oxford is one of the lead researchers in this area who actually uses robust protocols. He has tended to find that correlation (between various screen time activities and desired outcomes) is generally positive, but small.
E.g.
www.nature.com/articles/s41562-018-0506-1

TheRookieMum · 20/12/2022 14:06

I bet OP has no thesis, no links, no research to share. Just wanted an interesting thread to watch.

Ah well, I've enjoyed it, so thanks for that at least. But I would still love to read your hypothesis, methods, inclusions, exclusions, limitations, evidence, discussion, etc, you know, when you're ready to "dox" yourself.

LolaSmiles · 20/12/2022 13:38

So we're still waiting for a single link to support the OP's research then?
We are indeed.

I'd be interested to hear what groundbreaking conclusions they've drawn that show it's simple when the consensus in the field tends to be, or was a few years ago when I did a professional project on it, that it's a complex topic and there's wider social factors to consider as well.

JazbayGrapes · 20/12/2022 11:11

Umm... yes and no. There are numerous educational apps which are excellent. However, leave kids to it and all they do is play Candy Crush and watch mindless Youtube.

unfortunateevents · 20/12/2022 10:49

So we're still waiting for a single link to support the OP's research then?

FurAndFeathers · 20/12/2022 07:03

PennyRa · 19/12/2022 16:26

I'm obviously no going to dox myself but there are a lot of papers out there in this area. I think I used 20 something for the harm/benefit section alone. One of them was old on the use of calculators in school because people thought it would produce a generation devoid of any mathematicians, which obviously didn't happen and seems laughable by today's society.

So you aren’t providing any actual evidence then @PennyRa

As a research scientist you expect us to believe the opinion of a randomer on the internet simply because you claim to have done credible research (with no evidence of this).

sure that’s definitely how critical thinking and science communication works!

KvotheTheBloodless · 20/12/2022 06:50

Like most things, it massively depends on parental control and oversight. Playing in the park = good for development, but not so great if you just dump your small children there and leave them! Screens are the same, they're not a babysitter and shouldn't be used like that frequently. Parents should choose the content their DC are exposed to in the same way you choose their books and clothing. DC get a say, but the final decision is on you.

WordtoYoMumma · 20/12/2022 06:38

I hate how much my teens are on their phones. Looking at them while they walk around. My catchphrase is "phone away please". How can it possibly be a good thing that my 14 year old spends all his time (or would if I let him) even when out, staring at some singing monsters on a phone?

I'm thankful it wasn't really an issue when mine were toddlers but I'd like to think I absolutely would not have let them have phones and tablets so young, and not in the pram when they should be interacting with the world.

Now, I've not done a thesis or anything but I do work in education visiting dozens of early years settings and the kids coming through aged 2-3 across the board are experiencing speech delay, limited play and social skills; so many that I see don't know how to play with actual toys. 2 year olds aren't talking or playing with each other.

Why?? I don't know. Im not a researcher into child development, I only know what I see. Pandemic effects, lockdown babies, poverty increasing, facilities shut down, lack of health visitors, no children's centres, no access to parenting classes. All possible reasons. But we have to consider throwing use of screens and devices into the mix. You don't have to have a PhD in child development to figure out that a child in a buggy staring at YouTube is having less social experience than the one looking around and being spoken to by the old ladies in the queue at Tesco...

EarringsandLipstick · 20/12/2022 06:31

You think watching a lecture that you are interested in has NO educational benefits‽

What child is interested in a 'royal institution' lecture? You are projecting what an adult might find educational onto a child.

You clearly haven't a clue either about education, or technology.

Givemyheadpiece · 20/12/2022 06:17

‘Hours of Royal institution lecturers yes,’

and famously this has been an surprise hit with children, they’re all watching lectures theses days.
particularly the under 8s

PorridgewithQuark · 20/12/2022 06:10

MadeForThis · 19/12/2022 19:15

Khan Academy kids is a free app for iPad. Loads of content. Pretty sure you can change language too.

Thank you! I will look today.

As op wrote a thesis on iPad use specifically (apparently) you'd have thought they'd have researched apps extensively and have recommendations at their fingertips...

curiouslycinnamon · 20/12/2022 06:10

PennyRa · 19/12/2022 21:52

Just don't put cocomelon and the like on the tablet

Do you have kids? 😂

Find me a 13 year old who has not succeeded in getting what they want on their tablet/ youtube/ etc and I will give you a medal.

Givemyheadpiece · 20/12/2022 05:31

Kids by absorbing the world around them, not with their head in a screen.
If you have a tablet at a restaurant table you’re not helping your child learn how to socialise at meals out, or behave.
if they have one on a car journey then they are missing the world around them.
if you use audio books to read to them then they’re missing out on the interaction with you, their parent.

and on and on …

Givemyheadpiece · 20/12/2022 05:28

Someone I know, running an Ed Tech company he helped start, has just quit because every piece of research they do has shown the apps they make for the under 10s ‘learning’ apps are addictive and harmful.
Theyndonthe research mainly for R&D and marketing.
he couldn’t do it any more.
so YABU. Doesn’t matter how great the ‘content’ is, children are learn to read and write better with books, paper, play.

iPads teach them to be consumers of content, not creators.

hopeisathingwithfeathersx · 20/12/2022 03:07

Ok, I can understand you don't want to link your own thesis.

Instead, please could you link or cite the articles or studies that you relied upon?

GoldenCagedBird · 19/12/2022 22:53

I don’t think your ‘thesis’ is ready to be submitted if this is the best you can do

weRone · 19/12/2022 22:52

you lost me at "kids in buggy on a tablet" sorry I absolutely do not get it!

Let the kids look around. Even if they are the stroppiest kids in the world who will scream in the buggy... let them have a strop.

But a tablet (or phone) when out and driving about? Shocking.

Yes, we have raised 3 kids, 100% in a buggy and 100% on public transport.

OTOH if you must use screens, yes it can be good but for a very short time (especially when they're buggy age)

yadaya · 19/12/2022 22:46

They have their place but they can't or shouldn't replace interaction. As part of a wider learning experience they can have some benefit but they shouldn't be the only source of learning.

I do an awful lot of online teaching and from a pedagogical perspective someone just watching a screen or a lecture isn't considered good practice.

Testina · 19/12/2022 22:45

Your thesis 🤣
So, you’ve just written an essay based on a few papers… no actual analysis of your own, or even a meta analysis of those papers?
And you’re not going to link to any of those papers.

My teen has learned a fuckton from TikTok. Not even being sarcastic there 🤣
So I’m pretty pro screen time for the right child. But I’m not convinced by your “thesis”.

CuteAsDuck · 19/12/2022 22:41

Hours of Royal Institution lectures - LOL. Honestly this is the best thing I've heard today.

In all seriousness, I too would be interested in links to some of the papers you refer to.

I don't think it's news to anyone that screens when used in structured learning can be useful and effective. I'm not convinced by your overarching claim in your first post though,

Abraxan · 19/12/2022 22:39

I'm a big advocate for tech - it's part of my jib these days.

iPads and other tablets have their uses with children, They can bring lots of positives when used well, with controls and restrictions but they also have negative concerns too.

In the end a tablet is simply a tool. It's how, where and when you use it that's important and what determines if it's a good one or not.

Transferwaiting · 19/12/2022 22:21

Usee8789754 · 19/12/2022 06:23

Absolute bollocks.

My dc have grown up with screens. Until they were teens I was quite strict with them. I lost control at the point at which school insisted that every child have a laptop. They are now completely addicted and it’s had a detrimental effect on their lives.

your research is bollocks and clearly flawed. I suggest you rethink your methods before you submit it anywhere.

plus you’re shears going to get peoples backs up preaching at then like you’re the font of all knowledge.

Wholeheartedly agree. My DC can't function without screens. I hate what they have done.
As someone involved with schools I'd also hedge a bet that the big issues coming through related to early years speech and language development could be linked to screens.

CrazyBiscuits · 19/12/2022 22:16

Really? Just seeing a 3 year old in a buggy with a tablet and only having it taken off them for a Facebook photo with the ducks then back on the tablet is lazy parenting.
Children are losing the ability to socialise and communicate. Its only going to get worse. Technology has ruined communities imo.

Dulcetto · 19/12/2022 22:14

I agree tech is not binary good/bad and it’s about context and content.

However this statement I do not agree with, tailored content can be better than a teacher.

You are narrowing down to the smallest denominator to prove your argument and all good thesis’ have to include the limitations of the research 🧐 so this is post is a little disingenuous in that regard.

Swipe left for the next trending thread